Impact on public appreciation of Victorian literature and culture
Submitting Institution
Leeds Trinity UniversityUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
The literature of the Victorian era has an enduring popular interest, as
evidenced by the plethora of film and television adaptations of novels and
authors' biographies. Though this popularization has brought Victorian
literature to the foreground, there is a need for the public to be better
informed about this literature. Members of the English UOA are engaged in
research into Victorian literature and have drawn on this research to help
members of the public gain better understanding and deeper appreciation of
this literature. They have achieved this through public lectures,
seminars, and poetry readings, as well as at events organized through
links fostered with local galleries.
Underpinning research
Leeds Trinity has an international reputation for research in the area of
Victorian Studies. The Leeds Centre for Victorian Studies (LCVS) is a
flagship interdisciplinary research centre based at Leeds Trinity with
close links to the British Association for Victorian Studies and
University of Cergy-Pontoise, Paris. Several staff members in the English
unit work within this research centre.
The key researchers within this case study are:
(i) Dr Richard Storer: 1995-present Lecturer in English (now Associate
Principal Lecturer), Leeds Trinity University. 2007-2008, Acting Head of
Department of Humanities, Leeds Trinity University; 2009-present Director
of Programmes in English, Leeds Trinity University.
(ii) Dr Nathan Uglow: 2002-present, Lecturer in English (now Associate
Principal Lecturer), Leeds Trinity University.
(iii) Rev Dr Jane de Gay: 1999-2012, Lecturer in English, Leeds Trinity
University; 2012-present, Reader in English Literature, Leeds Trinity
University.
Dr Richard Storer has a reputation for research on F. R. Leavis, most
notably his volume on F. R. Leavis in the Routledge Critical
Thinkers series (2009). The 2009 book is the most up-to-date introduction
to F. R. Leavis available — and the first published since 2000. It is not
just a synthesis of previous studies of Leavis (though it does fulfil this
function) but includes lots of information (bibliographical and
contextual) not found in other books on Leavis, and also highlights some
key passages from his writings which have not been analysed or discussed
in any previous studies. It is not designed to be just a student guide but
an authoritative resource for any reader wanting to get past the often
caricatured way in which this controversial figure is usually mentioned in
public debate (e.g. debates on ideas of culture and the `two cultures', on
the place of theory in literary study, on canon-formation, or on higher
education — there are chapters on all these topics in the book). This work
highlights the importance of key figures from the Victorian period for
Leavis's perspective on literature and society. Storer has developed this
idea in further research by highlighting striking parallels between
Leavis's work and that of some late Victorian figures with whom he is not
normally linked — for example, Oscar Wilde and Sir Henry Irving.
Dr Nathan Uglow's research is in Victorian literature and ethics,
covering authors as diverse as Robert Browning, John Ruskin, Thomas
Carlyle, Charlotte Brontë and Elizabeth Gaskell. His research on Elizabeth
Gaskell's novel North and South argues that this work is unusual
for a mid-C19 industrial novel because it refuses the typical Romantic
attitude of rejecting the city as the corrupt artificial alternative to
Nature. Through the plotting of the novel and its reconciliation of city
(North) and Nature (South) Mrs Gaskell takes a more Aristotelian stance
toward this opposition (the mean is the best position balancing against
extreme alternatives). Aristotle's idea of the balance of opposites,
mediated through reasoned discourse, provides both the political and moral
basis for the novel. In further research on Ruskin, Uglow counters a
prevalent view of Ruskin's work that his career trajectory took him from
Puritanism to paganism and back to spiritualised Christianity. Through a
close examination of Ruskin's enthusiasm for Fra Angelico's religious
painting, the paper traces Ruskin's consistent desire to seek a balanced
stance toward life: mixing `feminine' subtlety and spirituality with
`masculine' resoluteness and self-control. Against previous
interpretations the paper demonstrates that Ruskin did not drop Fra
Angelico in the late 1850s, when he `un-converted' from Christianity, but
repeatedly used his work as a symbol of the kind of marriage of wisdom and
grace that was central to his moral and social message.
Revd Dr Jane de Gay has an international reputation as a Virginia Woolf
scholar, most notably for her research into Woolf's intellectual heritage
(including the influence of Victorian writers, critics and thinkers such
as Sir Leslie Stephen, Anne Thackeray Ritchie, Julia Margaret Cameron,
John Ruskin, George Eliot and the Brontës). Dr de Gay's book, Virginia
Woolf's Novels and the Literary Past (Edinburgh University Press,
2006) was the first to explore Woolf's preoccupation with the literary
past and its profound impact on her novels. The monograph provides the
most wide-ranging account to date of Woolf's reaction to Victorian
writings, analysing her responses to the Brontës, William Cowper, Charles
Darwin, George Eliot, Thomas Hardy, Coventry Patmore, Anne Thackeray
Ritchie, and John Ruskin, among others. In particular, it shows that
Woolf's father, Victorian man of letters Sir Leslie Stephen, was a more
significant and more positive influence than critics had recognised.
References to the research
• Storer, R. F. R. Leavis (Abingdon: Routledge, 2009)
Reviewed in Style, 45(3), as a work that, even for a reader with
considerable knowledge of Leavis, provides `new insights' due to `Storer's
comprehensive knowledge of Leavis's writings and their reception', and
which contains `carefully-balanced considerations of (and challenges to)
what have sometimes become mechanically orthodox ways of placing Leavis'
(pp. 552 - 553). According to Chris Terry (Times Higher Education)
F.R. Leavis is `informative, succinct, circumspect; an exacting
introduction to Leavis as an incisive master critic'. Favourably reviewed
in Use of English (2010), 61(2).
Cited by: Hilliard, C. English as a Vocation: the `scrutiny' movement,
(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012); Parry, J. & Simpson, E.
(2012) `David Pocock's Contributions and the legacy of Leavis', Contributions
to Indian Sociology, 46, pp. 393 - 397; and Gardiner, M. The
Return of England in English Literature, (Palgrave Macmillan, 2012).
• de Gay, J. Virginia Woolf's Novels and the Literary Past
(Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press/New York: Columbia University
Press, 2006; paperback 2007), 288pp. ISBN: 0 7486 2349 3 [peer reviewed]
Reviewed in the Times Literary Supplement as a study with
numerous `interesting and powerful themes' and that the `strong account of
Woolf's relation to tradition in Virginia Woolf's Novels and the
Literary Past will surely facilitate further study of the gender
politics of Modernism'. Professor Laura Marcus (University of Sussex)
described the work as `an important intervention at a time in which there
is particular interest in Woolf's relationship to the past' and Professor
Vara Neverow (University of Connecticut) assigned the book to be
`essential and intellectually provocative reading for Woolf scholars and
for common readers alike'.
The work is frequently cited in conference papers and articles on
Virginia Woolf, and it is listed in a survey of significant criticism in
Susan Sellers (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Virginia Woolf, 2nd
edition (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010), p.175). Published
in both the UK and US, Viriginia Woolf's Novels and the Literary Past
is available in libraries worldwide.
• de Gay, J. 'Behind the Purple Triangle: Art and Iconography in To
the Lighthouse', Woolf Studies Annual 1999 (New York: Pace
University Press, 1999), pp. 1-23. [peer reviewed]
• Uglow, N. `Elizabeth Gaskell's North and South: the industrial
city and the moral self', in François Baillet and Odile Boucher-Rivalain
(eds.), Parcours Urbains (Paris: L'Harmattan, 2011), pp.97-118.
[REF entry]
• Uglow, N. `But Humble — Ruskin and Victorian Spirituality' in Jane de
Gay (ed.), Victorian Spiritualities (Leeds: Leeds Trinity
University College, 2012), pp.236-47. [REF entry]
Key grants
£200 from British Association for Victorian Studies for Victorian
Spiritualities colloquium (2012)
Details of the impact
The body of research detailed above has contributed towards a better
informed public on Victorian literature, through public talks, events and
publishing in accessible formats. Collectively they have engaged with an
estimated 100 members of the public (through public talks and events) and
up to 222,000 people who have accessed research published in an accessible
format (including readability).
De Gay has reached a wide audience with her research on Virginia Woolf.
Her monograph (which was published in hardback and paperback) has had a
wide readership that includes general readers as well as academics and
students. It has had particular impact through its influence on subsequent
publications of Woolf's novels. De Gay's research has been acknowledged by
at least one editor of the new, definitive edition of Virginia Woolf's
novels from Cambridge University Press (Mrs Dalloway, edited by
Anne Fernald (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, forthcoming)), so her
research has the impact of providing general readers with a more accurate
and informed edition of Woolf's work.
By invitation, de Gay gave the Virginia Woolf Birthday Lecture London
January 2009, delivered to an audience of 100, including general readers.
The lecture was published as a pamphlet entitled Virginia Woolf and
the Clergy (Southport: Virginia Woolf Society of Great Britain,
2009). This pamphlet has been circulated among church groups interested in
the role of women in the church. De Gay demonstrates that Woolf, although
not a Christian, offered a detailed critique of the religious structures
that exclude women. This research therefore makes a contribution to
current debates about Women Bishops.
To aid public engagement with their research, the unit have communicated
their research outcomes in accessible formats, targeted at members of the
interested public. Such publications have been on a national and
international scale with articles in the Oxford Dictionary of National
Biography (ODNB) and Literary Encyclopedia. Both of
these are online resources widely available outside the academy. Grounded
in his research on Victorian and early twentieth-century writing, Storer's
entries in the ODNB include the editor and publisher A.H. Bullen
(1857-1920); Sheffield professor G.C. Moore Smith (1858-1940); and the
Victorian Shakespeare scholar and controversialist C.M. Ingleby (1823-86).
Similarly Uglow has also made an extensive contribution, based on his
research in Victorian literature, to the Literary Encyclopedia,
contributing 21 articles (whilst at Leeds Trinity), and to the ODNB,
contributing two articles on Victorian artists. Since publication (2002),
Uglow's articles in Literary Encyclopedia have been accessed over
222,000 times. It is not possible to break this data down by year, but it
might be estimated that the articles were accessed around 101,000 times
during the REF assessment period, assuming an even number of hits per
year.
The public have also been engaged in a deeper appreciation of Victorian
literature through numerous public lectures and events hosted by the
institution. Based on his research in Victorian literature and as Deputy
Director of the LCVS, Uglow has shared his expertise and knowledge with
public audiences through the coordination a seminar series from 2008 to
the present. The seminar series drew in members of the public to hear
papers and engage in debates on topics in Victorian Studies. There are six
seminars each year with an average audience size of around 12, of which
typically three are members of the public. This has resulted in a total of
40 members of the public attending these public lectures. Members of the
unit have also moved beyond the physical location of the institution to
deliver public lectures. Storer has presented his work on F. R. Leavis at
the Leavis international conference in York, 2010, which was open to those
beyond the academy. Storer's presentation was favourably mentioned in an
article on the Conference in the Times Literary Supplement. In his
presentation Storer played a rare recording of Leavis reading some of
Eliot's poetry, an act that was described as `sensitively choreographed',
`one of the highlights of the afternoon' and that Storer's `introduction
made it clear ... that this was the voice of a man whose engagement with
Eliot's poetry ran deep' (TLS 19 November 2010).
The public's knowledge of the period has been influenced and enriched
through inviting non-academic yet interested parties to events, hosted at
the institution, broadly linked to Victorian literature. De Gay, for
example, organised an interdisciplinary colloquium on Victorian
Spiritualities (March 2012) which attracted 35 participants from around
the world, including members of the public. The event featured an
exhibition by the newly-founded Friends of Lawnswood Cemetery and a short
talk from one of its members: they provided some positive feedback,
commenting that it was useful to actually mount a display and as a
consequence they have taken this, or a version of it, to various other
events, thus raising their profile. They also found the level of interest
in the display rewarding and they made useful contacts, including a member
of the Friends of a cemetery in the south, who supplied them with a
fundraising idea of producing sympathy cards using pictures of monuments
from Lawnswood.
Establishing a partnership with the Mercer Art Gallery, Harrogate, and
based on his research in 2009-11 Uglow organised a one-day conference on
Leeds artist Atkinson Grimshaw (held at Leeds Trinity, May 2011). This
coincided with the Gallery's hosting of the first major exhibition of
Grimshaw's work for a generation. Speakers included artists, curators and
poets as well as academics, and 27 people attended. An unpublished
biography written by his descendants has been unearthed, revealing a sharp
sense of humour, a love of art and a fierce dedication to his family.
There are photographs and sketchbooks, letters and personal effects,
creating stories that turn the paintings from fairytales into history.
Feedback from members of the public (including a member of Grimshaw's
family) afterwards expressed appreciation of the event.
Sources to corroborate the impact
Jane Sellars, Curator at Mercer Art Gallery, Harrogate
Email communication from contact at Friends of Lawnswood Cemetery
Email communication from Anne Fernald, Fordham University, New York
http://www.virginiawoolfsociety.co.uk/vw_publications.htm
http://friendsoflawnswoodcemetery.co.uk/