Generating applied insights into criminal justice through HMP Grendon
Submitting Institution
Birmingham City UniversityUnit of Assessment
Social Work and Social PolicySummary Impact Type
LegalResearch Subject Area(s)
Studies In Human Society: Criminology, Social Work
Summary of the impact
The case study refers to research conducted by the Centre for Applied
Criminology (CAC), which has focused on HMP Grendon. This document
evidences the following impacts:
* Effects on and changes and benefits to policy and practice within and
beyond HMP Grendon.
* Reduction or prevention of harm / negative effects upon staff and
prisoners at HMP Grendon.
* Effects on awareness and understanding of needs specific groups of
prisoners at HMP Grendon.
* Changes and benefits to opportunities available for HMP Grendon
prisoners and applicants.
* Benefits in terms of awareness of penal issues amongst audiences of
specific media.
Underpinning research
CAC has a particularly strong tradition of research relating to the penal
system, which has grown from a long-standing relationship with HMP
Grendon. This prison wholly operates as a therapeutic community — a unique
facility for prisoners who have demonstrated a genuine desire to change.
Prisoners must be serving sentences that allow for a stay of at least 24
months at HMP Grendon and during their time there, they engage in
group-based therapy underpinned by collaborative, democratic, humane and
participative principles.
The research developed from 1997, building upon the initial work of
Professor Wilson, who was able to draw upon his access to the long-term
prisoners to launch a successful programme of enquiry and which has
resulted in his Chairing the charity The Grendon Friends Trust — the first
and only charity in the UK to support an individual prison. CAC's
partnership with the prison was formalised in 2009 through a Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU). The subsequent research has been strongly needs-led
and strategically informed by a commitment to `application', both within
and beyond the Grendon community. A portfolio of HMP Grendon-based
research has evolved around a central theme of `understanding and
responding to diverse offenders and prisoners', contributing to CAC's
strategic aim — to generate applied research that recognises and responds
to the needs of stakeholders in and around the CJS, and three strategic
objectives — to promote a better public understanding of the CJS; improve
the operation of the CJS within specific agencies and institutions; and
enable offenders to tackle barriers to desistance. A summary of
underpinning research is provided below, which has provided the foundation
for the impact detailed in section 4.
CAC's critical analysis of the English and Welsh prison estate, drawing
upon HMP Grendon as an exemplar of good practice, is detailed in our
earliest research, an authored book, What Everyone in Britain should
know about Crime and Punishment, which ran to two editions, with
Blackstone Press in 1998 and Oxford University Press in 2001. Professor
Wilson's subsequent work generated general insights into the prisoner
perspective on the therapeutic process (Wilson & McCabe, 2002). This
has been continued jointly with Visiting Professor Brookes, who draws upon
his professional perspective as Director of Therapeutic Communities at HMP
Grendon (Brookes 2010a, 2010b).
CAC's research has shed light upon the nature of specific groups of
offenders at HMP Grendon and their needs whilst incarcerated, particularly
paedophiles and Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) prisoners. With regards to
the former, research has investigated how the fantasy lives of paedophiles
relates to their index offences (Wilson & Jones, 2008) and how to
manage paedophiles within custody and after release (Silverman &
Wilson, 2002). In terms of the latter, Brookes and Wilson, with Glynn — a
former PhD student funded by CAC (2010-2013), researched how therapeutic
communities should understand and accommodate needs specific to prisoners
from Black and Minority Ethnic backgrounds (Brookes, Glynn & Wilson,
2011). In addition, CAC research led by Dr Caulfield evaluated particular
initiatives at HMP Grendon, notably the Artist in Residence, and explored
the experiences of women prison officers working with male offenders.
Key researchers
Brookes. M. Visiting Professor (2009-ongoing)
Caulfield, L. Senior Lecturer in Psychology (2007-2013)
Wilson, D. Professor of Criminology and Founding Director of the Centre
for Applied Criminology (1997-ongoing)
References to the research
Brookes, M. (2010a). `Putting principles into practice: The therapeutic
community regime at HMP Grendon and its relationship with the "Good Lives"
model'. In R. Shuker & E. Sullivan (Eds.). Grendon and the
emergence of therapeutic communities: Developments in research and
practice (pp. 99-113). Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
Brookes, M. (2010b). `The impact of Grendon on changing lives: Prisoner
perspectives'. The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 49(5), pp.
478-490.
Brookes, M., Glynn, M. & Wilson, D. (2012). `Black Men, Therapeutic
Communities and HMP Grendon', International Journal of Therapeutic
Communities, 33(1), pp. 16-26.
Silverman, J. & Wilson, D. (2002) Innocence Betrayed:
Paedophilia, the Media and Society. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Wilson, D. & Jones, T. (2008). `"In My Own World": A Case Study of a
Paedophile's Thinking and Doing and His Use of the Internet', The
Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 47(2), pp. 107-120.
Wilson, D. & McCabe, S. (2002). `How HMP Grendon "works" in the words
of those undergoing therapy. Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 41(2),
279-291.
The quality of the research can be evidenced by the fact that firstly,
all of the outputs cited above have been subject to rigorous peer review
processes. In addition, Silverman & Wilson (2002) received over 140
citations as well as the following reviews from authoritative sources:
We fear it and loathe it but if we want to protect our children we
must understand it too. The authors use formidable research to put
paedophilia in context. This book is uncomfortable reading — but
essential. (John Humphrys, 'Today', BBC Radio 4).
No one has previously put the case so well for having an adult,
rational debate about how we should respond to paedophilia. Nor have the
counterproductive dangers of outing, naming and shaming with responses
like Megan's Law been so clearly discussed. A thoroughly researched and
well-argued study. (Rod Morgan, Her Majesty's Chief Inspector of the
Probation Service for England and Wales 2001-2004).
Silverman and Wilson manage to achieve what many of us aspire to — a
book that will appeal both to a specialised and lay audience. In the
emotionally charged atmosphere of considering the threat posed by
predatory paedophiles ... it is important that we have a text that is
thoughtful and measured, while also recognising the deep emotions that
the topic raises among the populace. ...[T]his is a well-written book
that can be recommended to the interested layperson ... while, for the
specialist, it draws the threads together of the recent painful scenario
where the News of the World has largely orchestrated the terms of the
debate. (The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice).
Details of the impact
CAC's relationship with HMP Grendon is characterised by a culture of
exchange, in which both parties benefit from the applied knowledge
generated through research. The research cited has both reach and
significance and can be demonstrated in a number of ways for the different
audiences who have used the research:
Dr Caulfield's 2011 evaluation of the Artist in Residence, commissioned
by the Marie-Louise von Motesiczky (MLVM) Charitable Trust, resulted in
the residency being extended for a further two years (2012 and 2013),
demonstrating effects on and benefits to practice within the prison and
benefits to opportunities available to Grendon prisoners. The recreational
art group built around the Artist in Residence currently has places for 15
prisoners and resulted in 107 entries being made to the Koestler Trust
Exhibition in 2013 — the highest number of entries from the prison in its
history. Of note, the work of the artist and the prisoners with whom she
worked will be exhibited at the offices of the Guardian in March 2014. The
Chair of the MLVM Charitable Trust stated, "The evaluation demonstrated
the impact of the artist in residence programme to date. This is turn
was the basis for the MLVM Charitable Trust's decision to fund the
programme for a further two-year phase".
CAC research with BME prisoners has resulted in the prison improving its
cultural sensitivity when applying core values of decency, respect,
equality and diversity. The research was presented as evidence during an
inspection of the prison, is cited in the publicly available inspection
report (HM Chief Inspector of Prisons, 2011) and as such, is indicative of
the wider reach of the research. The proportion of BME prisoners at HMP
Grendon has increased as a result of the research. This evidences effects
on, changes to and benefits to policy and practice within and beyond
Grendon, effects on, awareness and understanding of group-specific needs
and reduction or prevention of harm / negative effects upon staff and
prisoners. Evidence of this impact is provided in the testimony of the
Governor of HMP Grendon and Springhill, who stated that the research "was
part of our project to better understand the experience of BME people
before and during treatment at Grendon. This helped to revise our recruitment
processes and the internal environment. The BME population has now
increased to 27%". It is further stated, "This research was an
important element in a wider programme of engaging with diversity of
race and ethnicity. Historically BME people have been under-represented
in treatment services and this had been the experience at Grendon (16%
compared to 25% of the prison population as a whole)". In addition,
the publicly available inspection report (HM Chief Inspector of Prisons,
2011, p. 18) notes the contribution of the research to achieving key
performance indicators, "2.28. The race impact assessment on
treatment delivery and other relevant assessments should be informed
by consultation with black and minority ethnic prisoners. (3.50)
Achieved. Equality impact assessments demonstrated some
good quality consultation with black and minority ethnic prisoners.
Birmingham City University had been commissioned to undertake a
consultation with black and minority ethnic prisoners about the
therapeutic regime and the results were being applied in a review of
these prisoners' experience of the therapeutic regime. The report of the
consultation had been made available to prisoners on the residential
units and a series of meetings planned to discuss the findings and agree
actions to improve the situation".
Professor Wilson is the Chair of the Howard League for Penal Reform's
Policy Committee and in this capacity, Chaired the Commission on English
Prisons in 2009. Professor Wilson's research was among that cited in the
publicly available report of the Commission, entitled Do Better; Do
Less: The Report of the Commission on English Prisons Today. The
research undertaken by Professor Wilson at HMP Grendon played a
significant role in his selection as Chair of the Commission. This
demonstrates impact in terms of effects on awareness and understanding of
public and policy audiences regarding contemporary issues in the CJS. The
Chief Executive of the Howard League for Penal Reform stated, "David
Wilson's invitation to Chair the Commission came about through his
reputation as a leading criminologist in his field, having been a
high-profile prison governor and based on the research that he had
undertaken into the therapeutic community at HMP Grendon. David led
discussions with ministers, officials, NGOs and the media on publication
of the report so that the findings influenced UK government policy
embedding concepts of justice reinvestment, penal moderation and
restorative justice. The Coalition Government championed restorative
justice and ministers introduced justice reinvestment pilots,
particularly for youth justice, into local authorities across the
country".
HMP Grendon and CAC remain committed to an annual debate between the
prison and final year students at BCU, evidencing benefits to the
opportunities available to HMP Grendon prisoners. Around 40-50 prisoners
participate in the debate each year.
Insights into the offending behaviours of the prisoner groups specified
above has resulted in West Midlands Police commissioning CAC to jointly
host four training seminars at the University between 2010 and 2012 to
better train Senior Investigating Officers during murder investigations.
Therefore, CAC's underpinning research around understanding and responding
to diverse offenders demonstrates effects on practice in policing and
criminal investigation.
Evidence of impact is also demonstrated in terms of the continuous and
extensive media presence of the work of CAC members, demonstrating
benefits in terms of awareness of penal issues amongst audiences. `Reach'
is considerable as reporting has taken place locally, nationally and
internationally. Professor Wilson is frequently quoted in mainstream media
items about HMP Grendon (see for example McClatchey, 2011). Items relating
to CAC's expertise in `understanding and responding to diverse prisoners'
has been widely disseminated through these media, particularly relating to
sex offending, murder and serial killing. These latter three themes are
underpinned by knowledge directly developed through the Grendon
relationship. `Significance' can also be evidenced here in that Professor
Wilson has been identified in published, peer reviewed research
(Groombridge, 2007) and the higher education press (Corbyn, 2009) as a
leading, frequently quoted criminologist in the media.
Sources to corroborate the impact
- Corroborating Statement, Governor, HMP Grendon and Springhill.
(Participant in process of impact delivery)
- Corroborating Statement, Chief Executive, Howard League for Penal
Reform. (Reporter on the process of impact delivery)
- Corroborating Contact, Treasurer, The Friends of Grendon. (Reporter on
the process of impact delivery)
- Corbyn, Z. (2009). CSI: Crime Story Interpreters. Times Higher
Education, 23rd July. Retrieved from:
http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/news/csi-crime-story-interpreters/407484.article?sm=407484
- Groombridge, N. (2007). `Criminologists Say: An analysis of UK
national press coverage of criminology and criminologists and a
contribution to the debate on "public criminology"', Howard Journal
of Criminal Justice, 46(5), pp. 459-475.
- HM Chief Inspector of Prisons (2011). Report on an unannounced short
follow-up visit of HMP Grendon. 15th-17th August
2011. Paragraph 2.28:
http://www.justice.gov.uk/downloads/publications/inspectorate-reports/hmipris/grendon-2011.pdf
- McClatchey, C. (2011). HMP Grendon: Therapy for Dangerous Prisoners. BBC
News UK. 16th November. Retrieved from: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-11947481