Conservation of pre-medieval sculptures on 6th century Christian site and regeneration of the surrounding area
Submitting Institution
University of GlasgowUnit of Assessment
Geography, Environmental Studies and ArchaeologySummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Built Environment and Design: Architecture
History and Archaeology: Archaeology, Curatorial and Related Studies
Summary of the impact
    Stephen Driscoll's archaeological research has driven conservation and
      regeneration campaigns in the Glasgow area of Govan, raising public
      awareness of Govan's important cultural heritage resources and its status
      as one of the earliest sites of Christian worship in Northern Britain. His
      work has been instrumental in achieving Scheduled Ancient Monument status
      for Govan Old Churchyard, has influenced urban regeneration efforts — in
      particular the formal establishment of the Govan Conservation Area by
      Glasgow City Council — and has helped to establish a sustainable future
      for Govan Old Church as a museum housing significant early medieval
      sculpture.
    Underpinning research
    Between 1994 and 1996, Stephen Driscoll, Professor of Historical
      Archaeology at the University of Glasgow (1991-present), undertook three
      excavations in and around the grounds of Govan Old Church, producing the
      first radiocarbon dates of the site and establishing the extent and
      character of the archaeological deposits in the heart of Govan. His
      research showed that Christian activity had begun by the 6th century and
      uncovered an internationally important collection of Early Medieval
      sculpture — some 41 monuments dating from the 10th and 11th
      centuries, including five `hogback' style sculptured stones, an
      Anglo-Scandinavian style of tombstone thought to have originated in
      Yorkshire. Not only is this collection of sculptured stones the largest in
      Scotland but there are only four other sites in the UK with five surviving
      hogbacks. Driscoll's excavations also revealed aspects of the Early
      Medieval topography: in particular, dating a forgotten 9th-10th
      century road established a connection with the site where an open air
      court of justice was held in ancient times, known as the Doomsterhill.
      Together these discoveries allowed the Govan area — and Partick on the
      opposite bank of the Clyde — to be recognised as principal royal seats of
      the lost British Kingdom of Strathclyde. (2003, 2004).
    In 2007, in response to a proposal to redevelop the Water Row area of
      Govan, Driscoll led an extensive examination of the heart of Govan on
      behalf of Glasgow City Council. In addition to improving knowledge of the
      late 1st century Doomsterhill site, these excavations exposed
      key industrial features relating to the Govan shipyards, an earlier
      textile dye works and a ferry slipway; they also exposed a sequence of
      later medieval and early modern domestic buildings.
    Taken together, these excavations established the cultural significance
      of the archaeological resources in central Govan.
    Between 2007 and 2009, Driscoll was commissioned by Historic Scotland to
      evaluate the archaeological and architectural heritage of Govan as part of
      the government's Burgh Survey programme. This study produced the first
      comprehensive mapping of Govan's physical cultural heritage assets. The
      Geographical Information System built for the study was adopted by the
      West of Scotland Archaeology Service (2008) for use in evaluating planning
      applications. The narrative account, resource evaluation and
      recommendations were published as Historic Govan (2009) accompanied by a
      suite of historical maps. Although part of a series aimed primarily at
      planners, Driscoll and his team varied the format to make it more
      attractive to a popular audience. The original print run of 700 sold out
      within a year; a second print run of 500 copies sold out in 2010.
    In his research Driscoll has sought to situate the Early Medieval
      sculpture within its wider cultural and historical contexts. One study has
      explored the so-called Govan School of sculpture which reflects the
      cultural and political domination of the central Clyde valley by the kings
      of Strathclyde (2005). Another examines the Norse influences in the Viking
      Age component of the Govan sculpture (2011). Current research includes the
      survey and study of the early modern monuments in the churchyard and their
      relationship to the Early Medieval sculpture which was reused in
      post-medieval times. This information is designed to contribute to the
      conservation management plan for the churchyard. Another strand being
      explored is the relationship between the ministry of Govan and the
      restoration of Iona Abbey and the creation of the Iona Community, which is
      an important chapter in the Govan story that has the potential to
      contribute significantly to the tourist interest in Govan.
    References to the research
    
2003 Driscoll, S. T., `Govan: an early medieval royal centre on the
      Clyde', in The Stone of Destiny Artefact and Icon, R. Welander, D.
      Breeze and T. O. Clancy (eds) Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of
      Scotland Monograph 22, 77-83. (ISBN 0903903229). [PDF link]
     
2004 Driscoll, S. T., The Archaeological Context of Assembly in Early
      Medieval Scotland — Scone and its Comparanda, in Assembly
          Places and Practices in Medieval Europe, A. Pantos and S.
      Semple (eds) Dublin: Four Courts Press, 73-94. (ISBN 1-85182-665-3).
      [available from HEI]
     
2005 Driscoll, S. T., Grady, O. O., Forsyth, K. The Govan School
      revisited; searching for meaning in the early medieval sculpture of
      Strathclyde, in Able Minds and Practiced Hands, S. Foster and M.
      Cross (eds) Leeds: Society for Medieval Archaeology Monograph, 135-58.
      (ISBN 9781904350743). [available from HEI]
     
2009 Dalglish, C., Driscoll, S.T., Maver, I., and Shearer, I. Historic
        Govan: Archaeology and Development, York: Council for British
      Archaeology & Historic Scotland. (ISBN 9781902771625 / 1902771621).
      [available from HEI]
     
2011 Driscoll, S. T., Owen, O., Norse Influence at Govan on the Firth of
      Clyde, Scotland, in Viking
          Settlements & Viking Society, S. Sigmundsson (ed.).
      Reykjavik: Proceedings of the Sixteenth Viking Congress, 333-46. (ISBN
      9789979549239). [available from HEI]
     
Details of the impact
    Contribution to improved social, cultural and environmental
        sustainability
    Historically, Govan Old Church served as the spiritual and social
      cornerstone of the area, but, over time, the shrinking congregation has
      diminished its strength. In 2007, a parish reorganisation resulted in
      making Govan Old Church redundant as an active place of worship. During
      the 1960s and 1970s, shipbuilding — the main employer in Govan — went into
      a near terminal decline. Today only one shipyard is still active, large
      areas of central Govan are derelict, unemployment levels exceed 50% and
      the population has declined significantly. In 1912 Govan was until an
      independent burgh with an estimated population of 100,000; it is now one
      of the most deprived districts in the city of Glasgow with a population
      estimated at 66,100 in 2008 (Scottish Neighbourhood Statistics).
    As a result of his extensive research in the area, in 2005, Driscoll was
      approached by Govan Workspace Ltd, a not-for-profit community-based
      regeneration group, to contribute to its proposed Conservation Plan for
      Govan. This plan led directly to the formulation of the Govan Conservation
      Area Proposal — that led, in 2008, to the area being given conservation
      area status by Glasgow City Council. The group assembled by Govan
      Workspace was formalised into the Govan Heritage Advisory Group, which
      includes Driscoll. This group actively promotes urban regeneration
      initiatives in the area, chiefly through the adaptive reuse of historic
      buildings.
    Enhancements to heritage preservation, conservation and presentation
    The most significant contribution made by Driscoll concerns Govan Old
      Church, which was made redundant by the Church of Scotland in 2007. This
      development caused considerable concern to those interested in the future
      of Govan because it was the oldest and most distinguished element of the
      historic fabric of the area. The church itself is A-listed and, as a
      consequence of the University of Glasgow excavations, the churchyard was
      designated as a Scheduled Ancient Monument in 2003. Driscoll subsequently
      contributed to the Govan Workspace Options Appraisal (2008-10), which
      sought to identify a sustainable future for the church and its collection
      of medieval sculpture. The proposal was to transform the church into a
      museum/cultural resource centre capable of providing impetus to the
      regeneration of Govan. The first stage aimed at improved access and
      interpretative resources to make the church site attractive to tourists;
      the second stage included a major refurbishment to combine commercial
      rental space (in the basement of the old church) with state-of-the-art
      displays in the main body of the church.
	  Figure 1: Hogbacks display
     Figure 1: Hogbacks display
     
	  Figure 2: The unique Govan sarcophagus
     Figure 2: The unique Govan sarcophagus
     
     Funding for the first phase (£120,000) was secured in 2011 from the
      Heritage Lottery Fund, Historic Scotland, the Church of Scotland and other
      sponsors. Driscoll has applied his expertise to interpret the history and
      meaning behind the sculptures and was a primary contributor to the new
      display, known as the Govan Stones project (http://www.thegovanstones.org.uk), installed
      and launched in 2012. Prior to Driscoll's research and the collaboration
      with Govan Workspace, there was little public awareness of the importance
      of the stones and the church and the stones were poorly displayed, with
      limited access. This initial phase of work is addressing these issues. As
      well as managing the displays and information in the new museum, Driscoll
      has contributed to a display in Glasgow's Riverside Museum which draws
      particular attention to Govan Old Church, which sits just across the
      river. As part of the groundwork to establish the viability of Govan Old
      Church as a tourist attraction, the Govan Heritage Advisory Group
      successfully lobbied for the reinstatement of the Govan ferry to link
      Govan with the newly reopened and heavily visited Riverside Museum. The
      Govan Stones project is now fully open to the public, with free admission
      for the first three years. It has a schools outreach programme and is a
      venue for events as part of its income generation strategy — the Jimmy
      Reid Foundation hosted Scotland's First Minister Alex Salmond, in January
      2013, in the first of series of public talks which will be held in the
      Govan Old Church space. Govan Workspace has reported early progress in the
      drive to increase the number of visitors to Govan Old and the Govan
      Stones, with an increase of 146% between 2010 and 2011, largely owing to
      extended opening hours. Visitor numbers between 2012 and 2013 more than
      doubled, with 2,477 visitors in 2012 and 5,379 in between January and
      September 2013. The Managing Director of Govan Workspace stated:
     Professor Driscoll has played a leading role as part of a local group
      which has been drawing attention to Govan's special heritage and the
      potential contribution it could make to local regeneration. His
      professional input — in particular his knowledge of the history of the
      Govan Burgh and his archaeological expertise on the Govan Stones — helped
      bring early credibility to the work and has been instrumental in the
      success of various funding applications.
    The activity associated with the regeneration of the church building
      prompted Glasgow City Council Land and Environmental Services in 2012 to
      initiate a £200,000 conservation programme for the churchyard, the first
      phase of which is the development of a conservation management plan, to
      which Professor Driscoll is contributing. The conservation and
      regeneration work on Govan Old Church has contributed significantly to the
      aims of the Govan regeneration initiative (Central Govan Action Plan) and
      also forms part of Glasgow's ambitious Clyde Waterfront regeneration
      programme.
    Over the course of the Glasgow involvement in the Govan Old Church site,
      significant effort has been devoted to publicising and interpreting the
      discoveries at Govan. Much of this has been accomplished through local
      media, but there are two noteworthy TV events. During the initial
      archaeological dig, an entire episode of Channel 4's Time Team
      programme was dedicated to Govan. Although this occurred prior to the
      eligibility timeframe for impact, it did encourage Glasgow City Council to
      fund an additional season of excavation. Most recently, in May 2012, Govan
      featured prominently in the opening episode (`Britannia') of The Great
      British Story series presented by Michael Woods for BBC 2, which aired to
      an estimated 1.66million. The site has also been written up in a 2011 book
      by Nick Mayhew-Smith entitled Britain's Holiest Places, which was
      featured on Radio 4's Excess Baggage programme and BBC Two's Countryfile
      show.
    Sources to corroborate the impact 
    Evidencing the importance of the Glasgow University research in the
        campaign to gain conservation area status for Govan:
      Corroborative statement from Govan Workspace (2013) [available from HEI]
      Govan
        Workspace Annual Report 2012, referencing archaeological research
      findings and Prof
      Stephen Driscoll in reports of the successful funding for Govan Stones
      project
      Govan
        Conservation Area Appraisal 2008 (Glasgow City Council)
      Govan
        Workspace Annual Report 2005, citing the research findings as one of
      the main reasons for
      a conservation plan
    Evidencing links of Govan Old Church to wider Govan and Clydeside
        regeneration:
      Press
        information Riverside Museum opening 2011
    Evidencing increased recognition of historical significance of Govan
        Old Church site:
      `Britannia' episode
      of The Great British Story, BBC2 (2012)
      Excerpt
        from Britain's Holiest Places, by Nick Mayhew-Smith (2011)
      `Govan's Rich History Revealed': Historic Scotland press release on Launch
        of Historic Govan book by Scottish Culture Minister Fiona Hyslop
      (2010)