History of Philosophy without any Gaps Podcasts
Submitting Institution
King's College LondonUnit of Assessment
PhilosophySummary Impact Type
SocietalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Philosophy and Religious Studies: Religion and Religious Studies
Summary of the impact
The project makes accessible the history of philosophy `without any gaps'
to a global audience. It
capitalises on one of the Unit's research strengths, the history of
philosophy, and brings this
expertise to the general public maintaining a high level of intellectual
rigour while making it
accessible both intellectually and practically, thus maximizing reach. The
public has access to the
research through a series of podcasts (downloadable audio content)
available on the project's
website: www.historyofphilosophy.net,
via software like iTunes. The podcasts are free to download
and have been accessed more than 4 million times by thousands of listeners
around the world.
Because of their detail and format (often interviews) the podcasts convey
advanced ideas and the
fruits of recent research to this broad audience. The impact of the
project lies in its ability to
present our intellectual heritage in an accessible form, transforming the
imaginations and
sensibilities of individuals, enriching and expanding their lives and,
given the nature of the topics
discussed, informing and influencing their intellectual, cultural and
personal development.
Underpinning research
(1) The podcasts produced up to the end of the assessment period centre
on Prof. Adamson's
main areas of research interest: ancient philosophy, including late
antiquity and Islamic philosophy.
The inclusion of the latter links the podcasts to Prof. Adamson's
Leverhulme-funded research
project `Natural Philosophy in the Islamic World', which has provided
resources for the production
of the podcast. One of the central motivations of the project has been to
bring knowledge of these
areas to a wide audience, since they are little known outside of
specialist academia. Although the
podcasts are aimed at a wide audience, the episode scripts themselves
constitute an original
research contribution. The scripts will appear in revised form as a
multi-volume series with Oxford
University Press, to be called A History of Philosophy. The first
volume will cover the Pre-Socratics,
Plato and Aristotle, and will be published in early summer 2014.
(2) The podcasts also draw extensively on previously published research
by Prof. Adamson and
other members of the King's philosophy faculty. Numerous episodes (both
scripted and interviews)
disseminate the research on the history of philosophy by King's faculty.
Current and former King's
staff who have appeared on the podcast are Prof. MM McCabe (at King's
since 1990), Dr. Raphael
Woolf (at King's since 2006), Prof. Richard Sorabji (retired from King's
in 2000), Dr. Frisbee
Sheffield (temporary lecturer at King's during the period), Dr. Fiona
Leigh and Dr. John Sellars
(both previously assistants to Prof. Sorabji's Commentators Project). For
instance, in episode 6,
Prof. McCabe discusses her influential view that Heraclitus' fragments
need to be read as an
invitation to a kind of `dialogue' with the reader; in episode 50, three
current King's ancient
philosophers discuss work they have done on Aristotle's reaction to Plato;
in episodes 17 and 72,
Dr. Woolf draws on his published studies of Socrates and Cicero.
Similarly, the podcasts have
allowed Prof. Adamson to give other scholars from outside King's a chance
to disseminate the
fruits of their research. Interviews on ancient philosophy have featured
Malcolm Schofield, David
Sedley, George Boys-Stones, Serafina Cuomo, R.J. Hankinson, and numerous
others.
Prof. Adamson's own research became especially important for the podcasts
starting with
episodes which aired in spring of 2013, when he reached philosophy in the
Islamic world. A major
goal of the podcasts is to disseminate Prof. Adamson's work on philosophy
in the late ancient and
Islamic traditions, by first building an audience through episodes on
classical philosophy, and then
covering late antiquity and the Islamic world in considerable detail. To
give just one example, Prof.
Adamson is the author of a monograph on al-Kindi, the first Muslim
philosopher, and the podcasts
will give him an opportunity to disseminate this research to a wide
audience. The same point goes
for Plotinus, Avicenna, Averroes and other philosophers dealt with in
Prof. Adamson's publications.
Some indication of the tight relationship between his research and the
podcasts is the `further
reading' recommended on the podcasts' website, which indicates primary and
secondary literature
for listeners to pursue further, and on which the episodes were based. As
of episode 120, the
further reading nearly always includes one or more of Adamson's
publications, the relevant
episodes being partly or wholly concise presentations of these
publications.
Prof. Adamson is Professor of Ancient and Medieval Philosophy at King's,
and Professor of Late
Antique and Arabic Philosophy at the LMU in Munich. He began at King's in
2000.
References to the research
The following list indicates the underpinning research relevant to
selected podcast episodes. In fact
this is a small sample, as Adamson's publications on Islamic philosophy
have provided the basis
for more than a dozen episodes on this topic. A fuller picture can be had
by looking at the `further
reading' after each episodes on the website.
3.1 P. Adamson, `Posterior Analytics II.19: a Dialogue with
Plato?' in Aristotle and the Stoics
Reading Plato, ed. V. Harte, MM McCabe, R.W. Sharples and A.
Sheppard, London: Institute of
Classical Studies, 2010, 1-19 [episodes 36 & 50].
3.2 P. Adamson `Plotinus on Astrology', Oxford Studies in Ancient
Philosophy 35 (2008), 265-91
[episode 85 on astronomy, astrology, and ancient philosophy].
3.3 P. Adamson, The Arabic Plotinus: a Philosophical Study of the
`Theology of Aristotle' (London:
2002) f05bepisode 122f05d.
3.4 P. Adamson and P.E. Pormann (trans.),The Philosophical Works of
al-Kindī (Karachi: Oxford
University Press, 2012) and P. Adamson, Al-Kindī (New York: OUP,
2007) [episode 123f05d.
3.5 P. Adamson, `Knowledge of Universals and Particulars in the Baghdad
School', Documenti e
Studi sulla Tradizione Filosofica Medievale 18 (2007), 141-64.
f05bepisodes 128 & 129f05d.
Examples of underpinning research by other King's staff who have appeared
as interview guests
include:
3.6 MM McCabe (as MM MacKenzie), `The Moving Posset Stands Still:
Heraclitus fr. 125',
American Journal of Philology 1987, 542-55 [she explains the
textual emendation proposed here
in episode 6].
3.7 R. Woolf, `Socratic Authority', Archiv für Geschichte der
Philosophie 90 (2008), 1-38 [episode
17].
Grant information: Half of the funding for the podcasts comes from King's
College London; the
other half comes from the Leverhulme Trust. The podcasts are intended also
specifically as a
platform for research into natural philosophy in the Islamic world, for
which Prof. Adamson received
a grant of £250K from the Leverhulme Trust. The grant period is Oct 1
2010-Sept 30 2013. Thus
the launch of the podcast was timed to coincide with the beginning of this
funded project.
Details of the impact
The podcast project has benefited thousands of users internationally,
inspiring them, enriching
their lives and informing and influencing their intellectual, cultural and
personal development. This
has been made possible by the way in which the project makes high-level
research physically and
intellectually accessible. The format of the podcast series makes it
possible to convey advanced
and detailed philosophical research findings to a broad audience.
Moreover, the podcasts are
easily and freely available, as they can be downloaded from an RSS feed
(via software such as
iTunes). This has ensured that the podcasts have reached a broad audience,
both in academic
and non-academic settings. The total number of downloads as of
July 31, 2013 was over 4
million for 139 episodes — an average of almost 30,000 downloads per
episode. Within 1-2
weeks, an episode will typically be downloaded about 7,000 times. The
podcast homepage has
been viewed just under 600,000 times. Total views for each episode are
available amongst the
sources in 5 below, but here is a sample of relevant statistics: the first
episode has been viewed on
the website about 38,000 times, an early interview with MM McCabe on
Heraclitus 10,000 times, a
more recent episode on al-Kindi about 3,000 times. This indicates how many
times people have
listened to episodes streaming directly off the website, as opposed to
downloading them.
In light of these statistics it is clear that the podcasts have thousands
of regular listeners. This
impression is confirmed by the facebook fan page of the podcasts, which
has over 4000 fans; and
the Twitter account (@HistPhilosophy) maintained by Prof. Adamson which
has about 2600
followers. Both the facebook page and Twitter account are used to
publicize new episodes, to
interact with listeners and answer questions, and to disseminate related
information such as
philosophy events in London and beyond.
Because podcasts can be accessed globally, listeners have written from
far-flung places like
Australia, Canada, Mexico, Norway and Russia. Two listeners got in touch
from Brazil and Korea
to ask about translating the podcasts into Portuguese and Korean. Many
listeners indicate that
they are not academics — for instance one listener said that they enjoyed
listening while driving
their UPS truck, another wrote to say that they are writing a blog about
their attempts to replicate
the educational experience of a BA using only freely available internet
resources, and that with the
help of this podcast they are `majoring in philosophy.'
The impact of the podcasts is also shown by hundreds of comments on
iTunes, the podcasts
website, facebook page, and direct emails to Prof. Adamson. These
illustrate the fact that the
podcasts produce great excitement and inspiration in regular listeners of
all ages and
backgrounds, and have been taken up in formal education from secondary to
university graduate
levels. Here is a small sample that provides an indication of the nature
and significance of the
impact:
`Hopefully it won't sound void if I say that the world is a better place
with you (and your podcast)
around. Now, I know what you're thinking: that I must be listening to them
from time to time! Well
no, actually I listen to an episode a day, and then again and again; and
every time there's a new
aspect, a new idea popping up from among the layers of your argumentative
discourse: Antiquity
revived.'
`Your work has rekindled my love of thinking.'
`I have just started listening to your series from the beginning, and I
find all the podcasts
magnificent! Listening to the program on Heraclitus while doing the dishes
really lights up that
menial task. The program on Xenophanes was brilliant.'
`My highest education is a Bachelor of Commerce in 1973 and while it did
not include any
philosophy courses, for some reason I have a general curiosity about the
subject. I'm now retired
and two years ago audited a one semester introductory course but for
various reasons have not
been able to take more — but will.'
`Thanks for the excellently accessible podcasts — combined with Librivox
audio versions of the
primary texts they open up a whole new world.'
`Thanks very much for your wonderful podcast. It's very accessible. I
began listening to it with little
interest of the subject, now I head straight to the philosophy section
when I walk into a bookstore.
I've bought the 'The Presocratic Philosophers' as recommended and the
'Complete Works of
Plato'.'
`I recently came across your philosophy podcast, and wanted to express my
thanks for doing such
a good job, on such a worthy task. Until very recently I was a stranger to
philosophy, but since
taking a course on Roman history at university I've began to open the door
to its vaulted treasures.
It feels like I'm still only peeking through a crack in the door — much of
the information in your
podcast is entirely new to me — yet the position I'm in is a deeply
exciting one.'
`I am thoroughly enjoying the podcasts. At age 72 I have `suddenly'
discovered Philosophy and am
quite taken by Aristotle and St Thomas Aquinas. The sessions on Aristotle
have been a big assist
to my organizing my reading of his works. Please continue. From: Fan in
California.'
`Just want to thank you for this. I think this is needed for this
society. This site was introduced to
me by my uncle who found you. I had been interested before, so I was
gladly ready to start the
podcast. I really like it. Now I am reading St. Thomas and I can't wait
before you get there, and on
other great philosophical figures.' [From a 12 year old listener.]
`After 3 months of exclusive listening to your podcast on my regular
commute, I have finally caught
up with your most recent podcast... As one who had never before studied
anything philosophical
(or historical, for that matter!), your podcast has opened a fascinating
world to me and I am ever so
grateful.'
`I would just like to add my voice to the chorus of thanks and
congratulations you are deservedly
receiving. As a teacher myself, I particularly admire your skill at
explaining complex concepts
succinctly and clearly without the need to 'talk down'. Your use of humour
and links to modern
examples is so well-judged and skilful, and leads to a rapid and complete
engagement with the
subject.'
`I've recently dived into the podcast, and I've enjoyed it immensely!
I've just begun graduate school
in Greek and Latin, but I don't have a strong philosophy background (my
undergraduate degree
was Computer Science). I have always enjoyed philosophy though, and the
podcast has been both
a delight and a way to make up for lost time! Keep up the excellent work!'
`I have been listening intently. I use it as I drive to and from work
where I take 000 calls. It means I
can still believe that reason still exists.'
`I graduated with a degree in philosophy in 2009 and, as I'm sure is true
of most philosophy
graduates, I now live a life where opportunities to discuss (let alone
`do') philosophy are rare.
These podcasts are just the thing I needed to keep the topics fresh in my
mind, and keep me
encouraged to continue my study, if only informally.'
`Loved it! I'm a mailman, not a scholar... Will be listening to the
entire library.'
`I'm 19 years old and have recently developed a passing interest in
philosophy. Before I go ahead
and start to learn on a more in-depth level about particular philosophers,
I'm trying to develop a
good core knowledge of the whole subject. That way, I can choose which
aspects appeal to me the
most and find some more specialised material on them. Your podcast series
is a brilliant starting
point for me, since you talk in a way that even somebody, like me, who is
not a student in the
subject can understand. You don't assume that the person listening to the
podcast is already
educated in philosophy like some of the other resources that I have found
do.'
`I thought you might like to know that alongside Nigel Warburton's
Philosophy Bites your podcasts
are also becoming part of my A-Level teaching and that my students are
making use of them to get
insights and opinions I have not offered. I merely provide a sheet of
timed questions and some
headphones and set them off. Happily several have then gone on to listen
to all those others not
immediately relevant.' [From a UK secondary school Philosophy teacher].
A fuller impression of comments and exchanges between Prof. Adamson and
listeners can be
found on: www.historyofphilosophy.net/comments;
or on the facebook page and Twitter accounts.
Sources to corroborate the impact
5.1 Page `snap shots' of statistics for the website, the RSS feed and
iKing's are available, showing
the total number of downloads up to July 31, 2013 standing at over 4
million, and giving an exact
breakdown for each episode. This illustrates the reach of the project's
impact.
5.2 The comments page already mentioned, and the facebook page, are
publicly available and can
be used to gauge audience participation and reaction, which are an
indication of the significance of
the project's impact : https://www.facebook.com/pages/The-History-Of-Philosophy-With-No-
Gaps/163670583644929?v=info
5.3 The feedback function in the iTunes store also displays ratings and
customer reviews by
country. This evidence supports claims about the significance and reach of
the project's impact:
https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/history-of-philosophy/id396903391
5.4 Sample discussions with listeners on Reddit are also available and
the Twitter feed is
@HistPhilosophy. These discussions themselves constitute further pathways
to impact, as well as
giving an indication of the project's significance for its users.
5.5 The well-respected Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy has added
links to podcast episodes
on several pages, see e.g. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pythagoras/
under `internet resources.'
This increases dissemination and, therefore, reach for the project's
impact.