Enhancing public engagement with history: France during the Second World War
Submitting Institution
University of BathUnit of Assessment
Area StudiesSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Studies In Human Society: Political Science
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Diamond's research has enhanced public understanding of the lives of
French civilians during World War 2. Her work with cultural professionals,
including radio and television producers, museum curators, non-academic
editors and publishers, has enhanced economic prosperity in the creative
sector. She has been able to integrate new ways of thinking about the
period into public discourse and to extend her reach to global audiences.
She has used the internet to communicate her research and her interactive
website has enabled numerous individuals to gain public recognition for
their stories. This co-production of historical knowledge provides an
innovative way for cultural heritage to be preserved and conserved
digitally.
Underpinning research
The research has centred on the experiences of ordinary people in France
during and after the Second World War. It falls into two themes; both
associated with a significant monograph. The first deals with issues of
Gender, and the second with the French experience of defeat in 1940.
Diamond's research on Gender and the Second World War in France
(A) uncovered the different ways in which French men and women experienced
the war. The book was the first to chart the pressures faced by women and
their experience of the transition into the post-war period. It
demonstrates that women's age and family situations had an important
bearing on their daily life choices and their chances of survival. Her
work illuminated our understanding of how women could be drawn into
resistance or collaboration through their everyday lives. It argues that
the Occupation explicitly brought politics into the private sphere in a
way which provided an opportunity for women to act `politically'; for
example by inviting a German officer into their home or hiding a Jewish
family in their attic. However despite gaining the right to vote in 1944,
most women struggled to carry through this political commitment into their
post-war lives and the immediate post-war period saw most women withdraw
from the public sphere and focus on rebuilding their home lives with the
return of the men.
Her second area of research on France's experience of defeat
(B) was the first exploration in English of how it felt for French people
to become refugees in their own country. It explores the reasons why
people left their homes to risk all on the roads of France. It argues that
lack of preparation for possible invasion and the ensuing exodus of
civilians laid the path for Pétain's Vichy government to take power in a
climate of trauma and amidst the complete collapse of the structures of
the Third Republic. It explores the reasons why this important event in
the history of France has been completely overlooked in the historical
record and Diamond's research has had an important impact in drawing
attention to these events.
References to the research
A. Gender and the Second World War
£3,700 British Academy award in 1997.
1995 article : `Libération, quelle libération? L'expérience des femmes
toulousaines', F Thébaud (ed) Clio, histoire, femmes, et sociétés:
Résistances et Libérations, France 1940-45, Presses Universitaires
de Mirail, 89-109,http://clio.revues.org/517
1995 article: `Gaining the vote, a liberating experience?' Modern and
Contemporary France, 129-139. 10.1080/09639489508456229
1999 monograph: Women and the Second World War in France, 1939-48:
Choices and Constraints, Longman. 978-0582299108 (can be supplied by
HEI on request)
2005 co-edited book, Vichy, Resistance, Liberation, New Perspectives
on Wartime France, Berg. 978-1859737729 (can be supplied by HEI on
request)
B. France's experience of defeat.
2007 monograph: Fleeing Hitler, France 1940, Oxford University
Press, 978-0199532599 (can be supplied by HEI on request)
Details of the impact
Diamond has collaborated with a range of beneficiaries who have drawn on
her research as a way of engaging the public's interest in the period
allowing Diamond to impact on English speaking audiences globally, across
Europe, the US and Australasia through a variety of mediums. In June 2013,
Fleeing Hitler had sold close to 10,000 copies, mostly overseas,
largely in the US (6080). These figures demonstrate the significance of
her book which was well received and widely reviewed in the broadsheet
press including The New York Review of Books, The Times Higher
Educational Supplement, The FT Magazine (Culture), The Sunday Times
(Culture), Tribune, The Historian. In the London Review of Books
in May 2008, Jeremy Harding described the book as `a convincing piece of
history drawing on contemporary accounts'. It was translated into Japanese
in 2009 with a print run of 2,000 copies. Diamond's books have been widely
adopted on University courses relating to French/ European history and
Gender history across the UK and the US (including at Yale, Amherst and
McMater, Canada).
Contribution to the creative sector
1. In the media
As detailed below, the wide dissemination of Diamond's publications have
led her to be regularly approached by radio and TV producers who engage
her to shape the delivery of her research for their programmes. She has
been able to change their assumptions and shape their outputs thereby
refining existing narratives about the period. In particular, she has
showcased women's voices and experience. Her work has informed the ways
that the public understand and remember the everyday of the Second World
War.
Radio producers
Diamond made an expert contribution to a BBC World Service's `The Why
Factor' in October 2012 on `The Shaved Head'. She was interviewed about
her research on the women whose heads were shaved in `punishment' for
sleeping with the enemy after the Liberation of France. `Dr Diamond
played an important role ... She provided invaluable background
and helped contextualise the story and issues raised in a powerful and
moving way. ... Dr Diamond sent us some very useful research material,
including her own very accessible book on this period, which helped to
pull together a major section of the programme. We were extremely
grateful for Dr Diamond's input and look forward to working together
again in the future. ... the World Service has a weekly audience of 180
million globally'. (1) http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00zf17r
TV producers
Diamond has twice acted as consultant for Wall to Wall productions who
make the series `Who Do You Think You Are?' for the BBC. In April 2011 she
prepared material for an episode with JK Rowling and provided context for
her relative's wartime letters. `Her expertise on the daily life of
French civilians during the Second World War helped Jo Rowling to
understand what her great grandfather experienced while he was trapped
in the suburbs of Paris' (consolidated viewing figures 7 million —
filmed interview not included). (2) She researched a further episode on
Patrick Stewart whose father experienced post traumatic stress as a result
of his experiences in France in May 1940. Diamond's research and the
additional documentation she uncovered enabled them to better communicate
the suffering of civilians caught up in events. (3.5 million viewers,
Diamond credited in the end titles).
In October 2012 she contributed to a New Zealand based production
company's film on NZ born SOE agent Nancy Wake. `Her on camera
interview ... informed us as producers, as it will our audiences, to
help comprehend the risks that Nancy as a woman agent ran in Occupied
France. [It] has played an important role in helping our
audiences to understand the context of the world in which the resistance
operated and thereby gave us further insights into the aspect of Nancy
Wake's own experience that should be communicated to audiences.
Diamond's research ... will really help to inform the public
understanding of hidden aspects to these significant events' (3).
The film has been delivered to New Zealand's TV One. Distributors expect
to sell the programme into Europe, the UK and Australia.
Diamond also advised Maryland based Gardner Productions about the
civilian experience in Paris1939-43 for their film on woman SOE agent
Noor-un-nisa Inayat Khan. `Diamond's
contribution has played an important role in informing this documentary
project both for us as producers in helping us to shape the material
that will be communicated to audiences and more directly as a result of
her on-screen interview' (4). The programme will be screened on PBS
in the US in the autumn and is expected to be sold to Channel 4 and other
European channels. Working with media professionals has enabled Diamond to
reach global audiences and to bring changes in understandings of this
period across the English speaking world.
2. In the curatorial sector
Fleeing Hitler was used as the basis for 4 of 22 panels (18%) of
an exhibition in Germany on the German invasion of France entitled "Das
überschreitet die Grenzen der Vernunft — Mythos Blitzkrieg" which ran at
the German Tank Museum, Munster, Lower Saxony, from August 10 - November
30 2010. During this period, roughly 40.000 people physically walked
through the hall in which the exhibition was shown. The exhibition was
then lent to the "Wehrgeschichtliches Museum Rastatt" in the south of
Germany from April 24 - August 15 2011 where a further 5.000 - 10.000
visitors saw the exhibition. The curator of the exhibition wrote: "...
it's safe to say that the exhibition was at least in some cases able to
change viewpoints fundamentally, based on a deeper understanding of the
human side of this historical event. "The French" of 1940 in the mind of
these visitors were no longer only the soldiers — now these visitors
thought also of the civilians and what they had to endure "(5).
3. Non-academic editors and publishers
Diamond has written reviews and a column for the THES (2-8
September 2010) in their section entitled `The Canon' on Lucie Aubrac's, `Ils
partiront dans l'ivresse' (1984). Following an invitation she wrote
a preface to Fernande Davis, 2008, `Girl in the Belgian Resistance: A
Wakeful Eye in the Underground', Beach Lloyd Publishers, 2nd
Edition. In one telling example, Charlotte Heatherley recounted her
elderly friend's reactions to reading Diamond's book: ` As I read
excerpts aloud to Josette, I witnessed a transformation ... Finally,
here was validation and corroboration of all she had told her family
through the years. Hearing these stories gave her a kind of peace.
Sharing her memories, getting them permanently recorded, became
Josette's focus during the last month of her life. She said that it had
made the dying process easier'. They were published as a book
entitled `Saga of a French Dish' (2010) (6).
Contributing to wider public understanding of the Second World War
in France
The public have been exposed to Diamond's work through her interactions
with the creative sector as described above and she has also been involved
in further public engagement activities which have given her the
opportunity to engage directly with interested parties.
1. Via community engagement
Diamond's was invited to participate in the events around the 70th
anniversary of De Gaulle's Appel in 1940, and on 17 June 2010 she spoke at
a day conference on `Charles de Gaulle, London and the Resistance' held at
the Institut Français on women in the French resistance. She
broadcast two live radio interviews on the morning news (BBC Bristol and
BBC Wales) about her VIP invitation to attend the commemorative ceremony
held at the Chelsea Barracks involving both the French President Sarkozy
and the British Prime Minister Cameron.
2. Via the web
Diamond's interview on the death of Resistance hero Raymond Aubrac in
April 2012 published by the CNN website provoked considerable discussion
about the nature and extent of the French Resistance and the contribution
it made to the Second World War. http://edition.cnn.com/2012/04/11/world/raymond-aubrac-obit
It received 250 posted comments and 613 recommendations on facebook.
Diamond is a strong believer in the power of the internet as a tool for
public engagement. Her work continues to be the subject of web discussions
on sites like goodreads.com, Coolread4.html, wordpress.com and http://thathideousman
testifying to its reach. On 3/12/2010 one blogger wrote of `Fleeing
Hitler': `we can read this kind of book as a background when we
try to understand what is happening in our times. ... The kinds of
thoughts that were in the minds of Parisians in 1940 should to some
extent correspond to the thoughts in the heads of people fleeing from
Srebrenica'.
https://whenthenightcomesfallingfromthesky.wordpress.com/2010/12/03/book-fleeing-hitler-france-1940-why-people-run-away-in-war/
The continuous flow of correspondence from readers of her work in the UK
and the US offering her accounts of their and their family's war-time
experiences inspired Diamond to secure funding to put together an
interactive website to enable people to post their family stories and
share their experiences with one another and other interested users. (See
www.fleeinghitler.org). This
provides valuable evidence of the level of public engagement and the
transformative influence her work has had on readers. The website is
currently populated with 44 stories and blogs from a total of 26
contributors. Comments made both by contributors and users visiting the
website indicate that Diamond's work provides families with a form of
authentication of their stories and has thereby had a significant impact
in helping them to come to terms with that past. One user commented `A
wonderful opportunity for people to have a voice with their stories,
which otherwise might have disappeared unheard'. Contributors have
embraced the opportunity to share their family stories with other
interested parties.
Ivor Samuels wrote `When we told my aunt about Hanna Diamond's website
project, it inspired her to recount her story after previously refusing
to put anything down or give an account which was more than disconnected
anecdotes. We all felt that the website offered her an appropriate way
to present her memories and could offer those interested in the period
and the events a valuable resource' (7). A psychotherapist commented
on the website that this sharing was important `to help them to face up
to and work through the intergenerational impact of family members
either surviving or indeed perishing in the Holocaust'. The website
launch was attended by 150 people and generated local media attention.
Since its launch in January 2013, the website has attracted 32 comments
and over 1400 visitors throughout the world. It is notable that users
spend close to four minutes on the site, viewing an average of at least
four pages per visit which is a remarkably high figure. The site is
valuable depository for testimony to be preserved digitally; an example of
how digital technology can be used to create a living historical resource
which is a widely available, growing digital archive.
Sources to corroborate the impact
- Senior Producer, BBC Radio Current Affairs.
- J.K.Rowling episode, Asst Producer.
- Senior Producer, The Gibson Group.
- Documentary film producer.
- Research director/ Curator, German Tank Museum.
- http://www.fleeinghitler.org/blog/2012/10/guest-post-by-charlotte-heatherley-recording-josettes-story/
- http://www.fleeinghitler.org/blog/2013/05/ivor-samuels-family-and-experiences-on-the-fleeing-hitler-website/