Dr Williams’s Centre for Dissenting Studies: research benefiting an independent library and its users
Submitting Institution
Queen Mary, University of LondonUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Information and Computing Sciences: Library and Information Studies
Language, Communication and Culture: Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
The Dr Williams's Centre for Dissenting Studies, a collaboration between
the Queen Mary English Department and Dr Williams's Library, Gordon
Square, London, has undertaken a long-term and ongoing programme of funded
research projects, public engagement events, and publications in print and
online. Dr Williams's Library is a non-HEI (owned by Dr Williams's Trust,
Charity number 214926) dedicated to the preservation and study of
collections related to the history of Protestant dissent. Prof Isabel
Rivers (QMUL 2004-), and Dr David Wykes, Director of the Library, founded
the Centre in 2004 because of their mutual interest in the field. The work
of the Centre's Queen Mary researchers, including publications hosted on
the Centre's website, has enhanced the public profile of the Library,
improved its accessibility to the wider public, and transformed the public
understanding of the history of Protestant dissent.
Underpinning research
The Dr Williams's Centre for Dissenting Studies began in 2004 as a
collaboration between Prof Isabel Rivers, and Dr David Wykes, Director of
Dr Williams's Library. The collaboration aimed to utilise the Library's
unique but then under-researched holdings of books and manuscripts to
increase knowledge and understanding of the importance of puritanism and
Protestant dissent in English society and literature. Protestant
dissenters who would not conform to the Church of England were
criminalized after the Restoration of Charles II; though the Act of
Toleration of 1689 granted Presbyterians, Congregationalists, Baptists,
and Quakers freedom to worship, they remained second-class citizens till
the early nineteenth century, and developed their own parallel religious,
intellectual, and literary traditions. Through a programme of research
(including funded projects, conferences, studentships, and fellowships), a
series of publications, both print and digital, and online databases,
Queen Mary researchers at the Centre have since transformed public
awareness of the culture of Protestant dissent.
Initial publications by Rivers (2003) and Wykes (1996) had identified the
importance of the history of the dissenting academies — educational
institutions intended to provide Protestant students dissenting from the
Church of England with a higher education similar to that at Oxford and
Cambridge, from which they were largely excluded. The Leverhulme and AHRC
funded Dissenting Academies Project led by Rivers is creating a
comprehensive, archive-based history that has already increased, through
its published online databases, scholarly understanding of the importance
of the Protestant dissenting academies to higher education and
intellectual life in Britain and overseas for a period of two hundred
years.
The research is based on manuscript and print sources, predominantly in
Dr Williams's Library, but also in a wide range of repositories, including
Bristol Baptist College, Harris Manchester College, National Library of
Wales, John Rylands Library, Manchester, and Castle Hill United Reformed
Church, Northampton. The researchers have so far entered in a relational
database c.230 academies, 700 tutors, 4,300 archival sources, and
10,000 students; 63 academy histories and 52 tutor biographies have been
published, with many more being written and edited. It is now possible to
make chronological, regional, and denominational (Congregational,
Presbyterian, Baptist, or Methodist) or theological comparisons of academy
size, subjects studied, kinds of student, entry requirements,
qualifications of tutors, students' subsequent careers, and student and
academy funding.
Online digital open-access publication has been key to the Centre's
research programme. By entering the material into databases, and
establishing cross-cutting relations between the data, Rivers and the
Centre's team of post-doctoral researchers have developed a new history of
dissenting education and culture. A relational database of The Surman
Index, a card catalogue of c.32,000 Congregational ministers
held at the Library, funded by a British Academy Small Grant to Wykes, was
published by the Centre in 2009. This was later integrated into the
Centre's innovative large-scale resource, Dissenting Academies Online
(2011), which publishes the records of dissenting higher education,
1660-1860, in two linked databases: the Database and Encyclopedia,
containing c.15,000 entries on students, tutors, archives, and
academies, together with academy histories and tutor biographies; and the
Virtual Library System, a unique union catalogue recording c.20,000
catalogue records of seven leading Baptist, Congregational, and
Presbyterian academy libraries in England. With c.30,000
individual borrowings from some of these libraries included, the Virtual
Library System illuminates the reading practices of students and
tutors. The Centre's collaborative doctoral students have published online
editions of manuscripts held by Dr Williams's and other libraries: sources
for John Jennings's academy, letters of Joseph Priestley, and the archives
of New College, Hackney.
In January 2013 Dr James Vigus succeeded Rivers as Co-Director of the
Centre. Vigus's previous work (including 2010, 2013) on the very extensive
collection of Henry Crabb Robinson's manuscripts held at the Library
underpins a major new research project at the Centre. The Crabb
Robinson Project was launched on 12 July 2013 through a workshop at
the Library funded by a British Academy/Leverhulme Trust Small Grant (to
Vigus). Under the general editorship of Prof Timothy Whelan (Senior
Visiting Fellow) it will publish a multi-volume critical edition of
Robinson's Reminiscences and Diary with OUP over the next 15
years.
Practice has been shared through the four AHRC collaborative doctoral
projects Rivers has supervised with Wykes; Wykes has regularly contributed
to the department's MA seminars, introducing students to the library's
archives. The doctoral students have made research presentations to the
Library Committee of Dr Williams's Trust.
The archival research and editorial work presented in the databases has
been accompanied by a series of print publications on dissenting literary
culture. Rivers (2009) established the parameters for the study of
religious publishing in the eighteenth century. Whitehouse (2010) and
Rivers (2010) applied these general principles to the edition of the New
Testament by the tutor and hymn writer Philip Doddridge, which he designed
for both a student and family audience, to show how dissenting academy
scholarship was disseminated through astute publishing strategies. The
Centre has published five edited collections arising from its conferences,
two edited by Rivers and Wykes, including Dissenting Praise
(2011).
Key researchers at submitting unit:
(i) Isabel Rivers: Professor, QMUL 2004-, co-director of the Centre
2004-12
(ii) James Vigus: Visiting Fellow (while Post-Doctoral Research Fellow at
Ludwig Maximilian University, Munich) 2009-12; Lecturer, QMUL 2012-;
co-director of the Centre 2013-;
(iii) Tessa Whitehouse: QMUL Collaborative Doctoral Award Student
2007-11, Lecturer QMUL 2012-
(iv) Post-Doctoral Research Fellows: Simon Dixon (QMUL 2008-11); Rosemary
Dixon (QMUL 2009-11); Kyle Roberts (QMUL 2009-11)
(v) Collaborative Doctoral Award Students: Simon Mills (QMUL 2005-09);
Stephen Burley (QMUL 2007-11); Mark Burden (QMUL 2007-11)
(vi) Post-Doctoral Research Assistants: Benjamin Bankhurst (QMUL
2012-13); Rachel Eckersley (QMUL 2012-13)
References to the research
1. Rivers, Isabel, `Religious Publishing', in The Cambridge History
of the Book in Britain, vol. 5, 1695-1830, ed. Michael
Suarez and Michael Turner (Cambridge University Press, 2009), 579-600.
ISBN: 978-0521810173 — book chapter, can be supplied by the HEI on
request; quality justification: positive peer reviews.
2. Rivers, Isabel, `Philip Doddridge's New Testament: The Family
Expositor (1739-56)', in The King James Bible after 400 Years:
Literary, Linguistic and Cultural Influences, ed. Hannibal Hamlin
and Norman Jones (Cambridge University Press, 2010), 124-45. ISBN:
978-1107654136 — book chapter, can be supplied by the HEI on request;
quality justification: positive peer reviews: for example Diarmaid
MacCulloch, LRB 33:3 (3 February 2011). Submitted REF2014.
3. Rivers, Isabel, and David L. Wykes (ed.), Dissenting Praise:
Religious Dissent and the Hymn in England and Wales (Oxford
University Press, 2011). 299pp. ISBN 978-0199545247 — edited collection,
can be supplied by the HEI on request; quality justification:
peer-reviewed publication. Introduction demonstrates the collaboration
directly. Positively reviewed on publication: `The importance of the hymn
may have dwindled in popular culture, but it is still crucial in
understanding cultural development and religious identity of the
seventeenth to the nineteenth centuries. This is an ideal guide, and
invaluable resource, for such scholarship.' Felicity James, The Review
of English Studies 63:261 (2012).
4. Vigus, James, `"All are but parts of one stupendous whole"? Henry
Crabb Robinson's Dilemma', in Symbol and Intuition: Comparative
Studies in Kantian and Romantic-Period Aesthetics, ed. Helmut Hühn
and James Vigus (Legenda, 2013), 123-38. ISBN: 978-1907625046 — book
chapter, can be supplied by the HEI on request; quality justification:
this chapter builds on Vigus's edition Henry Crabb Robinson: Essays on
Kant, Schelling, and German Aesthetics (MHRA, 2010): positively
reviewed on publication: `an essential text for anyone interested in late
Enlightenment and early Romantic thought in Germany and in what Robinson
did to disseminate that thought beyond the borders of the German-speaking
world.' Eugene Stelzig, New Books On Literature 19, (28 June
2011). Both items submitted REF 2014.
5. Whitehouse, Tessa, `The Family Expositor, the Doddridge Circle
and the Booksellers', The Library, 7th ser., 11:3 (2010), 321-44 —
Journal article, can be supplied by the HEI on
request; quality justification: peer reviewed journal.
Funded by: Leverhulme Trust (Research Project Grant, ref. F/07 476/AG)
£247,173; AHRC Religion and Society Programme (Large Grant, ref.
AH/G014019/1) £366,269; AHRC Follow-On Fund (ref. AH/J008656/1) £95,821.
Details of the impact
The Centre's research, events, and publications can be shown to have had
an impact on the work of Dr Williams's Library and those who use its
collections, on the varied audiences for the Centre's events, on Bristol
Baptist College (a non HEI), and on a much wider global audience who use
the databases. The Centre's research and publications have also
transformed public and academic understanding of the field of Protestant
dissent, contributing to the re-evaluation of its cultural legacy.
Enhancing access to Library resources
The Centre's research projects have brought a new and very demanding
readership to the Library, which has made it a stimulating place to work.
The Queen Mary researchers' need to consult manuscripts regularly has
meant that the Library has focused on preparation of these for reading and
has implemented conservation plans. The digitization projects have made
previously unknown material accessible; transcription and summaries have
made information much easier to interpret; the relational databases have
created new open-access knowledge. The online articles written by Rivers,
Wykes and their team for the Database and Encyclopedia have
provided an entirely new history of dissenting higher education for both
academic and general readers. The Surman Index Online allowed the
typed card catalogue, hitherto usable in the Library alone, to be
consulted all over the world. The editorial projects, especially The
Crabb Robinson Project, for which Vigus is Assistant Editor, benefit
the Library by saving fragile manuscripts from wear through use. The
Dissenting Academies Project has also had an impact on another
non-HEI, Bristol Baptist College, where much of its archive was
uncatalogued. In 2009-10 the Centre's Post-Doctoral Research Fellows
entered its manuscript catalogues into the Centre's Virtual Library
System where the records are fully searchable by the public.
Transforming public understanding of Protestant dissent
Queen Mary researchers in the Centre have raised the Library's public
profile through a strategic programme of public engagement. The digital
databases are free and open-access, and have been used extensively by
non-academic audiences around the world, especially those interested in
family history, genealogy, and church history. Most of the Centre's events
are open to the public, the seminars are free, and are regularly attended
by non-academics (33 seminars in the REF period). The public events (the
seminar series and annual conferences) have brought in a wide range of
attendees, some of whom then become library users. Thus for the Dissenting
Hymn conference, a large number of members of the Hymn Society attended;
for the Nonconformist Architecture conference, arranged with the Chapels
Society, many members of that society attended. On average the attendance
at seminars is 15-20 and at conferences 50 to 70. Public engagement
road-shows, organised by the Centre, demonstrated the new digital
resources to audiences at Harris Manchester College, Oxford, John Rylands
Library, Manchester, and the Leeds Library. The online resources have
generated high numbers of unique users in 2012 (the first complete year):
Database and Encyclopedia: 6419; Surman: 9326; Virtual Library System:
9302. In the period June 2011 to July 2013 inclusive, the databases
received 780,357 page views, demonstrating that users engage with the
resources in a deep manner.
Enhancing the Library
Queen Mary's support for the Centre has been highly beneficial for the
Library. Queen Mary, through the Faculty and the Department, has supported
the Centre with resources and staff time to sustain the collaboration with
the Library; hosted the research fellows, research assistants, technical
assistant, and doctoral students; provided funding (£18,000 2004-07,
£15,930 2008-2013) to support the Centre's events at the Library; and
provided the Centre with web and publication design services and computing
resources for the development, mounting and maintenance of the databases.
Collaboration with the Centre's researchers has played an important part
in the Library's recent and ongoing programme of enhancements. For
instance, the Centre has provided the Library with a specialist camera and
tripod for making high-resolution images of print and manuscript,
purchased using AHRC funding for one of the Centre's projects. Rivers and
Vigus served on a Working Group of the Friends of Dr Williams's Library
that has submitted a detailed report containing recommendations for the
further development of the Library's reader services and its research
profile in the longer term. In the wake of the QMUL large grants from the
Leverhulme Trust and the AHRC, the Library has obtained small grants from
a number of different bodies: Manchester Academy Trust, Manchester
Memorial Hall Trust, Congregational Memorial Hall Trust, and Pilgrim
Trust. Through the work of the Centre's Queen Mary researchers, and their
publications and databases, Dr Williams's Library, a charitable
institution dedicated to the preservation and study of Protestant dissent,
has wider reach and significance, and its resources can increasingly be
consulted globally. In his letter corroborating this impact statement,
Wykes has commented: `The collaboration has been an outstanding success;
it has achieved everything and more that the Trustees had hoped when the
Centre was established in 2004. It has not only enhanced the work and
reputation of the Library, it has been of direct benefit to its staff,
members, and the wider dissenting community.'
Sources to corroborate the impact
Individual
- Director, Dr Williams's Library; for increased use of DWL's
collections; preparation and conservation of collections for users;
attendance at Centre events; collaboration in teaching.
- Editor of the scholarly blog Dissenting Experience; for broad impact
of the open-access publications.
- Director of the AHRC/ESRC Religion and Society Programme; for impact
of the large grant funded by the Programme, `Dissenting Academy
Libraries and their Readers, 1720-1860', and the research of the CDA
holder also funded by the programme.
- The Librarian, Bristol Baptist College; for impact on the College
Library of the work of the postdoctoral research fellows and of Dissenting
Academies Online: Virtual Library System.
- President of the United Reformed Church History Society, and former
Moderator of the General Assembly of the United Reformed Church; for use
of Surman Index Online and Dissenting Academies Online:
Database and Encyclopedia by URC.
Other sources
- Statistics are collected for the three Centre databases Surman
Index Online, Dissenting Academies Online: Database and
Encyclopedia and Dissenting Academies Online: Virtual Library
System using AWStats.