Improving athletes’ preparation for optimal sporting performance
Submitting Institution
University of BrightonUnit of Assessment
Sport and Exercise Sciences, Leisure and TourismSummary Impact Type
SocietalResearch Subject Area(s)
Medical and Health Sciences: Human Movement and Sports Science, Public Health and Health Services
Psychology and Cognitive Sciences: Psychology
Summary of the impact
The impact of this research has been to improve the performance of elite
athletes and safeguard the well-being of Paralympians. It has affected the
management of athletes' dynamic physiological responses and advanced the
regulatory frameworks of sporting bodies. This has changed the strategies
of the USA Olympic Committee, the International Paralympic Committee and
the British Paralympic Association. The indirect impact of this primary
research has been to change the routine training practices of recreational
athletes and influence the advice on exercise given to military personnel
and people with disabilities.
Underpinning research
Origins: Sport and exercise science research at the University of
Brighton (UoB) has its origins in the 1980s. Dedicated laboratories were
established and equipped to measure human function in exercise and in many
sports, from rest to maximum effort, and UoB had one of the first
laboratories to have a dedicated environmental chamber. Environmental
investigations utilise the specially constructed chambers to control heat,
cold, humidity and oxygen partial pressure and focus on the application of
fundamental environmental physiology to the exercising human athlete. The
research has been characterised by rigorous analysis of the methodologies
and their application to the assessment and enhancement of sports and
exercise performance across different activities and environmental
conditions, for people of all abilities and those with disabilities
[references 3.1, 3.2, 3.3, 3.4].
Early work by Jones and DOUST [3.1] was the first publication to validate
a laboratory-based test to `normal' exercise performance outside of
laboratories. They showed that starting a treadmill test with a 1%
gradient effectively mimics the average outdoors conditions experienced
during running. People using treadmills with a 1% incline would,
therefore, be tested and assessed for their performance in conditions
similar to those exercising outdoors. This research informed the methods
and hypotheses of subsequent laboratory-based research at UoB [3.3], which
showed how scientific evidence can be used to improve the prediction of
the consequences of training and preparation in particular locations and
conditions for sport (eg, events in warm regions) and so enhance
strategies to improve the performance of athletes.
Broadening the field: Research at UoB has encompassed continuous
types of exercise and, more recently, intermittent sprint type exercise,
simulating the changes in pace experienced in field sports such as
football, rugby and hockey. Using rigorous science in sports-relevant
protocols, including intermittent and repeated sprint exercise, MAXWELL,
Castle, WEBBORN and WATT have demonstrated how improved performance in hot
conditions can be achieved by optimal precooling strategies, leading to
significant gains in work done in such conditions [3.3].
Related UoB research in Paralympic medicine started in the late 1990s.
This has extended the initial research further by developing new
understandings of the thermoregulatory physiology of novel situations,
such as those exhibited by tetraplegic athletes, who do not have normal
physiological control mechanisms for sweating and body temperature
regulation. The research has identified the appropriate interventions and
the best forms of support that are required to enable Paralympic athletes
to compete more safely in all environments and to perform to the best of
their ability safely [3.4].
Further Paralympic research involved large-scale multinational studies
monitoring injury occurrence at the Summer and Winter Paralympics [3.2,
3.5]. The research has revealed the complex medical and physiological
interactions that occur in Paralympic athletes, defining the patterns and
incidence of injury and illness [3.2, 3.4, 3.5]. The accepted model of
injury prevention first defines the extent and severity of the injury
problems and then establishes the mechanisms of injury so that preventive
measures can be put in place. Using this model, the International
Paralympic Committee has been able to work with sports federations to
implement the research outcomes. The research also demonstrated the
improvements required to better safeguard Paralympic athletes through
enhanced safety preparation for events and post-injury care pathways [3.2,
3.5].
Translation and intervention: The translation of the research has
been integrated with the academic research through key collaborations with
sporting organisations and participants as discussed in REF3a. In the
1990s, the UoB was contracted by four sports as part of the UK's Sports
Science Support Programme, to undertake applied research for sports
performance and assessment.
Research on heat cooling amongst Paralympic athletes was funded in 2003
by UK Sport to enable UoB researchers to work with the British Paralympic
Association to develop heat and acclimatisation strategies for use in the
Athens 2004 and Beijing 2008 Summer Olympic Games. Further funding from UK
Sport enabled WEBBORN to be part of a multi-disciplinary Beijing
Acclimatisation Group that, between 2006 and 2008, developed the
acclimatisation strategy for the 2008 Summer Paralympic Games.
This research on injury occurrence at the 2008 Summer Paralympics was
linked to the first Injury Survey conducted by the International
Paralympic Committee and was initiated by WEBBORN at the 2002 Winter
Paralympics. The survey highlighted that up to 24% of all Paralympic
athletes reported an injury during the Games. The success of this first
survey led the International Paralympic Committee to repeat it at the 2006
and 2010 Winter Paralympic Winter Games.
Key researchers:
Jonathan Doust: |
Lecturer (April 1987–Aug 1988), Senior Lecturer (Sept
1988–Aug 1992), Principal Lecturer (Sept 92–Feb 2000), Professor of
Sport and Exercise Science (Jan 2004–to date), Head of School (Jan
2006–to date). |
Neil Maxwell: |
Lecturer (Sept 1997–Aug 1999) Senior Lecturer (Sept
1999–May 2004), Principal Lecturer (June 2004–to date). |
Peter Watt: |
Reader (Dec 2001–to date). |
Nick Webborn: |
Principal Research Fellow (April 2004–to date). |
References to the research
[3.1] JONES, A.M. and DOUST, J.H. (1996) A 1% treadmill grade most
accurately reflects the energetic cost of outdoor running. Journal of
Sport Science 14 (4): pp.321-7. [Quality validation: output in
leading peer-reviewed journal, and a reference point for others.]
[3.2] WEBBORN, N. and VAN DER VLIET, P. (2012) Paralympic medicine. The
Lancet, 380 (9836): pp.65-71. [Quality validation: output in leading
clinically related journal.]
[3.3] CASTLE, P.C., MACDONALD, A.L., PHILP, A., WEBBORN, A., WATT, P.W.
and MAXWELL N.S. (2006) Precooling leg muscle improves intermittent sprint
exercise performance in hot, humid conditions. Journal of Applied
Physiology 100 (4): pp.1377-1384. [Quality validation: output in
leading peer-reviewed journal.]
[3.4] WEBBORN, N., PRICE, M.J., CASTLE, P.C. and GOOSEY-TOLFREY, V.
(2005) Effects of two cooling strategies on thermoregulatory responses of
tetraplegic athletes during repeated intermittent exercise in the heat. Journal
of Applied Physiology 98 (6): pp.2101-2107. [Quality validation:
output in leading peer-reviewed journal.]
[3.5] WEBBORN, N., WILLICK, S. and EMERY C.A. (2012) The injury
experience at the 2010 winter Paralympic games. Clinical Journal of
Sport Medicine 22 (1): pp.3-9. [Quality validation: output in
leading peer-reviewed journal.]
Details of the impact
Safeguarding Paralympian well-being: UoB research on injuries and
risk factors has protected the well-being of Paralympic athletes by
improving how injuries are monitored, changing acclimatisation strategies,
safety rules and equipment design, and enhancing the education and
practices of clinicians working with Paralympic athletes. The findings on
pre-cooling in Paralympic athletes influenced the strategy for Great
Britain's athletes in the Beijing 2008 Olympic Games. The research was
adopted in the acclimatisation strategy used by the British Paralympic
Association to safeguard athletes from heat stress in Beijing and is
identified by the English Institute of Sport as having impacted on the
sports performance of athletes during the Games.
Following the Beijing Olympics, the English Institute of Sport has
confirmed that this strategy has ongoing use within individual sports, in
particular wheelchair rugby and tennis (source 5.1).
Based on empirical evidence collected by WEBBORN at successive Winter
Paralympics, there have been rule changes for ice sledge hockey,
instigated by the International Paralympic Committee in the 2008 rule
book, which require standardised sledge design and the mandatory use of
protective clothing (5.2). The rule changes have been followed by a
reduction in injuries during the Paralympics and the eradication, thus
far, of certain injury types (5.2). Ice sledge hockey produced only one
lower limb fracture out of the 40 injuries (2.5%) treated in the 2010
Winter Paralympic Games compared with 4 of 12 (33%) of the injuries in
2002, before the introduction of the regulation change.
WEBBORN's research, along with his advisory roles to the International
Paralympic Committee and as Chief Medical Officer to the London 2012
Summer Paralympic Games, have ensured his findings have been disseminated
widely to clinicians. The International Paralympic Committee has
acknowledged that WEBBORN's work has made a significant contribution to
the Paralympic movement in relation to the education of clinicians in the
field, resulting in improved medical care. The injury study initiated by
WEBBORN in 2002 has now been integrated by the International Paralympic
Committee as a standard practice in all future Winter and Summer
Paralympics (5.3).
Improving elite athletes' preparation and acclimatisation: The
research on pre-cooling as a coping strategy for competition in hot
environments has also benefitted elite athletes. The findings were used by
the USA Olympic committee to guide its strategy for its athletes competing
in the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games (5.4). The USA Olympic Committee's
preparation manual that advises coaches and athletes on competing in heat
and humidity contains four recommendations, all of them based on
referenced sport science research publications written by leading
researchers and institutions in the UK and Europe. UoB's research
publications underpin three of the four recommendations for cooling
strategies, including cooling vests, whole-body immersion and ice
packs/towels. The manual notes the recommendations will help to delay and
potentially prevent body core temperature from rising to a point where it
impairs performance (5.4).
The Brazilian Olympic Committee has also acknowledged the importance of
the research, in particular the underpinning research publications [3.3]
and [3.4] above, and that this research is currently being used as
evidence in devising pre-cooling and heat acclimatisation strategies
designed to improve performance in the 2016 Olympics and Paralympic Games
(5.5).
Enhancing the training practices of recreational athletes: The
innovative findings of the sport science research at UoB have resulted in
improvements to the training equipment used by recreational athletes,
having a indirect impact on personal fitness. It has also led to changes
in the advice given to military personnel and people with disabilities
taking part in physical exercise.
The research by Jones and DOUST showing that starting a treadmill test
with a 1% gradient brings the same benefits as exercising outdoors has
contributed to personal fitness by changing how people are tested and
advised in gyms. Most treadmill tests of exercise function for fitness
assessment and personal training in sports and gyms use the principles
verified in this research and adopt the 1% gradient. The USA Navy refers
to the UoB research in online advice to navy personnel on how to maintain
personal fitness and recommends adding an incline of 1% when using a
treadmill (5.6).
Recreational athletes with disabilities are one of the target audiences
for the Peter Harrison Centre for Disability Sport, which has been
developing a `Fit and Healthy Resource for People with a Disability'.
WEBBORN has undertaken consultation and research activities that inform a
series of recommendations on which this new resource is based. These
recommendations have led to changes in how the centre delivers and frames
material to ensure that practical resources are available for people with
disabilities to engage in recreational physical activity (5.7).
Sources to corroborate the impact
5.1 Testimonial available from the Deputy Director of Performance at the
English Institute of Sport. This confirms that UoB research has been used
in the development of the heat and acclimatisation strategy for the
Paralympics and is used on an ongoing basis within individual sports, in
particular wheelchair rugby and tennis.
5.2 International Paralympic Committee (2008). Ice Sledge Hockey Rule
Book. Rules on sledge design and protective clothing are included on
page 22 onwards. Available at: http://www.blazesports.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/Sled-Hockey-IPC-Rulebook.pdf
[Accessed: 11 June 2013].
5.3 Testimonial available from the Medical and Scientific Director at the
International Paralympic Committee. This confirms that UoB research has
been used to inform standard practice at all Winter and Summer Paralympics
and has reduced injury.
5.4 `Preparation for Competing in Heat and Humidity'. Document presented
by the Environmental Physiology Team, Performance Services Division,
United States Olympic Committee. This document considers cooling
strategies for Beijing. UoB's research underpins three of the four
strategies. This document is available on request.
5.5 Testimonial available from a Distinguished Knowledge Consultant,
Brazilian Olympic Committee. This confirms that UoB research is currently
being used as evidence in devising pre-cooling and heat acclimatisation
strategies to improve performance in the Rio 2016 Olympics and Paralympic
Games.
5.6 The `US Navy' Treadmill vs Outside Walking Available at: http://www.med.navy.mil/sites/nhoki/Patients/CommunityHealth/HealthPromo/Documents/A
rticles/treadmill_vs.htm [Accessed: 11 June 2013]. The US Navy
refers to the UoB research in advice to navy personnel on how to maintain
personal fitness and recommends adding an incline of 1% when using a
treadmill.
5.7 Testimonial available from the Peter Harrison Centre for Disability
Sport. This confirms that recommendations made by University of Brighton
researchers form the basis of the Centre's Fit and Healthy Resource for
People with a Disability. Available on request.