Guiding treatment and leading advocacy for podoconiosis, a common but highly neglected tropical disease
Submitting Institution
University of SussexUnit of Assessment
Biological SciencesSummary Impact Type
HealthResearch Subject Area(s)
Medical and Health Sciences: Public Health and Health Services
Summary of the impact
Podoconiosis reduces the health and well-being of an estimated 4 million
people globally and constrains economic development in a number of
tropical countries. Our research has had significant impact on tropical
societies and economies where podoconiosis is endemic. Through world-class
genetic, public-health and social-science research, we have generated the
evidence base for simple foot-hygiene treatment and prevention that has
now reached at least 60,000 Ethiopian patients. Our team has worked with
the private sector to secure the donation of several hundred thousand
pairs of shoes for disease prevention, and has ensured the rapid
translation of research results through assisting the development of a
national podoconiosis forum in Ethiopia, and through the creation of Footwork,
the International Podoconiosis Initiative.
Underpinning research
Podoconiosis is a non-infectious geochemical disease that results in
swelling of the lower legs. It is caused by the long-term exposure of bare
feet to red clay soil derived from volcanic rock. In southern Ethiopia,
where much of our research has been conducted, and north-western Cameroon,
it affects 5-8 per cent of the population and is more common than HIV, TB
or malaria. Podoconiosis imposes immense economic burdens (the estimated
cost to Ethiopia's economy is $208 million per year) and severe social
stigma. Very little research on disease aetiology or pathogenesis has been
done, yet such research is needed for the rational deployment of limited
resources towards the prevention, treatment and, ultimately, eradication
of the disease. To address this situation, Professor Gail Davey (2006-10
Senior Clinical Research Fellow at the Brighton & Sussex Medical
School (BSMS) based in Ethiopia; 2010 onwards Reader, then Professor of
Global Health Epidemiology at BSMS) established a multidisciplinary
research group that covers the aetiology (genetic, mineral and
biochemical), consequences (economic, ethical and social) and clinical
management of podoconiosis.
The genetics arm of our group (led by Professor Melanie Newport, BSMS)
has provided convincing evidence that an area of the genome commonly
involved in human responses to infectious and environmental challenges
plays a major role in a person's susceptibility to podoconiosis [see
Section 3, R1]. Establishing the importance of genetic susceptibility has
justified the use of a family-history tool in determining which children
should be offered shoes for the prevention of disease when such shoes are
a scarce resource. Other key research outputs include:
- an epidemiological description of podoconiosis in three endemic
regions of Ethiopia [R2];
- the quantification of the severe economic impact of podoconiosis on
impoverished communities [R3, R4];
- the development and testing of educational and training materials to
be used in endemic communities;
- a description of the social impact on, and coping strategies adopted
by, people with this debilitating and stigmatising condition [R5];
- the development and validation of clinical and quality-of-life scales;
- the novel use of a rapid ethics assessment prior to obtaining consent
for genetics research in a low-income setting [R6]; and
- completion of the first genome-wide association study (GWAS) on a
non-communicable disease in an African population.
Significant research grants have been awarded by the UK Medical Research
Council, the Wellcome Trust, UKAid/DfID and the USA National Institutes of
Health. Personal fellowships include a Wellcome Trust University Award
(Gail Davey) and a Training Fellowship (Kebede Deribe). Collaborations
with:
- the Addis Ababa University Schools of Public Health, Social Science
and Earth Science;
- the National Human Genome Research Center, National Institutes of
Health, USA;
- the Clinical Trials Facility, Kilifi, Kenya;
- the University of Buea, Cameroon; and
- the Natural History Museum, UK,
have enabled the development of research capacity through PhD and
Master's training for 10 African scientists to date. Through Professor
Davey's substantive appointment in 2006, BSMS has become the global hub
for podoconiosis research from which international collaborations are
coordinated (http://www.podo.org/research/).
References to the research
R1 Ayele, T.F., Adeyemo, A., Finan, C., Hailu, E., Sinnott, P.,
Diaz Burlington, N., Aseffa, A., Rotimi, C.N., Newport, M.J. and Davey, G.
(2012) `The HLA class II locus and susceptibility to podoconiosis', New
England Journal of Medicine, 366(13): 1200-8.
R2 Desta, A., McBride, C., de Heer, H., Watanabe, E., Gebreyesus,
T., Tadele, G., Tora, A. and Davey, G. (2012) `The association of beliefs
about heredity with preventive and interpersonal behaviors in communities
affected by podoconiosis in Rural Ethiopia', American Journal of
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 87(4): 623-30.
R3 Taye, B., Alemayehu, B., Birhanu, A., Desta, K., Tsegaye, A.,
Addisu, S., Petros, B. and Davey, G. (2012) `Podoconiosis and
soil-transmitted helminths (STHs): double burden of neglected tropical
diseases in Wolaita zone, rural southern Ethiopia', PLoS Neglected
Tropical Disease, 7(3): e2128.
R4 Davey, G. (2010) `Podoconiosis', in Warrell, D.A., Cox, T.. and
Firth, J.. (eds) The Oxford Textbook of Medicine, 5th ed.
R5 Sikorski, C., Ashine, M., Zeleke, Z. and Davey, G. (2010)
`Effectiveness of a simple lymphoedema treatment regimen in podoconiosis
management in southern Ethiopia: one year follow-up', PLoS Neglected
Tropical Disease, 4(11): e902.
R6 Tekola, F., Bull, S.J., Farsides, B., Newport, M., Adeyemo, A.,
Rotimi, C.N. and Davey, G. (2009) `Tailoring consent to context: designing
an appropriate consent process for a biomedical study in a low income
setting', PLoS Neglected Tropical Disease, 3(7): e482-7.
Outputs can be supplied by the University on request.
Grants in the last five years
2013-18 Wellcome Trust Strategic Award for the WT-Brighton and Sussex
Centre for Global Health Research: £251,000.
2013-16 University of Sussex Chancellor's International Research
Scholarship for Henok Negussie. `Defining and managing acute
adenolymphangitis in podoconiosis lymphoedema in Northern Ethiopia':
£48,600.
2013-16 Wellcome Trust PHATIC Training Fellowship for Kebede Deribe.
`Nationwide mapping of podoconiosis in Ethiopia': £299,000.
2013-15 Wellcome Trust Enhancement Award. Validating a combined
geo-epidemiological approach to sampling for a geo-chemical disease:
£161,412.
2013-16 MRC/DfID/Wellcome Trust. RCT of podoconiosis treatment in
Northern Ethiopia: £791,000.
2013-15 NIH Social and Behavioral Research Branch. Using Behavioural
Research to Optimize Shoe Use and Enhance Prevention of Podoconiosis —
Community Intervention Trial: $193,148.
2012-15 MRC IIB Research Grant. Discovering podoconiosis susceptibility
genes: from molecules to disease control for a `neglected' NTD: £504,188.
2012-13 Association of Physicians of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
Identification of reasons for loss to follow up of patients with
podoconiosis: £9,980.
2012-13 Higher Education Innovation Fund, University of Sussex. `Shoes
are the New Bednets': Engagement with US and UK Shoe Companies to Prevent
Neglected Tropical Diseases: £4,200.
2011-13 NIH Social and Behavioral Research Branch. Using Behavioural
Research to Optimize Shoe Use and Enhance Prevention of Podoconiosis —
Phase 2: $29,025.
2011-12 TOMS Shoes. Advance support for Ethiopian Nationwide Podoconiosis
Mapping: $26,800.
2010-15 Wellcome Trust University Award. PI. Gene-environment
interactions in podoconiosis: £550,000.
2009-11 NIH Social and Behavioral Research Branch. PI. Using Behavioural
Research to Optimize Shoe Use and Enhance Prevention of Podoconiosis —
Phase 1: $45,625.
2008-10 Association of Physicians of Great Britain and Ireland. Building
links in Histopathology and Geology between Ethiopia and the UK through
elucidation of the role of ultrafine particles in the pathogenesis of
podoconiosis: £9823.
2007-10 Wellcome Trust. The genetic basis of podoconiosis — a model for
gene-environment interaction?: 20a4280,187.
Details of the impact
Our research has had a direct impact on patient care, community-wide
disease prevention, the training of health professionals in disease
management, the raising of awareness of podoconiosis in scientific and
policy fora, and the mobilising of the private sector to engage in disease
prevention.
• Patients, their families and communities
Untreated, podoconiosis causes disability and disfigurement. Patients
suffer pain and immobility, are highly stigmatised and are excluded from
social and religious gatherings and marriage. Our research provides
evidence that enables communities to initiate simple treatment
programmes that improve physical and psychological health. These
programmes now reach an estimated 60,000 patients in three regions of
Ethiopia [see Section 5, C1]. Our research into genetic susceptibility
has provided a robust scientific rationale to targeting shoes to
children with a family history of disease [C2]. Our behavioural research
in collaboration with the Social and Behavioral Research Branch at the
National Institutes of Health, USA, is testing community interventions
(campaign materials and household-level training sessions) to improve
the use of shoes distributed to prevent disease [C3].
• Health workers
At a workshop in June 2013, the Ministry of Health in Ethiopia agreed
to deliver training for the trainers of community health workers based
on our research outputs. This will cover 10 disease-endemic locations in
Ethiopia and Cameroon and will reach approximately 300 trainers
altogether [C1]. Twelve Regional Heads of Special Needs Education were
trained at a workshop in Addis Ababa in June 2011. The Ethiopian Federal
Ministry of Health has also approved an in-service training module on
podoconiosis which will be used for the refresher training of 30,000
Health Extension Workers [C1, C4]. This module was developed by
Professor Davey on the basis of research results and previous training.
• Private sector:
Contact with TOMS (a US-registered shoe company whose aim is to give a
pair of shoes to a child in need for every pair sold, www.toms.com)
developed at a time when they were looking to increase the impact of
shoes being distributed in low-resource settings. TOMS founder, Blake
Mycoskie, and his team visited podoconiosis-endemic sites and consulted
with members of the research team to optimise the design of shoes
distributed to prevent disease [C5]. As a consequence, we have also
drawn in significant research and advocacy support from TOMS. TOMS have
funded the preparations for a nationwide mapping of podoconiosis and
recently appointed an epidemiologist (Dr Shira Shafir) to be their
Director of Impact Assessment and ensure the shoes being distributed are
having the impact intended. TOMS is also contributing $500,000 to the
support new Footwork posts, including an Executive Director (www.podo.org).
• Policy-makers, national and international agencies
Professor Gail Davey was a member of the Guideline Development
Committee that used research generated by this group to write the
Ethiopian National Guideline on Morbidity Management of Lymphatic
Filariasis and Podoconiosis, which is ongoing. Our research findings
have underpinned successful advocacy to include podoconiosis among eight
priority Neglected Tropical Diseases in the Ethiopian National Plan for
Integrated Control of Neglected Tropical Diseases which was launched in
June 2013 [C6]. Professor Davey is a founding member of and now advisor
to the Ethiopian National Podoconiosis Action Network (NaPAN) [C1].
In October 2010, Professor Davey presented evidence to the Department
for Control of Neglected Tropical Diseases at the World Health
Organisation which led to podoconiosis being recognised for the first
time as a Neglected Tropical Disease [C7]. Professor Davey serves as
Director of Footwork, the International Podoconiosis Initiative
[C8]. In November 2012, Footwork initiated talks between key
stakeholders in lymphatic filariasis and podoconiosis in Atlanta, GA,
USA, paving the way for a joint mapping of both diseases in Ethiopia and
a subgroup working on improved diagnostics to enable differentiation of
these diseases in tropical settings. This work is underway [C9].
Sources to corroborate the impact
C1 Data and corroboration available from Biruk Kebede, Director of
National Podoconiosis Action Network (NaPAN), www.podo.org/ethiopia/napan/.
C2 Ethiopian Herald (Sunday Edition) 68(174): 1 April
2012. `Researchers identify genetic basis of tropical foot and leg
lymphoedema'.
C3 http://clinicaltrials.gov/show/NCT01160523
C4 Open University HEAT website:
http://labspace.open.ac.uk/mod/oucontent/view.php?id=452781&direct=1
C5 CBS documentary on TOMS visit to podoconiosis sites: http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-18563_162-5439649.html
(including patient testimony at 01:45).
C6 Copy available at:
http://www.ntdenvision.org/sites/default/files/docs/national_ntd_master_plan_ethiopia_2013-2015_1.pdf
C7 WHO NTD website: http://www.who.int/neglected_diseases/diseases/en/
C8 Lancet profile:
http://download.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS0140673612604188.pdf
C9
http://www.ehnri.gov.et/news-and-information/144-national-lymphatic-filariasis-and-podoconiosis-mapping-launched.