East looks west: engaging European publics with ideas of constructed difference
Submitting Institution
University College LondonUnit of Assessment
Area StudiesSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Professor Wendy Bracewell's collaborative, cross-disciplinary project
focuses on Europe's limits and divisions as depicted and debated in East
European travel writing from 1550 to the present day. The research she has
led has had an impact in two distinct areas. In the anglophone West, and
particularly in the UK, it has contributed to increased cross-cultural
awareness and understanding, and influenced the development and delivery
of public education. In eastern Europe, the research has raised the
profile of this genre of writing amongst the public and amongst
specialists.
Underpinning research
The East Looks West (ELW) project led by Professor Wendy
Bracewell at UCL's School of Slavonic & East European Studies
challenged scholarly approaches to travel writing that treated this genre
primarily as a technology of Western power and depicted east Europeans as
the immobile objects of Western travellers. Historically, travel writing
from eastern Europe was little known outside its countries of origin,
while even in eastern Europe, it tended to be studied as a minor literary
genre. ELW discovered a wealth of east European travel writing about
Europe and demonstrated how east Europeans used this genre for their own
purposes relating to audiences at home and abroad. An important finding
was the wide diversity of responses to perceptions of European difference,
from `cultural cringe' to insouciant superiority. ELW showed that east
European travel writing played an important role in the complex
transnational interactions that created understandings of European
belonging and otherness, modernity and backwardness, civilisation and
barbarism, `East', `West' and indeed `Europe'. Ultimately, ELW proved that
travellers from eastern Europe have been active agents in creating/using
these ideas, rather than being simply the objects of others'
representations.
The research directly underpinning impact was led by Professor Bracewell
at UCL in an AHRC project entitled `East Looks West: East European travel
writing on Europe, 1550-2000' (01/09/2001 to 31/12/2005) which led to the
publication of two collective volumes: an anthology of texts [a in section
3] and a collection of essays [b], as well as a bibliography [c] and a
popular anthology [f]. In addition to being sole or co-editor, she
contributed key chapters, selected and edited the texts for the scholarly
anthology, and translated about 30% of them. Her collaborator in the AHRC
project was Alex Drace-Francis (post-doctoral scholar and lecturer at UCL
until 2005, then of Liverpool, now University of Amsterdam), a
collaboration which continues to the present. Drace-Francis co-edited and
contributed research to the collective volumes.
More broadly, research led by Professor Bracewell between 2001-2013 has
identified materials, collated and translated key texts, and provided a
framework for the use of travelogues to study ideas of European
identities. Professor Bracewell and her colleagues elaborated a definition
for `east European travel writing' and established a periodisation for its
development; made surveys of the place of travel writing in the national
literatures of the region (in many cases providing the first systematic
bibliographies of these texts); published annotated translations into
English; convened conferences and public events in the UK and abroad
focusing on travel writing as a window into the world, but also into the
writers' own cultures; and published studies aimed both at scholarly and
more popular audiences.
References to the research
(indicative maximum of six references)
[a] Wendy Bracewell, ed., Orientations: an anthology of East European
travel writing, ca. 1500-2000, East Looks West, vol. 1
(Budapest and New York: Central European University Press, 2009).
[Available on request.]
Favourably reviewed in the following authoritative sources: Slavic
Review, East Central European Journal, Slavic and East European Journal,
Slavonic and East European Review, Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas,
Austrian History Yearbook, H-NET reviews. "Makes an important
contribution to the lively debates about mentalities, identities, feelings
of belonging, about knowledge and power, cultural transfer and cultural
change and enriches cultural studies with rare or even unknown documents."
— Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas 58.2, 2010.
[b] Wendy Bracewell and Alex Drace-Francis, eds., Under Eastern Eyes:
a comparative introduction to East European travel writing on Europe,
East Looks West, vol. 2 (Budapest and New York: Central European
University Press, 2008). [Two chapters by Bracewell; listed in REF2.]
"An important contribution to European studies conceived in the broadest
possible sense." — Slavic and East European Journal 53.4, 2009.
[c] Wendy Bracewell and Alex Drace-Francis, eds., A bibliography of
East European travel writing on Europe (Budapest and New York:
Central European University Press, 2008) [Available on request.]
"The first comprehensive survey of this kind." — Slavonic and East
European Review 90.3, 2012
[d] Wendy Bracewell and Alex Drace-Francis, eds., Balkan Departures
(New York and Oxford: Berghahn, 2009) [Two chapters by Bracewell;
available on request.]
Reviewed favourably in Slavonic and East European Review,
Anthropological Notebooks, Journal of Transport History, Jahrbücher für
Geschichte Osteuropas, Slavic and East European Journal, Narodna
umjetnost, Revue des études sud-est européennes.
[e] Wendy Bracewell, `Lovrich's joke: authority, laughter and savage
breasts in an 18th-c. travel polemic'. Études Balkaniques 2-3
(2011), 224-249. [Listed in REF2.]
[f] Wendy Bracewell and Alex Drace-Francis, eds., Where to Go in
Europe: A Garland of Travellers' Toilet Papers (London: SSEES &
UCL Centre for Publishing, 2013) [Available on request.]
Key peer reviewed grants:
• Wendy Bracewell (PI). `East Looks West: East European travel writing on
Europe, 1550-2000', AHRC: £174,211, duration: 01/09/2001 to 31/12/2005.
End-of-grant reported received `outstanding' grade. Outputs: [a], [b], [c]
and [f].
• Wendy Bracewell (PI). `East European And Balkan Travel Writing On
Europe In Comparative Perspective', AHRC: £14,438, duration: 01/09/2003 to
30/04/2004). Output: [d]. Wendy Bracewell (PI). `East European Travel
Writing And The Invention Of Europe', Leverhulme Trust Major Research
Fellowship: £88,305, duration: 15/09/2009 to 14/09/2011. Output: [e].
Details of the impact
East Looks West (ELW) expanded horizons, particularly in eastern
Europe. By encouraging audiences to engage with different perceptions of
the world, ELW has challenged stereotypes, increased self-awareness in
East and West, promoted cross-cultural communication, and
contributed to debate on issues of difference and foreignness.ELW research
has contributed to the cultural life of east European audiences by
creating a new awareness of, and dialogue about, the richness and
diversity of travel writing from the region. Its publications have helped
to show the value of East European travel writing as a source for the
cultural history of Europe, and created new resources now used in
higher education in eastern Europe and beyond.
Through publications and media partnerships research contributed to
cultural life and stimulated discussions of travel and identity
across eastern Europe. Indicative evidence includes Romanian blogs (e.g.
on the utility of ELW approaches to East/West divisions) and news reports
(e.g. ELW illuminating cross-cultural perceptions in the new EU) [1].
Bracewell's article `Lovrich's Joke' [e] was selected for translation and
broadcast on Croatian national public radio (9-10 May, 2013) for its
provocative use of `cultural cringe' to unpack Croatian attitudes to
`Western' cultural authority [2].
More specialised audiences influenced by ELW include collectors. Two
Greek examples are a) the uniquely valuable 30,000 volume E. J. Finopoulos
collection of travel books on the Balkans and Levant, and b) the private
Lekkas collection on Ionian history. Using ELW research, their consultant
librarian alerted these collectors to the significance of travel book
production in Eastern Europe, and made it possible to identify new items
for purchase, enlarging both the scope and utility of their collections
and contributing to a major scholarly and cultural resource. The
Finopoulos collection was recently donated to the Benaki Museum, thus
making these texts available to a wide public [3].
Research publications are used as unique educational resources
which enable teachers at higher education institutions to pose new
questions and introduce unfamiliar perspectives, particularly across local
linguistic boundaries, allowing the use of texts that were otherwise
inaccessible. For example, ELW resources counter mono-causal
interpretations of the `Western invention of Europe' in history syllabi
(Collegium Artes Liberales, Warsaw; Central European University, Budapest;
University of Szeged; McMaster University, Canada; University of St
Andrews), while courses in travel literature and cultural studies at the
Universities of Cyprus, Bucharest and Prague use ELW research to contrast
eastern and western European travellers and introduce specifically east
European perspectives [4]. A Bucharest public symposium used Under
Eastern Eyes [b] to focus discussion of Romanian reconfigurations of
identity, and a teachers' handbook from the University of Athens uses Where
to Go in Europe [f] to explore foreign city-soundscapes [5].
Indeed, the availability of ELW publications on pirate download sites such
as LibraryGenesis, hosted in Russia, is further evidence of demand!
Where to Go in Europe [f] was an important channel using
accessible and amusing content to promote public engagement with the
research. This anthologised travellers' lavatorial anecdotes to show how a
universal necessity has been used to construct East/West divisions and
thus engage an English-speaking public with the ideas of constructed
differences examined in the research described in section 2. First
printed in 2009, and praised by Times Literary Supplement Editor Peter
Stothard on the TLS Blog [6], all 200 copies were rapidly distributed. In
May 2013, students in UCL's MA in Publishing produced an expanded edition
of 650 print copies and an e-version, launched through a series of
exhibitions, readings and interviews attended by some 200 visitors,
predominantly young, non-academic Londoners and tourists. Lively comment
focused on a new awareness of cultural construction, prompted by
travellers' expectations (e.g. "what is a normal toilet?"). In the
first two months following the re-issue (to 31 July 2013), a third of the
print-run (208 copies) was sold at a RRP of £4.99. Sales were to a broad
audience beyond the academic community, such as a book club whose convenor
cited the combination of accessibility and serious message. Other
responses emphasised the effectiveness of toilet humour as a prompt to
self-reflection: as an Amazon reviewer stated: "The book's pervasive
humour, by inviting us to laugh at these constructed differences,
simultaneously does its part in working to dissolve them"; "shows that
differences, within the Balkans, and also East/West, are never so clear
and consistent as imagined" [7].
In 2009, Professor Bracewell organised a series of public engagement
events together with the Leverhulme writer-in-residence Tony White, using
ELW research into east European representations of London, which provided
an important London forum for public debate on experiences of migration.
Destination London (19 October to 7 November 2009) events included
podcasts of readings, a radio broadcast on east European London in
collaboration with Resonance FM, a book launch, a public panel of travel
writers, and writing workshops which promoted cross-cultural
communication between migrants and hosts. The reach is demonstrated by the
attendance: around 200 people (about half of east European heritage)
attended and many commented that it was their first engagement with
academic research on migration. The significance of this impact is
demonstrated by the fact that all available books sold out (worth over
£1,000). The lively discussions at the event were echoed in the positive
visitor feedback received ("Tonight really helped me understand my
feelings as an immigrant in London, and as a Londoner back at home in
Poland"). Subsequent coverage of the event in the Croatian press (Večernji
list, Zagreb, 24 Nov 2009; one of the two largest dailies in the
country), noting the significance of London as a Croatian destination,
applauded ELW's recognition of `a new outlook on the city' created by
immigrant travel writing [8].
The success of the 2009 event was repeated in 2013 at Through
Different Eyes, part of UCL's Festival of the Arts, 11-12 May 2013.
This actively sought to use research to challenge stereotypes in the
context of UK debate on east European immigration, and thus contribute
to social cohesion and cultural understanding. Some 50 participants,
British, Polish and Romanian, used travel writing to look `through
different eyes', in a reading group and discussions with artists, writers
and workers. The positive feedback indicated that the experience was
transformative for both migrants and hosts, deepening discourse about
migration by including the voices of those who are more often depicted
than heard. Comments included: "many times it revealed not only the
ignorance about the `foreigner' but also the contradictions in the `eyes'
of the viewer!"; "I think that we can understand a country, no matter
which, when we stop comparing with what is familiar to us"; "We are not so
different, but what a gap between us! If only that type of exchanges of
ideas would happened more often, maybe the gap was smaller"; "the other
side of the story is how outsiders have themselves reshaped the city and
have actively transformed it". The events were reported by UK migrant
blogs, showing reach within the community. One Romanian migrant, after
reading an 1840 ELW travelogue of London, blogged his own version:
"I follow in Codru's trail and see London today as a very different city.
But Codru has opened my eyes to things I did not see before". This text
was subsequently republished by a website showcasing oral histories of
migration for a popular and academic audience in Romania and was
accompanied by a report, applauding the attempt to understand migration
`from within' in contrast to UK tabloid journalism [9].
Sources to corroborate the impact
[1] Sample blog post (May 2010) on discussion sparked by research: http://bit.ly/GKw3is,
and an interview with a researcher in the Romanian financial daily, Financiarul,
16 May 2013, http://bit.ly/17Rwxge.
[2] Corroborating statement provided by the translator of 'Lovrich's
Joke' (Assistant Professor, University of Split); available on request.
[3] Corroborating statement provided by the consultant to E. J.
Finopoulos Athens and D. Lekkas and research librarian at the Benaki
Museum; available on request.
[4] A portfolio of syllabi with examples of use in higher education is
available on request.
[5] Bucharest public symposium chaired by critic Liviu Papadima, Dec
2011: http://bit.ly/17SaTsh.
University of Athens' teachers' handbook (see page 65): http://bit.ly/15jJuyq
[PDF].
[6] Where to Go in Europe 2009 edition: privately printed, 200
copies. Notice in the TLS: http://bit.ly/19ckhFu.
[7] 2013 edition: co-published by UCL Centre for Publishing & SSEES,
25 May 2013, 650 copies.
Where to Go in Europe Evaluation Report available on request.
Statement provided by book club convener is available on request.
Amazon customer reviews: http://amzn.to/17RBVjs.
[8] Destination London Evaluation report: http://bit.ly/15XPES0
[PDF].
Coverage in Croatian press: Večernji list
(Zagreb) 24 Nov. 2009: http://bit.ly/GKQfjo.
[9] Through Different Eyes Evaluation Report is available on request.