Submitting InstitutionUniversity of Cambridge
Unit of AssessmentHistory
Summary Impact TypeCultural
Research Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Literary Studies, Other Language, Communication and Culture
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Prof Christopher Clark's book Iron Kingdom: The Rise and Downfall of
Prussia 1600-1947 has had a broad impact both on academic debate and
on public discussion. It served as the foundation for an hour-long
documentary which aired on BBC4 and was awarded numerous prizes, including
the Wolfson Prize. It was widely discussed in the German media. The author
was invited to Bellevue Palace, Berlin to brief the then President of the
German Federal Republic, Horst Köhler, on the issues raised by it. There
were numerous podium discussions, public lectures and radio and newspaper
interviews. Der Spiegel ran a four-page interview with the author
and the book was credited with shifting the public mood in Germany on what
had traditionally been a controversial subject matter.
The underpinning research, presented in Iron Kingdom: The Rise and
Downfall of Prussia 1600-1947 [ref 3A], was conducted by
Professor Christopher Clark between 1999 and 2006. During this time
Professor Clark was a University Assistant Lecturer, Lecturer, Senior
Lecturer, and then Reader in Modern European History at the University of
Cambridge. Clark consulted archives in Berlin and London, and read widely
across the secondary literature and the corpus of printed primary sources.
The book offered a major re-interpretation of its subject matter. As one
reviewer (William Hagen, author of several standard works in the field)
put it in the journal Central European History in 2008: 'Clark's
Herculean reading endows him with an historiographical command unmatched
east or west of the Rhine and enables him to offer a synthesis of Prussian
history that, in substantive breadth and interpretative freshness, towers
above all others. . .There emerges from Clark's work a mapping or
modelling of Prussian history such as no overarching work has offered
The fresh findings generated by the underpinning research can be summed
up as follows:
(i) A new emphasis on the role of religion as a constitutive factor in
state-building processes, the emergence of a distinctively Prussian
political culture and the formation of horizontal collective identities
across the population.
(ii) A departure from the old 'compromise' theory, by which it was argued
that state and nobility allied in the state-building project at the
expense of the peasantries and the townsfolk. By contrast, Iron
Kingdom argued that an increasingly bureaucratic state 'cohabited'
with old-agrarian-aristocratic and guild-bound urban authorities,
'disciplining' them to advance its military fiscal interests, but
otherwise leaving them intact. The state was in any case far too weak to
counter the economic forces that had begun to transform Prussian society
long before the upheavals that followed the French revolution.
(iii) A new interpretation of Prussian political culture after Napoleon:
rather than separating liberal sheep from reactionary goats - a
time-honoured practice in the Prussia literature — Iron Kingdom
focused on Hegelian liberalism, Christian statism, anti-statist religious
revivalism and dissent and proletarian mobilisation, drawing out their
interactions and synergies and showing how they became the crucible in
which the ideological politics of modernity caught fire.
(iv) Iron Kingdom was the first general history of Prussia to
integrate the history of the Prussian minorities — Jews, Poles, Masurians,
Philipponen etc. — and to incorporate into the spinal narrative the
problem of Prussia's constantly changing boundaries, which imposed on each
new generation the task of integrating 'new Prussians' into the fabric of
state, economy and society.
(v) The book placed at the centre of the narrative the process by which
the Prussian state acquired a sense of its own historicity — beginning
with Pufendorf and Frederick the Great and moving the story forward via
Hegel and Marx to Fontane. In doing so it offered novel insights into the
self-reflexive character of the state's political evolution.
References to the research
A. Christopher Clark, Iron Kingdom. The Rise and Downfall of
Prussia 1600-1947 (777 pp., Allen Lane: London, 2006).
Details of the impact
The book was favourably received by the daily and weekly press in Britain
and the USA. It served as the foundation in 2011 for a 55-minute
documentary programme entitled 'Frederick the Great and the Enigma of
Prussia', presented by the author, directed by Chris Wilson and produced
by Adam Kemp for Aenon and Fresh One Productions [ref 5A], last
aired on BBC4 on Saturday 22 October 2011. The book was also translated
into French, Czech and Polish.
But it is in Germany (Preussen. Aufstieg und Niedergang, 1600-1947,
Deutsche Verlagsanstalt: Munich, 2007) that its impact was broadest and
deepest. Sales exceeded 100,000 (the book was no. 1 on the Spiegel
non-fiction bestseller list for several weeks and remained on the list for
several months). There were numerous full-page reviews in the daily and
weekly press and many radio interviews (Bayerischer Rundfunk, Rundfunk
Berlin-Brandenburg, Mitteldeutscher Rundfunk, Hessischer Rundfunk). Der
Spiegel ran a four-page author-interview and there were hundreds of
reviews in the metropolitan, provincial and regional papers. The author
was invited to the Palace of Bellevue, residence of the President of the
Federal Republic in Berlin, for an interview with the then Federal
President Horst Köhler, in which the author was asked to brief the
President on the issues raised by the book. In a speech he gave a week
later, President Köhler cited remarks made in the interview on the renewed
public interest in the history of Prussia, as exemplified by Clark's book.
This immediate reception occurred after German hardcover and paperback
publication in 2007-8, but the book has continued to receive intensive
publicity and discussion in Germany throughout the period currently under
review: for example, an interview with DeutschlandRadio Wissen (5
Nov. 2010), an invited contribution to Tagesspiegel (15 Jun.
2011), and a tribute in a speech by Minister of Culture Bernd Neumann (20
Mar. 2012). Subsidiary rights were procured by the Bundeszentrale für
Politische Bildung, so that a special edition could be produced for
subsidised distribution to `mediators in political education and
interested parties in tertiary education and at schools' [5J]. The
author was interviewed on the subject of Prussia for one hour on the
bi-weekly programme `Klassik à la Carte' (Norddeutscher Rundfunk — est.
audience 850,000) on 23 January 2012, and contributed interview material
to the RBB Docudrama 'Friedrich: Ein deutscher König' starring Anna and
Katharina Thalbach, and broadcast on 7 Jan 2012. The author also
contributed interview material relating to Prussia for the Gebrüder Beetz
docudrama `Die Akte Kleist', broadcast by ARTE on 24 March 2011 [5B]
and for the Credo Film docudrama `Rahel — eine preußische Affäre' [5C],
broadcast by ARTE on 5 December 2009.
On 27 November 2011, Die Zeit printed a debate on Frederick II
between the author and the Polish journalist Adam Krzeminski [5D]
and on 7 December 2011, Stern-Magazin published an interview with
the author [5E].
On 6 November 2010, the author became the first person from outside
German-speaking Europe to receive the triannual 'Deutscher
Historikerpreis' awarded by the Bavarian Academy of Sciences. The prize
was presented by Federal President Christian Wulf (Köhler's successor) who
spoke of the book's importance in transforming public perceptions of
Prussia and inaugurating a different way of conceptualising the
relationship between present and past in Germany. The event received wide
media coverage [5F, 5G].
On 23 January 2012, the author was asked to deliver the keynote address
on the occasion of the official anniversary marking the 300th
birthday of Frederick II in the Konzerthaus in central Berlin. The other
speakers were Federal President Wulff, the Lord Mayor of Berlin, Klaus
Wowereit, the Minister-President of Brandenburg, Matthias Platzeck and the
Prince of Prussia. The event was broadcast live by Rundfunk
Berlin-Brandenburg and the author's address was reprinted in Berliner
Zeitung and Süddeutsche Zeitung, and reviewed in over one
hundred newspapers [5H].
In short: the impact of this book has been felt far beyond the usual
academic milieux. It is seen as having helped to transform contemporary
German engagements with the country's past. In 2008, the Süddeutsche
Zeitung cited the book prominently in a 4-page comment piece
entitled 'Prussia is Sexy Again', and in a book-length conversation with
the former German foreign minister Joschka Fischer, published this year,
the American emigré German-Jewish historian Fritz Stern spoke of the
'Prussian renaissance' (Preußen-Renaissance) triggered by the book [5I].
Sources to corroborate the impact
H. Full text of the address at http://www.perspectivia.net/content/publikationen/friedrich300-studien/clark_friedrich;
full publicity file available from DVA Munich.
I. Gegen den Strom. Ein Gespräch über Geschichte und Politik,
by Fischer, Joschka and Stern, Fritz [C.H. Beck, 2013])