High Impact Public Engagement in Cosmology
Submitting Institution
University of PortsmouthUnit of Assessment
PhysicsSummary Impact Type
SocietalResearch Subject Area(s)
Physical Sciences: Astronomical and Space Sciences, Atomic, Molecular, Nuclear, Particle and Plasma Physics
Summary of the impact
The Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation (ICG) runs a successful
programme of community engagements with local schools, science centres and
tourist attractions to influence public awareness and understanding of the
world-class research we perform. In 2012-13, ICG engaged with 4858 people,
including 2412 school children. Through our "Cosmology Masterclass", we
have inspired hundreds of A-level students from across the region; 60%
said we had increased their interest in university. In 2012-13, staff
engaged with 50 different schools across the UK. For the last 3 years, we
have interacted with thousands of people running BBC Stargazing Live
partner events, receiving almost unanimous praise from the public via our
feedback.
Underpinning research
Over the last decade, cosmology has experienced a golden age of discovery
leading to a detailed view of our Universe full of stars, gas, galaxies,
photons, dark matter and dark energy. Moreover, the Universe also provides
a diverse set of physical conditions ideal for testing fundamental laws of
physics, while also having a profound impact on the engagement of science
by the public, by addressing philosophical questions like the origin of
the Universe and the possibility of life beyond Earth.
Over the same period, the Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation (ICG)
has grown to become a centre of research excellence in astrophysics and
cosmology. Building on the success of RAE2008, where 75% of the ICG
research was judged to be "internationally excellent" or better (ranked in
the top six departments in the Applied Mathematics UoA), we have broadened
and strengthened our research base to include a deeper involvement in
large international cosmological experiments and study the details of how
galaxies have evolved over the lifetime of the Cosmos. This growing body
of underpinning research has been vital to inform our high impact public
engagement by ICG staff.
In addition to our high productivity in publishing high impact research
papers, ICG staff also hold prestigious leadership roles in several
international collaborations that are helping to shape the present
cosmological paradigm, e.g., David Bacon is joint lead of the LOFAR
Surveys Cosmology Working Group, Claudia Maraston is chair of the Sloan
Digital Sky Survey III (SDSS-III) BOSS Galaxy Evolution Working Group
(WG), Rita Torejio is co-chair of the SDSS-III BOSS Large Scale Structure
WG. Furthermore, Bob Nichol, Will Percival and Daniel Thomas are chairs of
the Dark Energy Survey (DES) Supernova, LSS and Galaxy Evolution WGs
respectively. Involvement in such key cosmological experiments ensures
that our public engagement activities are topical, showing a clear
connection between the physics of the Universe and how we test that
physics.
Our team has received several prestigious awards over recent years
demonstrating the quality of our staff and their ability to communicate
their passion for cosmology. For example, Tasinato presently holds a STFC
Advanced Fellow, while David Bacon was an RCUK fellow until 2012. Percival
and Koyama have both won ERC Starting Grants (2008-13) as well as the
Philip Leverhulme prize. Percival further won the RAS Fowler Award in
2008, while Nichol won a Marie Curie Award in the same year. David Wands
was awarded the Daiwa-Adrian Prize in 2010 for his international
collaborative cosmology work. Claudia Maraston held a Marie Curie
Excellence Team Grant for 2007-11. Karen Masters received the 2008 IAU
Gruber fellowship (2008-2010), the only UK winner of this prize in the
world, and a Leverhulme Early Career fellow (2010-2012).
ICG staff are at the forefront of recent cosmological research and have
used their knowledge to facilitate high impact public engagement through
coordinated events as described below.
References to the research
As outlined in Section B3 of REF document 01.2012 ("Panel criteria and
working methods"), we provide a body of cosmological research that
underpins our high impact public engagement programme. This research has
directly influenced the emergence of the standard cosmological model and
has thus directly relevant to our recent public engagement activities,
both locally and nationally. These results are also directly used in our
public engagement events.
*[1] Boughn & Crittenden, 2004, "A correlation between the
cosmic microwave background and large-scale structure in the Universe",
Nature, 427, 45. DOI: 10.1038/nature02139
(428 citations on Thomson Web of Knowledge) which established the
Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect as a key probe of dark energy
[2] Bamford, Nichol, et al. 2009 "Galaxy Zoo: the dependence
of morphology and colour on environment", MNRAS, 393, 1324. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.14252.x
(126 citations on Thomson Web of Knowledge)
[3] Eisenstein et al. (including Nichol as a major author), 2005,
"Detection of the Baryon Acoustic Peak in the Large-Scale Correlation
Function of SDSS Luminous Red Galaxies", The Astrophysical Journal,
633, 560. DOI: 10.1086/466512
which demonstrated the power of the Baryon Acoustic Oscillation scale for
cosmological constraints (1624 citations on Thomson Web of Knowledge)
*[4] Percival, Cole, Eisenstein, Nichol, et al., 2007, "Measuring
the Baryon Acoustic Oscillation scale using the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
and 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey" MNRAS 381, 1053. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.12268.x
(428 citations on Thomson Web of Knowledge)
[5] Kessler et al. (including Nichol as an author), 2009, "First-Year
Sloan Digital Sky Survey II Supernova Results: Hubble Diagram and
Cosmological Parameters", The Astrophysical Journal Supplements,
185, 32. DOI:10.1088/0067-0049/185/1/32
(279 citations on Thomson Web of Knowledge)
Underlined names are ICG researchers present at the University of
Portsmouth during the published research. We identify with asterisk the
three papers required to judge research quality.
Details of the impact
The ICG undertakes a broad range of outreach activities, which regularly
reaches thousands of people per year (4858 in 2012-13; 6424 in 2011-12).
In addition, the ICG has invested resources in a dedicated programme of
"high impact" sustainable events that optimize our public engagement that
draws upon our leading cosmological research above, thus ensuring our
impact is topical, well-informed and inspiring.
The first of these regular (at least annual) events is the ICG ``Cosmology
Masterclass" which began in 2010 through a collaboration with
Portsmouth Grammar School (PGS) [1]. These one-day events are designed to
supplement the A-level national curriculum (specifically the Cosmology
module of OCR Physics G485 and the IB Physics Astrophysics option),
providing students with an expert view of basic concepts such as the
expansion of the Universe (through the Hubble Diagram of supernovae based
on ICG-related research [see 5 above]) and different types of galaxies
[see 2 above]. Since 2010, we have expanded the reach of the event to
include 120 PGS students a year and, since 2012, many local state-run
schools: Portsmouth College, South Downs College (2012, 2013), Ryde
Academy, Farnborough, Bay House School, Brentside High School, Isle of
Wight College, St. John's College, Christ the King Sixth. The feedback
from teachers and students has been positive, e.g., 60% of non-PGS
students indicated our Masterclass may have increased their interest in a
wider range of university courses [1,2]. Furthermore, thirteen students
have subsequently joined us for summer Nuffield bursary placements or for
work experience, of which four cite their ICG research experience as
helping them decide on pursuing a STEM subject at university and aided in
their UCAS application [1,3]. The next Masterclass is December 2013.
In addition to the PGS, we continue to work with the University Education
Liaison and Outreach Team as outlined in our Impact Template (REF3a) to
engage school pupils of all ages during campus visits and have provided
many one-off school visits upon request, e.g. in 2012-13, ICG researchers
engaged with more than 50 different schools across the UK (28 in 2011-12).
Since 2011, when we begun collecting detailed demographical information,
ICG researchers have reached over 6000 school pupils [4].
Since 2006, the ICG has worked with Intech; our local science centre near
Winchester, which attracted 140,000 visitors in 2012. Over the last 3
years, we have contributed to the Intech "World Space Week" [5],
including developing hands-on demos about dark matter, components of the
Universe (using Lego) and talks about telescopes (all linked to our
research). These annual festivals have significant reach engaging
thousands of people, typically doubling the normal visitor rate at Intech.
A vast majority of our feedback is positive especially for the "After
Dark" events run by ICG researchers (Dominic Galliano, Tim Clemson) aimed
at adult audiences [5,6]. At our last "World Space Week" (Oct
2013), we reached 716 people, including 634 children.
Our final high impact event exploits the national media coverage
generated by BBC Stargazing LIVE. Starting in 2011, we ran a small
event at Gunwharf Quays (local shopping centre) to allow passing shoppers
the opportunity to look through a telescope (in many cases for the first
time). In 2012, we expanded the reach of the event to include 25 members
of the ICG (coordinated by Karen Masters) to help promote a significant StargazingLIVE
event at the Portsmouth Spinnaker Tower. This event was initiated by the
BBC and became their flagship event for BBC South. In collaboration with
PGS teachers and students and Hampshire Astronomical Society, we provided
many activities and demonstrations on all floors of the Spinnaker Tower
including astronomicallythemed crafts, "Science on Tap", "Genius Bar"; all
of which drew on our cosmological knowledge. Overall, 450 ticketed guests
attend the whole event, with over a hundred passers-by engaging with ICG
researchers at the base of the tower. In 2013, we repeated the event, but
this time using the HMS Warrior 1860 and the Mary Rose Museum as our venue
(also in collaboration with University of Portsmouth Physics Society, HMS
Warrior 1860 and Mary Rose Trust education teams and the British Science
Association). Again, we had over 450 ticketed guests (limited only by
venue size) who experienced a wide range of activities, many of which were
directly related to ICG research (e.g. hands-on demonstration of
gravitational lensing). The impact was significant and unanimously
positive [7] and we are already planning a major StargazingLIVE
event for Jan 2014.
All our events were covered in the local media thus increasing the reach
of the ICG engagement and all venues wish to continue their relationship
with the ICG.
Sources to corroborate the impact
[1] Private communication from Acting Head of Physics, Portsmouth Grammar
School.
[2] Statistical analysis of our feedback forms from the 2012 Cosmology
Masterclass show the overwhelming positive impact of such events, e.g., an
average score of 4.1 out of 5 for interest in our astrodome sessions,
while 75% of teachers believed the lectures increased their students
engagement in the subject. Examples of student comments from our
masterclasses include: "awe inspiring", "enhanced my knowledge of
higher level physics", "sparked an interest in physics related
courses", "More interested in uni now".
[3] Two PGS students on Nuffield bursaries are now studying Mathematics
at Cambridge and directly credit the importance of their ICG experience,
i.e., "clarified my ideas about career choices" and "really
assured me that theoretical physics and applied mathematics is the right
path". One student won the 2010 Exscitec Platinum Award for his ICG
project.
[4] Since 2011, the demographics of our school visits are 436 (KS1), 1636
(KS2), 1376 (KS3), 1122 (KS4) and 1447 (KS5). We have also engaged 662
teachers during this time.
[5] Private communication from Planetarium Manager, Intech Science
Centre, Winchester.
[6] Visitor numbers for Intech for World Space Week are 1727 (2011) and
1256 (2012), of which approximately half are teachers and students (KS2, 3
& 4). The "After Dark" event attracted 160 and 132 members of the
public in 2011 and 2012 respectively. Based on feedback forms, 64% of
visitors to the ICG stand said they had learnt at least one new fact.
Examples of testimonials include: "Thanks for a memorable day", "The
pupils were very impressed and came back on Monday morning chatting all
about the day they had".
[7] Of the 67 attendees that completed our 2013 StargazingLive
questionnaire, 100% said they enjoyed the event. Examples of feedback
include: "didn't realise it could be so interesting", "she came home
buzzing with excitement and ready to go into school today to tell her
teachers & friends all the new facts she'd learnt.".