The Poet Laureate: A Case Study In Creative Leadership
Submitting Institution
Manchester Metropolitan UniversityUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Carol Ann Duffy has, for nearly two decades, rooted her impact and public
engagement work as a poet in the Writing School at MMU. In 2009, she
became the first woman ever to be appointed Poet Laureate. From the
outset, she set a pattern for her laureateship as inclusive,
public-facing, and clearly aimed at broadening public understanding,
appreciation and access to poetry and poets. This impact is wide-ranging,
providing creative and academic leadership benefiting emerging poets and
new audiences for poetry, challenging and questioning political and
cultural positions, and contributing to a revitalised approach to the
teaching of poetry in schools.
Underpinning research
Carol Ann Duffy was first appointed as a lecturer at MMU in 1996. Now she
is Professor of Contemporary Poetry and Creative Director of the
Manchester Writing School at MMU. In the last 18 years her work has been
central to establishing an internationally renowned centre for critical
and creative poetry research in the English Department at MMU, and this
has given her a base to build her model of creative leadership within and
beyond the university.
Her own work as a poet ranges from the polemical wit of The World's Wife
(1999) [1] to the intimate love lyrics of the TS Eliot
Prize-winning Rapture (2005) [2] and the blend of personal and
public (Laureate) poems in The Bees (2011) [3]. Writing in the
Guardian when Duffy was appointed Laureate in 2009, Alison Flood said: `As
one of the bestselling poets in the UK, Duffy has managed to combine
critical acclaim with popularity: a rare feat in the poetry world.' This
rare balance is the result of formal skill with rhyme and metre (which
makes her poems readily memorable), and the versatility to write poems of
dry wit and satirical edge, but also poems of great intimacy and
tenderness. As Charlotte Mendelson wrote in The Observer in 2002 `Part of
Duffy's talent — besides her ear for ordinary eloquence, her gorgeous,
powerful, throwaway lines, her subtlety — is her ventriloquism. Like the
best of her novelist peers ... she slides in and out of her characters'
lives on a stream of possessions, aspirations, idioms and turns of
phrase.'
She demonstrated from the outset a determination to speak freely and
accessibly through her laureate poems, even if this meant challenging
political and social conventions. Her first Christmas poem as laureate,
The Twelve Days of Christmas 2009
[http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2009/dec/06/poet-laureate-duffy-christmas-poem],
addressed such issues as species extinction, the Copenhagen conference on
climate change, the banking crisis and the war in Afghanistan. In 2008
when she published a poem Education for Leisure [http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2008/sep/04/gcses.english]
about violence and knife-crime in a schools anthology, it precipitated a
national debate in press and on radio and television about the
responsibility and impact of poetry, when it was alleged that exam board
AQA had urged schools to destroy copies of the unedited anthology. Duffy
said at the time: `It's an anti-violence poem. It's a plea for education
rather than violence.' In both these ground-breaking poems, Duffy
demonstrated her ability and desire to use her work as a public poet to
create impact and leadership in its contribution to political and cultural
debate and forging a path for other poets to engage more directly with
these issues through their work.
In her reach into other art forms and new audiences, she is the most
eclectic Poet Laureate for generations. Already, during her term of
office, she has written a new stage musical for the Royal Exchange
Theatre, produced a widely acclaimed new set of carols (`The Manchester
Carols' with composer Sasha Johnson-Manning [4]), worked
extensively with printmaker and artist Stephen Raw, written a short drama
for the Bush Theatre's 2011 project `Sixty Six' about the King James Bible
[http://www.bushtheatre.co.uk/sixtysix/],
and written and performed extensively for children, working with a range
of illustrators and musicians. Duffy's conviction is that the
laureateship, and poetry itself, should not be confined to its familiar
cultural contexts (the page, the public reading), but can communicate
widely without compromising quality or complexity by working in concert
halls, theatres [5] and galleries.
She has sought to use the traditional laureate `occasions' to bring in
other poetic voices, and to make those occasions connect more broadly with
the experiences of readers and listeners. For example, on the occasion of
the wedding of Prince William and Kate Middleton, Duffy took over four
pages of the Guardian newspaper, and commissioned a wide range of
contemporary poets to write on the subject of `new wedding vows', and for
the Queen's Jubilee she commissioned a new anthology [6]. Under
Duffy, the laureate role has become a conduit for a broad range of
contemporary poetry (including `performance poetry', which has often been
regarded as a separate form) to connect with a wider public. This reflects
her sense of British poetry as an eclectic, but crucially collective,
project.
References to the research
[1] The World's Wife (1999) 96 pages, Picador, ISBN:
978-0330372220 [A themed collection that takes characters, stories,
histories and myths which focus on men, and presents them anew to look
at the women who were hidden behind the men. It is a set text on A2 and
AS Syllabuses of English Literature in England and Wales. Still in
print, the book was adapted into a stage play and performed at the
Edinburgh Festival and Trafalgar Studios.]
[2] Rapture (2005) 80 pages, Picador, ISBN: 978-0330433914 [poetry
collection] winner of the TS Eliot Prize 2005.
[3] The Bees (2011) 96 pages, Picador, ISBN: 978-0330442442 [poetry
collection including first published Laureate poems] winner of the Costa
Poetry Prize 2011.
[4] The Manchester Carols Vocal Score (2007), 127 pages, Faber
Music Ltd, ISBN: 978-0571521210 [choral collaboration with composer
Sasha Johnson-Manning, performed at Manchester's Royal Northern College
of Music and broadcast on BBC Radio 4]
[6] Jubilee Lines (2012), 160 pages, Faber & Faber, ISBN:
978-0571277056 [poetry anthology]
Carol Ann Duffy's awards and honours include the TS Eliot Prize (for
`Rapture', 2005) the Whitbread Poetry Award, the Forward Prize, a major
NESTA Award (2001), the PEN / Pinter Prize (2012), Scottish Arts Council
Book Awards and the Laureateship itself (2009). She was appointed OBE in
1995 and CBE in 2002, and made a fellow of the Royal Society of Literature
in 1999.
Details of the impact
Since she joined MMU, the culture of the MMU Writing School has helped
Duffy to form her vision, that British poetry — in reinvigorating its
traditional forms and modes, such as lyric, elegy, dramatic monologue —
could reconnect with a broad popular audience. This conviction is
confirmed by her book sales. In the past two years, according to Nielsen
BookScan, the three bestselling poetry titles in the UK have all been by
Duffy [The Christmas Truce (38,181), The Bees (29,716) and The World's
Wife (19,933)], and this at a time of falling poetry sales.
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2013/may/24/salt-poetry-market-slump.
In conjunction with colleagues like the broadcaster, publisher and critic
Michael Schmidt, the poet and critic Jeffrey Wainwright, and fellow poets
with a popular following like Simon Armitage and Sophie Hannah, Duffy was
able to develop a genuinely populist poetic following without compromising
the quality of the work itself, giving her the ideal grounding for her
work as Poet Laureate.
The Laureate is chosen according to three main criteria: poetic
achievement and reputation, ability to connect and communicate with a
broad range of people across the UK, ability to write accessible `public'
poetry. Duffy more than meets these criteria. Her poetic achievement over
more than four decades has won her the TS Eliot, Forward, Whitbread and
PEN/Pinter Prizes, plus an OBE and CBE. Her ability to connect with wide
audiences is evinced by her high media profile, the presence of her work
on the GCSE and A-Level syllabus [A], and the continuing demand
for her to read at schools, festivals and other public venues, a schedule
averaging around three performances a week. Her skill at writing an
accessible `public' poetry is demonstrated by the lasting popular success
of work such as `The World's Wife'.
Within months of being appointed Poet Laureate in May 2009, Duffy set out
to act as an ambassador for British poetry and poets, and immediately set
up a number of new impact-generating initiatives to change the role,
providing creative and academic leadership, reconnecting the British lyric
poetic tradition with the largest possible number of people and finding a
place for poetry as a public art in contemporary Britain. The chief
beneficiaries of her impact-generation are young writers and readers,
teachers and educators, emerging poets and new audiences beyond the core
readership of poetry books. Her vision for the laureateship is to revive
and reshape it as public-facing and inclusive.
From the announcement of her laureateship she has rooted her laureateship
in the northwest of England, where she lives, and her regular commitment
to working with northwest based artists and arts organisations (Sasha
Johnson-Manning and Royal Northern College of Music for `Manchester
Carols', Opera North, the Royal Exchange Theatre) has had an impact on the
range of opportunities for northwest poets, performers and audiences. Her
flagship readings series `Carol Ann Duffy and Friends' at Manchester's
Royal Exchange Theatre [B] has been a huge success, regularly
selling out within days of the programme being announced, and has given a
platform to new, emerging poets.
With her regular broadcasts and poetry pages in the Daily Mirror [C]
and the Guardian [D], she has extended the impact of her creative
leadership, by commissioning new work from many fellow poets, established
and developing, and enabling them to participate in the laureate's public
role, and to reach new audiences. This inclusive approach to the
laureateship has continued with commissioned anthologies, including the
2012 `Jubilee Lines', in which Duffy commissioned 60 fellow poets each to
respond to a different year in the Queen's reign.
She gave up the annual stipend that goes with Laureateship, and put it in
the hands of the UK Poetry Society, to establish an annual prize (of
£5,000) for `New Work in Poetry', under the title `The Ted Hughes Award' [E].
This has quickly become a well-regarded and acclaimed prize honouring
ground-breaking work by poets. Its remit to honour previously neglected
areas of poetic work (performance based and collaborative) has had a
significant impact on poets working in those fields, and on audiences
discovering this new work.
Like many areas of the arts in the UK, recent cuts in Arts Council
funding have threatened some major poetry organisations. As Laureate, CAD
organised benefit readings in London and Manchester (2011) to raise money
for, and awareness of, the work of the Poetry Book Society [F],
which was set up by TS Eliot in 1953 to support the propagation of poetry.
She gave the PBS further support by agreeing to chair the judges for their
TS Eliot Prize in 2012 [G]. Her work on behalf of PBS had a
significant impact on their profile and fundraising, and has helped them
to continue their work.
Her extensive work in schools as Poet Laureate has contributed to a
resurgence of interest in reading and writing poetry at that level, and
has `opened the doors' to a literary form often regarded as too
old-fashioned or too difficult [H]. As the most widely read and
best-known poet in Britain today, Duffy has made the Laureate's role her
own, generating not just cultural impacts, but contributing to social,
economic and policy impacts too. Her growing overseas reputation and
travel has given the Laureate's role a genuinely international dimension.
[I]
Sources to corroborate the impact
[A] AQA Examination Boards (re her impact on schoolchildren
through her poetry on the curriculum) http://anthology.aqa.org.uk/index.php?currmenu=duffy
[B] Royal Exchange Theatre, Manchester (re `CAD & Friends'
readings series and her drama for children `Rat's Tales') http://www.royalexchange.co.uk/event.aspx?id=761
[C] Daily Mirror, books pages (commissioned poems by CAD herself,
and sub-commissions from other poets) http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/carol-ann-duffy-new-poem-1249433
[D] Claire Armitstead, Literary Editor, The Guardian.
(commissioner of poems and `pages' in which CAD sub-commissions other
poets for occasions such as Royal Weddings and Olympic Games). Example: http://www.theguardian.com/books/2011/apr/23/wedding-carol-ann-duffy-poetry
[E] Ted Hughes Award (established in 2010, administered by the
Poetry Society, funded by the Laureate's traditional stipend of £5,000)
http://www.poetrysociety.org.uk/content/competitions/tedhughes/
[F] The Poetry Book Society (established by TS Eliot in 1953 to
promote the art of poetry, CAD has been instrumental in supporting and
raising awareness of the PBS in recent years)
http://www.poetrybooks.co.uk/
[G] T S Eliot Prize website (run by the Poetry Book Society,
judging panel chaired by CAD in 2012, herself a former winner) http://www.poetrybooks.co.uk/projects/4/
[H] Poetry Live (performing for 75,000 schoolchildren per year in
50 venues across the UK)
http://www.poetrylive.net/
[I] The British Council Literature Department (evidencing CAD's
international impact)
http://literature.britishcouncil.org/carol-ann-duffy