3. Practical Waveform Engineering - Reshaping Today's Communication Systems
Submitting InstitutionCardiff University
Unit of AssessmentGeneral Engineering
Summary Impact TypeTechnological
Research Subject Area(s)
Mathematical Sciences: Applied Mathematics
Information and Computing Sciences: Computation Theory and Mathematics
Technology: Communications Technologies
Summary of the impact
Practical Waveform Engineering, developed at Cardiff, is having a major
impact on how modern- day microwave power amplifiers are designed,
delivering real competitive advantages for global communications companies
such as Nokia-Siemens-Networks and M/A-COM.
Economic impact is through reduced time-to-market and lower
design costs, leading to high- performance power amplifier products.
Examples include $40M revenue and employment of additional staff for
M/A-Com, and the successful spin-off company Mesuro Ltd., generating
revenue in excess of £2.5M.
Impact on practice is through successful demonstration of
new device technologies and amplifier architectures, the introduction of
PWE-based CAD models, and most significantly, the introduction of the
"Cardiff Model" into mainstream simulation tools.
Environmental Impact is by improving the efficiency of
power amplifiers and significantly reducing the carbon contribution of
mobile communications systems, translating into savings of approximately
£2.5M/year and a 17 kiloton reduction in CO2 emission for a
typical EU network.
Radio Frequency (RF) and microwave power amplifiers (PAs) are critical
components used to boost signal levels in all mobile and satellite
communications networks, including military and security systems.
Traditional approaches to power amplifier design are non-optimal,
iterative and labour-intensive, and so the research focus of the Centre
for High Frequency Engineering (CHFE) has been to address this issue by
transforming the way in which power amplifiers are designed.
Practical Waveform Engineering (PWE) is a technique developed by Prof
Tasker of Cardiff, and is the ability to modify or "engineer" voltage and
current waveforms at the terminals of an amplifier or transistor, allowing
near-theoretical, optimum performance within a practical system [3.1]. The
integration of measurement and waveform engineering capabilities enables
PWE and is unique, leading to a number of patents that have now been
transferred to a spin-off company, Mesuro. PWE provides the major
commercial advantage of streamlining development of both the PA modules
and the underlying transistor technology. Using PWE to "emulate" the
complex harmonic load environment within a PA and around a transistor
significantly reduces reliance upon prototyping and enables optimal,
"first-pass" design success [3.2].
The following research developments have led to impact:
Hardware developments enabling PA "emulation"
- PWE measurement systems were developed to address the needs for
increasingly complex and realistic stimulus signals, including modulated
and pulsed signals at higher frequencies and powers [3.1, 3.3]. This
resulted in the establishment of University's spin-out Mesuro Ltd. by
Profs Benedikt and Tasker, and recent funded lectureship and product
development with National Instruments led by Prof Benedikt.
Concept development and utilisation
- PWE has uniquely demonstrated how real transistors can support
near-theoretical signals, and hence realise "state of the art"
performance in terms of output power and efficiency [3.4]. This is very
important for the assessment of new semiconductor technologies, and has
increased Mesuro's sales (such as to Miyoshi and Infineon).
- PWE has provided new insight into transistor operation that has
transformed PA theory, leading to the invention of "continuous amplifier
modes" [3.5] by Profs Tasker and Cripps. This has been recognised by
industry as a major and timely breakthrough in wide-band PA design.
- A number of PA demonstrators have been realised that meet industry's
challenging design specifications in terms of power, efficiency and
bandwidth, without the need for extensive prototyping and costly design
- PWE has allowed complex RF/microwave PA architectures to be analysed
and realised for the first time, most notably including harmonic
injection PAs pioneered by Prof Benedikt, as well as broadband
push-pull, class-J and continuous mode PAs by Profs Cripps and Tasker.
CAD integration and behavioural modelling
- A measurement-based behavioural modelling approach has been developed
by Prof Tasker, allowing PWE data to be fully exploited within the
computer-aided design (CAD) environment , allowing the most recent
and promising device technologies to be quickly adopted.
Key staff contributing to the research are Prof PJ Tasker (1996- ,
Founder and Director of CHFE), Prof J Benedikt (PhD 1997-2000, research
associate 2000-2004, academic staff 2004), Prof SC Cripps (2008-) and Dr J
Lees (PhD 2001-2004, research associate 2005-11, academic staff 2011).
PWE has attracted research income in excess of £3.5M: from EPSRC
(EP/F033702/1, £2.5M jointly with Bristol University, 2008-13), UK MoD
(EMRS DTC, £346k, 2004-09), EU (FP7 NoE TARGET IST-1-507893-NOE, £317k,
2004-06) and industry contributions of more than £1.25M. Research outputs
linked to PWE involves over 20 international journal papers, over 100
international conference papers and 3 patent applications.
References to the research
3.1 Benedikt J., Gaddi R., Tasker P.J. and Goss M. (2000)
High-power time-domain measurement system with active harmonic load-pull
for high-efficiency base-station amplifier design, IEEE Transactions
on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 48 No. 12 pp. 2617- 2624. 10.1109/MWSYM.2000.862249
3.2 Wright P., Lees J., Benedikt J. Tasker P.J. and Cripps
S.C. (2009) A Methodology for Realizing High Efficiency Class-J in a
Linear and Broadband PA, IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and
Techniques, Vol. 57, No. 12 pp. 3196-3204. 10.1109/TMTT.2009.2033295
3.3 Williams D.J., Leckey J. and Tasker P.J. (2002) A
study of the effect of envelope impedance on intermodulation asymmetry
using a two-tone time domain measurement system, , Microwave Symposium
Digest, IEEE MTT-S International, June 2002, pp. 1841-1844. 10.1109/MWSYM.2002.1012221
3.4 Roff C., Benedikt J. and Tasker P.J. (2007) Design
Approach for Realization of Very High Efficiency Power Amplifiers, , Microwave
Symposium Digest, IEEE MTT-S International, June 2007, pp. 143-146.
3.5 Cripps S.C., Tasker P.J., Clarke A.L., Lees J. and Benedikt J.
(2009) On the Continuity of High Efficiency Modes in Linear RF Power
Amplifiers, , IEEE Microwave and Wireless Components Letters, Vol.
19 No 10 pp 665-667. 10.1109/LMWC.2009.2029754
3.6 Hao Q., Benedikt J. and Tasker P.J. (2009) Nonlinear
Data Utilization: From Direct Data Lookup to Behavioral Modeling , IEEE
Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol 57 No 6 pp
Details of the impact
Cardiff's PWE has achieved global economic impact since 2008, with
world-leading companies applying it to develop new products. PWE has
resulted in a successful spin-off company, Mesuro Ltd. [5.1], attracting
industrial funding of over £1.25M from Selex, LabTech, Milmega, Copham,
M/A-COM, Freescale, Agilent and QinetiQ.
The streamlined development and emulation capabilities afforded by PWE
reduce the need for prototyping, minimises time-to-market and provides
competitive edge. PWE, according to M/A- COM, plays a "significant
role in developing and optimising the circuit used in the final design"
[3.2] [5.2]. This was recognised from the outset by key players in the
mobile communications industry, e.g. from 2004-2007 Nokia provided
financial support of £400k and benefited from reduced development time and
costs by using PWE to evaluate device technologies for next generation
mobile communications systems [3.1] [5.3].
M/A-COM is an excellent example of a beneficiary that has achieved
time/cost savings and major competitive advantage. It used PWE [3.3] to
develop a high-performance PA product for satellite telephones ahead of
competition, "to successfully secure the design win" [5.2]. This
product alone has directly generated over $40M revenue and employment of
eight additional staff in 2009-2013. PWE has enabled additional amplifier
products with expected revenue of $15M for 2013-2018 [3.2] [5.2].
Furthermore, QinetiQ (2008) and WIN Semiconductors (Taiwan) (2012-13) have
used PWE for rapid optimisation of their gallium nitride (GaN) technology
The successful demonstration of a system based upon fundamental PWE
concepts [3.1] at the International Microwave Symposium in 2008 (the
largest such exhibition, attracting over 200 exhibitors and 15,000
attendees) indicated its potential for direct commercialisation. After
raising an initial investment of £1M from three investors (Fusion IP,
Invest Wales and ERA Foundation), the Cardiff University spin-off company
Mesuro [5.1] was established in 2009.
Mesuro supplies PWE systems directly to the relevant industries, e.g.
mobile communications, semiconductor foundries, military and satellite
systems, and has exploited PWE to establish a successful market presence
and leadership. It currently employs 7 FTE staff. In 2010-11 it secured
investment of £450k and revenue of £220k, with revenues for 2011-12 and
2012-13 rising to £700k and £1.5M, respectively. This includes sales to
Infineon and M/A-COM in the USA, and Miyoshi (Mitsubishi) in Japan.
In 2009, and as a result of the success of PWE, Welsh Government funding
(£370k) enabled the "Green Communications Centre" within the Knowledge
Transfer Centre (KTC), which increased technological capabilities and
improved business access; it is now part of Cardiff School of
Engineering's "Business Gateway". To date, this industry-focussed,
PWE-related activity [3.1] has generated £160k from customers including
EADS-ASTRIUM, Cobham CTS, UMS, TNO, Plextek, WIN-Semiconductors and
Impact on Practice
CREE, currently the world -leading company in the RF-power semiconductor
sector, used PWE to successfully demonstrate the potential of their GaN
technology for very efficient PAs (2008) [3.1], [3.3]. CREE have
introduced PWE-based CAD models for mainstream simulation tools, for their
newest 50V GaN technology (2013) [5.5]. This new generation of models
gives circuit designers unique access to PWE by displaying the internal
voltage and current waveforms within CREE transistors - "a technique
driven by the published work and activities of the Cardiff CHFE group"
[5.5]. Similar work was undertaken for Freescale on its LDMOS technology
(2008) that translated into two funded PhD studentships (£100k).
In his plenary presentation at the 2013 IEEE Radio and Wireless Week, the
President, CEO and Founder of National Instruments (NI) highlighted PWE's
impact on their new products [3.6],[5.6]. The "Cardiff model" has now been
integrated into NI's mainstream microwave simulation tool (AWR Microwave
Office). NI is also providing £250k of funding (2013) to support
device-modelling aspects of PWE research at Cardiff in addition to funding
a NI Lectureship post (2013).
Since 2008, industrial engagement with PWE has been promoted through 16
EPSRC CASE and other industry-funded studentships with M/A-COM (x2),
QinetiQ (x2), Selex (x2), Freescale (x2), Alcatel-Lucent, Copham,
Millmega, Roke Manor, Labtech, Mesuro, NXP and EADS. International PhD
funding from Agilent (USA) is a direct result of Cardiff's reputation for
working with industry on a wide range of challenging practical areas. The
impact of PWE is also promoted through the targeted recruitment of Cardiff
PhD graduates to relevant industries, including three students into
Alcatel-Lucent (UK) in 2009 and one into Ericsson (Sweden) in 2010.
Emerging communication systems must minimize their environmental impact
through improved energy efficiency. In collaboration with Alcatel-Lucent,
Nokia-Siemens-Networks, France Telecom - Orange, Freescale and other
members of the OperaNET-2 consortium, Cardiff is using PWE to improve
efficiency of power amplifiers and so reduce the carbon footprint of
mobile communications systems [5.7]. A 20% efficiency improvement in a
typical (2013) 3G base-station power amplifier translates into savings of
approximately £2.5M/year and a 17 kiloton reduction in CO2
emission for a typical EU network (with 12,000 base-stations).
Sources to corroborate the impact
5.1 Confirmation of Cardiff's role in establishing successful spin-out
Mesuro Ltd (http://www.mesuro.com/index.php/about/history).
5.2 Confirmation from Engineering Manager M/A COM UK of advantages of
using PWE in design and development and resulting revenue in excess of $40
5.3 Confirmation from Chief of RF Technology (Radio Platforms), Nokia
Siemens Networks, of reduced development time and cost benefits from using
PWE for next generation mobile communication systems.
5.4 Confirmation from Associate Vice President (Technology), WIN
Semiconductors (Taiwan) that they have used PWE for rapid optimisation of
their GaN technology.
5.5 Confirmation from Strategic Business Development Manager CREE that
CREE has introduced PWE-based CAD models, underpinned by Cardiff research,
for mainstream simulation tools for their newest 50V GaN technology.
5.6 Confirmation from Vice President (Europe) National Instruments of PWE
impact on product development.
5.7 Confirmation of OperaNET2 consortium objective of improving
efficiency of PAs and reducing CO2 emissions - http://projects.celticplus.eu/opera-net2/.