Projecting Ireland’s Media and Cultural History
Submitting Institution
St Mary's University, TwickenhamUnit of Assessment
Communication, Cultural and Media Studies, Library and Information Management Summary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
The impact described here focuses on the complex issue of Ireland's
representation in film, its exhibition and cultural remediation. It
derives from a research project undertaken during two discrete periods
(1993-2001) and (2011-2013), the most recent configuration of which at the
Centre for Irish Studies (CIS) at St Mary's University College, aims to
produce a new cultural history that includes its diasporic forms and
transnational axes. The research findings have informed agendas for
cultural institutions, adult education programmes and cultural events. The
case study addresses the issue of filmic variation across regional,
national and international contexts thus contributing to debates about
transnational cinema.
Underpinning research
The main research insight is to establish the strong connection between
film as a visual medium and its contribution to migrant identity
formation, adaptation and cultural interpretation. This is demonstrated to
operate in both first and subsequent generation Irish people, but in
different ways, and consequently it informs a wider, longitudinal
understanding of Ireland's cultural history. Further the research findings
distinguish between forms of exilic and diasporic Irishness as evidenced
in films, creative migrants and audiences. Coining a new critical term,
the research posits the operation of what it defines as "scopic diaspora
space" to explain the way film constructs a visualised, cognitive map of
"here and there'. In its most recent phases, the research has explored a)
how this scopic regime is cinematically shared partially by those who
might define themselves as `native' or `indigenous' to problematize a
self-perceived, secure, anchored identity, b) how "scopic diaspora space"
is the site of cross-over recognitions by other migrant groups, c) how
`Irish' film travels, produces pleasure and cultural affiliations beyond
Britain and Ireland in other highly transnational cultures such as Brazil.
In this latter regard, the issues of creative interpretation, cultural
translation and sub-titling have come to the fore in the practice of
production and organizing events.
Pettitt's work is situated within a group of researchers engaged in film
at CIS. Pettitt was a lecturer/senior lecturer at St Mary's
between1992-2001 and was subsequently returned to the HEI and was
appointed to a Chair in Screen Media (March 2011). Zaluczkowska, a PhD
student since October 2011 and supervised by Pettitt, is working on a
creative writing doctorate focused on post-Troubles drama; Dr Keith
Hopper, appointed Research Fellow (September 2012, 3 year fixed term)
recently completed an Oxbridge doctorate on Neil Jordan's fiction and
film; Charles Barr, appointed Professorial Research Fellow (September
2012, 3 year fixed term) has published on John Ford, film adaptations of
Irish drama and film Irish/British identity. Research undertaken by Barr,
Pettitt and Hopper has consisted of a series of periodic visits to film
archive material and print sources held at the IFI Dublin, RTE Dublin,
BBCNI, the BFI and C4 London, BBC Written Archives Centre (WAC), the BL
and National Library Dublin, and the National Archives, Kew and the Ford
Archive in the USA.
Focusing on Pettitt, numerous film festival viewings of contemporary and
historic film material have been undertaken in Britain, Ireland, North
America, Europe and Brazil/Argentina. Pettitt has participated in
presentations, Q & As and discussions with academic peers, archivist
professionals and the public (including at adult education classes, and
community group screenings) that have informed the case study's
overarching project to understand audience, transnational context and
remediation. A secondary literature of review, written commentary, web
audio-visual sources (University of Ulster's CAIN website, Trinity College
Dublin, Irish Film Institute and the BFI/St Mary's CIS), journal and
academic writing, has been used to critically frame and compare these
specific viewing contexts to determine the shifting meanings that attach
to or are recast for different viewings. Pettitt and Hopper have
themselves also contributed to this review literature in publications such
as The Irish Post and Times Literary Supplement.
References to the research
All of Pettitt's REF2 outputs have been published by university presses
or in peer reviewed journals. Item 1 was submitted in RAE 2001 and its
chapter 11 `TV drama the Troubles' was excerpted online for the CAIN web
project, achieving mid-decade, viewing rates of 3,281 (Jan-Dec, 2006) and
1,088 (Jan-May, 2007). It can be found at:
http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/images/cinema/pettitt/pettitt00.htm
[accessed 5 November 2013]. Annual ALCS statements (2007 and 2008)
indicated a sustained activity in registered photocopying of Screening
Ireland, with higher rates in EU, Scandinavian territories and
Canada in particular. Non-academic review and expert comment important to
gauging the impact of the work includes: `a long over-due new reference
work for students of Irish cinema the world over' (Minister of State,
Department of Foreign Affairs, Dublin); `a major academic study...it will
provide an exceptional benchmark for students of the cinema for many years
to come.' (Books Ireland); `[Pettitt's] articulate style and
critical insights are a valuable addition to the growing field of Irish
screen scholarship and an important exploration of the complexities and
contingencies of identity in the digital age.' (The Irish Times);
`The chapters on film are fascinating...[Pettitt] has an eye for details
which resonate beyond Irish borders.' (Times Literary Supplement);
'A large gap has been filled by Lance Pettitt's Screening Ireland
which is deft and incisive.' (Declan Kiberd, Sunday Tribune,
Dublin).
The second period of research (2011-2013) has attracted dissemination
support from a Culture Ireland (CI) grant (€2k in 2013, Brazil/Argentina)
— linked to outputs 4 and 6 respectively, was a follow-on project linked
with output 3 that had been awarded a CI grant (€2k) in 2010. These recent
successes are based on a successful track record of research in the
interim period (2001-2010) underpinned by three British Academy small
grants to Pettitt in (2003 — £1,700; 2006 — £2,048; 2007 — £2,048) and as
a co-researcher with QUB (Belfast)/UU (Ulster) in an AHRC network
(2007-2009 — £19k) submitted under RAE2008.
1. [Monograph] Screening Ireland (2000) with 2nd
revised edition (contracted Manchester UP, 2014) ISBN: 0-7190-5270X.
Widely cited in subsequent work in the field. 1st edition print
run of 2,250 sold out. Copy available from HEI. The first edition was
based on research undertaken 1993-1999 and subject to three anonymous
academic readers for MUP.
2. [Journal article] (2011) `Exilic Irish Cinema in England', Irish
Studies Review, 19: 1 (February). Special Issue: Screening the Irish
in Britain. pp. 41-52. ISSN: 0967-0882. REF2 submission. This article
is based on an invited keynote lecture at Trinity College, Dublin
(September 2009) and was peer-reviewed for publication.
3. [Essay in collection] (2011) `Holywood Hobohemian: The filmwork of
John T. Davis', in Pettitt and Kopschitz Bastos, eds. Sao Paulo:
USP/Humanitas Press, 2011 pp. 21-50. The Uncle Jack. ISBN:
978857732171-1. REF2 submission. This essay was based on an invited
round-table paper given at the ABRPUI conference, Sao Paulo (June 2009).
4. [Essay in collection] (2013) `In the Crack Between Cultures: Art,
cinema and migrant memory in The Woman Who Married Clark Gable
(co-edited with Kopschitz Bastos as 3. above). Sao Paulo: USP/Humanitas,
2013. ISBN: 978-85-7732-225-1. REF2 submission. This essay was based
on research at the IFI Dublin and given as a peer-review paper for IASIL
at Queen's University Belfast (July 2013).
5. [Essay in collection] (2013) `Screen Fictions of William Trevor', in
ed. Paul Delaney and Michael Parker William Trevor: Revaluations.
Manchester University Press, pp. 76-92. ISBN: 978-0-7190-8790-5. REF2
submission. This essay was based on research conducted the BBC archives
and an invited keynote given at the ABEI conference at the Federal
University of Parana, Brazil. It was peer-reviewed by MUP for
publication.
6. [Co-editor] (2013) The Woman Who Married Clark Gable by
Thaddeus O'Sullivan (with Beatriz Kopschitz Bastos). Sao Paulo:
USP/Humanitas. A critical, dual-language edition of O'Sullivan's 1985
screenplay and critical essays + subtitled DVD (Portuguese) published with
USP Brazil/Humanitas, the university publisher and Ciu Ludens, Sao Paulo,
an independent production company. REF2 submission. This series forms
part of a research agreement between St Mary's and USP (2011- ongoing)
and Pettitt is a nominated researcher for the WB Yeats Chair of Irish
Studies at USP.
Details of the impact
The impact feeds into a developing network of links with cultural and
community organizations in Britain and Ireland in particular, but
increasingly further afield. One of the key modes of impact for CIS is
exemplified in this case study, primarily working through public
engagement via networks and associations to achieve a concentrated reach
as defined by REF criteria. This successive public engagement has led to
impact through providing materials and interpretational tools by which
people can better understand cultural change and provoke societal
questioning of received ideas about Irish/migrant identity and Irish
history through screen media. The main findings of the research outlined
above in 2) have been successfully disseminated to audiences at screening
events and talks (listed below) and non-academic publications (The
Irish Post article, DVD booklet, Stones in his Pocket for
Tricycle Theatre programme notes) and discussions in community, national
and international settings.
The research has had demonstrable impact on the programming agendas of
cultural, educational and diplomatic organisations. Notable amongst these
is the online BBCNI/BUFVC resource `Chronicle' https://chronicle.bufvc.ac.uk
and http://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/latestnews/2012/chronicle.html
[access 10 Nov 2013] that repurposed BBC Northern Ireland film
archive material, curated it and provided critical context for the digital
platform. Pettitt served on its academic advisory board 2010-2011 and
participated in a user-workshop prior to the website launch in 2012.
Pettitt delivered invited talks and more formal lectures at
community/arts organisations, university venues with public attendance and
film festivals to audiences totalling over 800 individuals (attendance at
individual events where known shown in parentheses):
- Belfast Film Festival — 2009 and QFT — March 2012 `Uncle Jack' (84);
- Credited consultant — BBC4 television `Life through a local lens'. Tx.
July 2011 (Aud. 335,000 — with rpts). http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b012p58h
;
- Irish Arts, Leeds — Nov 2011 Seven Arts Centre — `The Gathering' (105)
and Nov 2012 (150);
- Irish Cultural Centre — July 2012 `Billy Plays' for the ICC adult
education evening class (28) and Feb 2013 `'Irish Writing London' day
conference (68);
- London Irish film festival — Nov 2011 `Opening Address' (250);
- Manchester's World Irish Centre — May 2012 `William Trevor' (24);
- Irish Literary Society, London — `Belfast Bohemian' Feb 2013 (47);
- Birkbeck College's London Screen Archive public film series on Hurst —
March 2012 (45) and on O'Sullivan's early Royal College of Art films for
`Diaspora Film' screening — May 2013 (27).
The research underpinning the case study has brought filmmakers and films
to the attention of curators and festival programmers in London/Dublin,
other city regions of the UK (Leeds, Manchester, Belfast) and Irish
department of foreign affairs-funded events in Brazil, Mozambique and
Argentina. The economic impact can be seen principally in the commissioned
production for retail of 1000 units of DVD and accompanying book (Output 6
above), but also in helping to sustain the vibrancy of cultural programmes
and providing the basis for future projects, including a "Story of the
London Irish" exhibit, research resource in Hammersmith and a forthcoming
retrospective festival of Hurst's films at the IFI, Dublin in 2014. Two
examples of impact products and events directly based on research
underpinning this case study include an educational DVD (March 2014) and a
travelling film festival in South America (August 2013) that are listed
below:
- [DVD] Thaddeus O'Sullivan: Early Films, 1974-1985. Curated
with introduction booklet by Lance Pettitt. 2-disk: 5 digitally
re-mastered archive films. Dublin: Irish Film Institute.
- Mostra de cinema Irlandes — Five events travelling film festival of
screenings, seminars and discussions with filmmaker and curator, three
of which include public arts venues and engagement between 6-27 August
2013.
Acknowledging that these fall beyond the impact census period (July 2013)
in terms of audience, we argue here that the significance of impact lies
in the influence exerted by the research on a government department
(Foreign Affairs in Brasilia and Buenos Aires) and a national heritage
institution in Dublin to publish the DVD and commit resource to the
festival schedule during the early part of 2013 within the census
period.
Sources to corroborate the impact
Individuals:
- Chief Executive or Project Researcher at BUFVC
- Cultural Attache, Embassy of Ireland, London
- General Manager, Irish Cultural Centre, Hammersmith.
- Irish Ambassador to Brazil and Argentina.
- Curator IFI, Dublin
Websites:
- BUFVC/BBC/JISC `Chronicle' https://chronicle.bufvc.ac.uk
-
The Uncle Jack — screening based on subtitled version of film
published in August 2011 — http://www.ccfmoz.com/agenda/cinéma-cinema/
[accessed 12 November 2013] This subtitled version was also screened in
Brasilia in 2013.
- CAIN website, University of Ulster. http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/images/cinema/pettitt/pettitt00.htm
- CINEUSP — Mostra in August 2013. Plus hard copy/poster/programme.
-
Southern Cross — newspaper item on Thaddeus' screening and film
work in Argentina, 2013.