The public understanding of Jews and other minorities in the Great War
Submitting Institution
University of ChesterUnit of Assessment
HistorySummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Philosophy and Religious Studies: History and Philosophy of Specific Fields
Summary of the impact
Speaking in 2012, David Cameron declared proudly that the Great War is `a
fundamental part of
our national consciousness'. But what is acknowledged far less is the role
of minority groups in the
conflict. Jews, national minorities and colonial troops all fought and
died at the front. Tim Grady
has helped to push this knowledge to the centre of the public's
understanding. His talks, magazine
articles, podcasts and consultancy work have raised awareness of the
diverse range of voices
involved in the First World War, highlighting the impact of other
combatants, as well as the
involvement of the Jewish community.
Underpinning research
Over the last decade, Grady has undertaken a large body of research on
German Jews'
experience and commemoration of the First World War. This work originally
began as a PhD
project at the University of Southampton (2003-2006). Then from 2008,
following his appointment
as Lecturer in History at the University of Chester and from 2010 as
Senior Lecturer, Grady has
deepened insight into the subject still further. He conducted archival
research in Britain, Germany
and Israel, while at the same time adding to his core case studies with
work on the Jewish
communities in Munich and Dresden.
During his time at Chester, Grady has published a series of important
articles on German-Jewish
history and, most recently, the highly acclaimed book, The
German-Jewish Soldiers of the First
World War in History and Memory. This is the first major study to
consider how the German-Jewish
communities were involved both in the conflict itself as well as in
shaping Germany's post-war
memory culture.
In particular, Grady's work in this field has examined how Jews and other
Germans remembered
some 100,000 Jewish soldiers who fought in the German army. One of the
most significant aspects
of this approach has been the temporal breadth of historical study. His
work has investigated this
group of soldiers not just during the Great War itself but also across
three subsequent eras of
German history: the Weimar Republic, National Socialist Germany and the
post-war Federal
Republic.
The picture that emerges from this historical investigation is of a group
of soldiers who were active
participants in Germany's memory culture both during and immediately after
the war. With the
decline of the Weimar Republic, the public commemoration of the Jewish
soldiers faded, as
Germany's Jewish communities were systematically destroyed by the Nazi
regime. It was only very
gradually after the Second World War that both Jews and other Germans
began to rediscover and
to re-remember this largely neglected group.
Grady's research, therefore, reveals how contested memories of the First
World War fed into
Nazism and genocide, and how, since 1945, Germans have attempted to move
beyond these
dangerous legacies. Each of these deeply debated themes has great
significance for
understanding the contours of twentieth century European history.
Placed together, they also demonstrate how German Jews played an active
role in shaping
modern German history not just as victims but also as participants. As a
consequence, it is clear
that Grady's research is not only of academic importance, but is also of
considerable relevance to
the wider public on both a national and an international level.
References to the research
1. The German-Jewish Soldiers of the First World War in History and
Memory (Liverpool:
Liverpool University Press, 2011).
2. `Creating Difference: The Racialisation of Germany's Jewish Soldiers
after the First World
War', Patterns of Prejudice, 46 (3-4) (2012), pp. 318-338.
3. `Fighting a Lost Battle: The Reichsbund jüdischer Frontsoldaten
and the Rise of National
Socialism', German History, 28 (1) (2010), pp. 1-20.
4. `"They died for Germany": Jewish Soldiers, the German Army and
Conservative Debates
about the Nazi Past in the 1960s', European History Quarterly, 39
(1) (2009), pp. 27-46.
5. `A Common Experience of Death: Commemorating the German-Jewish
Soldiers of the First
World War, 1914-1923', in Alon Confino, Dirk Schumann and Paul Betts
(eds), Between
Mass Death and Individual Loss: The Place of the Dead in
Twentieth-Century Germany
(New York / Oxford: Berghahn, 2008), pp. 179-96.
All five publications listed above appear in high quality journals and/or
books. As a marker of
esteem, Grady's monograph has received highly positive reviews in The
American Historical
Review, Central European History, English Historical
Review, Historische Zeitschrift, Vingtième
Siècle: Revue d'histoire and on H-Net. The book was also
awarded proxime accessit for the
Gladstone Prize of the Royal Historical Society in 2012. The three journal
articles have been
published in leading, peer reviewed, journals in the field of European
history. The chapter (number
5 above) appears in a volume edited by three leading scholars of German
history. As a sign of its
quality, the volume as a whole has also received warm praise in
international journal reviews.
References 1, 3, 4 and 5 have been submitted in REF2, item 2 can be
supplied if requested.
Details of the impact
As the centenary of the First World War approaches, the remembrance of
the conflict has taken on
a new poignancy. Equally important, though, is the type of remembering
that is undertaken. As
Hew Strachan recently argued, the challenge of commemoration today is to
ensure that the public
looks beyond `the mud of the Western Front' to remember the contribution
of Commonwealth
countries and other minority groups (Daily Telegraph, 11.01.2013).
Grady's work goes to the heart
of this agenda. He has utilised his impressive range of academic research
to make the wider public
aware of the role of other combatants, while at the same time helping
ensure the Jewish
contribution to the war is not forgotten.
Grady first brought the history of minority participation in the First
World War to a wider audience
through a number of popular publications. Most significantly, in 2011 he
authored a feature for the
magazine History Today on West Germany and its Jewish soldiers. He
also contributed a shorter
piece to the popular French magazine, Books. To reach an even
larger section of the public, Grady
followed up these publications with a podcast on Jews in the Great War on
the History Today
website. Together these different forms of media helped to foster a debate
over how the German-
Jewish soldiers should be commemorated which played out in History
Today's letters page.
Alongside this published work, Grady has also sought to reach a
non-academic audience through
an extensive programme of public lectures across the North West of
England. Over the last four
years, he has spoken about wartime minorities to audiences as diverse as
the Rotary Club and the
Grosvenor Museum in Chester. As a representative of the Grosvenor Museum
commented, these
talks made a `distinctive and important contribution [...] to the museum's
public programmes'.
The second strand of his impact activity has seen Grady working with
military history and veterans'
organisations. As these groups are now the primary holders of the war's
memory, it is crucial that
they place greater emphasis on the role of minorities in the conflict. To
this end, Grady has
organised a series of lectures with the Western Front Association - a
non-academic organisation
dedicated to understanding the war. To date, he has spoken to several of
the group's branches on
German Jews and the Great War: North Wales, 03.09.2011 (audience 30);
Merseyside,
06.09.2012 (audience 25); Lancashire and Chester, 14.12.2012 (audience
45). At the same time,
Grady has also been heavily involved in a series of remembrance workshops
at the National
Memorial Arboretum which brought together academics with members of the
British Legion and the
British armed forces. In May 2011, he spoke to these collected groups
about Jews in the First
World War (25 participants). Taken together, this activity has helped to
embed narratives of the
wartime experience of minorities into a wider memory culture.
A third strand of Grady's efforts has led him to engage with Jewish
community groups. This
process began when he launched his monograph at the Wiener Library in
London on 16.02.2012
(audience 30). The Library is not only an internationally recognised
centre for Holocaust research,
but is also an important hub for first and second generation Jewish
survivors of the Nazi genocide.
By choosing this forum, Grady was able to reach individuals who had a
direct connection to the
Great War and to help many of those in the audience piece together aspects
of their own personal
histories. For example, local media coverage of the event led a daughter
of a German-Jewish war
veteran to recount her own memories of the war in a lengthy letter. She
even gifted Grady a copy
of her father's own 1920 memorial book for the Jewish war dead of
Nuremberg. By giving the
Jewish soldiers of the Great War public recognition, therefore, Grady has
provided surviving family
members with a means to remember their own loved ones. A series of letters
in the Association of
Jewish Refugees' newsletter, written in response to Grady's work confirmed
this analysis, as a
number of respondents recalled their own family's role in the First World
War.
Over the next year, with plans for the war's centenary already in motion,
the influence of Grady's
work will continue. Indeed, in November 2011 he advised museum
professionals in the Association
of European Jewish Museums as to how they could best exhibit the Jewish
war experience in 2014
(audience 20). This event highlighted the crucial significance of his
research for furthering popular
understanding, as well as its direct impact on the wider heritage sector.
Sources to corroborate the impact
1. Corroborating information in paragraph two on Grady's work to reach a
wider audience:
2. Information to corroborate public lectures in paragraph three:
- Copies of emails of appreciation from the Grosvenor Museum, Chester
are held on file by
the University.
3. Sources for paragraph four on Grady's collaboration with military
groups:
4. Corroborating information for paragraph five on engagement with Jewish
community groups:
5. Heritage links, as outlined in paragraph six: