Karl Gutzkow: Electronic Publishing and Public Engagement
Submitting Institution
University of ExeterUnit of Assessment
Modern Languages and LinguisticsSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
The Gutzkow project, co-directed by Lauster and Vonhoff of the Department
of Modern Languages (German), has transformed public access to the
author's work through open-access, on-line publication. The project, which
combines specialist scholarship with innovative editing, has considerably
enhanced public appreciation of a widened canon of 19th-century
German literature (impact 1). User testimonies, the international
press, public acknowledgement and public involvement in events in the
region reveal a significant renewal of public interest in Gutzkow. The
editorial results of the Gutzkow project have been requested by an
interdisciplinary linguistic digitization project in Berlin and will be
fully integrated in this open access linguistic database (impact 2).
Underpinning research
As project founders, Professor Martina Lauster (Professor of German at
Exeter from 2000-2008, currently Professor Emerita and Honorary University
Fellow) and Professor Gert Vonhoff (Associate Professor of German,
appointed 2001) have collaborated on the Gutzkow Editionsprojekt since
2001. It uniquely combines editorial progressiveness (internet-based work
in progress) and technological innovation (the Kronos electronic
publishing platform) with a critical interrogation of a largely neglected
literary and journalistic corpus. Gutzkow had been the figurehead of the
Young German movement which introduced European liberalism into German
cultural life after the death of Goethe and Hegel. His writings
continually promoted these moderate values when, after the failed
revolution of 1848/49, the German intellectual elite broadly split into
conservatism and socialism and as an effect sidelined his liberal agenda.
This first modern edition of his complete works aims to re-establish
Gutzkow as a major contributor to 19th-century German culture.
In 2001, Lauster and Vonhoff launched the online-edition and edited the
first volume introducing the Gutzkow project to the public (3.5).
Since then both have acted as co-directors of the international Gutzkow
project and secured external funding (3.7, 3.8). Lauster's main
research interests in comparative literature of the nineteenth century,
with a particular focus on the 'journalistic revolution' that began to
affect all forms of writing and publishing from 1830 onwards, supports her
research into Gutzkow's journalistic enterprises. A 2007 monograph
reassessed the status of journalistic writing in nineteenth-century Europe
(3.3) and forms the basis of her editing text and commentary of
Gutzkow's contemporaneous overview Die Zeitgenossen in 2010. She
is currently working on the development of intercultural networks of
knowledge in the nineteenth century, and the place of Gutzkow within those
networks.
Vonhoff's long-standing research interests in prose fiction and
narratology and in scholarly editing have combined to bear fruit in the
Gutzkow Editionsprojekt. An internationally recognised Gutzkow specialist
(3.1, 3.6), Vonhoff focussed on setting up the hybrid
edition in its early years (developing the website; securing a publishing
contract). Together with Lauster, he now directs the Exeter-based website
of the edition. In his 2007 monograph (3.4) Vonhoff developed
categories which help to describe narrative evolution in a social context;
this research helps specify Gutzkow's standing within narrative fiction.
The efforts to raise the author's profile were rewarded by an excellent
field of participants joining a conference held in Exeter in 2010 in
anticipation of the bi-centenary of Gutzkow's birth; the proceedings were
then published on the bi-centenary in March 2011 (3.2) with the
support of Forum Vormärz Forschung, one of the leading literary
societies for the 19th century. Vonhoff is currently working on
Gutzkow's novellas and literary criticism with the aim of enlarging the
understanding of the innovative contexts of the 1830s. His major
Leverhulme-funded research project (3.7) focuses on widening the
reception of narrative prose after 1850 and will help to re-establish
Gutzkow's place within our memory of the 19th century.
References to the research
(indicative maximum of six references)
Evidence of the quality of the research is indicated by the fact that 1,
2 and 4 are the results of external grant funding, 2, 3 and 6 were
rigorously peer-reviewed, and 3, 4, 5 and 6 were submitted to RAE2008.
1. G. Vonhoff, `Gutzkows Ästhetik und das Berufsschriftstellertum', in
Wolfgang Lukas and Ute Schneider (eds.), Karl Gutzkow (1811-1878).
Publizistik, Literatur und Buchmarkt zwischen Vormärz und Günderzeit
(Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2013), pp. 21-33.
2. G. Vonhoff (ed.), with J.L. Sammons, M. Perraudin, D. Goettsche, P.
Hasubek, P. Stein, B. Fuellner, B. Schofield, F. Krobb, H. Chambers, D.
Large, Karl Gutzkow and His Contemporaries / Karl Gutzkow und seine
Zeitgenossen (Bielefeld: Aisthesis Verlag, 2011).
3. M. Lauster, Sketches of the Nineteenth Century. European
Journalism and its `Physiologies' 1830-1850 (Houndmills: Palgrave
Macmillan, 2007).
4. G. Vonhoff, Erzählgeschichte. Studien zur erzählenden Prosa
(Münster: MV Wissenschaft, 2007).
5. M. Lauster and G. Vonhoff, Gutzkows Werke und Briefe. Kommentierte
digitale Gesamtausgabe. Eröffnungsband (Münster: Oktober Verlag,
2001).
6. G. Vonhoff, `Gegenlektüren in Gutzkows Wally, die Zweiflerin', in G.
Frank and D. Kopp, eds, Gutzkow lesen! Beiträge zur internationalen
Konferenz des Forum Vormärz-Forschung vom 18.-20. September 2000 in
Berlin (Bielefeld: Aisthesis, 2001), pp. 19-50.
Grants awarded to support the research outlined above:
7. G. Vonhoff (PI), `German Narrative Prose Fiction after 1850',
Leverhulme Project Grant, 2009, £156,672. This project (2010-13) aims to
remap German Realist prose, the history of early working-class prose and
the question of whether one can speak of a white-collar workers' prose.
8. G. Vonhoff (PI), `Gutzkow Edition Project', Modern Humanities Research
Association, 2002, £11,000. The funding was for a MHRA Research
Associateship (Dr Catherine Minter, 2002-03) and was matched by
University of Exeter funding of £11,000.
Details of the impact
Impact 1: Enhanced public appreciation of a widened canon of 19th-century
German literature
The project has impacted on public engagement with the 19th-century
German novel and its heritage. As the only editing project on this author
that is currently available, it has redefined Gutzkow's place in the
literary canon, transformed public access and raised Gutzkow's public
profile. The project website was launched 22 Jan 2001. From January 2008
to June 2011, it is calculated from earlier figures that the site received
more than 3,000 hits. In July 2011 a new counter was installed, which
reveals 4,750 hits from that date to 30 July 2013 (5.3), suggesting
increasing interest as the number of texts and commentaries available has
expanded. Evidence of this transformed public profile can be found in the
press. Germany's leading daily broadsheet Frankfurter Allgemeine
Zeitung, which has a daily circulation of approximately 362,000 and
the highest distribution abroad of any German broadsheet, highlighted
Gutzkow's relevance for today's readers on Gutzkow's bicentenary, 17 March
2011, stressing his `concept for a modern novel'. In addition, the project
has revolutionised the Gutzkow corpus, placing journalistic texts and
critical commentaries alongside his more widely-known literary works for
the first time.
(a) Media Reports (Press and Radio)
When the project was first launched, non-academic reviews appeared in the
international press, which highlighted the innovative nature of its peer
editing and the re-location of Gutzkow in the public sphere rather than
specialist literary domains; these aspects continue to attract interest in
articles of leading papers up to the present day (5.7, 5.8), which
call the concept behind the edition `ingenious' (5.7).
In 2008, an article in the leading German weekly newspaper Die Zeit
(distribution of 500,000), took the publication of Gutzkow's influential
novel Der Zauberer von Rom as a welcome opportunity to celebrate
the fact that Gutzkow's `remarkable novels were being made available
again' and this time for a wider audience and with a commentary (5.8).
The 2011 Gutzkow bicentenary was a further catalyst for public engagement
with Gutzkow. Vonhoff and Lauster's 3.5 is the foundation of the
project. This, together with the 9 volumes published so far (one of which
is in its 2nd edition), is acknowledged in the leading Swiss
daily Tages-Anzeiger (distribution of 550,000) (5.7). The
article refers to the `innovative concept of an "edition in progress",
which uses the internet to produce publications that are financially
affordable and are at the same time of the highest scholarly standard'.
The columnist highlights the importance of the commentaries, `as without
them readers will not be able to understand the works adequately any
longer'.
Project member Ute Schneider was also interviewed by a regional German
radio programme on SWR2, a culture channel produced for Baden-Württemberg
and Rheinland-Pfalz, but broadcast nationwide with an estimated audience
of 300,000 per day (5.9). She was asked about the conference in
Mainz that celebrated Gutzkow's bicentenary, and acknowledged the role the
Gutzkow edition has played for the revival of the author.
(b) Non-academic Readers
The project's combination of edited texts available in print and online,
alongside the documents and commentaries published exclusively online, has
proved particularly successful in drawing the attention of non-academic
users. There has been a sea-change in readers' perceptions of Gutzkow.
Readers' testimonies comment on peer editing; for example, a member of the
Redaktion SPRACHKUNST made a suggestion for additional material in October
2009, and praised `the great potential' he saw in `the interactive online
approach for commentaries' (5.2). A scientist reader from CERN (the
European Organization for Nuclear Research), Switzerland, contacted the
project leaders in July 2008 with information about a reading of Gutzkow's
novel Die Ritter vom Geiste in the "Klassikerforum", an online
reading group (5.2, 5.4). Between 31/5/2008 and 24/9/2008 these
forum users produced more than 15 pages of comments on their reading
experience (5.4). Contributions include a general recognition of
the importance of the novel as well as the author, the discussion of
individual characters, and the frustration about not having a reliable
edition of it easily available. A web counter shows more than 35,000 hits
in this exchange between non-professional readers over this period, and
the exchange led to direct approaches to various members of the project
team. Other users of the edition contributed to the open-question section
of the edition.
For the bicentenary, Vonhoff, alongside other leading researchers in the
field, was invited to contribute two essays to the popular and
highly-regarded online literary magazine literaturkritik.de (5.5).
The March 2011 issue was dedicated specifically to Gutzkow. Together the
two articles have been visited by 4,337 readers between 11 March 2011 and
30 July 2013.
The project is also referenced on a literary blog in December 2010 (5.6);
the popularity of this blog in general is evidenced by its web counter
which shows more than 900,000 hits since July 2010.
(c) Arts Organizations / Libraries and Archives
A member of the Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg informed the project of a
newly discovered letter exchange (May 2009) (5.2).
From 2008 to 2013, the Universitätsbibliothek Johann Christian
Senckenberg (Frankfurt/Main), which holds the literary estate of Gutzkow,
spent 19,826 Euros on the conservation and restauration of archived
letters to and from the author (21,500 pages), a direct consequence — as
the Director of the Manuscript Department attested — of the increased
interest in and usage of these holdings (5.1).
Impact 2: Request for full integration into a linguistic database of
principal German texts from 1600 to 1900
In October 2012, the Deutsches Textarchiv in Berlin
(Berlin-Brandenburgische Akademie der Wissenschaften), an
interdisciplinary linguistic digitization project, requested access to the
texts of the Gutzkow edition with the aim of fully integrating the results
of the editorial work on Gutzkow's texts within their linguistically
annotated public database. After negotiations and a general agreement with
the publically financed body in early 2013 (5.10), first texts were
made available in the testing section DTAQ (currently 265 registered
users) of the DTA in January 2013. The linguistic portal of the DTA, where
the texts finally will be made accessible, currently has more than 11,000
visitors with approx. 100,000 page hits per month. The collaboration is
ongoing.
Sources to corroborate the impact
Correspondence
- Letter by the Director of the Manuscipt Department of the
Universitätsbibliothek Johann Christian Senckenberg (Frankfurt/Main),
dated 28.8.2013.
- Emails from 2009: 18.10.09 from Redaktion SPRACHKUNST; 12.5.09 from
Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg; email from 2008: 1.7.08 from a scientist
(CERN) in Switzerland.
Websites
- Counter for the homepage of the Gutzkow Project, since July 2011, with
4750 hits:
http://extremetracking.com/open?login=gvekgho,
[accessed 30/07/2013].
- Klassiker forum reading group, available at:
http://www.klassikerforum.de/index.php?topic=2709.0.
- Gert Vonhoff, `Der Autor im zeitgenössischen Kontext', text and
counter available at:
http://www.literaturkritik.de/public/rezension.php?rez_id=15330&ausgabe=201103;
and `Neue Wege der editorischen Arbeit', text and counter available at:
http://www.literaturkritik.de/public/rezension.php?rez_id=15365&ausgabe=201103
literaturkritik.de [accessed 30/07/2013], together 4,337 hits.
Blog
-
http://loomings-jay.blogspot.co.uk/2010/12/karl-gutzkow.html
[accessed 30/07/2013].
Press
- Rudolf Walther, `Der Mann hinter der skandalösen "Wally"', Tages-Anzeiger,
16 March 2011.
- Rolf Vollmann, `Tempo: Rasend. Karl Gutzkows Romane sind wieder da.
Ein Leseabenteuer', Die Zeit, 3 Jan 2008, S. 50, available at: http://www.zeit.de/2008/02/Tempo_Rasend
[accessed 30/07/2013].
Radio
- Ute Schneider interview on German radio programme: SWR 2, Aus dem
Land — Musik und Literatur, broadcast 12 March 2011. Information
about the programme available at: http://programm.ard.de/Programm/Radiosender/swr2-aus-dem-land--musik-und-literatur/eid_284676265389228?sender=28467&monat=10&jahr=2011&datum=2011-03-12&list=main&archiv=1#top;
information about the average audience available at:
http://www.swr.de/unternehmen/presse/pressemitteilungen/swr-erfolgreichster-radioanbieter/-/id=11165302/vv=print/pv=print/nid=11165302/did=11754974/1m505gi/index.html
Lingustic digitization
- Emails from Deutsches Textarchiv, Berlin, dated 30.10.2012,
11.12.2012., 15.1.2013, 5.7.2013. Integration of Gutzkow texts in DTAQ:
http://www.deutschestextarchiv.de/dtaq/about;
login data for registered testing site DTAQ:
g.vonhoff@ex.ac.uk, password br99un13G.