The Development of Novel Strategies and Values for the Preservation, Conservation, and Presentation of Cultural Heritage
Submitting Institution
University of ExeterUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Information and Computing Sciences: Artificial Intelligence and Image Processing
Studies In Creative Arts and Writing: Film, Television and Digital Media
History and Archaeology: Curatorial and Related Studies
Summary of the impact
Staff in the Centre for Intermedia at the University of Exeter research
methods of documenting,
archiving, and replaying multi-media art, heritage, and performance. Their
work demonstrates how
ideas and practices of performance, particularly sharing and replay of
audience experience, can
broaden and enhance public encounters with museums. Developed in
collaboration with
international artists, technologists, and major cultural organisations,
the main impacts of this
research have been to:
- help professionals and organizations adapt to changing cultural values
- preserve, conserve and present cultural heritage
- generate new ways of thinking that influence creative practice
Underpinning research
Professor Gabriella Giannachi and Professor Nick Kaye
joined Exeter in 2004 to set up the
Centre for Intermedia which promotes advanced interdisciplinary research
in performance and the
arts. They became part of the English Department in 2011 to build up
synergies with existing
research strengths in English in film, visual technology, and performance,
and to create a research
cluster that places Exeter at the forefront of new developments in digital
humanities. Their work on
documentation, archiving and replay is relevant to scholars in the
humanities and Computer
Science, as well as artists, technologists, and museums.
Between 2004-11 Giannachi and Kaye used a wiki hosted by
project-partner Stanford University
and the virtual world Second Life to develop fourteen original
documentations which directly
involved artists and technologists in capturing and documenting the
project's research and
development (3.1) This prompted insight into the user experience
which was published in the
catalogue of an international exhibition dedicated to audiences (3.5).
Subsequent experimentation
with novel methods and tools, including motion capture and physiological
data, led to the
theorisation of how performance, new media and computer science
methodologies can be brought
together to create new forms of documentation, archiving, sharing and
replay (3.1; 3.2; 3.3; 3.4).
This research, initially funded by the AHRC (2004-9) and the Langlois
Foundation (2006), was
subsequently funded by RCUK (2009-14) (3.6) and further facilitated
by an AHRC award (2011-14)
in collaboration with Bristol Drama and Arnolfini, Bristol, to investigate
the replay of live art archival
materials within the context of a museum (3.7).
Giannachi's research for Performing Presence (3.2)
and the EPSRC-funded network, `New
Research Processes and Business Models for the Creative Industries'
(2009-10), resulted in a
long-term collaboration with computer scientists at Nottingham (2006- ).
Subsequent research on
the documentation of user experiences led to several publications
including a paper on a
framework for interpreting user experiences as designable `trajectories'
through physical and virtual
environments. This paper was given the `best paper' award at the ACM
Conference on Human
Factors in Computing Systems in 2009, and was later developed into a book
(3.1). This prompted
an invitation to Giannachi to join the RCUK-funded `Horizon' digital
economy research hub at
Nottingham, where in 2010-11 she led an interdisciplinary team in the
design and development of
an original tool called CloudPad. This uses cloud computing for the
documentation, archiving,
sharing and replay of mixed media artworks (3.6).
Dissemination of Giannachi's RCUK-funded research led to a partnership
with Tate to develop `Art
Maps', a mobile application allowing users to link artworks to specific
locations through geotagging
and annotate their experience through social media (3.4). Research
into the museum user
experience also led to a Nesta award to research user engagement with
digital media at Imperial
War Museum, particularly in relation to the use of QR codes to embed
objects with audience
interpretation (2012) (3.8); and to an award from the AHRC's REACT
knowledge exchange hub to
collaborate with the Royal Albert Museum and Gallery, Exeter. This
collaboration researched
playful engagement with RAMM's Dartmoor heritage collections through the
creation of a mobile
web app, which encourages annotations by users to contribute to the
museum's knowledge about
its collections (3.9; 3.10).
References to the research
Evidence of the quality of the research: research peer-reviewed at
publication stage by scholarly
journals and publishers and by major external funding bodies at grant
application stage.
1. Benford, S., and Giannachi, G. (2011) Performing Mixed
Reality, Cambridge,
Massachusetts: MIT Press.
2. Giannachi, G., and Kaye, N. (2011) Performing
Presence: Between the Live and the
Simulated, Manchester: Manchester University Press, nominated in
Theatre Library
Association 44th Annual Book Awards.
3. Giannachi, G., Lowood, H. (Stanford Libraries), Worthey, G.
(Stanford Libraries), Rowland,
D., Benford, S., Price, D. (2011) `CloudPad — a cloud-based documentation
and archiving
tool for mixed reality artworks', paper presented at Digital Humanities
2011, Stanford June
19-22, published in Digital Creativity (2012) 1-17.
4. Giannachi, G., Sinker, R. (Tate Learning), Keep, M. (Tate
Learning), Beaven, K. (Tate
Online), Stack, J. (Tate Online), Mundy, J. (Tate Research), McAuley, D.,
Benford, S.,
Price, D., Carletti, L. (2012) `Art Maps', paper presented at Computers
and the History of
Art (CHArt) 2012, London, 15-16 November 2012.
5. Hertz, B.-S., Kaye, N., Giannachi, G., Weiner, A.,
Wreight, S. (2012) Audience as Subject,
exhibition catalogue, Yerba Buena Center for the Arts, San Francisco.
Key grants:
6. Giannachi, PI for Exeter in `Horizon' digital economy
research, RCUK funded (2009-14),
value to Exeter £264,115. The project involves 19 investigators from
Nottingham, Reading,
Exeter, Cambridge and Brunel, 36 partners, and works on transport,
creative industries and
energy, total funding £12,459,687 (excluding industrial contributions).
7. `Performing Documents: modeling creative and curatorial engagements
with live art and
performance archives' (2011-14). CI Kaye, PI Jones (Drama, Bristol
University), CI Clarke
(Drama, University of Bristol) and Arnolfini. AHRC award: £452,000. Value
to Exeter:
£99,800.
8. `Info-Objects: embedding objects with audience interpretation' (2012).
PI Giannachi, CI
Benford and McAuley (Computer Science, Nottingham University), partner
Imperial War
Museum. AHRC, Nesta, ACE, Digital R&D Fund for Arts and Culture. Award
to Exeter:
£8,460.
9. `Moor Stories: Reimagining the Dartmoor Landscape' (2012). PI Giannachi,
partners:
Royal Albert Memorial Museum and Art Gallery (RAMM) and 1010 Media. REACT
(AHRC)
HEIF award to Exeter: £6,250.
10. `Moor Stories: Reimagining the Dartmoor Landscape' (2013). PI Giannachi,
partners:
Royal Albert Memorial Museum and Art Gallery (RAMM) and 1010 Media. REACT
(AHRC)
award to Exeter: £24,000.
Details of the impact
Helping professionals and organisations adapt to changing cultural
values; generating new
ways of thinking that influence creative practice
Giannachi and Kaye have collaborated with a number of
artists towards the creation of novel
forms of documentation that encompass the user experience. The `Performing
Presence' online
research facility (2004-11), disseminating the team's research to the
general public, had a wide
reach, receiving between 260,000-625,000 hits in 2010 alone (5.1).
The documentation of the
artwork Life Squared (2006-9) led to a series of conversations
that the creator, an award-winning
US media artist, described as follows: `working with [Giannachi and Kaye]
has expanded and
enriched original conceptual themes as well as allowed a remapping of
strategies that greatly
expanded the original notion of what constitutes archives [...] I doubt
very much if my work would
have expanded as fully as it did without the dialogues with them' (5.2).
An impact of this exchange
was that the technologist who developed Life Squared created a
virtual world, Sirikata, and then
founded the company Katalabs, aimed at creating virtual worlds that can be
embedded in websites
and accessed through browsers with WebGL (5.3). Giannachi's
research into CloudPad led an
award-winning British artist company to devise a new form of archival
work, Riders Have Spoken,
documenting their work Rider Spoke, which was shown at British
Library as part of their Growing
Knowledge Exhibition (2011). The company acknowledged that Giannachi's
`inquisitive, rigorous
interrogation and elucidation of the group's work enabled [them] to learn
more deeply, reflect more
fully and disseminate more widely' (5.4).
Kaye's research into the theory and practice of documentation for
multimedia and installation
practices led to his invitation to act as consultant to the Israel Museum,
Jerusalem, for the
selection, installation, and curation of the permanent exhibition of
artists' film, video and
performance documentation in the newly-built 20th-century wing.
In particular, he contributed to the
integration of film and performance art into the galleries. Funded by the
Rockefeller Foundation,
the wing opened in 2010, receiving c. 400,000 visitors in the first year.
Kaye's work contributed to
the ongoing enrichment of public appreciation of the Dada, Surrealist, and
Fluxus works in the 20th-century
wing and to the integration of additional media within the galleries (5.5).
Kaye also
collaborated with Arnolfini, Bristol, towards Version Control, a
large-scale interdisciplinary
exhibition about the re-use and re-visiting of art works and performances,
which received 32,507
visitors between February and April 2013 (5.6).
Preserving, conserving and presenting cultural heritage
Giannachi's research led to a series of international invitations
to arts festivals (ars electronica,
Linz 2009; Transmediale, Berlin 2010; ISEA, Düsseldorf 2010; ICK2011,
Amsterdam). These in
turn prompted numerous subsequent invitations to `closed' expert workshops
on conservation
(Netherlands Media Art Institute; Virtueel Platform, the sector institute
for e-culture in the
Netherlands, Amsterdam 2011; Tate, London 2012; Gulbenkian
Foundation, Lisbon, June 2013).
The exchanges between Giannachi, museum curators, and sector institutes
were influential on the
Dutch field of digital arts conservation: `As a professional in the field
of art documentation, I believe
the work that has been done on documentation far extends the regular work
that is done in
museums and arts organizations' (5.7).
Giannachi's research with Horizon led to the development of Art
Maps, which makes over 68,000
artworks by Tate available through a web app to mobile users. Art Maps,
which `might not only
provide valuable data to Tate but also deliver the fundamentals of Tate
Learning Strategy and the
Mission itself' (5.8), was described by a user as something which
`takes art to people who wouldn't
necessarily access it and it broadens other people's horizons, [...]
people who probably have never
been to an art gallery' (5.9). Art Maps, which has been in receipt
of an EPSRC impact award held
by project Research Fellow Laura Carletti, was exhibited at Tate Britain
as part of the Looking at
the View Exhibition (February-June 2013). Giannachi's
collaboration with RAMM on Moor Stories
has similarly made it possible to connect the museum's collections from
Dartmoor with their
original locations. The web app, which has supported RAMM's policy of
facilitating access to its
collections as widely as possible, has thus far been showcased at RAMM's
Festival of Archaeology
(2013) (5.10).
Sources to corroborate the impact
- Analytics provided by Stanford University.
- US artist statement by email 3/4/2011.
- Katalabs, San Francisco, USA, by email 22/3/2011.
- UK artist statement by email 29/3/2011.
- Adina Kamian-Kahzdan (ed) (2010), Modernism in Dialogue:
20th-Century Painting
and Sculpture in the Israel Museum, Jerusalem: The Israel Museum,
p. 9.
- Analytics provided by Arnolfini, Bristol.
- Virtueel Platform, Amsterdam, Netherlands, by email 16/7/2011.
- Tate Online, http://www.tate.org.uk/context-comment/blogs/art-maps-mapping-art-collection
(25/3/2012).
- Tate Online, http://www.tate.org.uk/context-comment/blogs/art-maps-modes-engagement
(22/8/2012).
- Corroboration can be obtained from the Digital Media Officer, Royal
Albert Memorial Museum
and Art Gallery, Exeter, UK.