3. What are you reading? : Editing Robert Louis Stevenson
Submitting Institution
University of EdinburghUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
The Stevenson project, in collaboration with the National Library of
Scotland, has built bridges between general and scholarly readers of a
major, popular Scottish author. The project helped to change the ways in
which members of the public understand the significance of editorial work
and book-history. Providing readers with practical skills with which to
approach varying editions of Stevenson's work, it promoted broader
understanding of how we encounter the work of major authors. It has also
influenced the ways in which the National Library of Scotland (NLS)
communicates its central mission to the public, by demonstrating how to
expand appreciation not just of literary works themselves but also of the
Library's collections and its role in preserving and presenting our
literary heritage.
Underpinning research
Funded by a £184k Royal Society of Edinburgh Major Research Grant for the
Arts and Humanities, the Stevenson project addresses interest in one of
the most enduringly popular Scottish authors—Robert Louis Stevenson. At
the core of the project is a definitive edition of all of Stevenson's work
(39 volumes), begun in 2009 at a workshop funded by a £7k Royal Society of
Edinburgh Workshop Grant, which is expected to be complete by 2017. The
project relies on original research into the historical contexts and
material production of Stevenson's work, both to extend and activate
public knowledge of his writing and to educate the public in the
significance of editing and book-history in understanding and preserving
our literary culture.
Led by Penny Fielding (Professor of Nineteenth-Century Literature,
appointed UoE 1995) with the participation of Robert Irvine (Senior
Lecturer, appointed UoE 1999) and Alex Thomson (Senior Lecturer, appointed
UoE 2006), the project is run by Scottish Writing in the Nineteenth
Century (SWINC), a research grouping in the department of English
Literature that explores the contexts for Scottish writing and organizes
public and academic events. The participants are all published researchers
of Stevenson's work whose expertise informs the editorial project.
Fielding is one of four General Editors of the new complete works of
Stevenson. Irvine has edited Prince Otto (in press for 2014), and
Thomson is volume editor of Memories and Portraits, one of a
5-volume set of Stevenson's Essays, the first time they will have been
brought together, edited and indexed. These volumes each contain an
introduction to the historical and literary context, extensive explanatory
endnotes, and a history of the text from inception to reception, as will
all subsequent volumes in the series. The completed edition, contracted to
Edinburgh University Press, will include all of Stevenson's published
work, much of it edited for the first time. The Edition team has already
revealed much regarding Stevenson's practices as a writer and historical
researcher, his collaborations, the way he amended his work and the
history of his publication and readership. The Stevenson project is also
creating a database of digitizations of all the materials drawn on for the
edition. Clean and fully searchable texts of all the early publications
and editions of Stevenson's works, sourced from the National Library of
Scotland's holdings, will be made available through the NLS website.
References to the research
3.1 Edited book. Penny Fielding (ed). The Edinburgh Companion
to Robert Louis Stevenson. Edinburgh University Press, 2010.
Includes Chapters: `Romance and Social Class' (Robert Irvine),
`Stevenson's Poetry' (Penny Fielding), `Stevenson's Afterlives' (Alex
Thomson). (Submitted in REF2.)
3.2 Journal article. Alex Thomson, `Familiar Style in Memories
and Portraits,' Journal of Stevenson Studies 9 (2012) 119-148. (Can
be supplied by HEI on request.)
3.3 Edition. Robert Irvine (ed). Prince Otto. Edinburgh
University Press, in press for 2014. (Proof copy can be supplied by HEI on
request.)
3.4 Penny Fielding (PI). `The New Edinburgh Edition of the
Collected Works of Robert Louis Stevenson'. Royal Society of Edinburgh
Major Research Grant for Arts and Humanities. 2011- 2014. £183,490.
3.5 Penny Fielding (PI). `Robert Louis Stevenson in the 21st
Century', Royal Society of Edinburgh Research Workshop Grant. 2009.
£7,290.
Details of the impact
A commitment to enhancing the broader impact of its research was built
into the Stevenson project from its inception. The impacts described here
all occurred during the process of the project, in a series of activities
accompanying work on the edition that helped members of the public to
develop an enhanced appreciation both of the work of the National Library
of Scotland, and of how textual scholarship can enrich cultural capital.
Between October and December 2011, a public engagement programme, jointly
organized by the NLS and SWINC, mounted a series of three public talks and
workshops at the NLS, presented under the general title What Are You
Reading?. This directly introduced over 200 members of the public to
the Library's extensive Stevenson holdings, offering the opportunity to
gain hands-on experience of textual scholarship, to appreciate the
changing receptions of this major Scottish author, and to understand the
nature and purposes of the NLS collections. The three events drew directly
on the Stevenson Edition team's findings and NLS holdings. The first
offered lectures on the textual history of canonical works such as Hamlet
and Ulysses; the second discussed the value of edited texts for
general readers along with an electronic demonstration of digital editing.
The third event was a group workshop in which live problems generated by
work on the edition were explored in small groups led by members of the
Stevenson editorial team. Possible solutions were investigated and
participants generated their own mini-editions to take away. The programme
was booked out with 100 people at each of the first and second events, and
3 groups of 6 attending the workshops. Participants were mainly
Scottish-based but also came from the rest of the UK, France, Germany,
Asia and the USA. (Corroborating sources: 5.1, 5.6)
Impact on members of the public is evident in various forms. Firstly,
participants' understanding of the role and purpose of the NLS was
expanded by enabling them to see the workings behind the public face of
the library. They were engaged not just, as already interested readers,
with an author's works, but with the obligations involved in the
acquisition and management of the collections of a copyright library, in
particular why the NLS should collect so many different editions of the
same work. The edition team also brought the public `inside' the process
of its own research, by enabling participants to observe and even try for
themselves the methods of textual scholarship used by the edition. This
generated a substantially increased appreciation of the vital but often
overlooked role that textual scholarship plays in understanding of
Stevenson's (and other authors') work and significance. Questionnaire
responses testified to these changed perspectives. Of 82 respondents to
questionnaires over the 3 events, 46 reported they had a new perspective
on texts and almost half said they now understood how specific examples of
textual scholarship worked. The interactive element of the final workshops
was particularly valued (`It was very unusual and was very
interesting to have the experience of a workshop with hands-on
experience'). Participants reported changes in personal engagement with
literature, suggesting they had gained, `an awareness of editing processes
and the incentive to consider differences in editions and the consequences
of these differences'; `Definitely sparks curiosity and the desire for
more in depth discussions & thinking.' (Corroborating source: 5.6)
Beyond the What are you Reading? events, research for the edition
has also led not only to a significant widening of public access to the
full corpus of Stevenson's writing, but to the engagement of general
readers with questions surrounding the editing, reception and continuing
significance of his works. This is apparent from media attention during
the early stages of the edition: for example, the decision to regroup the
short stories according to Stevenson's own wishes was covered in The
Observer (24.4.2011) and The Scotsman (27.4.2011). A
significantly widening body of readers has also been drawn in via the
project's interactive blog that directly engages the public with the
textual editing of Stevenson's works. Traffic on the blog has increased
dramatically since it was launched in July 2010, from 426 visits in the
first year to over 7k in 2013. Much of this traffic comes from outside the
academy, and members of the public have been active in themselves
suggesting manuscript readings for the edition and possible sources for
elements of Stevenson's texts. The project blog has thus created an active
on-going forum for exchange and development, demonstrating how the impacts
of the research are extending well beyond the workshop series.
(Corroborating sources: 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 5.8)
The project brought significant benefit to the National Library of
Scotland. The Royal Society of Edinburgh grant covers the costs for both
the digitized archive of NLS Stevenson holdings, and the material costs of
workshop 3 in the What Are You Reading? series. That programme
specifically helped the Library to communicate and demonstrate to a wider
audience the value of its work in preserving and presenting Stevenson's
writings, and the importance of its collections of multiple editions of
the same work. It also offered opportunities for the use of these
resources beyond the professional scholarly community. This was clearly
appreciated by participants (`A different `take' on the usual book centred
talks'), with two thirds of questionnaire respondents saying they would
definitely attend future NLS events. The NLS Events Officer confirmed that
the project had introduced new practices in communicating the Library's
mission: `the events have been a huge success .... It is the Library's
mission to provide access to and promote the remarkable items that we hold
in our collection and this programme of events has done this effectively
through its series of fascinating lectures ... and workshops'.
(Corroborating sources: 5.1, 5.6, 5.7)
The Stevenson project was devised so that its initial impact on
participants of the NLS programme will continue to extend to new,
potentially global communities of readers. The digitization project will
provide the Library with a valuable upgraded public-access searchable
electronic archive of its Stevenson holdings. While attracting new users
of the collections, this will also disseminate the project's developing
insights into Stevenson's working practices, readership and significance
during his lifetime. As this resource grows it will build up a complete
picture of his works' textual history which will be available to all NLS
users. This extended reach is in keeping with the Stevenson project's
emphasis on enabling general readers to make richer judgments about
literary texts and the significance of their cultural history.
(Corroborating source: 5.5)
Sources to corroborate the impact
URLs below are original links. Should any be unavailable, see archived
copies at: www.wiki.ed.ac.uk/display/REF2014REF3B/UoA+29.
5.1 Contact: Events Officer, National Library of Scotland. Can
confirm `What are you Reading' events, participant numbers and domiciles.
5.2 Project blog, `EdRLS' (http://edrls.wordpress.com/).
Demonstrates active engagement of public with textual editing of
Stevenson's works.
5.3 Newspaper article. `Robert Louis Stevenson gets his revenge on
sneaky literary agent — 120 years later', The Observer 24 April
2011. (http://www.theguardian.com/books/2011/apr/24/robert-louis-stevenson-fairytales
) Corroborates claim of generation of public interest in editorial issues.
5.4 `Fairy tale ending for Stevenson book row', The Scotsman
26 April 2011. (http://www.scotsman.com/news/fairytale-ending-for-stevenson-book-row-1-1607989
) Corroborates claim of generation of public interest in editorial issues.
5.5 Contact: Digital Collections Specialist, National Library of
Scotland. Can confirm project's agreement with the NLS to provide clean
and updated digitizations of the Library's Stevenson holdings.
5.6 `What Are You Reading?' participant questionnaire digest.
Confirms participants' data and quoted responses. (Can be supplied by HEI
on request.)
5.7 A letter from the Development and Events officer, NLS.
Corroborates quoted statement, paragraph 5. (Can be supplied by HEI on
request.)
5.8 E-mail from Richard Dury, General Editor Stevenson edition.
Confirms web hits on the blog. (Available from HEI on request.)