Place-names and the public: letting the landscape speak
Submitting Institution
University of NottinghamUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Studies In Human Society: Policy and Administration
History and Archaeology: Archaeology, Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Research undertaken by Dr John Baker at the University's Institute for
Name-Studies (INS) through the Leverhulme-funded Landscapes of Governance
project has:
- actively engaged community groups and individuals in academic research
as volunteers: fifty of the project's 350 early medieval assembly sites
were recorded by volunteer groups and individuals, a number of whom were
inspired to undertake further related research of their own;
- enhanced public awareness and understanding about assembly sites
through public engagement events, media coverage, `popular' publications
(with local and national audiences totalling over 2 million) and freely
available web resources, particularly the Key to English Place-Names
(accessed by 18,913 individuals between January 2012 and July 2013);
- informed practice at the BBC through the provision of expert advice on
a range of onomastic matters.
Underpinning research
The underpinning research was undertaken by Dr John Baker (Nottingham
2005-), Senior Research Fellow in the INS, as part of the
Leverhulme-funded project, `Landscapes of Governance: assembly sites in
England, 5th to 11th centuries' (UCL and Nottingham, 2009-12). Baker and
his UCL counterpart, Stuart Brookes, worked full-time on the project and
each contributed 50% to the research and its resulting outputs. Baker's
specialism is place-names.
Baker has developed an innovative methodology, established in the
Leverhulme-project `Beyond the Burghal Hidage' (2005-2008) whose main
output (3.1) uses place-names as a core part of a thoroughly
interdisciplinary approach to issues fundamental to an understanding of
the early medieval period. Public assembly, and its role in the government
of Anglo-Saxon England, is one such subject. Where previous work in the
area has focused primarily on documentary accounts or laws, or has
attempted to understand the nature of the sites and their evolution from
the basis of a single discipline, Baker, together with landscape
archaeologist Brookes, has harnessed the evidence from place-names,
archaeology, documentary history, topographical studies, and site visits,
and has brought it together on an equal footing, using GIS. The
application of this interdisciplinary methodology to Anglo-Saxon
assemblies is explored in 3.6 and 3.7. The importance of the place-name
evidence and the site visits, alongside archaeological evidence, is clear
from the nuanced results seen in 3.2, which treats a specific `class' of
assembly-place, the so-called `hanging promontory' sites. Their main
characteristics, geographical distribution, datings and functions are
explored, alongside comparisons with other forms of open-air assembly
sites which throw light on a possible hierarchy of early medieval
England's administrative territories. 3.3, on the other hand, applies the
methodology to particular parts of England — the Scandinavian-settled
areas — and demonstrates how it can illuminate a complex reality of
administrative and territorial organisation, with considerable variations
in scale, structure, and terminology from region to region. 3.4 shows how
research on assembly-sites can be brought to bear upon other episodes in
history, in this case the landing of a Viking force at Fulham in 878.
Both 3.2 and 3.3 demonstrate that detailed analysis of individual sites
makes possible a clearer differentiation between judicial assemblies that
formed the focus of hundredal units, and other types of assembly site
(e.g. those belonging to a different level within an administrative
hierarchy, or servicing a different specific communal requirement). This
is significant in understanding how the hundredal organisation of the
tenth and eleventh centuries fitted into the wider landscape of public
assembly, how it evolved from or within systems established earlier on,
and how the purpose of these gatherings changed. In this regard, the
functionality of sites indicated toponymically is especially important.
3.5 shows how the methodology can be applied to a particular site within
the context of community archaeology; this is explored further in section
4.
Altogether, the research forms the basis for retrogressive analysis of
the evolution of public assembly and administrative geography, enhancing
our knowledge of early medieval government and its origins. They allow us
to track the changing dynamics of public and private power as expressed
through administrative geography, adding considerably to our understanding
of the growth of state institutions, and the organisation of the early
medieval landscape.
References to the research
The project, `Landscapes of Governance: assembly sites in England, 5th to
11th centuries', was funded by The Leverhulme Trust (ref. F/07 134/CS;
£260K of which £119K came to Nottingham) for the period 19/10/09-18/10/12.
The interdisciplinary methodology was established in `Beyond the Burghal
Hidage: Anglo-Saxon Civil Defence in the Viking Age', funded by The
Leverhulme Trust (ref. F/07 134/AY AWEQ; £204K of which £90K came to
Nottingham) for the period 1/10/05- 30/9/08.
3.1. J. Baker and S. Brookes (2013a), Beyond the Burghal Hidage:
Anglo-Saxon Civil Defence in the Viking Age (Leiden: Brill). (Listed
in REF2)
3.2. J. Baker and S. Brookes (2013b) 'Monumentalising the Political
Landscape: a special class of Anglo-Saxon assembly-sites', The
Antiquaries Journal 93, 147-62. (DOI:10.1017/S0003581512001333)
3.3. J. Baker, and S. Brookes (2013c forthcoming), `Governance at the
Anglo-Scandinavian Interface: hundredal organisation in the Danelaw', Journal
of the North Atlantic. (available on request)
3.5. J. Baker, S. Brookes, A. Gaunt, L. Mallet and S. Reddish (2012b),
'Community archaeology at Thynghowe, Birklands, Sherwood Forest', Transactions
of the Thoroton Society 116, 53-71. (available on request)
3.1 won the 2013 Verbruggen prize for medieval military history. 3.2,
3.3, 3.4, and 3.7 are in peer- reviewed journals. 3.5 and 3.6 have dual
status as research outputs (see 2, above) and as elements of the impact
narrative (see 4, below).
Details of the impact
New knowledge and capacity for amateur local historians,
archaeologists and onomasts
The adoption of the standard reporting proforma designed by Baker (and
underpinned by his research) by local historians, archaeologists and
onomasts demonstrates the significance of the research to a range of
specialist user communities. The proforma (available along with precise
instructions for amateur participants through the project website)
facilitated a new approach to recording all putative early medieval
assembly sites in a systematic and detailed way (5.1). Certain groups en
masse (including the Community Landscape and Archaeology Survey Project
(CLASP), the Wiltshire Archaeological & Natural History Society
Archaeology Field Group (AFG), The Sussex Archaeological Society, the
Odsey study group), and a number of individual enthusiasts have been
directly involved with data collection using the proforma. The results of
this data collection have:
- fed back into the project (research and surveys carried out by
volunteers accounted for 50 of a total of 300 surveys);
- formed the basis for further Society work (5.2). The following are
examples:
- CLASP became involved in 2010 after Baker's talk in Paulerspury,
undertaking a range of fieldwork in Northants; Baker made site visits
in 2011, and CLASP presented their results as a poster at the project
conference, UCL, November 2011.
- The Odsey group was brought together by a Hertfordshire enthusiast,
after she attended the project conference. The group includes amateur
researchers but also local authority personnel (e.g. Historic
Environment Record officers, English Heritage employees, county
archaeologists). It has met three times to discuss Odsey as a
meeting-place, and Baker has attended all three meetings as an advisor
and contributor.
- The AFG undertook fieldwork at the meeting-places of the Wiltshire
Domesday hundreds. Brief progress reports are to be found in Wiltshire
Archaeological & Natural History Magazine 105 (p. 245) and
106 (p. 278).
- resulted in further work by independent scholars; resulting
independent publications are beginning to appear (such as that by a
former archivist in Gloucestershire History 25 (2011), and that
in Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Society Magazine
107 (2014); work on Odsey is to appear in Hertfordshire Past and
Present) (5.3);
- been integrated into a broad range of education initiatives, e.g.
courses at the Institute of Continuing Education, Madingley Hall,
Cambridge (6/12/10, 10/4/11, 2-4/12/11), at the Institute of Continuing
Education, Rewley House, Oxford (26/3/2011), and for Wuffing Education,
Woodbridge (10/12/11, 20/4/13) (5.4).
Informing and supporting follow-on projects initiated by community
groups
Relationships developed over the course of this project indicate a high
degree of sustainability through the embedding of the research outcomes in
additional, independent projects. For example, data was provided to the
project by the Friends of Thynghowe, a local Nottinghamshire society which
rediscovered the Thynghowe (`assembly mound') in Sherwood Forest and which
promotes knowledge about it within the local community. The Friends became
involved in the project in 2009. Baker assisted them in examining the site
(including a Geophysical Survey), and co-authored a discussion of the site
for publication in Transactions of the Thoroton Society (3.5).
Baker contributed to the Friends' successful application for a Heritage
Lottery Fund grant (£50K). The grant's authors acknowledged the key role
that Baker's research had played in the success of the grant (5.5). This
HLF project funded a LiDAR Survey and a range of events for the public,
including Volunteer Workshops (Nov 2012 and March 2013), Ground Truthing
(Nov 2012 to March 2013) the Annual Perambulation Walk (20/4/2013) and the
Viking Spring Thing (18/5/2013- 19/5/2013), thereby extending the reach of
Baker's original research.
Enhancing public awareness and understanding about early medieval
assembly sites
The interest of Baker's research for the `Time Team'-type audience is
evidenced by 2011a — British Archaeology magazine has a
circulation of 16,000. Its reach is evidenced by dissemination at public
engagement events to local archaeological and historical societies (e.g.
Kent Archaeological Society, Leicestershire Museums Archaeology Fieldwork
Group), and through day-schools and other Continuing Education initiatives
(see above) (5.4). More than 500 individuals attended these events, which
took place in Bedford (21/9/09-23/11/09), Paulerspury (15/9/10), Rochester
(6/11/10), Northampton (9/4/11), Leicester (19/1/12), Leicester (28/4/12),
Welwyn (14/7/12), St Neots (1/3/13), Norton (13/3/13) (5.6). All of these
talks included discussion of the project's methodology, and discussion of
variation in types of meeting place (e.g. `hanging promontory' and `extra
potentiary' types), and in function (e.g. mustering or leisure alongside
governance) and therefore drew on aspects of research from all of the
publications listed in 3, although the function shifted depending upon the
event's location and theme. For example, at the Landscapes of Violence
study day (Woodbridge, 20/4/13) 3.4 was foregrounded, while in St Neots
(1/3/13), 3.3 was of particular interest.
Significant media coverage has in turn prompted increased public interest
in the research evidenced by the increase in web traffic to the project
website: the INS website and, in particular, the Key to English
Place-Names (see further below) experienced spikes in hits after the
following radio interviews about assembly sites: BBC Radio 4's `Open
Country' (9/4/11; audience approx. 2 million) and BBC Radio Nottingham,
`The Mark Dennison Show' (14/4/11; audience approx. 50,000). The success
of these interviews is reflected in the continuing requests for INS
speakers (Mark Dennison Show, 23/5/12; BBC Radio Leicester, Down to Earth,
8/7/12). Project fieldwork at Thynghowe gained the attention of The
Guardian in April 2012 (<www.guardian.co.uk/uk/the-
northerner/2011/apr/12/boulby-polyhalite-cleveland-potash-krebs-dark-matter-otley-kate-middleton-thynghowe>). Baker was subsequently asked by the BBC to
contribute to one in a series of events accompanying the BBC2 series, The
Great British Story (Michael Wood, broadcast 25/5/12- 10/8/12) to engage
the general public in local history. Baker's event in Appleby Magna,
Leicestershire (8/7/12) attracted 470 individuals (despite atrocious
weather and unforeseen competition from Andy Murray in the Wimbledon
final!). Baker gave a talk on the day focused upon the site of Spellow
(`speech-hillspur'), less than a mile away, around which he had devised a
place- names walk. The project's findings about the wider administrative
context of meeting places fed into the talk, and around 280 leaflets
giving details of the walk and its names were distributed (a copy was also
made available on the INS website).
The freely-available AHRC-funded Key to English Place-Names web resource
(5.7), re- launched in January 2012 with a Google-maps interface, offers
clear explanations of England's town- and village-names for the general
public through a clickable map. The Key contains project information
relating to the hundred-names. Results not just from Landscapes of
Governance but from all externally-funded INS projects (The Survey of
English Place-Names (AHRC, British Academy); The Vocabulary of English
Place-Names (AHRC); Beyond the Burghal Hidage (Leverhulme); Anglo-Saxon
Mint-Names (AHRC)) are being fed into this resource. Since its relaunch in
2012, we have information about site hits: 18,913 visitors made 23,999
visits to the site, with a total of 132,569 page views. While most
visitors were from the UK, some 20% were international (5.8). As of August
2012, the Key has been available as an iPhone app, freely available in the
iTunes store (between its launch and 31/7/13, there were 511 downloads).
Thus, we seek to present the cultural and linguistic heritage accessible
through place-names to the widest possible audience.
Enhancing factual accuracy of programme content for the BBC
The INS has an ongoing and fruitful relationship with the various arms of
the BBC, and is regularly contacted to offer advice and expertise on
onomastic matters, thus enhancing the factual accuracy of programme
content. Baker contributed in various project-related ways to BBC
Education's support for the TV series, The Great British Story (see
above). He co-hosted an information day (20/10/11) for BBC Learning,
Salford and BBC Lab UK, London, in order to help the team plan the
nationwide events accompanying the series. Baker presented ideas for
place-name walks which included assembly sites for the events, and which
therefore drew explicitly on project material. Ultimately, the locations
nationwide were chosen `drawing in no small part' (5.9) on this
information day, and in part the results of this consultancy work can be
seen in the account of the Appleby event described above. To help with
preparation for Appleby, Baker provided the BBC Learning Manager for the
East Midlands with information and suggestions via email between February
and July 2012. (5.9)
Sources to corroborate the impact
5.1: Project website www.ucl.ac.uk/archaeology/research/projects/assembly
5.2: Documentation relating to society activities (available on
request)
5.3: Articles in Gloucestershire History (2011) and Wiltshire
Archaeological and Natural History Society Magazine (forthcoming
2014): http://www.gloshistory.org.uk/publications.php
http://www.wiltshiremuseum.org.uk/shop/index.php?Action=2&pID=27
(available on request).
5.4: Feedback from education initiatives and talks to local
historical societies, etc. (available on request).
5.5: Documents relating to the Thynghowe HLF application and
activities (available on request). See also the Friends of Thynghowe
website, www.thynghowe.org.uk
5.6: Full details of Baker's outreach and impact activities can be
found at http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/english/people/john.baker
(under Impact and Outreach).
5.7: The Key to English Place-Names http://kepn.nottingham.ac.uk/
5.8: Google analytics documents relating to access to The Key
(available on request).
5.9: Emails relating to activities with BBC Learning (Salford,
London, East Midlands (available on request).