Voiceworks:promoting voice in collaborative practice and the making of new song repertoire
Submitting Institution
Birkbeck CollegeUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Studies In Creative Arts and Writing: Film, Television and Digital Media, Performing Arts and Creative Writing
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Voiceworks exemplifies the impact
of Birkbeck's Contemporary Poetics Research Centre and its contribution to
cultural life and creative industries, specifically in the field of song,
composition and performance. A seven-year collaboration between poets from
the Centre, composers and singers from Guildhall Conservatoire, and
Wigmore Hall, Voiceworks annually creates new works for voice from a long
process of reflective exchange, improvisation and practice. These are
performed publicly at Wigmore Hall, and form new repertoire, accessible
online. An emerging generation of creative Voiceworks practitioners have
developed their practice in innovative directions, and continue to
collaborate successfully on projects nationally and internationally.
Underpinning research
After an approach from Wigmore Hall, London's international venue for
song, Voiceworks was established in 2006 by the directors of the
Contemporary Poetics Research Centre (CPRC), Professors Carol Watts and
William Rowe, with colleagues from Guildhall. The resulting collaboration
shifted the traditional `setting' of poetic text to music onto innovative
ground. Drawing on the rich experimental research culture of the Centre,
and under its aegis, on students and practitioners within and outside
Birkbeck, Watts and Rowe opened up a range of poetic practice and
research, including sound, and visual and digital forms of poetic
material. The aim is to transform the thinking and practice of cross-arts
collaboration, creating a twenty-first-century song repertoire for a new
generation of artists.
Practice-based research has threaded through a continuous series of
related events at the Centre and public venues, exploring voice and sound:
innovative work with singular voice, evidenced in the essays and videos of
the multimedia `Constellation: Alice Notley' (2008); poet Susan Howe's
seminar with her collaborator, musician David Grubbs, and public
performance on London's South Bank (jointly organized with Royal
Holloway); open seminars on acoustics and notation (2009); on video poetry
and music (2009); on polyvocalia (2011). Voiceworks' development was
further informed by cross-arts research collaborations PartlyWriting (with
poet Caroline Bergvall and Bury Text Festival, 2005), and the rolling
colloquium Translated Acts (with the International Centre for Fine Art
Research at Central St. Martin's and Southampton University, 2009).
Voiceworks' collaborative processes unusually involve the poet and
composer working with the voice of the singer from the outset to generate
song compositions. This encounter with voice is central to reflective
experiment, testing the practice and communication of collaboration, and
to the production of new repertoire at Wigmore. As Voiceworks developed,
poets and composers began to report on this ongoing work, eg. `Documents
of Collaboration: The Poem in Song and Opera' (2009); TEXTMUSICTEXTMUSIC
(2009), a colloquium exploring Voiceworks findings with international
musicians, academics and performers with public performances at the Horse
Hospital in London; and VOX//XOV in 2013 with renowned sound poet,
musician and Schwitters specialist Jaap Blonk. These events inform the
exchange of those taking part in Voiceworks, shaping their understanding
of the practice of voice, text and sound. The critical and poetic work of
Watts and Rowe has similarly been fully engaged. Watts' published research
includes an essay on site-specific practice and harmonics (Ref 1); Rowe's
pays close attention to lyric voice (Refs 2 & 3). Watts' collection Occasionals
(Ref 4) pushes voice and breath through a score of `irrational cuts',
while Rowe's poetry explores political `pulse' as a condition of song.
Watts' article on collaboration and the concept of encounter (Ref 5)
draws explicitly on Voiceworks, challenging notions of text setting. Her
discussion of US composer Michael Pisaro's work with poetry led to public
discussions with Pisaro and performances as a voice among musicians
realizing Wandelweiser scores. Her practice-based explorations of text and
sound, with collaborator Will Montgomery, eg `Pitch' (Ref 6), have been
performed, exhibited, and played on internet radio. This consistent
investigation of voice, sound and collaboration has emerged from the
Voiceworks project and also feeds it: like the Voiceworks participants,
Watts' practice has been transformed.
References to the research
2. William Rowe, The Earth Has Been Destroyed (London: Veer
Books, 2009). Political poetry that draws on Rowe's long engagement with
song, history and pulse, which fed into the Voiceworks project.
3. William Rowe, Three Lyric Poets: Harwood, Torrance and MacSweeney
(Tavistock: Northcote House, 2009). Alive to the vocality of lyric
practice: `In one arresting passage he scores Harwood's punctuation and
spacing, measures it against a recording of the poet in performance to
give a close-read musical sense of the subtlety of this delightful poet's
approach to meaning: his broken narratives, his gaps, his questioning
suspensions' (Review by John
Muckle).
4. Carol Watts, Occasionals (Hastings: Reality Street Editions,
2011). Reflects Watts' research based poetic practice, testing voice and a
Deleuzian concept of irrational cuts. One reviewer wrote `I have seldom
read a poetry so exact, yet so longing, expressive of what just might be,
somewhere. So abundant, yet with such awareness of our partialness. A
poetry that makes of its sentences an architecture that invokes, at the
same time, brokenness and clarity.'(Review
03/05/2012)
5. Carol Watts, `Set,
Unset: Collaboration, Encounter and the Scene of Poetry', Contemporary
Music
Review 29:2 (April 2010), 145-57. Article that reflects on
Voiceworks and collaborative practice in poetry and music, questioning the
concept of text setting and exploring the translation of poetry by
composer Michael Pisaro.
6. Carol Watts, text collaboration with sound artist Will Montgomery, Pitch.
Homage to Luigi Nono. Electronic composition (2011). `Pitch
nestles in the contours of protest work. Its language is the persistent
unpinnable shiver left by shock and loss of articulate response and
agency', Caroline Bergvall, `Indiscreet Ghosts', catalogue essay for The
Whisper Heard exhibition by Imogen Stidworthy, Matt's Gallery.
Funding:
2010: AHRC Digital Equipment and Database Enhancement for Impact grant
(£136,498) for Voiceworks project (Watts as P.I.)
Details of the impact
The major feature of the Voiceworks project has been the partnership
between Birkbeck, Guildhall School of Music and Drama, and Wigmore Hall,
UK's leading venue for chamber music and song. As a consequence it has
made a significant, ongoing impact on cultural life, through developing
the creative expertise of a new generation of composers, singers and
poets, creating new repertoire and performances. It has also helped an
important cultural institution transform contemporary song and interest
audiences in new classical and experimental material. For Wigmore Hall,
`Voiceworks is a vital part of the development of the genre, introducing
Song as a living art form to a new generation of writers, composers and
artists, and fostering a career-long engagement with the genre'
(Testimonial 1). The venue provides various platforms for young artists,
including competitions and recitals, and the Voiceworks project forms a
unique part of that strategy by nurturing young composers, song writers
and performers.
Wigmore Learning, which reaches over 8000 young people every year,
piloted a Voiceworks programme with school children aged 12-18, initiated
by Carol Watts, which resulted in work integrated into the main Voiceworks
Wigmore performance in May 2012. The Head of Wigmore Learning writes: `As
the number of Voiceworks alumni grows and those who have been part of the
programme become established as professionals, their experience gained
through the project will not only influence their work but also have an
impact on those with whom they collaborate.' She adds that Voiceworks is
unique because `the collaborative writing process is still a relatively
rare thing within the classical music world and something the students and
young professionals involved in Voiceworks will take with them into their
careers' (Testimonial 1). One of the school students, whose work was
performed, went on to win the BBC Proms Inspire Young Composer's
Competition in 2012 (12-16 age category). Wigmore Learning plan to extend
the Voiceworks project into their schools programme triennially from 2013.
For the Guildhall School of Music and Drama, the Director of Composition
writes, `Voiceworks has had a major and significant impact on the creative
practice not only of ...[our] composers but also on the depth and meaning
of cross-collaboration between composers, singers and instrumental
performers over the past seven years. This has been powered at its heart
from the deep thoughtfulness and intellectual curiosity that staff and
student poets from Birkbeck College have brought into the creative culture
of the Guildhall school.' He adds, `It has completely transformed our
postgraduate composers' sense of what cross-art collaboration means in
terms of creative practice and in a very specific sense inculcated in
student composers a far greater degree of sensitivity and responsiveness
to text and the limitless potential of its relationship to sonic/musical
material' (Testimonial 2). The deputy head of Vocal Studies explains, `the
unique value of Voiceworks is the space it offers for practitioners ... to
encounter each other's practice. Out of this opportunity have emerged
lasting artistic relationships between Voiceworks participants, and an
interest in working collaboratively has been kindled especially among
singers whose involvement would conventionally only be in the later stages
of the creation of new work.' Individual participants have gone on to
involve other non-Voiceworks collaborators in this interdisciplinary mode
of practice, extending its impact (Testimonial 3).
There are now over 130 alumni of the Voiceworks programme, many of whom
have used it to launch or develop their creative careers; it has enabled
them to extende their portfolios (with new commissions and collaborative
work), and several continue to work in collaborative teams. Alumni
indicate that the experience has profoundly influenced their approach to
creative composition and led to new opportunities in their working lives.
A young singer (Voiceworks, 2010-11), for example, `feel(s) very grateful
to Voiceworks for sparking what has been an exciting collaboration. My
interest in contemporary music has continued to grow and I feel more
courageous in tackling new ideas and works. This ... has helped me in my
career. I am currently involved in a new opera ... at the Linbury Studio,
Royal Opera House with four other performers. The audition process asked
me to vocally improvise — to feel free to create, a task I would not have
been so comfortable doing had I not taken part in Voiceworks' (email
21/08/2013, Source 7).
A prizewinning composer, whose song cycles have been performed at
numerous venues in the UK and internationally and on BBC Radio 3, also
testifies that `I do feel my vocal music written before and after Voiceworks
are different, particularly in terms of the increased awareness of the
interworking of text and music, the impact of vocal writing on both the
interpreters and the impression the resultant work will make on the its
listeners' (email, 22/08/2013, Source 7). As a freelance poet writes, `I
consider Voiceworks to have been a true launch-pad for my
practice. ... As a result of the work I produced for Voiceworks... I was
successful in my application to work on a newly commissioned project for
Dartington International Summer School' (email 10/09/13, Source 7).
As a further outcome of Voiceworks, Carol Watts is an advisor on
collaborative practice on London Sinfonietta's Jerwood funded Blue
Touchpaper scheme and an alumni of the project won one of its hugely
competitive commissions (Source 4). Other organisations which have
recognized and benefited from the expertise of Voiceworks alumni include
Royal Opera House, Welsh National Opera, Arcola Theatre, Traverse Theatre,
the Liverpool Biennial, Museum of Art, Bury Museum of Art (Source 5),
Manchester, the Wellcome Institute and the Dana Centre at the Science
Museum, and literary and music festivals in the UK and internationally
(Paxos, Switzerland, Hong Kong, South Africa, US, France, Spain).
The digital repertoire of Voiceworks now extends to at least 48 pieces,
all available on the website, developed with an AHRC Digital Equipment and
Database Enhancement for Impact grant designed and led by Carol Watts. In
one year from June 2012, the website recorded 69,156 sessions with an
average of 7 minutes per session (Sources 8 and 9). Live performances have
been captured digitally, building a growing body of work stored on the
website. As Voiceworks' Guildhall partners express it, `On every level, we
regard Voiceworks as a paradigm for the formative development of creative
practitioners and the effective dissemination of the fruits of their
collaborative endeavours' (Source 2).
Sources to corroborate the impact
Testimonials
- Head of Wigmore Learning (factual statement)
- Director of Composition, Guildhall School of Music and Drama (factual
statement)
- Deputy Head of Vocal Studies, Guildhall School of Music and Drama
(factual statement)
- Chief Executive, London Sinfonietta (factual statement)
- Director of Museum of Art, Bury, Manchester (and Text Festival
Director) (factual statement)
Other evidence
- A full list of 130 participating artists since 2006 (114 within the
REF period) is available on the Voiceworks website.
It features short biographies of each of the participants, together with
details of their explorations in composing, writing and performing
reflected in their blogs.
- Participant feedback: We can supply a folder of statements by alumni
with feedback on the effect of the programme on their careers and
creative approach, from which we have drawn some of the quotations
above.
- The Voiceworks website
lists 48 pieces (41 sound files, 33 in REF period) that have been
performed at Wigmore Hall with explanations about how they were created.
- Analytics of Voiceworks website usage available on request.