Documentary Film Practice as Self-reflexive Interaction Between the Filmmaker and Marginalised Communities
Submitting Institution
Roehampton UniversityUnit of Assessment
Communication, Cultural and Media Studies, Library and Information Management Summary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Studies In Human Society: Sociology, Other Studies In Human Society
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies
Summary of the impact
The impact case study relates to two documentaries, ABC Colombia
(2007) and Home Sweet
Home (2012). Enrica Colusso's practice-as-research exposes,
challenges and critiques social
structures and institutions, relations of power, oppression and resistance
affecting marginalised
communities. Her work prioritises the experience of ordinary people living
in difficult times. Through
the process of filming, screening and broadcasting of her documentaries,
this work has had a
direct impact upon the communities she films, on the organizations that
support them, and on the
audiences that view them. This work has an international reach, and
significant impact in the
following areas:
- Shaping public discourse and enhancing understanding of complex issues
surrounding
disenfranchised and marginalised communities in Colombia and London.
- Influencing and empowering local community action.
- Informing and influencing policy debates around the impact of the drug
trade in Colombia
and the urban regeneration of the Elephant and Castle.
Underpinning research
Enrica Colusso (Senior Lecturer, 2003 to date) has established a research
commitment to a
documentary practice in which the filming process, and subsequently the
film-text, become a fertile
space of encounter between the self and the world. The process is both a
way of relating to and a
negotiating with those involved: the maker, the people filmed and the
audience. This is practice-as-
research conceived as a cognitive and relational process, a way of
creating models of subjectivity
and fostering film's transformational power and social impact with an
end-goal that extends beyond
the finished artefact. Colusso's documentary practice puts at its centre
the process of engaging
and interacting with actuality, of mediating it through shooting, editing
and screening.
ABC Colombia (2007) follows children in a one-classroom elementary
school. It is an intimate
portrait of a small rural community in an area entirely controlled by
paramilitary forces, rendered
through the eyes of the children who grow up there, and who are often
forced into very difficult
choices between picking coca leaves or joining the paramilitaries. The
film follows the personal
growth of the young protagonists in this problematic environment through
an entire school year,
exploring some of the realities that nurture and perpetuate the violence
in Colombia from the cross
perspectives of the children and the author. The film is narrated as a
personal journey of discovery
and inquiry by the author who, together with her Colombian husband, is
building a home there. The
parallel processes of filming and building entwine, functioning as a way
of coming to terms with this
complex reality that is at the same time a part of the author's existence
and utterly "other".
Colusso's latest project Home Sweet Home (2012), explores a
different community, among the
most ethnically diverse and deprived areas in central London, The Elephant
and Castle. Fifty-four
months in the making (from conception to completion), Home Sweet Home
interrogates the social,
political, economic and aesthetic vision that informs a radical urban
regeneration scheme. The
documentary follows the people affected as well as the decision-makers
behind the scenes of the
massive regeneration scheme set to completely transform the borough. The
film offers a complex,
intimate narrative of urban and social change where conflicting visions
and interests are at stake.
Drawing on the extensive video archives (over 200 hours) created for Home
Sweet Home, with
other relevant data and archives, including content from the National
Archives and the local
Cuming Museum's catalogue, Ghost Town is in interactive
documentary that provides an
opportunity for users to critically engage with its traces, to develop
into active citizens capable of
connecting, understanding and engaging with the complex modern urban space
we inhabit, and
ultimately empowering them to promote change and play an active role in
society.
References to the research
Films:
1. ABC Colombia (90mins, 2007). First broadcast by ARTE,
September and October
2007 (France and Germany), it has had a wide distribution on television,
in its video format,
in DVD, and online, both within the academic and other contexts (third
sector and
community).
2. Home Sweet Home (90 mins, 2012). TV Transmission by ARTE
(France and
Germany) and distributed on DVD by Les Film d'Ici. REF2.
3. Ghost Town, interactive documentary (2013). REF2.
Indicators of Quality:
Grants:
• European Media Development Fund (ABC Colombia and Home Sweet
Home).
• ARTE France, Channel 4, ITVS (US), Yle (Finland), PROCIREP (the French
Société des producteurs de Cinéma et Télévision), CNC (Centre National de
la
Cinematographic, France) ABC Colombia).
• In September 2010 Home Sweet Home was commissioned by ARTE, to
the sum of
£135,000.
• CNC (Centre National de la Cinematographic, France) £ 42,000 (Home
Sweet
Home)
• September 2011 the Commission for support of creative television work
of the
PROCIREP granted a further £15,000 towards Home Sweet Home.
Awards:
ABC Colombia — Spirit Award for documentary at the Brooklyn
International Film Festival; the
Audience Award at the London Latin American Film festival; the Prix Media
2009 (Documentary)
Foundacion pour l'Enfance (France); the Youth Award and the Jury Award at
Cimameriche Film
Festival (2009).
Nominations:
ABC Colombia — Prix Italia; TV3 Award (la Corporación Catalana de
radio y televisión — Corporació
Catalana de Ràdio i Televisió — CCRTV) a platform for all productions
covering the violation of
human rights; 2008 Learning on Screen Award, BUFVC, UK, category:
broadcast; The
International Academy of Television Arts & Sciences selected ABC
Colombia in the Documentary
category for the 2008 International Emmy Awards competition.
Home Sweet Home — nominated for the Time Out Best City Film Award
(June 2012).
Details of the impact
Colusso's practice as research — as exemplified across various formats
and outlets including TV
and documentary film, social media, academic publications and
participation in various public
forums — has led to enhanced audience awareness of the relationship
between politics, hierarchies
of power and resistance. Her work demonstrates extensive public
engagement, reaching and
impacting on social activists, opinion formers and policy makers, as well
as the communities with
which they collaborate.
Reach:
The reach of Colusso's research is evidenced by the range of
international broadcasters and
festivals that have showcased her work. In 2007 ABC Colombia was
screened in France and
Germany on ARTE and More 4 in the UK. Since 2008, it has been broadcast on
Yle TV in Finland
in May 2008 and PBS World in July 2008 in the USA as part of the `Global
Voices' series. The film
has also been available online via amazon.com, Hulu, iTunes, and YouTube,
with a total of
200,744 streams on this platform alone. Home Sweet Home was
broadcast in France and
Germany on ARTE TV on the 18th and 31st October 2012
respectively, and is also available in
these countries as video on demand.
Significance:
In addition to high-profile broadcasts and online streaming, which has
broadened public awareness
of these issues, Colusso has screened ABC Colombia and Home
Sweet Home to community
audiences and to policy makers to influence change. This direct engagement
with the communities
affected and those who govern them has had a significant impact on both as
evidenced in the
following examples.
Shaping public discourses and enhancing understanding of issues
surrounding disenfranchised
and marginalized communities:
Organisations such as Children of the Andes and Justice for Colombia have
benefited from public
screenings of ABC Colombia which have increased awareness of the
situation for children in
Colombia, as well as by fundraising generated by the screenings of the
film (for example, 16
November 2008 Latin American Film Festival). As Heidi Araque, Events
Community Fundraiser for
Children of the Andres (COTA), explains, the film helped "reach a number
of people who were
unaware of our work to support children at risk and to re-engage existing
supporters, making them
reflect on some of the obstacles that need to be overcome if Colombia is
to be a more peaceful
and secure country." Similarly, Eva Tarr-Kirkhope, Director of the London
Latin American Film
festival (LAFF), states that "COTA & LAFF see ABC Colombia as
a great instrument to raise
awareness about the situation of some of the most disadvantaged
Colombians. Part of the
proceeds of the night will go to the charity Children of the Andes."
Selections of Colusso's work-in-progress of Home Sweet Home were
screened for a series of
events exploring urban regeneration and the processes of social
transformation in one of the most
deprived areas of central London. These included her participation in The
Elephant in Time (18th
June 2009, organized by the British Film Institute). The event brought
together architects,
documentarists, historians and local residents to explore the past,
present and future of this part of
London, allowing for a multidisciplinary and lively debate on the reality
of the regeneration and the
role of media in documenting and critically representing change. Colusso
also participated in the
Open City/Design for London City Visions Exhibition (May 2010) which
showcased her film-in-progress as part of the exhibition's closing event.
Since the film was completed in June 2012 it has been presented to
various audiences in London:
from the wider community at Open City Docs Film Festival to the local
community (Tate Film Club,
and Pembroke House screening organised by UrbanLab Films UCL and Open City
Docs), to more
specialized groups such as urbanists, architects and policy makers,
facilitating open debate and
discussion of the issues of urban regeneration. Audience feedback from Home
Sweet Home
screenings within local communities demonstrate that the film changed
perception and raised
awareness of the complexity of the issues affecting residents, as
illustrated by the following
examples:
"I've realized there are many conflicting views coming from different
realities"
"I am more conscious than ever to hear about how the people removed are
coping in their
new homes. I am more keen than ever to see the situation resolved"
Influencing and empowering local community action:
The various constituencies who are the subject of - and participants in - these films are the ultimate
beneficiaries of this practice-as-research, as the work enhances public
and political awareness,
which is forging new paths to social change.
For instance, after the filming of ABC Colombia a 17 year old
participant decided (with the
filmmaker's support) that he would not join the paramilitary after all. He
is now living in Bogota,
happily married and working. Similarly a local residents' participant and
social activist can attest to
Home Sweet Home's impact on local councils and decision makers, as
well as its value as a
`truthful' and detailed record of the process and a work which challenges
the clichés about people
living in council estates, and its impact on both individuals and the
community (source four).
As some of the viewers of both films have also stressed, one of the
strengths of Colusso's work is
the powerful voice they give to people who would otherwise not be heard.
This has a significant
impact on the people filmed, by fostering their sense of worth and
self-awareness, and on the
different constituencies and institutions responsible for addressing the
root causes of the violence,
as it provides invaluable access to the reality on the ground.
An indicator of the significance of this impact is evident from
personal testimony by Oscar Teran, in
a personal email to Colusso after watching ABC Colombia on 31
December 2010: "Not only have
you created a beautiful film but you have given a powerful voice to your
subjects."
Informing & influencing policy:
ABC Colombia was selected to be screened to members of the USA
Congress examining
Colombian paramilitary communities to inform votes on an aid bill (Hewlett
Foundation Report
2008). Similarly, in October 2008 the film was selected to be shown in the
Cultural Educational
Film Symposium organised by the Independent Television Service (ITVS), the
Naval Postgraduate
School, the Defence Language Institute Foreign Language Centre and
Monterrey Institute of
International Studies. The purpose of the symposium and accompanying
screening was to explore
the use of documentary films to train future military and civilian leaders
in cultural awareness and
international affairs.
It was also screened at the Geneva Forum on Social Change organised by
ITVS and Geneva
University (June 2009) and was accompanied by a panel discussion in which
Colusso was an
invited panellist, which took place at USC and was streamed live in Geneva
as part of this Forum.
The forum focused on the use of documentary film as a tool for education,
cultural diplomacy and
policy making in international public affairs.
Sources to corroborate the impact
- Producer and consultant; Head of Documentary Unit at ARTE France
1987/2008.
- Events and Community Fundraiser — Children of the Andes: "ABC Colombia
helped to illustrate,
without simplifying or sensationalizing, some of the difficulties that
many young people face in
Colombia. It helped Children of the Andes to reach a number of people
who were unaware of our
work to support children at risk and to re-engage existing supporters,
making them reflect on some
of the obstacles that need to be overcome if Colombia is to be a more
peaceful and secure
country."
- Director & Founder London Latin American Film Festival
- Elephant & Castle local residents' participant and social activist
- Southwark Council's Director of the Elephant & Castle Regeneration
- Audience feedback collected at screenings of Home Sweet Home
at the Tate Community Film
Club on the 8th April 2013 and at Pembroke House on the 15th
April 2013.