Republishing Welsh Women’s Classics
Submitting Institution
University of South WalesUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Since 1997 Professor Jane Aaron has been the founding and continuing
editor of the series `Welsh
Women's Classics', published by the independent Welsh feminist press Honno
with the aim of
bringing back into print virtually forgotten texts, prefaced by scholarly
introductions. Twenty-two
volumes have appeared in the series to date, five of which Aaron edited
and introduced. Their
impact on the reading public and on higher educational institutions in
Wales has been
considerable; far more Welsh women writers — the majority of them
published in the series — are
taught, researched and read today than in the mid-1990s.
Underpinning research
Professor Aaron started her researches on Welsh women writers in the late
1980s; she has to date
published two monographs, 13 book chapters, 17 journal articles and 33
biographical dictionary
entries on the subject. Her pioneering studies have recovered an important
and hitherto neglected
body of writing by Welsh women, and they have been well received. Both her
monographs have
won major Welsh literary prizes, and she has lectured extensively on Welsh
women's writing, to
academic audiences (63 conference papers/lectures), to historical
societies and at literary festivals
in Wales (27 talks/lectures), and on the media (12 tv and radio
talks/interviews). Professor Aaron
also co-edits the University of Wales Press' Writers of Wales
series, with particular responsibility
for the volumes on female authors, and in 2006 she founded the same
press's interdisciplinary
series Gender Studies in Wales. Nine volumes have appeared in this
series to date, four of which
have been devoted to literary themes, with two further literary titles
currently in press.
The first publication in that series, Aaron's Nineteenth-Century
Women's Writing in Wales
(2007), for which she was awarded an AHRC research grant, discussed the
work of over a
hundred writers, most of them out of print and the majority long
forgotten. Through its use of
postcolonial and gender theory to explore and articulate the complex
reasons for the particular
neglect of Welsh women's writing in English, it established a context
which enabled a more
accurate and nuanced understanding and appreciation of Welsh women's
writing generally. It also
pushed back the historical boundaries of the canon of Welsh writing in
English, correcting the
previous critical consensus that no significant Anglophone Welsh
literature was published before
the twentieth century, and exploding the widely-held notion that, in the
words of the influential critic
Gwyn Jones, `the Anglo-Welsh genre has tended to be a masculine affair'
(G. Jones, ed., Classic
Welsh Short Stories, OUP, 1971, rptd. 1992, x).
Her earlier 1998 Welsh-language monograph on the portrayal of Welsh women
in
nineteenth-century literature was published just after Aaron was awarded a
Professorship at USW.
Since moving to live and work in the Valleys, she has also researched and
published on the
twentieth-century female authors of the south Wales industrial townships,
e.g. the novelist Menna
Gallie. Women writers of the Welsh border country, e.g. Margiad Evans and
Hilda Vaughan,
became another area of research interest, on which she published in her
co-edited volume
Gendering Border Studies (2010), an international and
interdisciplinary essay collection focussing
on gender issues at global borders.
International interest in her work is also evinced by the fact that she
has twice taught Welsh
women's writing modules at the University of Tübingen as Visiting
Professor (in 1997 and 2004),
and lectured on the topic in France, Germany and the United States. Her
work has been published
in German and Croatian journals and, through UWP's affiliation with the
University of Chicago
Press, it has also been disseminated in the States. At USW, her
scholarship has been central to
one of the most vibrant research areas in the English Unit, inspiring
colleagues and emerging
scholars — including Diana Wallace, Claire Flay and Alison Fauvre — to
research in this area and
produce editions for Honno's series.
References to the research
Key outputs from the research described in the previous section:
• Nineteenth-Century Women's Writing in Wales: Nation, Gender and
Identity (Cardiff:
University of Wales Press, 2007), viii + 248 pp. ISBN 978 0 7083 2060 0
• Pur fel y Dur: Y Gymraes yn Llên Menywod y Bedwaredd Ganrif ar
Bymtheg [Pure as Steel:
The Welsh woman in nineteenth-century women's writing] (Caerdydd: Gwasg
Prifysgol Cymru,
1998), x + 249 tud. ISBN 0 7083 1481 3
• `Taking sides: Power-play on the Welsh border in early
twentieth-century women's writing',
in Jane Aaron, Henrice Altink and Chris Weedon, eds., Gendering Border
Studies (Cardiff:
University of Wales Press, 2010), pp. 127-141. ISBN 978-0-7083-2170-6
• `Valleys' Women Writing', in Alyce von Rothkirch and Daniel Williams,
eds, Beyond the
Difference: Welsh Literature in Comparative Contexts (Cardiff:
University of Wales Press, 2004),
pp. 84-96. ISBN 07083 1886 X
• ``Women in a Wales without miners', in Eberhard Bort and Neil Evans,
eds, Networking
Europe: Essays on Regionalism and Social Democracy (Liverpool:
Liverpool University Press,
2000), 111-127. ISBN 0-8532-3941-X
• `Zene u potrazi za velškim identitetom' [`Women in search of a Welsh
identity'], in Kolo:
Casopis Matice hrvatske [Croatian literary journal], 2 (2000),
301-311. ISSN 1331 0992
Evidence for the quality of the research:
• Nineteenth-Century Women's Writing in Wales: Nation, Gender and
Identity won the
Roland Mathias Prize in 2009, and was a leading output in USW's 2008 RAE
submission.
Favourable reviews for Nineteenth-Century Women's Writing in Wales
include: Louise Miskell,
Planet, 187 (2008), 106-7; Kirsti Bohata, New Welsh Review,
80 (Summer, 2008), 25-33; Cathryn
A. Charnell-White, Taliesin, 133 (2008), 143-145.
• Pur fel y Dur: Y Gymraes yn Llên Menywod y Bedwaredd Ganrif ar
Bymtheg won the Ellis
Griffith Prize in 1999, and was in USW's 2001 RAE submission. Favourable
reviews for Pur fel y
Dur include: Deirdre Beddoe, New Welsh Review, 46 (1999),
89-90; Ruth McElroy, Planet, 136
(1999), 102-103; Huw M. Edwards, Taliesin, 107 (1999), 119-122.
• `Taking Sides' is included in REF2014 outputs.
Details of the impact
As the founding series editor of `Welsh Women's Classics', which up to
2011 was entitled `Honno
Classics', Aaron (with Katie Gramich as co-editor of the series from
1997-2008) has ensured the
wider recognition and appreciation of Welsh women's achievement as
writers, internationally as
well as in Wales itself. In 1997 the works of virtually none of the
authors reprinted in the series
were in the public domain and they had not been for generations. Today
sales of `Welsh Women's
Classics' total over 14,000; best sellers amongst them include the short
story anthology A View
Across the Valley: Short Stories by Women from Wales1850-1950 edited
by Aaron (1,648 sales,
and currently on the English literature syllabus at the universities of
Aberystwyth, Bangor, Cardiff
and Swansea); a poetry anthology, Welsh Women's Poetry 1460-2001
eds. Katie Gramich and
Catherine Brennan (1,369 sales); and, among the individual novels, Menna
Gallie's The Small
Mine (1,531 sales) and Amy Dillwyn's The Rebecca Rioter
(1,282 sales). While these figures
indicate its reach, the significance of the series is evinced by public
recognition of its appeal as an
unique and pioneering project, and by its influence, in particular, on the
teaching and researching
of Welsh writing in English at the higher education institutions of Wales.
(In the data provided
below, care has been taken entirely to exclude all reference to teaching,
research and publishing
by USW staff and students.)
In fact, a quiet revolution has occurred in Welsh writing in English
studies. During the
twentieth century, very few women authors were included in its canon; in
1989, for example, the
only Welsh woman writer taught in Aberystwyth University's English
department, one of the few
which at the time offered Welsh writing in English modules, was the
Welsh-language novelist Kate
Roberts, taught in translation. Since Honno commenced operations, however,
the ratio of women
authors to men on the syllabuses has changed dramatically and continues to
increase. 16 Welsh
female authors featured on English literature syllabuses at Aberystwyth,
Bangor, Swansea and
Cardiff universities in 2010 compared to 20 male authors, and 33 women to
44 men in 2013. Of
course, these changes are in part the result of the long-term effect of
the second wave of the
feminist movement, but female-authored texts could not have been taught
had they not been
readily available. Of the 33 women writers taught in 2013, 21 had been
reprinted in the Welsh
Women's Classics series.
By now that teaching has also affected the topics chosen for postgraduate
research. Before
this century, theses on Welsh women writers listed in the National Library
of Wales' catalogue
were so few they could be counted on one hand, but of the nine PhD theses
on Welsh writing in
English (excluding those by USW students) listed from 2008-2013, three
were on male authors,
two on women writers (both novelists reprinted in Welsh Women's Classics),
and four included
chapters on both sexes' writings. Published criticism in the field has
also been marked by a similar
shift. In the mid 1990s records indicate that annually the ratio of
critical studies on Welsh
Anglophone women authors in relation to men was less than 1:10, with 4
outputs on women writers
published in 1994 compared to 61 on men, and 9 outputs on women to 91 on
men in 1995. By
2008, however, that ratio had changed to 23 women to 65 men, while in 2009
it improved again to
22 women (17 of whom had been reprinted in the Honno series) to 45 men,
and 24 studies
comparing work by both sexes.
Lay readers too have welcomed the series. Each of the volumes has been
favourably
reviewed in print and/or broadcast media; and public bodies with
responsibility for the arts in
Wales, like the Welsh Arts Council and Literature Wales, have been
vociferous in their praise. The
series has proved particularly popular with book club members throughout
the country, with
Honno's move to digitalize all its Classics also being welcomed. For a
variety of historical reasons
Welsh culture was until very recently more than usually dominated by male
voices, a bias much
exacerbated by the fact that so few of the works by women who did succeed,
against the odds, in
becoming published writers were kept in print. But readers today want
their literature to represent
as fully as possible the heterogeneous diversity of past and present Welsh
life. The Welsh
Women's Classics series is helping to correct the gender imbalance, and
provide a varied array of
role models for the next generation of prospective Welsh women writers.
Its impact in terms of its
national significance for Wales has been profound and is likely to prove
long-lasting.
Sources to corroborate the impact
- The titles and sales (indicated in square brackets) of the series to
date are as follows:
- Jane Aaron, ed. A View across the Valley: Short Stories by Women
from Wales 1850-1950
(1999, rptd. 2003) [1,648]
- Jane Aaron and Ursula Masson, eds, The Very Salt of Life: Welsh
Women's Political
Writings from Chartism to Suffrage (2007) [296]
- Elizabeth Andrews, A Woman's Work is Never Done (1957), ed.
Ursula Masson (2006)
[657]
- Amy Dillwyn, The Rebecca Rioter (1880), ed. Katie Gramich
(2001, rptd 2003) [1,282]
- ____, A Burglary (1883), ed. Alison Favre (2009) [262]
- ____, Jill (1884), ed. Kirsti Bohata (2013) [144].
- Dorothy Edwards, Winter Sonata (1928), ed. Claire Flay (2011)
[196]
- Margiad Evans, The Wooden Doctor (1933), ed. Sue Asbee (2005)
[379]
- Menna Gallie, Strike for a Kingdom (1959), ed. Angela John
(2003, rptd. 2010) [857]
- ____, The Small Mine (1962), ed. Jane Aaron (2000; rptd 2003,
2010) [1,531]
- ____, Travels with a Duchess (1968), ed. Angela John
(1996; rptd. 2010) [669]
- ____, You're Welcome to Ulster (1970), ed. Angela John and
Claire Connolly
(2010) [294].
- Katie Gramich and Catherine Brennan, eds, Welsh Women's Poetry
1460-2001 (2003)
[1,369]
- Eiluned Lewis, Dew on the Grass (1934), ed. Katie Gramich
(2006) [578]
- ____, The Captain's Wife (1943), ed. Katie Gramich (2008)
[516]
- Allen Raine, A Welsh Witch (1902), ed. Jane Aaron (2013) [156]
- ____, Queen of the Rushes (1906), ed. Katie Gramich (1998)
[686]
- Bertha Thomas, Stranger within the Gates (1912), ed. Kirsti
Bohata (2008) [270]
- Lily Tobias, Eunice Fleet (1933), ed. Jasmine Donahaye (2004)
[576]
- Hilda Vaughan, Here Are Lovers (1926), ed. Diana Wallace
(2012) [215]
- ____, Iron and Gold (1948), ed. Jane Aaron (2002) [603]
- Jane Williams, Betsy Cadwaladyr: A Balaclava Nurse (1857), ed.
Deirdre Beddoe (1987;
rptd 2007) [838]
- To corroborate the list of titles and sales given above, contact the
editor of Honno Press [1].
For general information on Welsh Women's Classics, see
<http://www.honno.co.uk/chwilio.php?func=pori_adran&adran=Classic>.
- For the reading lists for Welsh writing in English modules, see the
relevant undergraduate
and postgraduate prospectuses of Aberystwyth, Bangor, Cardiff and
Swansea universities. The
syllabuses for 2013 are currently on the universities' websites.
- For Welsh writing in English postgraduate theses from 2008-2013, see
the `Theses
Collection Wales' in the National Library of Wales catalogue, <http://cat.llgc.org.uk/cgi-bin/gw/chameleon?lng=en&skin=theses>.
The
catalogue numbers for the theses referred to are as
follows: 2011/0375, 2011/0883, 2011/0770 (on male authors only);
2013/0256; 2012/0332;
2011/0710; 2010/0931 (comparative, including chapters on male and female
authors); 2009/0236;
NLW ex 2595 (on female authors only). That last listed thesis, on
Margiad Evans' The Wooden
Doctor (reprinted by Honno in 2005), was awarded a PhD from the
University of Rennes, an
indicator of the international reach of the series.
- For the data on publishing, see the annual bibliographies of criticism
on Welsh writing in
English for 1994 and 1995 in the journal Welsh Writing in English: A
Yearbook of Critical Essays,
vols. 2 and 3 (1996 and 1997); for the 2008 and 2009 figures see the
online `Bibliography of
scholarly work in the field of Welsh writing in English, 2006-2010' on
<http://ijwwe.wordpress.com/bibliography-of-scholarly-work-in-the-field-of-welsh-writing-in-english/2010-2/>,
the
International Journal of Welsh Writing in English's website,
- To corroborate the esteem with which the series is held by the Welsh
Arts Council, see, for
example, Professor Dai Smith, Chair of the Welsh Arts Council on
<http://thelibraryofwales.com/low/english/news_archive-62640.asp>:
`The women's press Honno
[...] have done terrific work in bringing women's literature back into
print'
- To corroborate the esteem with which the series is held by Literature
Wales see, for
example, <http://www.literaturewales.org/archive/i/138660/n/51/>:
`Honno Press has reprinted, in
its Classics series, four terrific novels by Menna Gallie. This [...]
helps to reassert Gallie's position
in the Welsh literary canon and offers readers and scholars fascinating
and complex texts with
which to engage.'
- For favourable media reviews see, for example, the Welsh national
newspaper, the
Western Mail's interviews and columns on the Honno classics over
the years (e.g. 27:04:13,
3:11:12) and its serialization of Eiluned Lewis's Dew on the Grass
when it was republished by
Honno in 2006; or a well-informed review article on Bertha Thomas, Amy
Dillwyn, Allen Raine and
the series' three anthologies in The Latchkey: Journal of New
Women's Studies, iv (2012),
<http://www.oscholars.com/Latchkey/Latchkey4/br/honno.htm>;
or Clare Morgan's review of Hilda
Vaughan's Here Are Lovers in the TLS, 19:10:12.
- For book club enthusiasm, see for example a member of the Bangor
`Reading Wales' book
club, on A View across the Valley: `You only have to scan the
author biographies at the back of the
book to understand how Welsh women writers have been neglected over the
past 200 years [...] in
many cases there has been no republication of the authors' work [...] If
it wasn't for Jane Aaron's
edited collection I would probably never have come across these unique
short stories'
(<http://readingwales.wordpress.com>);
or, from another reader, `liking' Vaughan's Here Are
Lovers, `I wouldn't have thought of reading this if it hadn't been
one of the book choices for our
local reading group, but did find it fascinating.' <http://www.amazon.co.uk/Lovers-Honno-Classics-Welsh
Womens/dp/1906784442>
- For the series' over-all impact, see, for example, New Welsh
Review, 80 (2008) 29: `It is
difficult to imagine a Welsh literary landscape without the Honno
Classics series.'