Re-Presenting Heritage through Community Research: Poltimore House
Submitting Institution
University of ExeterUnit of Assessment
HistorySummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Built Environment and Design: Architecture
History and Archaeology: Archaeology, Curatorial and Related Studies
Summary of the impact
Professor Henry French's research into the use of landed property and the
lives of the English gentry, undertaken since his appointment at Exeter in
2001, has contributed to a Knowledge Transfer Fellowship community
engagement project. This project trained volunteer groups to explore the
history and archaeology of the estate and gardens of Poltimore House,
Exeter. By transforming the capacity of Poltimore House Trust (PHT) to run
outreach activities, it significantly enhanced its educational work with
young people and schools. By enriching the history of the estate's almost
unknown gardens, it gave the PHT a beacon project to publicise and enhance
its wider re-development plans. By training community volunteers in
historical and archaeological research, it made public involvement central
to interpretation of historic landscapes, creating a template of
sustainable heritage research that can be applied elsewhere.
Underpinning research
Poltimore House is a country house on the edge of Exeter, previously
owned by the Bampfylde family, Lords Poltimore. The house, which contains
elements from the Tudor period onwards, is now semi-derelict, and along
with the surrounding grounds, once a garden and landscaped park, is owned
a local charity, PHT which is dedicated to its renovation. The PHT
knowledge transfer project utilised the research expertise of Professor
French on patterns of landownership and elite political and cultural
behaviour which allowed him to provide the social, economic and cultural
context for archaeological research on the elite landscape at Poltimore
house, and to guide PHT volunteers in archival research projects.
Professor French has researched patterns of landownership and power
relations among the English elite in a series of studies published between
2003 and 2007 (section 3 references 1, 2). His detailed study of
landownership and economic change in an English village community,
undertaken first with Professor Richard Hoyle of Reading University, and
subsequently on his own (Section 3, reference 4) provided model for
investigating the background of Poltimore house, by offering experience in
the interpretation and analysis of a wide range of estate archives, such
as rentals, surveys and maps. Furthermore, Professor French has studied
processes of cultural reproduction among the landed elite through his most
recent research into gentry social and gender identities (section 3
references 3 & 4). His research into the personal and estate
correspondence of 19 gentry households from across England in the period
1670-1900 allowed him to guide PHT volunteers in analysing the composition
and turnover of the household and garden staff at Poltimore, their
geographical origins and career patterns from census, estate letters and
newspaper sources. It also informed his work on the sale of the estate in
1923, for a public lecture for PHT volunteers and guides at a project
open-day in June 2012, and the subsequent Landscape History
article. All Professor French's publications listed in section 3 have been
subject to external peer review. The outcomes of his AHRC project
(AH/E007791/1) were graded as `good', and his book on this project with Dr
Rothery was reviewed recently in American Historical Review (vol.
118, no. 4, Oct. 2013, pp. 1247-9), and described as `exemplary' in
its use of estate materials to illustrate processes of cultural change.
During the PHT knowledge transfer project Professor French worked
alongside two archaeologists, Professor Oliver Creighton and Dr Penny
Cunningham, providing historical knowledge and archival expertise that
supported their archaeological investigations. Professor Creighton is an
expert on landscapes of the social elite in the historic period, both
urban and rural. He was co-director of a major AHRC-funded research
project investigating the historic townscape of Wallingford in Oxfordshire
AD 800-1300, giving him considerable experience of community archaeology
training and field-work activities for mapping above- and below-ground
archaeology that were applied to the Poltimore project. In addition, he
drew on Archaeology at Exeter's experience in community and schools-led
surveying, field-walking, test-pitting, and find cleaning/identification
archaeology through the Heritage Lottery-funded XArch project,
2004-8. Dr Penny Cunningham who had led the community archaeology events
in XArch was employed as the KT Fellow at Poltimore to lead
volunteer activities and public events, co-ordinate research projects and
link to schools and the wider community.
Academic research on Poltimore House has led to a peer-reviewed,
open-access journal article published by Landscape History in
2013, to disseminate findings about the function of academic research
processes and presentation in building cultural capacity in the
heritage/charitable sector.
References to the research
Evidence of the quality of the research: this research was the
result of external grant funding from the AHRC (final report grade `good')
and all the publications were peer reviewed.
1) H. R. French & R. W. Hoyle, `English Individualism refuted — and
reasserted: the land market of Earls Colne (Essex), 1550-1750', Economic
History Review, LVI, 4, (2003).
2) H. R. French & R. W. Hoyle, The Character of English Rural
Society: Earls Colne, 1550-1750 (Manchester U.P. 2007).
3) H. R. French & M. Rothery, Man's Estate: Masculinity and the
Landed Elite in England, c. 1660-1900 Oxford U.P., 2012). Research
funded by AHRC Standard Research Grant AH/E007791/1, £370,041 2007-2010.
4) British Academy Small Grants Award SG-091025 `Landlords, Tenants and
Paupers? Rural Society and the "Tripartite Model" in Eighteenth-Century
England: a case study', awarded 02/10, funding one 0.4 researcher for 4
months — £4,877.
5) AHRC Knowledge Transfer Fellowship Award AH/H03806X/1, `Community and
Landscape: Transforming Access to the Heritage of the Poltimore Estate',
(PI Oliver Creighton) funding KT Fellow (Penny Cunningham), and 5.6
hours/week funding over 24 months for CI (Henry French); total AHRC
contribution = £154, 924, 2010-12.
Details of the impact
Poltimore House is an emotive site with strong bonds to the city of
Exeter. Until 1921, it was a country house, the home of the Bampfylde
family, Lords Poltimore. Thereafter, it was a private school, and an NHS
hospital, before suffering serious fire damage in 1988. After a further
decade of neglect and vandalism it was acquired in 2000 by a charity, the
PHT, whose aim is its long-term preservation and re-use. In Feb. 2009, the
PHT approached the University of Exeter for academic guidance and to help
prepare a Heritage Lottery Fund bid. It quickly became clear that
instead of academics supplying ready-made expertise, the site and PHT's
300-strong volunteer base offered an opportunity to engage more fully by
creating a group of volunteer researchers who could recover and take
ownership of the house's past. This collaboration resulted in a successful
AHRC Knowledge Transfer grant award in April 2010.
Between Aug. 2010 and July 2012 the project focused on two elements:
a) Working with volunteers to trace the history and evolution of the
Poltimore House gardens and estate landscape primarily through detailed
documentary research and map analysis on the 18th and 19th
centuries. For instance, in 3-monthly project workshops Prof. French
introduced volunteers to the wider historical context of their detailed
analyses of nineteenth- century census records, and their findings from
surveys of nineteenth-century newspapers, maps and the 1910 Estate Duty
Act valuation.
b) Leading teams of volunteer, non-professional researchers in methods of
archaeological research (field-walking, geo-physical surveying, landscape
archaeology), to assemble a longer, archaeological time-scale for the
estate's development.
All the activities described below took place between 2010 and 2012
unless otherwise specified. Working alongside PHT, the project
developed on-site educational activities with primary and secondary
schools in East Devon, plus A-level students from Exeter College (the main
tertiary college in Exeter). During the course of the project 721 school
pupils from seven partner schools in Devon participated in 18 training and
outreach events mapped to the National Curriculum. Events included on-site
training workshops on masonry recording, archaeological survey, landscape
analysis and visits to schools and a film made by Broadclyst Community
Primary School (Section 5 reference 3). These sources, objects and
resources have enabled PHT's Volunteer Manager to provide on-site School
visits, and continued curriculum engagement with Broadclyst Community
Primary School in 2012-13, allowing pupils to produce artwork for PHT's
new on site information boards (Section 5 reference 2).
The project contributed significantly to PHT's future development
plans. The project team emphasized PHT's most accessible (but
unknown) legacy, the gardens and the estate history. This enabled PHT to
use this resource as a beacon project in its successful HLF bid, Access,
Interpretation, Learning and Archives (Section 5 reference 2).
This funded rebuilding of a service wing of the house, creating a base for
the PHT, and a first stage towards its wider re-development plans for the
site within Exeter and East Devon Growth Point. Archaeological fieldwork
in the environs of the house revealed a number of formerly hidden
landscape features, such as an Edwardian Chinese Garden, which were
surveyed in detail, for inclusion into new reconstructions and phased
plans `to support their long-term preservation by the PHT' (section 5
reference 2). Detailed sub-surface archaeological reports on the park and
gardens will inform the PHT's future management strategy, and enable
scheduling of the garden and park, as housing and business development
expands around the site as part of the East Devon Growth Point.
Public involvement in research was built into the processes of
research training and project co-ordination among PHT volunteers and
Poltimore village residents, including documentary research,
field-walking, archaeological surveying, geo-physical surveys, and finds
identification (Section 5, reference 7). PHT's partnership with the social
enterprise Forward25 provided placements and workplace experience for
young local unemployed people (Section 5, reference 5). The project `made
sure volunteers gained new knowledge and understanding of the processes
involved in landscape history' (section 5 reference 2). It also created a
template of sustainable public participation, research-skills training and
volunteering that can be applied elsewhere in a climate of long-term
declines in public funding and professional skills shortages in local
government. Since the end of the project in Aug. 2012, volunteers have
continued historical and archaeological research, through a research group
(Poltimore Estate History & Archaeology Group, PEHAG) founded in
October 2012, which was turned into a formally-constituted historical
society in Oct. 2013 (Poltimore Estate Research Society, PERS), affiliated
to PHT. Project participants have become a group of skilled volunteer
researchers, who can take forward further investigations into the history
of the estate, house and gardens.
The project increased public access to Poltimore House and its
grounds. Before the project started Poltimore House was open one afternoon
a month between March to October. As the project built capacity in the
form of trained volunteers, Poltimore House has been able to open twice a
week between March and October, significantly improving access to the
grounds and has made `a significant difference to the condition of the
parkland' (section 5 references 2 & 7). The project stimulated public
interest in the neglected historic landscape at Poltimore, by making
techniques of landscape research more widely accessible. During the course
of the project 2,127 members of the public participated in 86 training and
outreach events (including flagship launch events and an end-of-project
symposium), two project open events and other `local history days'
(section 5, references 6 & 7).
The project made the history of Poltimore house publicly accessible
with information about the heritage of the estate presented to the general
public through the creation of a specific project website (Section 5
reference 1), which contains 101 documents, photographs and analyses of
census, newspaper and mapping evidence undertaken by project volunteers.
For example, volunteers trained in analysis of the censuses have
undertaken detailed reconstruction and presentation of life in Poltimore
village in the nineteenth century (section 5, reference 7). A public
exhibition was held at Poltimore to mark the conclusion of the project in
July 2012 (section 5, reference 7). PERS have now taken over the website
in 2013 in order to continue its development. The project created new
archaeological find collections for PHT, moveable on-site displays and
five permanent on-site visitor display boards to present new
interpretative materials about Poltimore, its gardens and estates,
incorporating the work of school children and volunteers involved in the
project, and leaflets providing key information and maps. These have been
built into on-site presentations at open days by volunteer guides, and a
new guidebook to be written by the volunteers (PERS), sold to raise funds
for the PHT. Material from the project will be incorporated into a new
volume on the history of Poltimore House (J. Hemming, The House That
Richard Built), published by PHT in November 2013 to raise funds.
Sources to corroborate the impact
1. Project website http://elac.ex.ac.uk/poltimore-landscapes/
2. Letter from the chair of Poltimore House Trust
3. A record of Broadclyst Primary School's involvement with PHT including
a film made by the pupils: (http://elac.ex.ac.uk/poltimore-landscapes/page.php?id=152)
4. Letter from the Poltimore House Trust, PHT Volunteer Manager
5. The website of Forward25: www.forward25.com/
6. Poltimore Landscape's volunteer blog: http://elac.ex.ac.uk:8080/poltimorecommunity/pg/blog/lg287/read/1710/archaeology-display-for-the-annual-heritage-open-weekend-at-poltimore
7. Activities of the Poltimore project publicised via the local
newspaper. (a) volunteers recruited: http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Walkers-wanted-help-historic-house/story-13334380-detail/story.html;
(b) exhibition advertised: http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Exhibition-looks-Poltimore/story-16581494-detail/story.html
(c) open day reported: http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Poltimore-opening-work-starts-repair-roof/story-13229881-detail/story.html