Influencing DVD release strategies (British cinema)
Submitting Institution
University of East AngliaUnit of Assessment
Communication, Cultural and Media Studies, Library and Information Management Summary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Studies In Creative Arts and Writing: Film, Television and Digital Media
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies
Summary of the impact
Drawing on their insight and knowledge of British cinema history, Keith
M. Johnston and Melanie
Williams established partnerships with DVD releasing companies Studio
Canal UK and Network
Distributing. Applying and transferring their specific research insights
and knowledge (around
gender and technology in British cinema history) led to wealth creation
and added value for these
commercial organisations.
This was achieved through creating a research-led strategy that
identified lesser-known catalogue
titles for release, and contributing research knowledge through special
features material for
Woman in a Dressing Gown (1957; 2012 DVD release) and The
Ealing Rarities Collections
volumes 1-6 (2013 DVD releases).
Underpinning research
Johnston and Williams were employed to reinforce and expand the
University of East Anglia's
(UEA) reputation as a centre of British cinema scholarship. Developing the
legacy of UEA
academics such as Andrew Higson and especially Charles Barr, Williams'
research pursued
questions of gender through British cinema history, notably the
representation of women through
lesser known films such as Woman in a Dressing Gown (J Lee
Thompson, 1957), Ice Cold in Alex
(Thompson, 1958) and Dance Hall (Basil Dearden, 1950), and the
work of female workers within
the British film industry, particularly the `continuity girls' who worked
with directors such as David
Lean. This work challenged existing preconceptions of gender within
British cinema, demonstrating
a feminist sensibility within specific examples of film aesthetics,
narrative, and industry policy
(Williams 2008, 2012), audience memory (2013b), and arguing for more
attention to be paid to the
`invisible' creative input of female film personnel (2013a).
Johnston's work focused on British cinema's adoption (and resistance to)
technological changes
such as colour and 3D. Challenging and expanding Barr's seminal work on
Ealing Studios (3rd
edition, 1999) which placed the studio within a national tradition of
realism and restraint, Johnston's
research revealed the studio's overlooked experiments with the spectacle
offered by colour
cinematography and widescreen processes (Johnston 2010, 2012). Johnston
revisited all 95
Ealing films produced between 1938 and 1959 for a regular series of online
articles for the
Huffington Post UK (www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/dr-keith-m-johnston/, also
available via
www.keithmjohnston.blogspot.com), revealing and emphasising the studios'
fantastic and
spectacular heritage, and further challenging traditional perceptions of
its place within the British
film industry.
Identifying shared research interests (notably around Ealing Studios),
Williams and Johnston
developed joint projects that consolidated their expertise in this area:
- A series of research reports for DVD distributing companies (detailed
below) on British film
titles from the 1930s to the 1960s
- Instigating and enhancing a new collection of essays about Ealing
Studios with partners
from the British Film Institute and the University of Hull: Ealing
Revisited (2012)
- Consulting on the `Ealing: Light and Dark' season at BFI Southbank in
November-
December 2012, and providing screening introductions and printed notes
for selected films
KEY RESEARCHERS, POSITIONS, DATES
The research was undertaken by:
Dr Keith M. Johnston (Senior Lecturer, UEA, 2008-present)
Dr Melanie Williams (Senior Lecturer, UEA, 2009-present)
References to the research
KEY OUTPUTS
1. Johnston, Keith M. (2010) `Ealing's Colour Aesthetic: Saraband for
Dead Lovers,' Journal of
British Cinema and Television 7, 1: pp. 21-33.
2. Johnston, Keith M. (2012) `"A riot of all the colours in the rainbow':
Ealing Studios in
Colour.' In Mark Duguid, Lee Freeman, Keith M. Johnston and Melanie
Williams (eds.),
Ealing Revisited, London: Palgrave, pp. 195-205.
3. Williams, Melanie (2008), `Twilight Women of 1950s British Cinema'. In
Robert Murphy
(ed.) The British Cinema Book (3rd edition) London:
BFI, pp. 286-95.
4. Williams, Melanie (2012) `A Feminine Touch? Ealing's Women'. In Ealing
Revisited, pp.
185-94.
5. Williams, Melanie (2013a), `The Continuity Girl: Ice in the Middle of
Fire' Journal of British
Cinema and Television 10, 3: pp. 603-17
6. Williams, Melanie (2013b) `"Remembering `the poor soul walking in the
rain': Audience
Responses to a Thwarted makeover in Woman in a Dressing Gown
(1957)' Journal of
British Cinema and Television 10, 4: pp. 709-26.
JUSTIFICATION OF QUALITY
The six research articles or book chapters went through rigorous
peer-reviewing before they were
accepted for publication in their respective journal titles or
collections. The presence of three
articles in the Journal of British Cinema and Television (a key
peer-reviewed journal in this field),
and the involvement of BFI staff as co-editors of Ealing Revisited
with Johnston and Williams, are
also strong indications of quality.
Additionally, Ealing Revisited was selected as one of The
Independent's `Books of the Year 2012'
and described as `an intriguing and enlightening collection' (Independent
2012).
Details of the impact
The Process
After the publication of his first article on Ealing's Saraband for
Dead Lovers (Johnston 2010),
Johnston contacted Studio Canal UK (then operating under the name Optimum
Releasing) to
discuss the release strategy for its Ealing Studios Collection range.
Liaising with Candy Vincent-
Smith (then Optimum's Head of Catalogue Development, DVD), it became clear
that Optimum
would welcome research-led support around catalogue development. Johnston
and Williams were
then given unrestricted (and unparalleled) access to the Optimum back
catalogue of British cinema
titles, and asked to use their research expertise to suggest titles, shape
future catalogue
development, and contribute to Optimum's commercial success.
In 2012, Studio Canal UK licensed 450 titles from its British cinema
catalogue to Network
Distributing, another DVD company with which Johnston had a relationship.
Network's Head of
Marketing, Hugh David, contacted Johnston for a series of research reports
(based partly on work
already undertaken, but with a focus on a range of titles from the Ealing
Studios back catalogue):
again, the research expertise of Johnston and Williams was sought in order
to ascertain potential
titles for DVD release and to support Network's commercial success through
that release
programme.
Studio Canal UK and Network Distributing are, alongside Granada and the
BFI, responsible for
releasing the bulk of British cinema DVDs within the UK. They play a
significant role in the creation
of the British cinema DVD canon and demonstrate the important function
that academic research
can have on these gatekeepers, most notably around the wider cultural
rediscovery and
popularisation of older catalogue film titles.
Impacts and Benefits
Studio Canal:
- Studio Canal UK believe that Johnston/Williams' `academic research...
translates into
commercial activity' and is essential to improving `our knowledge of the
catalogue and the
release potential therein' (Vincent-Smith, March 2012)
- Studio Canal's decision to re-release Woman in a Dressing Gown
on DVD (and in a limited
cinema release) was propelled by Williams' research (2008, 2013b) and
recommendation
of it as a key title in British cinema
- Williams' championing of the film `as a feminist text' led directly to
Studio Canal applying for
funding from the Independent Cinema Office to release it as a
`culturally important film'
(ibid.). The film was subsequently screened at 39 cinemas across the UK
in August-
September 2012
- Studio Canal noted that special features such as Williams' interview
on the DVD would
`help sell DVDs' and would `legitimise' the release (ibid.)
- The Woman in a Dressing Gown DVD subsequently sold 2120 units
(British Video
Association (BVA) figures: Green, September 2013), described by
Vincent-Smith as a
`good' return for a catalogue release
- Johnston and Williams' recommendations from the catalogue also
included Dance Hall and
Nowhere to Go (1958), subsequently released on DVD by Studio
Canal UK in 2012-13
Network Distributing:
- Johnston's Ealing research (2010, 2012) `directly impacted the choices
and content for
releases in that series [Network's The Ealing Rarities Collection]...
the commercial value of
his... contribution is large indeed' (Hugh David, February 2013)
- Network had released 6 volumes of The Ealing Rarities Collections
(each containing four
films) by the time of submission
- Johnston's research around Network's 450 licensed titles `was huge...
doing work of a
depth and scale that we simply could not achieve in day-to-day industry
activity, confirming
some professional instincts, dismissing others, and speeding up the
process as a whole of
commercial assessments on this vast archive' (ibid.)
- By 16th September 2013, the first six Ealing Rarities
collections had sold a combined total
of 3827 units (Volume 1: 920; Vol. 2: 1038; Vol. 3: 739; Vol. 4: 521;
Vol. 5.: 388; Vol. 6:
221) (BVA figures: Green, 2013)
The impact here, then, is a direct contribution to wealth creation within
the DVD sector of the
creative industries, adding value to commercial projects through Johnston
and Williams' academic
research and the transfer of that knowledge to specific DVD distribution
partners. Williams' work on
Woman in a Dressing Gown (2008, 2013b) impacted Studio Canal's
plans for a DVD release and
created cause for a nationwide cinema re-release; Studio Canal relied on
Williams and Johnston to
expand their Ealing DVD range; and Network planned their 2013 Ealing range
around Johnston's
recommendations. In all these cases, the research impact has been on the
strategic and
commercial imperatives of Studio Canal UK and Network Distributing.
Studio Canal UK's business benefitted economically from Johnston and
Williams' research on
British cinema. It continues to `use their research to identify possible
commercial areas of
opportunity further in advance' (Vincent-Smith, March 2012); while Network
see the collaboration
as `huge', `making commercial assessments' that `impacted the choices and
content' of their
release strategy (David, February 2013).
Sources to corroborate the impact
- E-mail from Studio Canal UK (UK Catalogue Consultant, March 2012) -
quoted above
- E-mail from former Head of Marketing, Network (March 2013) - quoted
above
- Review 1 of Woman in a Dressing Gown DVD release (with
reference to Williams'
contribution to the disc): http://film.thedigitalfix.com/content/id/75809/woman-indressing-gown.html
- Review 2 of Woman in a Dressing Gown DVD release (with
reference to Williams'
contribution to the disc): http://www.eyeforfilm.co.uk/review/woman-in-a-dressing-gown-1957-film-review-by-neil-mitchell
- Review 3 of Woman in a Dressing Gown DVD release (with
reference to Williams'
contribution to the disc): http://www.reviewedonline.co.uk/dvd/2012/0812/1608/woman-in-adressing-
gown-dvd-film-review/woman-in-a-dressing-gown-dvd-film-review.htm
- Copy of Woman in a Dressing Gown DVD cover (indicating
presence of Williams' interview
in special features)
- E-mail from Fusion Media Sales (September 2013) confirming British
Video Association
sales figures for Woman in a Dressing Gown and Network's Ealing
Rarities Collections
(volumes 1-6)
- IOC reviews and list of cinemas that screened Woman in a Dressing
Gown
-
The Independent review of Ealing Revisited: http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-
entertainment/books/reviews/ios-books-of-the-year-2012-cinema-8373713.html