The King in the Car Park: The remains of the last Plantagenet king of England generate global interest, leading to diverse impacts at local, regional and national scale.
Submitting Institution
University of LeicesterUnit of Assessment
Geography, Environmental Studies and ArchaeologySummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
History and Archaeology: Archaeology
Summary of the impact
In September 2012, the announcement that human remains discovered under a
Leicester car park could be those of King Richard III (d. 1485) generated
worldwide interest which grew to a frenzy when identification was
confirmed in February 2013. This case-study illustrates the role played by
the UoA in realising and maximising the impacts that arose from this
remarkable discovery, namely: 1. direct economic benefits; 2.
boosting local identities and sense of place; 3. changes in local
and regional heritage and tourism; 4. stimulating public debate
about the past, the ethics of dealing with a dead king, and the value of
archaeology to contemporary society; 5. impact on schools and
curricula; 6. impact on the perception of Richard III (e.g. in the
theatrical profession and amongst disability campaigners); 7.
stimulating partnerships across political and geographical boundaries.
Underpinning research
Richard III (who reigned between 1483-85) is perhaps England's most
familiar medieval king. Portrayed by Shakespeare and others as an infamous
villain, yet also championed by many, since his death he has remained a
highly controversial figure within the realms of both history and drama.
Richard was killed at the Battle of Bosworth on August 22nd
1485, an event that effectively ended the Wars of the Roses. The
victorious Henry VII brought Richard's corpse to Leicester for public
display and on the 25th of August the body was laid to rest
with a minimum of ceremony in the medieval church of the convent of the
Friars Minor (Greyfriars). Ten years later Henry VII had an alabaster tomb
erected over the grave. The friary was dissolved in 1538 and probably
largely demolished; the location of Richard's last resting place was lost
in the process, though a legend developed that his bones had been
recovered and thrown into the River Soar during the demolition. If
Richard's grave had effectively disappeared, he lived on vividly in the
public imagination, in large part thanks to the work of Shakespeare
(c.1592). However, the extent to which Shakespeare's famous play mirrored
reality as opposed to Tudor propaganda has remained a subject of intense
and sustained debate.
The stimulus for the research came from the Richard III Society, an
amateur group who were interested in determining the true fate of
Richard's remains. In January 2011 the secretary of the Scottish branch of
the Society contacted the UoA with the idea of searching for the burial
place of Richard III on the Greyfriars site in Leicester. They
commissioned an archaeological desk-based assessment (2011) from
University of Leicester Archaeological Services (ULAS) to review the
evidence for Greyfriars from documentary sources, the city Historic
Environment Record and historic maps.
This revealed that most of the precinct of the Franciscan friary was
built over, leaving just three areas potentially accessible for
investigation: two operational car parks and a former school playground.
Permission was granted by Leicester City Council, which owned one of the
car parks, for exploratory works in that area. A Ground Penetrating Radar
survey was undertaken in August 2011 which revealed some anomalies and
service trenches, but no clear wall lines. As a result the decision was
taken to locate two overlapping north-south 30m trenches through the car
park on the basis that they might pick up the east-west walls of the
church and other friary buildings. Three weeks of excavation of the
trenches took place during Aug-Sept 2012, led by Richard Buckley (ULAS),
which aimed to discover the lost layout and buildings of the Greyfriars
precinct founded by about 1230, and if possible the grave of Richard III.
UoA academic staff Appleby (Lecturer in Archaeology, 2012-present,
specialising in osteoarchaeology), O'Sullivan (Lecturer in Archaeology,
1986-present, specialising in medieval friaries) and King (a specialist in
DNA with a joint appointment between Archaeology and Genetics,
2012-present) all took part in the research at the excavation stage.
In-depth post-excavation analysis included the archaeology of the site and
the finds, the skeleton, genealogical investigations, genetic research and
the historical texts. Working closely with Buckley, Morris and other staff
in ULAS, Appleby and King played major roles. Other staff in the School
(Thomas, Whitbread, Foxhall), in other University departments
(Engineering, History, English, Forensic Pathology, Physics, History of
Art), and external partners (Royal Armouries, British Geological Survey,
and the universities of York, Glasgow, Oxford, Toulouse, Dundee,
Cambridge, Loughborough) were also involved.
The excavation revealed the east end of the friary church, the chapter
house and part of a cloister walkway, permitting a basic understanding of
the friary plan. Crucially, at the east end of the church, the choir (with
footings for choir stalls) and the presbytery could be distinguished by a
difference in levels (a step up to the presbytery from the choir) and
flooring. The excavated burial was located in the choir, where the 1486
text of John Rous indicated the grave of Richard III had been placed, in
the SW area. The grave appeared to have been hastily dug and was too small
at the bottom to fit the corpse properly. The skeleton was initially
identified in the field as that of a man, aged mid-twenties to
mid-thirties, with two serious head wounds consistent with injuries in
battle and likely to have been fatal. Further peri-mortem injuries were
later identified including some which could be characterised as
`humiliation' injuries. He suffered from severe idiopathic
adolescent-onset scoliosis, a medical condition resulting in a severely
curved spinal column. The remains yielded a modelled radiocarbon date of
1455-1540 (95%). The mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) of the skeleton, which is
maternally inherited, is a rare type in European populations and matched
the mtDNA of two independent and genealogically verified modern
matrilineal descendants of Richard III's sister, Anne of York.
References to the research
Publications:
1. Buckley, R., Morris, M., Appleby, J, King, T., O'Sullivan, D., and
Foxhall, L. (2013) `The king in the car park': New light on the death and
burial of Richard III in the Grey Friars church, Leicester in 1485. Antiquity
87 (336): 519-538.
Details of the impact
REACH:
The period of British history which saw the end of the Plantagenets and
the rise of the Tudors, especially the figure of Richard III himself, is
fascinating and meaningful to a great many people both in the UK and
throughout the world. Our research was covered globally in newspapers and
magazines as well as on radio, TV and online (285 stories on the BBC
website alone) in at least 10,000 reports and interviews. As a result of
this media coverage the core project team alone have been contacted by
over 5,000 individuals and groups from across the globe for further
information, permission to use images, or to ask questions, specifically
because the research changed or informed their views about the historical
and archaeological past. The project was voted the 2013 `Research Project
of the Year' by Current Archaeology magazine, which aims at a
popular readership. The Channel 4 (C4) TV programmes broadcast 4th
and 27th Feb 2013 reached 5.4 million viewers and were the
highest rating specialist factual documentaries ever shown on C4. These
have now also been shown in Canada, the US and Australia (E1 — E
numbers relate to evidence listed in section 5). Many of these
viewers contacted us directly, and many as a result of our research, have
explored the project website (625,000 hits by 31st July 2013)
and even visited Leicester. Analysis of social media revealed that many
millions of Twitter users engaged with the project; peaks of impressions
were on 12 Sept 2012 (initial announcement: 39 million), 4 Feb 2013
(confirmation of discovery: 472 million) and 24 May 2013 (release of
Antiquity publication: 4.8 million). Facebook engagement via the
University of Leicester page on 4 Feb elicited 2,598 responses from as far
afield as Australia and South America as well as a strong local response (E2).The
Bosworth Battlefield Heritage Centre (BBHC) has hosted at least 16
`Richard-related' media events since the discovery.
SIGNIFICANCE:
Our research has: 1. enhanced cultural understanding; 2.
informed public attitudes and values; 3. shaped teaching
curricula; 4. guided heritage policy; 5. stimulated museum
development and tourism packages; 6. brought considerable
socio-economic benefits to the region. In addition, the find has opened
public debate and is actively changing attitudes and practice more widely.
For example, the issue of re-interment, particularly the place of
reburial, has been widely discussed, including in Parliament, and this has
also generated wider awareness of both the ethical and the scientific
considerations of dealing with human remains in archaeological contexts.
Another example is Shakespeare's Richard III, in film or on stage,
which will never be viewed in quite the same way again, now that we have
identified the circumstances of his death and burial. Stephen Fry
mentioned our research in this regard in the 2013 BAFTA awards ceremony,
and actors have publicly stated that it will change the way they approach
the play and the part of Richard III. Further, Richard III has now brought
scoliosis into the headlines and has served as a positive example of the
achievements of sufferers from this condition (E3).
For the people of Leicester and Leicestershire, the find has become a
symbol of local pride and identity for virtually all sectors of this
diverse, multicultural area. Open days on the site both before and after
the initial announcement in September 2012 attracted over 5,000 visitors.
The team have given >300 talks to local groups, excluding schools,
including two events at a local cinema showing Laurence Olivier's
depiction of Richard III which sold out on both occasions. The emails and
comments online in response to press coverage, the views of callers to
radio talk shows and the thousands of conversations with members of the
public at open days and talks demonstrate clearly that the research is
enormously meaningful to people who live in Leicester and Leicestershire
because it feeds into their sense of place. It is part of their connection
to the city and the region, enhances their identity as Leicester
residents, and makes people feel they belong to Leicester and its past,
whatever their background or socio-economic status (E2 & E4).
It has infiltrated many different aspects of life in Leicester and
Leicestershire. There has been a Richard III Beer Festival (20/3/2013) and
Richard III has become part of Leicester City football chants, appearing
on the `King Power' football shirts of fans.
Schools and teachers (primary and secondary) both locally and nationwide
have been particularly enthusiastic about incorporating our findings into
their curriculum. The research has a direct impact on history teaching,
but also on science and English literature. In response to the many
requests for outreach talks there have been 5 special events on campus for
schools (attracting 450 primary schoolchildren), on-line discussion and
Q&A sessions with schools, where pupils can ask questions directly, as
well as 3 workshops in schools. The AQA Examination Board have contacted
the University about using this research as a case study for A-Level
Archaeology since it shows how archaeology and history link up, as well as
demonstrating many scientific aspects of archaeology (E5) — this
is a direct impact on the school curriculum. Looking to Higher Education,
as a result of the findings the University of Sydney is now teaching a
Richard III course.
City and county heritage policy and plans have been affected dramatically
by our research, the research results playing a significant role in
Leicester's successful bid to be short-listed for designation as UK City
of Culture 2017 (E7). The small temporary museum exhibition in
Leicester's Guildhall attracted over 45,000 visitors in its first 8 weeks
which can be compared to the typical annual visitor numbers of
35,000. The city has invested £4 million on an historic building adjacent
to the Greyfriars site to develop as a visitors' centre focused upon
Richard III to open in 2014, and the visitor centre will serve as a core
element in the city's heritage strategy which seeks to promote social and
economic regeneration within the city (E6). The Cathedral, where
the bones are expected to be reburied, is also developing a strategy for
dealing with the large numbers of visitors expected after re-interment —
it has already noted a significant increase in visitor numbers coming to
look at the memorial stone alone (E4).
The find has also increased visitor numbers to the BBHC. February 2013
saw a 138% increase on visitor numbers compared to 2012, and the 2 months
following the public announcement on 4th Feb 2013 saw an
overall increase of 85%. The interpretation at the visitor centre has also
been updated to take account of the discovery of Richard III's body. BBHC
also produced a new temporary exhibition, Richard III: The Making of
the Myth which was scheduled to open at the same time as the
announcement, and held a special rose-laying ceremony with the Diocese and
Richard III Society in March. New art work by artist Graham Turner was
revealed at BBHC in June, featuring a depiction of the battle based on the
wounds of Richard III following the excavation. Further, the Ricardian
Boar badge discovered at the Battlefield site in 2009 forms a key part of
a new exhibition at another the county's flagship Snibston Discovery
Museum — Treasure! Shedding the Light on Leicestershire's Past
(23/3/2013-3/11/2013) (E6).
Direct economic impact on the city of Leicester and the immediate
vicinity has been an outcome of our research. The number of visitors to
Leicester has risen dramatically — visitor numbers to the Guildhall
increasing from 6,651 in Jan-Mar 2012 to 46,266 in 2013 (and from 9,819 to
50,269 in the comparable Apr-Jun period (E2)) and tourism is
expected to rise significantly (e.g. E8 & E9). For example,
the Guardian newspaper has continuously advertised a 3-day Richard III
tour of the Leicester area. Leicester Shire Promotions are currently
working with city and county museums to develop a new Richard III audio
tour to venues across the county, another focusing on Medieval
Leicestershire and walking tours joining up BBHC and Blue Badge Guides in
the city. During the site's open days in August and September 2012, all
Leicester accommodation was fully booked bringing significant economic
impact with hotel bookings in Leicester rising by 20.5% with room-rates up
16.9% (E10). In addition, the production of general books on
Richard III is on the increase as to date the UoA has had 50 requests for
permission to use images in popular, commercial books (beyond newspapers
and magazines or popular publications of our own). A wide range of other
merchandise, from T-shirts and greetings cards to hobby miniatures
featuring Richard III bursting out from the car park, have also been
produced. Meanwhile, sales of the Ricardian Boar Badge and other stock at
BBHC have increased significantly, with take-up of this emblem at other
venues including in the city.
At present, of course we have only the relatively short-term impacts of
the find, but the impacts on both public attitudes and values as well as
on the economy of the city and the region seem likely to be much longer
lasting.
Sources to corroborate the impact
E1. Letters from Channel 4 & Darlow Smithson Productions.
E2. Tourism statistics from Leicester Shire Promotions; Social
Media survey commissioned by the University of Leicester in June 2013
& Guildhall visitor data.
E3. http://www.artinfo.com/news/story/866116/identifying-with-richard-iii-a-qa-with-actor-ron-cephas-jones;
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/feb/05/richard-scoliosis-me-twisted-spines;
http://www.sauk.org.uk/news/123/64/A-royal-condition.html
E4. Letter from the Dean of Leicester Cathedral.
E5. Email from the AQA Examination Board.
E6. Copies of supportive documentation to corroborate impact from
Leicester City Museums & Leicestershire County Council.
E7. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leicestershire-21701487
&
http://www.leicestercityofculture2017.co.uk/cityofculture.aspx
E8.
http://fd2d.com/articles/2013/03/debating_the_impact_of_richard_iii_discovery_on_tourism_in_leicester_and_leicestershire_at_house_of_commons
E9. http://www.thisisleicestershire.co.uk/
Richard-III-Publicity-equivalent-pound-2m/story-18240719-detail/story.html#axzz2NE5ht6QJ
E10.
http://www.thisisleicestershire.co.uk/Richard-III-factor-credited-boost-hotel-bookings/story-18643576-detail/story.html#axzz2TSR3gAhC