Meeting the information needs of men with penile cancer
Submitting Institution
Leeds Metropolitan UniversityUnit of Assessment
Psychology, Psychiatry and NeuroscienceSummary Impact Type
HealthResearch Subject Area(s)
Medical and Health Sciences: Public Health and Health Services
Summary of the impact
Men with penile cancer often feel very isolated as they are reluctant to
talk to others about their condition, and as it is so rare, they do not
encounter others who have experienced it. Branney and colleagues' work has
produced a resource, available through the Health Talk Online website, for
men and their families: http://www.healthtalkonline.org/Cancer/Penile_Cancer.
Men with penile cancer are routinely signposted to this resource. An
exhibition of the project's findings has helped to raise awareness of the
condition in the general public. By increasing patient information
support, clinician insight and men's awareness of the condition, this
research has improved the quality of life of men with penile cancer.
Underpinning research
Branney, working with the Centre for Men's Health at Leeds Metropolitan
University, has undertaken a programme of work exploring how men engage
with healthcare, how they experience threats to their health, and how to
improve their experience of healthcare. Branney (Senior Research Fellow,
2009-12, Senior Lecturer in Psychology, 2012+) provides health psychology
expertise to the team, and alongside Gough, focuses on innovating the use
of qualitative methods in health-related research.
The research began with Branney piloting a participatory action research
methodology in which men with a health condition could themselves develop
an interview topic guide to explore experiences of living with it, their
choice of treatment and the extent to which their healthcare and
information needs are met by existing provision. Branney obtained funding
to run a feasibility study of using this approach with men with prostate
cancer (a feasibility study of patient-led interviews on the experiences
of choosing treatment after diagnosis of localised prostate cancer, funded
by the Leeds Teaching Hospitals Charitable Foundation in 2009, £9,308).
This was a collaborative study involving Branney (LMU), Sunjay (Urologist,
St James' Hospital) and the Leeds Prostate Cancer Carer Group. The study
demonstrated that the approach involving men themselves in the study
design could be successful.
When disseminating the results of the research to clinicians, discussions
highlighted that an area that lacks research is penile cancer.
Specifically, there was very little information available for men about
the condition and very little information for clinicians about men's
perspective about living with the condition and about their treatment
options. These discussions led to a successful grant application to
explore patient's experiences of this condition and its treatment and to
produce an information resource for men and people who care for them
(Patients' experiences of penile cancer: understanding and improving
experiences of treatment for penile cancer. Research for Patient Benefit
Programme, National Institute of Health Research. £172,207, 2010-2012).
The prostate cancer feasibility study was used to support the proposed
action research approach to producing a resource for men with penile
cancer. The research was a collaborative project led by Branney (Leeds
Met) and involving Eardley, (Urologist, St. James' University), Bullen
(Psychologist, Aberystwyth University), Ziebland (Medical Sociologist,
Oxford University), Edwards (Patient & Artist) and White (Professor of
Men's Health, Leeds Metropolitan University).
The research provided key insights into men's experiences of living with
penile cancer, including their diagnosis, telling other people, deciding
between treatment options, the impact on their sex life, and life
post-surgery. One of the findings was that while men do not feel confident
that they can talk to others about their cancer, there are major benefits
to their quality of life when they do so. It was apparent that there was a
need for a resource to help men talk about penile cancer. The research
also highlighted that while the treatment of penile cancer can be more
conservative if it is diagnosed earlier (e.g. a local excision rather than
an amputation) men often delay seeking help because they are unaware of
the symptoms.
References to the research
Branney, P., Jain, S., Hiley, C., Flowers, P., & White, A. K. (2009).
Choosing health, choosing treatment: patient choice after diagnosis of
localised prostate cancer. Urology, 74(5), p. 968-971 - http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/08870446.2010.502762
Branney, P., (2012). What is the UK Gender Duty and why is it linked to
men's health? Critical Public Health, 2(22),
121-126.http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09581596.2011.646955
Branney, P., Witty, K., Bagnall, A.-M., South, J., & White, A. K.
(2012). 'Straight to the GP; that would be where I would go': an analysis
of male frequent attenders' constructions of their decisions to use or not
use health-care services in the UK. Psychology and Health, 27(7), 865-880.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/08870446.2011.636443
South, J., Meah, A., & Branney, P. (2012). 'Think differently and be
prepared to demonstrate trust': findings from public hearings, England, on
supporting lay people in public health roles. Health Promotion
International, 27(2), 284-294. doi: 10.1093/heapro/dar022
South, J., Meah, A., Bagnall, A.M., Kinsella, K., Branney, P. , White,
J., & Gamsu, M. (2010). People in public health — a study of
approaches to develop and support people in public health roles.
Southampton, UK: National Co-ordinating Centre for NHS Service Delivery
and Organisation R&D. http://www.netscc.ac.uk/hsdr/files/project/SDO_FR_08-1716-206_V01.pdf
Details of the impact
Branney's work to disseminate his research on men's use of healthcare and
their treatment decisions to clinicians meant that a very specific
healthcare need — information for men on penile cancer — was identified
and a project team assembled to address this need. From the start of the
project the aim was to produce a resource that could inform men, their
families and their clinicians about this condition. While the team
initially comprised of clinicians and researchers in Leeds, it was
apparent that the resource produced would be of value nationally and so
the team was expanded to include Bullen (Aberystwyth), who had done some
earlier work on penile cancer, and Ziebland (Oxford), from the research
team behind Health Talk Online. Health Talk Online is a resource used by
people with the condition, their families and carers and clinicians.
The main output from the project is a resource for Health Talk Online.
This includes downloadable videos of 27 men talking about their
experiences of penile cancer and an information resource on the condition.
The men who participated in the study identified the information they
wanted to make available. This included signs and symptoms of penile
cancer, the treatment options, recovering from surgery, and some of the
concerns that men have such as how to tell other people about their
cancer, using the toilet, the effect on sex and relationships, and the
impact of surgery on men's sense of masculinity and confidence. This
resource was launched in the summer of 2012 and has already received over
237,000 hits and 22,000 views. A launch event took place at the Royal
Society on 23/10/12 and was attended by academics, relevant charities and
the general public.
To further disseminate the results of this research and increase public
awareness of penile cancer Branney and the team produced an art
installation that forms a travelling exhibition. This includes quotes from
the interviews illustrated by art from one of the patients and
grantholders who is also an artist (Edwards). This exhibition has been
installed in several venues in the UK:
- Biannual Conference, International Society of Critical Health
Psychology, Bradford University, 22nd-24th July 2013.
- St. James' Hospital, Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, 3rd-14th June
2013.
- Aberystwyth University, 22nd-26th April 2013.
- World Cancer Day & the first week of semester 2 teaching, Leeds
Metropolitan University, February 4th-8th 2013.
- Aston University, October 26th 2013.
It is typically installed for several days and open for the public to
view, sometimes accompanied by a series of presentations.
Branney has also talked about the research on the Radio 4 programme
Inside Health. A whole programme was dedicated to Penile Cancer and the
work of Branney and his team was central to the programme. This was first
broadcast on 24/10/12 and is available on the BBC iplayer. This programme
led to further interest in the research, and several articles and
editorials have been written that include reference to his research, e.g.
- Ally Fogg, When is it OK for a cancer campaign to be sexy? Comment is
Free, The Guardian, Wednesday 24th October, 2013
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/oct/24/cancer-campaign-sexual-hook
- Making men think about cancer, Yorkshire Evening Post, Wed 7th Nov
2012
- Penile cancer module gives men forum to shout about it, Clinical
Focus, Primary Care Today, November/December 2012, p. 31
The beneficiaries of this research are therefore:
- Men with penile cancer who can now access a resource that provides
information, answers their questions, helps reduce their feelings of
isolation, and helps them talk to others about their cancer. It can also
help them talk to their clinicians about their treatment options;
- The families and friends of men with penile cancer who can use the
resource to help them talk about the condition and its effects;
- Clinicians, who gain insight into what it is like to be diagnosed with
and to live with penile cancer;
- Students (e.g. medical students, nursing students, psychology
students) who can visit the website to gain insight into living with
this condition.
- Men more generally who are more aware of penile cancer and its signs
and symptoms and so may seek help earlier should they have this
condition.
Sources to corroborate the impact
- Health Talk Online web resource on penile cancer:
http://www.healthtalkonline.org/Cancer/Penile_cancer
- Penile cancer nurse specialist, St James Hospital, Leeds
- Orchid Cancer Charity (the men's cancer charity) has provided the
following statement:
"We routinely signpost men with penile cancer to Health Talk Online.
It's made a big difference. Penile cancer is such a rare condition
that men are not going to meet other men with it. It's particularly
useful for men who are having treatment or who are survivors. They can
identify with other men who have been diagnosed, been treated and who
have got through it."
(Male Cancer Information Nurse, ORCHID)