Reshaping Debates on the History of Italian Women
Submitting InstitutionUniversity of Dundee
Unit of AssessmentHistory
Summary Impact TypeCultural
Research Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Italiane. Biografia del Novecento has enhanced public discourse by
stimulating widespread and important debates in the Italian media, among
politicians and the public about the role of women in twentieth-century
Italy. Some of its arguments have been considered controversial, leading
many commentators, including the prominent journalist Paolo Mieli in 2012,
to call it a `courageous book' (Section 5:3). As the first scholarly but
accessible work of synthesis (in any language) ranging over the history of
Italian women in the whole twentieth century it is an important milestone
for Italian women's history and for discussions about women's role in
contemporary Italy. It has also made a significant contribution to history
teaching in Italian universities.
Professor Perry Willson (Professor of Modern European History at Dundee
since 2007) published Italiane. Biografia del Novecento in 2011
and it had immediate impact. The book is a work of synthesis which
explores and analyses the history of Italian women over the course of the
twentieth century, a path-breaking attempt to map and evaluate some of the
changes and continuities in women's lives during this period. The research
consisted in wide-ranging reading of secondary sources in both Italian and
English. Written in a clear and accessible manner, it nonetheless pays
considerable attention to historiographical issues and debates and, as
such, is aimed at both scholarly and wider audiences. The way in which it
has been received in Italy suggests that it has successfully reached both
kinds of readers and that its influence extends far beyond the academy.
It has a great emphasis on the role of politics (and the importance of
female agency) in historical change but also looks at social, economic and
cultural developments. Some of its arguments, particularly its
re-evaluation of `first-wave feminism' and the role of women in politics
in the immediate postwar period (both of which it argues have been
underestimated by most previous historiography), its approach to
`second-wave' feminism (which the book argues needs to be more
contextualised in the achievements of the previous generation) and its
mapping of some of the legacy of the Fascist political mobilisation of
women on subsequent political developments, have proved controversial with
Italian audiences. The book's wide-ranging approach has also enabled
numerous other long-term developments (often neglected in more narrowly
focused studies) to be explored such as trends in employment and
The research was carried out by Professor Willson alone but discussed
widely with other scholars, particularly historians of women in Italy and
the UK as well as colleagues in the History Programme in Dundee. Prominent
scholars in the field (listed in the acknowledgements) read and commented
on chapters before publication. A book of this nature, of course, builds
on a life-time of reading and research into the subject area — which
Willson has been studying since her PhD — but the quality of the book was
greatly enhanced by Willson's move to Dundee which enabled her to join a
thriving and vibrant research community of historians.
References to the research
The specific output that has generated significant impact is Perry
Willson, Italiane. Biografia del Novecento, Editori Laterza,
Rome-Bari, 2011, which is the culmination of the significant research in
Italian womens' history undertaken by Willson since her appointment at the
University of Dundee.
Italiane was also published in an earlier version as Women in
Twentieth Century Italy, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2010. The
impact claimed here stems from the Italian edition which is longer and
includes additional material in comparison to the English-language
version. This output has been submitted to REF.
Evidence of the quality of the research.
Some very positive reviews of the book have appeared.
For example, in a 7-page review in the gender history journal Genesis
(2010/2 but actually published 2011), Rosanna De Longis (former president
of the Società Italiana delle Storiche) called it, `not only an important
book, but a courageous challenge' and concluded that: `this book has
presented Italian women's and gender history with a network of questions
and hypotheses as well as a weighty legacy of ideas and questions to be
explored and I am convinced that the debt that research in this field now
owes to Perry Willson is one that will not be extinguished in the
The review of the book in the historical journal Mondo contemporaneo
(no.2, 2011), written by historian and politician Paola Gaiotti de Biase,
spoke of `being grateful to Perry Willson' and noted the book's
The peer reviewers for the manuscript of the English-language version
`..a real pleasure to read: it's pacy, engaging and stylish'
`...manages to offer some complex developments and interpretations in
clear and understandable language that at the same time maintains the
sophistication of good history discovery.'
`...an important and well-written book... Really great stuff...What an
Details of the impact
The excitement that Italiane: Biografia del Novecento has
generated in Italy has led to a good deal of attention from the media and
a number of high-profile public events.
A 25-minute television programme (part of the influential and
long-running series Le Storie Diario italiano, hosted by veteran
broadcaster Corrado Augias) was made about the book interspersing
documentary footage with an interview with Willson (Section 5:2).
Broadcast on the state Rai Tre channel on 22 April 2011, it attracted
audience figures of 932,000 viewers (6.19% of audience share). It is now
available on the internet and by September 2013 over 2,000 people had
viewed it online. Programmes from this series are frequently used by
schoolteachers as a teaching aid in class.
In January 2012, the Fondazione Nilde Iotti (a research foundation on
`women's issues' based in the Italian national parliament and run by
parliamentarians with academic advisors) organised a very lively debate on
the book in the Parliament Library (Section 5:3). The invitation stemmed
from the fact that academics participating in the inaugural session of the
foundation the previous year had already referred to issues raised in the
final chapter of Willson's book. Participants in this public event were,
in addition to the author herself, the well-known journalist Paolo Mieli
(head of RCS Libri, Italy's most important print journalism media group
and former editor of two prominent daily newspapers La Stampa and
the Corriere della Sera), historian Marina d'Amelia, philosopher
and former parliamentary deputy Claudia Mancina and parliamentarian and
former cabinet minister Senator Livia Turco (Section 5.9). This event
attracted a large audience (despite the considerable size of the room many
people had to be turned away due to fire regulations) and a column was
devoted to it in L'Unità newspaper the following day (13 January
2012) (Section 5:4). There were also reports on various websites (e.g.
giulia.globalist.it). As the L'Unità report noted, `in the room
there were a number of women, who, due to their political commitment, are
mentioned in the book' and the audience did indeed include a number of
prominent political figures (Section 5: 4).
There was also a panel debate devoted to the book at the Libri Come book
festival held in the Auditorium in Rome in April 2011 in which the book
was discussed by leading journalists Chiara Valentini of the weekly news
magazine L'Espresso and Concetta de Gregorio — editor of the
national daily L'Unità — as well as the actress, writer and
journalist Adele Cambria (Section 5:4).
Willson was also invited to take part in a series of other public debates
on the book. An initial round in 2011 was organised by a learned society
(the Società delle storiche) in Trieste, Padua, Florence and Rome, with
panels of academics and (in Trieste) local politicians from opposite sides
of the political spectrum. In Trieste, Elisabetta Vezzosi, President of
the Società Italiana delle Storiche (Female Historians Society), opened
the debate by emphasising the great importance of the book for the future
writing, teaching and debate on the history of Italian women. Although the
publisher Laterza was involved in organising the first few debates,
various others followed that were the result of spontaneous invitations
unrelated to the publisher's promotional interests, including a
well-attended day conference in Sassari (Sardinia) in 2011 which was
devoted to this book and two other recent publications in Italian women's
history, as well as debates in 2012 in Bologna, Naples and Lecce. The
debates were mostly held in universities but venues included a town hall
(Florence) and a public library (Rome) (Section 5:1).
In addition to scholarly reviews in historical journals, the book has
aroused considerable interest in the print media: articles on it have
appeared in major daily newspapers like La Stampa, Il Mattino,
Il Manifesto and L'Unità. It has also been featured on a good
number of Italian websites and blogs (e.g. Il paese delle donne; in
genere; giulia.globalist.it; donnedellarealta.wordpress.com) (Section 5:
5, 6 and 7).
The book has also cropped up more off the beaten track. In 2011 it was
chosen by a local library in Rubano (Padua) as one of 150 books that
symbolised the 150 years of Italian history since unification.
Book sales have been brisk with about 2,400 sold to date (which is very
good for a scholarly historical work in a country like Italy with a fairly
small reading public and virtually no export market for books) and is now
about to be reprinted (Section 5:1).
Italiane has also had an impact on the higher education teaching
of women's and gender history in Italy. Universities where the book has
been adopted as a set text include Genoa, Florence, Macerata, Rome (La
Sapienza), Rome (RomaTre), Bologna, Naples (Federico II), Salento, Milan
`Pathways to impact' have been further fostered by a second project
stemming from, and closely linked to, this one. Willson's (jointly with
Glasgow University) AHRC-funded interdisciplinary research network `La
Mamma: Interrogating a National Stereotype' further explores some of the
issues raised by Italiane (Section 5:8). The project, which
explores representations of maternity (both past and present) in Italy and
in the Italian diaspora, includes engagement with Italian politicians,
with the Italian-Scottish community and with the public in both Italy and
the UK. Two workshops have been held in Scotland as well as a public event
in the Parliament Library in Rome which brought together academics,
politicians and journalists and attracted good attendance from the general
public. The project has also included a public lecture in Dundee and a
further public lecture in Edinburgh is planned for 2014.
Sources to corroborate the impact
- Commissioning Editor, Editori Laterza (to confirm book sales), Rome,
- Link to online version of television programme, screened on state
channel Rai Tre to confirm political impact http://www.rai.tv/dl/RaiTV/programmi/media/ContentItem-1a7b6b7d-6a81-4d11-8afe-244e97bf47e8.html.
Viewing figures were provided by "Redazione Lestorie" (firstname.lastname@example.org).
- Fondazione Nilde Iotti. http://www.fondazionenildeiotti.it/index.php.
To confirm cultural and political impact. The website also includes an
account of the debate on the book held by the Fondazione. http://www.fondazionenildeiotti.it/iniziative_1.php?eventi_id=63.
- Weblink to Unità article in online edition: to confirm cultural and
political impact http://cerca.unita.it/ARCHIVE/xml/2365000/2363321.xml?key=massa&first=231&orderby=1.
- Weblink reviews and articles on Laterza website. To confirm cultural
and political impact. http://www.laterza.it/index.php?option=com_laterza&Itemid=97&task=schedalibro&isbn=9788842092933.
- Weblink to Il Manifesto article in online edition to confirm political
and cultural impact: http://micciacorta.it/home/naviga-tra-le-categorie/25-libri/5028-nel-900-delle-italiane-il-lfil-rouger-dellistruzione-.html.
Blogsite run by journalists with account of debate on the book in the
Parliament Library. To confirm impact on policy debate in Italy.
- Website of La Mamma: Interrogating a National Stereotype AHRC-funded
Research Network to confirm continuing cultural impact http://lamammaitaliana.wordpress.com/
- Member of the Senate, Parliament of Italy (corroboration of the impact
of the book on public debate on the role of women in Italian society).