The sustainable management of wetland environments
Submitting Institution
University of ExeterUnit of Assessment
Geography, Environmental Studies and ArchaeologySummary Impact Type
EnvironmentalResearch Subject Area(s)
Environmental Sciences: Environmental Science and Management
Biological Sciences: Ecology
History and Archaeology: Archaeology
Summary of the impact
Research by Exeter's Wetland Archaeology group has transformed our
understanding of the significance of wetlands as exceptionally
well-preserved but highly vulnerable records of past human achievement. By
informing public policy and advising planning and conservation bodies it
has played a major role in shaping management practices in the UK and
internationally. This includes Van de Noort's co-authorship of the English
Heritage Strategy for Wetlands, which informed the multi-agency Vision
for Wetlands that has distributed £8m of English Nature funding for
wetland conservation (2008-11), and £462k of English Heritage (EH) grants
(2011-15). The Vision for Wetlands emphasizes the need for
multi-agency working and as an example of this Rippon's AHRC KTF and
consequential contract research have involved collaborating with Essex
County Council, Southend-on-Sea Borough Council, RSPB, and Wessex
Archaeology in developing a major c.1,500ha nature reserve,
informing policies to increase public access to the countryside, and
planning for the future of the 2012 Olympic Mountain Bike venue.
Underpinning research
Wetlands contain remarkably well-preserved archaeological sequences, as
well as complex historic landscapes which are still in use today that
together provide a detailed record of past human endeavour. Exeter's
wetland expertise stems from a research group that included Coles
(Exeter 1972-2008), Rippon (Exeter 1996-present), Van de Noort
(Exeter 2000-present), and large number of PhD students. From the 1980s
Exeter played a leading role in the expansion of government-funded survey,
excavation and protection of previously neglected wetland landscapes in
Britain & Ireland. The 1996 RAE `flagged' Exeter's `Archaeology of
Wetlands' group and formal feedback from the 2001 RAE stated `the research
group on the Archaeology of Wetlands is of undoubtedly high international
standing'. The group has undertaken strongly inter-disciplinary research
across Europe that embraced not only archaeological and
palaeoenvironmental evidence, but also historic landscapes that remain in
use today. Following the pioneering Somerset Levels Project co-directed by
Coles (1973-1988; British Archaeology Awards Best Project 1976-1998), key
field-based work has included the Humber Wetlands Survey (completed while
Van de Noort was at Exeter in 2001) [1] and subsequent major
excavations at Sutton Common (2001-2007) [2]. Excavations such as
these have revealed the importance of wetlands for the preservation of
archaeological sites, and the significance of wetlands for past societies
as economic resources and places of ritual and refuge. Major comparative
analyses of wetland landscapes include Rippon's The Transformation of
Coastal Wetlands (2000) that revealed the contrasting patterns of
human exploitation, modification and transformation of wetlands across
Britain and mainland NW Europe, and included a case-study of the
distinctive traditional grazing marshes in SE England [3]. The
Wetland research group at Exeter also established the international Journal
of Wetland Archaeology.
Exeter's profile led in turn to a long-standing commitment to research
into the preservation and management of wetland archaeological sites and
landscapes. This included Coles' Wetland Management: A Survey for
English Heritage [4] which led to an international
conference organised by Coles and Adrian Olivier of EH (published as The
Heritage Management of Wetlands in Europe [5]). In 2000 EH
funded Van de Noort to undertake a survey of Monuments at Risk in
England's Wetlands. This revealed that at least 50% of lowland
peatland in England was lost during the last 50 years and that an
estimated 2,930 wetland monuments have been totally destroyed, but that
72% of local authorities had no policy for the identification, assessment
or management of wetland archaeology [6]. Following on from the
development of this survey, the Exeter group has carried out further
research targeted at specific issues. For example, Van de Noort's major
programme of survey and excavation at the Iron Age `marsh-fort' at Sutton
Common in Yorkshire included pioneering work on the in situ
monitoring of waterlogged deposits [2]. Following Rippon's initial
research into traditional grazing marshes, the RSPB and Essex County
Council invited him to research the landscape archaeology and history of
South Essex Marshes where a substantial c.1500 ha nature reserve
is being developed (which resulted in an AHRC KTF 2009-11: see Section 4).
References to the research
Key field-based research
[1]. Van de Noort, R. 2004: The Humber Wetlands; the
Archaeology of a Dynamic Landscape (Macclesfield; Windgather Press)
(book proposal underwent anonymous peer review, and a draft of the
complete text sent to an anonymous reader; included in the 2008 RAE. The
publication of this book was supported by a grant of £40k from English
Heritage in 2003).
[2]. Van de Noort, R., Chapman, H. and Collis, J. 2007: Sutton
Common: the Excavation of an Iron Age 'Marsh-Fort' (York: Council
for British Archaeology Research Report) (book proposal underwent
anonymous peer review, and a draft of the complete text sent to an
anonymous reader; included in the 2008 RAE. Project was supported by
£450k from English Heritage in 2000-7).
Key work of comparative analysis and analysis
[3]. Rippon, S. 2000: The Transformation of Coastal Wetlands:
Exploitation and Management of Marshland Landscapes in North West Europe
During the Roman and Medieval Periods (London: British Academy) (book
proposal underwent anonymous peer review, and a draft of the complete
text sent to an anonymous reader; included in the 2001 RAE. Funded
through British Academy Postdoctoral Fellowship the final year of which
was at Exeter, and a £2.2k British Academy small personal research grant
in 1997 when Rippon was at Exeter).
Management related studies
[4]. Coles, B. 1995, Wetland Management: A Survey for English
Heritage (London: English Heritage and WARP) (included in the
1996 RAE. This project was supported by £30k from English Heritage.
Research awarded the Institution of Civil Engineers' George Stephenson
Medal in 1995).
[5]. Coles, B. and Olivier, A. (eds) 2001: The Heritage
Management of Wetlands in Europe (Brussels: Occasional papers of the
Europae Archaeologiae Consilium No. 1) (included in the 2008 RAE;
supported by £33k from English Heritage, 2000-1).
[6]. Van de Noort, R., Fletcher, W., Thomas, G., Carstairs, I.,
and Patrick, D. 2002. Monuments at Risk in England's Wetlands
Project (Exeter: University of Exeter for English Heritage; http://hdl.handle.net/10036/29596)
(funded by grants to from English Heritage of £92k (2001-03) to
undertake the research that underpins the Strategy and implement
its key actions).
Details of the impact
Exeter's research has raised awareness of the importance of wetland
archaeology within public bodies in Britain and internationally, and
influenced policy with regard to landscape management practices. Following
English Heritage's (EH) commissioning of Van de Noort to produce its
survey of Monuments at Risk in England's Wetlands [6 above]
he co-wrote their Strategy for Wetlands (2002) which was updated in
2011 [A]. This is a high-level policy for conserving and managing
wetlands that has sustained EH's core activities of identifying,
understanding, protecting, and managing the historic environment.
These reports produced by Van de Noort led to a programme of EH research
in 2011-present valued at c.£462k [B; C].
This English Heritage Strategy for Wetlands, and the
research/data produced by Van de Noort and his team at Exeter, provided
the basis of the multi-agency (EH, Environment Agency, Natural England,
RSPB, and Wildlife Trusts) Wetland Vision's `Map of Historic
Environment Wetland Priority Areas' (2008) which characterises areas of
England with high potential for waterlogged archaeology and
palaeoenvironmental deposits [D]. Wetland Vision has
directed £8m of Natural England funding for the restoration of damaged
peatlands and the (re-)creation of new peatlands (2008-11) [E],
illustrating how Exeter's research has influenced public policy beyond
professional archaeology. A follow-on project (`Wetland Vision —
adapting wetlands to climate change', led by NERC's Centre for Ecology and
Hydrology) was commissioned by the Environment Agency to produce a
web-based tool (2012) designed for site managers concerned with the
eco-hydrological status of their wetlands and to support adaptive planning
and broader scale river corridor analysis and the delivery of England's Wetland
Vision. EH sponsored a heritage strand within it, with Van de Noort
as part of the consortium team, to ensure archaeological issues were
included [C; F].
More widely, Van de Noort's expertise is reflected in his membership of
the `Core Expert Panel' of the International Union for Conservation of
Nature UK Peatland Programme set up in 2009, and his co-authorship of its
report Peatlands and the Historic Environment: Scientific Review 2010
[G] that was debated and supported in the Scottish Parliament. He
also acted as scientific advisor to the archaeological survey undertaken
on peatlands milled by the Irish state company Bord na Mona (2007-09), and
chaired the review of archaeological research in the Irish peatlands for
Duchas (the heritage division of the Irish Department of the Environment).
The recommendations of this review are reflected in the 2012 Code of
Archaeological Practice between the Department of the Environment, the
National Museum of Ireland and Bord na Mona. Van de Noort's pioneering
research into in situ monitoring of waterlogged deposits at Sutton
Common has been held up as an example of `best practice' [H]. In
2013 DEFRA appointed Van de Noort Chair of the South West Regional Flood
and Coastal Committee, which was established by the Secretary of State
under the Flood and Water Management Act 2010. In this position, Van de
Noort has a key role in engaging local communities and authorities, and
external stakeholders appointed by the Environment Agency, in the
sustainable flood protection and coastal management of the South West of
England and, at a national level, in shaping policies in these areas as a
member of the Regional Flood and Coastal Committee Chairmen's meetings.
The aim of the Wetland Vision is to `show where new wetlands
could be created and current wetlands restored ... [to] protect our
heritage and reap the many benefits that wetlands can provide' [D],
while the EH Strategy for Wetlands (2002) stresses the importance
of management at a landscape scale [A]. An example of the impact
that Exeter's research has had in achieving this multi-agency
landscape-scale approach is a sequence of projects where Rippon has been
contracted by Essex County Council `because of his distinctive, historic
landscape focussed approach to research into wetland landscapes in
Britain, and Essex' [I] to provide advice on the management of
specific landscapes as a contribution to local and regional strategic
planning initiatives (eg Thames Gateway Parklands Vision, Thames Gateway
Local Nature Partnership, and South Essex Green Grid Strategy) that aim to
create high quality green space within/between extensive urban areas [I].
In 2009 Rippon was invited by the RSPB and Essex County Council (ECC) to
advise on the creation of a new c.1,500ha nature reserve in the
South Essex Marshes. An AHRC KTF allowed Rippon to work in partnership
with RSPB and ECC in the development of this reserve which now attracts
260,000 visitors a year (and which the RSPB expects to rise to 350,000
annually). The preparation of a report outlining the history and key
character defining features of this landscape had an immediate impact, for
example through Rippon's involvement in designing information provided for
visitors and so enhancing their experience and understanding, and in
shaping the design of the reserve in a way that protected key historic
landscape assets that in previous plans were going to be destroyed [I].
One reflection of the positive impact this project had on planners and
countryside managers is that Rippon was subsequently commissioned to
prepare a report (2011) for Southend-on-Sea Borough Council to inform
their Urban Habitats project to increase public access to the countryside
of coastal Essex) [I; J]. Subsequent work (2011-12) with Wessex
Archaeology for the Olympic Legacy Company and ECC has ensured that the
historic landscape is properly understood, protected and enhanced when
providing a legacy for the 2012 Olympic Mountain Biking venue in the
costal parish of Hadleigh that it is anticipated will increase annual
visitor numbers to the existing Country Park by approximately 250,000 by
2017 [I].
An important part of the wetland archaeology research group at Exeter has
been its PhD students, of which many have gone on to use their research in
a professional public policy environment including Will Fletcher (EH
Inspector), Richard Brunning and Rebecca Loader (HER Officers in Somerset
and Isle of Wight), and Jason Rogers (Research Director, Alaska Maritima).
Sources to corroborate the impact
A Original English Heritage Strategy for Wetlands (Van de
Noort, R., Fletcher, W. and Thomas, G. 2002. English Heritage Strategy
for Wetlands (Exeter: University of Exeter, http://hdl.handle.net/10036/3042),
updated in the 2011 English Heritage Research Advisory Panel Report (RAP
2011/9) Water and Wetland Strategy (http://www.english-heritage.org.uk/content/imported-docs/p-t/rap-jul11meeting-wetland.pdf).
B: English Heritage National Heritage Protection Plan Activity 3A5
Wetland and Waterlogged Archaeology, through which EH research valued at c.£462k
has been distributed (http://www.english-heritage.org.uk/professional/protection/national-heritage-protection-plan/plan/activities/3a5);
C Letter of support from Head of Strategic Planning and Management
Division, English Heritage, 1 Waterhouse Square, 138-142 Holborn, London,
EC1N 2ST, tel. 020 79733000.
D Wetland Vision (2008): A 50-year Vision for Wetlands.
England's Wetland Landscape: Securing a Future for Nature, People and
the Historic Environment (http://www.wetlandvision.org.uk/),
and specifically its Wetland Vision Map of Historic Environment
Wetland Priority Areas (http://www.wetlandvision.org.uk/dyndisplay.aspx?d=downloads).
E £8m funding (£2m annually) allocated by Natural England through
the Wetland Vision in 2008-11 (http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/ourwork/conservation/biodiversity/funding/wetlandvision/default.aspx
and http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/Images/wetlandsvisionupdate_tcm6-13877.pdf).
F English Heritage sponsored module `Wetland Tool for Climate
Change: Projecting the impacts of climate change on wetlands' in the Wetland
Vision partnership undertaken by the NERC-funded Centre for Ecology
and Hydrology, on which Van de Noort was a member:
http://www.ceh.ac.uk/sci_programmes/Water/Wetlands/ClimateChangeAssessmentToolforWetlands.html
G International Union for Conservation of Nature UK Peatland
Programme report co-authored by van de Noort: Peatlands and the
Historic Environment: Scientific Review 2010: http://www.iucn-uk-peatlandprogramme.org/commission/historicenvironment
H Discussion of Van de Noort's work on in situ monitoring
of waterlogged deposits at Sutton Common: English Heritage
Conservation Bulletin 43: http://www.english-heritage.org.uk/publications/conservation-bulletin-43/60yorkshireironagesite.pdf/
I Letter of support from Head of Place Services, Essex County
Council, County Hall, Chelmsford, Essex, CM1 1QH, tel. 01245 437790.
J Southend-on-Sea Borough Council Urban Habitats Project
(http://www.southend.gov.uk/info/461/parks_and_open_spaces-information_and_advice/396/urban_habitats)
that includes Rippon's report on Urban habitat Historic Landscape
Character Assessment
(http://www.southend.gov.uk/downloads/download/722/urban_habitats).