Centre for Robert Burns Studies: Locating Burns in Scottish and Global Culture
Submitting Institution
University of GlasgowUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
The Centre for Robert Burns Studies at the University of Glasgow has
played a major role in raising public awareness and enhancing
understanding of the work, global reputation and iconic status of
Scotland's national poet, Robert Burns. This has been achieved by (i)
forging Scotland-wide links between university, local authority and
national collections of Burns-related material, making readily available
the full extent of the country's rich holdings in this area for the first
time; (ii) increasing and encouraging global awareness of and access to
Burns's work through events, online resources and the use of social and
traditional media; and (iii) convening an international network of Burns
organisations and events. The Centre's exhibitions and performances have
attracted upwards of 200,000 visitors and participants in the REF period.
Underpinning research
The University of Glasgow (UoG) has a long-established base of research
expertise in the life and work of Robert Burns. The Centre
for Robert Burns Studies (CRBS), based in UoG's School of Critical
Studies, is the only research centre in the world devoted exclusively to
the study of Scotland's national poet. Researchers at CRBS have been
particularly concerned to bring about a reassessment of the various ways
in which Burns's life and work have been presented to the public during
and after his lifetime. This has been achieved in two ways: first, by
investigating the role of his early editors and the transmission of his
texts, both in print and in performance, up to the present; and, secondly,
by studying the influence of the Burns `myth' both in the sphere of
material culture (domestic ornaments, pictures, etc.) and in the contexts
of Scottish history and identity.
Between 2006 and 2008 CRBS researchers created an annotated digital
edition of the correspondence (127 letters) of Burns's first editor, James
Currie [see link].
Currie's Life and Works of Robert Burns (1800) is the most
significant publication in the early stages of the poet's reception,
setting in motion many `myths' as well as giving the basic biographical
facts. The CRBS edition of Currie's letters brought to light the subtlety
of his negotiations with Burns's acquaintances, showing how carefully he
worked to produce a text that would not embarrass the poet's dependents
after his early death, and how scrupulously Currie tried to ensure that
they received appropriate remuneration from his edition — thus
contradicting those commentators who have claimed that he rewrote the
poet's life and work purely to satisfy his own predilections.
Between 2007 and 2009 CRBS played a pivotal role in the AHRC-funded Global
Burns Network, organising a number of events at which new research
on Burns was shared and published. During that time CRBS staff
demonstrated particular expertise in the areas of song culture, publishing
history, postcolonial studies, and the posthumous reputation and
iconography of the poet. In the field of song culture, for example, CRBS
research into the American composer Serge Hovey's fascination with Burns
uncovered new information about Burns's original melodic choices and their
sometimes inconsistent treatment in early publications. In addition, CRBS
staff discovered the hitherto unknown French source for the song `The case
of conscience', and succeeded in authenticating Burns's note to the
`Highland Lassie', which gives a first-hand account of his famous love
affair with Highland Mary, dismissed by some Burns scholars as a myth. In
the field of publication history, CRBS research proved that the early
Burns editor R H Cromek was reliable, not fraudulent; and, in postcolonial
studies, staff demonstrated that Burns engaged in his poems with a
specific set of metaphors deployed in the contemporary transatlantic
discourse of slavery.
In 2010 Nigel Leask published the monograph Burns and Pastoral,
which demonstrated that a crucial context for the understanding of Burns's
work can be provided by a study of 18th-century agrarian economics and the
poet's training as an `improving' tenant farmer. Leask examined the poet's
reputation as a `heaven-taught ploughman' and showed this to be largely
dictated by the generic conventions of pastoral poetry, whose long
association with rural dialects also explains the widespread popularity of
his writing in Ayrshire Scots at a time of increasing linguistic
anglicisation. Leask's book offers fresh readings of all Burns's major
poetry in its historical and social contexts, the first to do so since
Thomas Crawford's study of 1960, and concludes with a new assessment of
his importance for British Romanticism.
CRBS research for the AHRC-funded project Beyond Text: Robert Burns:
Inventing Tradition and Securing Memory (2010-11) discovered more
about the relationship between Burns's work and wider material culture in
the 19th century. First, the material objects associated with Burns in
this period diverged from the biographical record in that they celebrated
the poet's connection with masculine conviviality and drinking culture,
rather than decrying these things, as was the tendency in the biographies.
Secondly, the legend of Burns's relationship with Highland Mary was
propagated by the manufacture of statues and objects rather than texts.
The CRBS team examined the commemoration of Burns in relics, artefacts and
memorabilia, while the University of Dundee was responsible for
researching his memorialisation in statues and monuments.
Key researchers during the REF period: Professor Gerry Carruthers,
Co-Director CRBS (Professor of Scottish Literature 2011 to the present,
Senior Lecturer 2007-2011); Dr Kirsteen McCue Co-Director CRBS (Senior
Lecturer in Scottish Literature 2009 to the present, Lecturer 2002-09);
Professor Nigel Leask FBA FRSE (Regius Chair English Language &
Literature 2004 to the present); Professor Murray Pittock FRSE (Bradley
Chair in English Literature 2007 to the present); Dr Rhona Brown (Lecturer
in Scottish Literature 2006 to the present); and Dr Pauline Mackay
(Lecturer in Robert Burns Studies 2013 to the present, Research
Assistant/Associate 2007-13).
References to the research
- Nigel Leask, Robert Burns and Pastoral: Poetry and Improvement in
Late 18th Century Scotland (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010).
Joint winner 2010 Saltire Prize for Best Scottish Research Book. ISBN
9780199572618 (REF 2 Output)
- Murray Pittock, ed., Robert Burns in Global Culture (Lewisburg:
Bucknell, 2011). Includes contributions from Leask, Mackay and Pittock.
ISBN: 1611480302 (Available from HEI)
- Gerard Carruthers, ed., The Edinburgh Companion to Robert Burns
(Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2009). Includes contributions by
Brown, Carruthers, Leask and McCue. ISBN 9780748636488 (Available from
HEI)
- Gerard Carruthers, `Some Recent Discoveries in Robert Burns Studies', Scottish
Literary Review 2.1 (2010), pp. 143-58, ISSN 1756-5634. (REF2
Output)
- Sharon Alker, Leith Davis and Holly Faith Nelson, eds., Robert
Burns and Transatlantic Culture (Farnham: Ashgate, 2012). ISBN
9781409405764. Includes contributions by Brown, Carruthers, Leask, McCue
and Pittock. (Available from HEI)
Grants
- 2007-8, Carnegie Research Grant for The Correspondence of James
Currie (£30k).
- 2008-9, AHRC award for Global Burns Network (£26k).
- 2010-11, AHRC award for Beyond Text: Robert Burns: Inventing
Tradition and Securing Memory, 1796-1909 (£145k).
- 2012-16, AHRC award for Editing Burns for the 21st Century
(£1.1m).
Details of the impact
CRBS has generated impact in the following ways:
1. Forging Scotland-wide links between university, local authority and
national collections of Burns-related material, thereby enhancing
cultural life and engaging civil society.
CRBS is a key member of Burns Scotland, formerly the Distributed National
Burns Collections Project, which was created in 2008. Burns
Scotland — a partnership between UoG, the National Library of
Scotland, National Galleries Scotland, National Museums Scotland, Glasgow
Life, Dumfries and Galloway Museums and East and South Ayrshire Museums —
coordinates management of and promotes access to and appreciation of the
approximately 36,000 items relating to Burns in Scottish public
collections.
In 2008 Carruthers served as academic consultant to the Burns Scotland
exhibition Zig Zag: The Paths of Robert Burns, which displayed
Burns-related items and his writings in order to throw light on his
participation in the creation of his own myth. Zig Zag attracted
52,991 visitors to venues in Edinburgh, Glasgow, Dumfries and Aberdeen.
Since 2010 Carruthers has also chaired the Burns Scotland Research
Committee. In 2012 Burns Scotland co-hosted the annual CRBS conference, Robert
Burns: Artefact, which attracted academic and non-academic Burns
enthusiasts from around the world, and included the display of
Burns-related treasures and performances of Burns-related music. One-day
Burns conferences have been held annually by CRBS since 2007, each
attracting around 150 specialists and members of the general public from
the UK and abroad.
In 2011 CRBS's MacKay co-curated a series of exhibitions entitled Robert
Burns Beyond Text with the National Trust for Scotland and Glasgow's
Mitchell Library, designed to enhance public understanding of Burns's
contribution to the Scottish cultural landscape. The project team also
developed the Mitchell's Treasure of the Month exhibition for January
2011, February 2011 and January 2013, during which time 120,258 people
visited the library. The exhibitions displayed objects held in the
Mitchell's Burns collections, with notes pointing visitors to the UoG
Beyond Text website (Robert
Burns: Inventing Tradition and Securing Memory, 1796-1909), which
offers new perspectives on his writing. As an example, among the objects
curated at the Mitchell were a number celebrating the link between Burns
and masculinity, with scenes from Tam o' Shanter depicted on items
associated with a range of `male' activities, including shaving (razor
hones) and smoking (snuffboxes) as well as drinking (whisky jugs). The
work of UoG's researchers enhanced public understanding of how different
materials have helped to inform the cultural memory of this national
figure. Impact was gauged using feedback forms, with almost 100% of
respondents finding the exhibition `interesting' or `very interesting'.
The Robert Burns Beyond Text exhibition was also hosted by the
Robert Burns Birthplace Museum in Alloway from March to April 2011, with
CRBS researchers working alongside the museum's curatorial and educational
staff. UoG's research input, again in the form of notes and website,
underscored the exhibition's emphasis on the relationship between literary
and material culture, addressing questions such as whether the choice of
means of commemoration (through particular kinds of object or images of
Burns) had an effect on public perception of certain poems or on
approaches to the writer's life. The museum drew 61,000 visitors during
the months of the exhibition. CRBS also curated exhibitions for the
University of Dundee (March 2011) and for UoG's School of Scottish
Literature (May 2011) and Hunterian Art Gallery (November-December 2011).
2. Promoting access to Burns's work through events, online resources
and use of social and traditional media, enhancing public engagement and
creating cultural capital.
CRBS researchers have taken an innovative approach to textual editing,
combining online data, scholarly editions and a taxonomy of Burns-related
objects with song recordings and crowd-sourced information-gathering from
the Burns Federation and the wider collecting community. In 2009-10 CRBS
worked with the BBC to create a permanent online
audio archive of Burns's works. The publicly accessible archive
features recorded performances of 716 works by celebrities including
Robert Carlyle, Robbie Coltrane, Brian Cox, Alan Cumming, Liz Lochhead,
Phyllis Logan, Ian McDiarmid, Siobhan Redmond, Elaine C Smith, Alex
Salmond and the Prince of Wales. The BBC producer describes embarking on
the project `armed with a Scots dictionary, and with Gerry Carruthers,
Director of the Robert Burns Centre at Glasgow University at the end of a
telephone or email to check any pronunciation or meanings' [see the BBC
Radio Scotland blog].
CRBS also commissioned a new work by Scottish composer James Macmillan in
2009 to mark the 250th anniversary of Burns's birth. Macmillan chose to
set one of his `most beautiful and lesser known poems', and The Lament
of Mary, Queen of Scots had its premier in UoG's Bute Hall on 16
January 2009 with an audience of 300. The concert included an additional
programme of Burns songs with arrangements by Haydn, responding directly
to a major new edition of Haydn's folksongs produced by UoG academics
Rycroft and Edwards (Music) and McCue (CRBS).
Following the international
conference Robert Burns 1759-2009 (2009), CRBS was approached by
the World Burns Federation to co-organise what turned out to be a
successful world record attempt to perform Burns's Auld Lang Syne
simultaneously in 41 different languages (2009) [see YouTube
video
link]. The Robert Burns 1759-2009 conference also provided a
platform to build important links with schools. CRBS collaborated with
Scottish publisher Itchy Coo to organise a drawing and writing
competition, encouraging children and young people to respond to Burns's
work. Hundreds of entries were received from schools throughout Scotland,
and about 100 children attended the awards presentation at the conference.
The digital resource from the Robert Burns: Inventing Tradition and
Securing Memory project went live in March 2011, and in that month
alone it received 3,262 hits, prompting correspondence from businesspeople
and surveyors as well as academics, and a chatroom on the World Burns
Federation website. The digital resources had received a combined total of
over 24,700 hits by June 2013 (statistics provided by Webalizer version
2.01). This research generated new interest in Burns's legacy, as
evidenced by the response from the press — e.g. The
Herald, 14 March 2011 (`The myth of Burns's mystery muse is
exposed') — and in social media, with significant discussion of the
project on UoG's Twitter account.
The recent AHRC grant for Editing Burns for the 21st Century
resulted in the creation of a global blogsite
and social network for the worldwide community of Burns enthusiasts, which
attracted widespread media interest on its launch in July 2012 and had
received over 13,000 visitors by July 2013. Performances of Burns songs in
various styles have been downloadable
on iTunes from the CRBS website since December 2012, and by October
2013 had been browsed 1,109 times and accessed 811 times.
3. Convening an international network of Burns organisations and
events that enhance understanding of his global influence.
Supported by CRBS, the Global
Burns Network (2008-09) was developed as an information exchange to
enhance understanding of the nature and scale of Burns's international
profile and influence. To commemorate the 250th anniversary of his birth,
the Network hosted a `Countdown to 2009' page
disseminating information about a series of international events in the
USA, Canada, Australia, South Africa, Costa Rica, Ecuador, Czech Republic,
Serbia and Russia. One of these events was the Robert Burns 1759-2009
conference noted above, a three-day event hosted by CRBS. The conference —
which was attended by 607 academics and members of the public — had a
strong outward-facing element, incorporating public talks and evening
performances, and offering a variety of speakers, papers and plenary
lectures. It attracted significant media interest, including press (The
Herald, The Daily Mail, The Sunday Herald, The
Dundee Courier), radio (BBC Radio Scotland, Real Radio and Clyde
One) and television (BBC Scotland's Newsnight and STV News.
Sources to corroborate the impact
Corroborating statements — available from HEI (evidencing benefit
to institutions and public):
- Manager, Manuscript and Archive Collections, National Library of
Scotland
- Director, Robert Burns Birthplace Museum
Testimonials — contact details available from HEI:
- Former Principal Curator, National Museums of Scotland
- Former Curator, Robert Burns Birthplace Museum (on the influence of
Beyond Text)
- Editor of 'Robert Burns Lives' (on influence of CRBS projects on Burns
community in the US)
Press and Media:
- The Herald, 14 January 2009: World's academics descend on city
for Robert Burns event — see [link];
BBC News, 15 January 2009: Three-day Burns festival begins — [link];
`Auld Lang Syne' world record attempt — see YouTube
video, 1 December 2009; BBC News, 14 March 2011: Robert Burns
Highland Mary muse theory disputed — at [link];
STV Website, 25 July 2012: New website created for Robert Burns fans from
around the world to connect — at [link];
Daily Record, 2 October 2012: Digital database with works of Robert
Burns to be created — at [link]
Other — available from HEI:
- Global Burns Network — Final project report for AHRC.
- Robert Burns: Inventing Tradition and Securing Memory, 1796-1909 -
Final report for AHRC.