Increasing the profile and availability of effective psychological therapy for bipolar disorder
Submitting Institution
Lancaster UniversityUnit of Assessment
Allied Health Professions, Dentistry, Nursing and PharmacySummary Impact Type
SocietalResearch Subject Area(s)
Medical and Health Sciences: Public Health and Health Services
Summary of the impact
Lancaster research has changed the understanding and treatment of bipolar
disorder (BD) from biological models and pharmacological treatments to
integrated psychosocial interventions complementary to routine medication
and matched to user needs. We have developed novel psychological
interventions (individual, family and group approaches), and reliable and
valid ways to assess valued outcomes and underlying mechanisms of change.
This research has delivered 3 major impacts. It has: fundamentally changed
understanding of the condition in professional and lay audiences; changed
treatment in terms of policy and practice, including NICE clinical
guidelines; changed professional training delivered both nationally and
internationally.
Underpinning research
Building on our previous work in this area, the specific research that
underpins our impact has all been published in high quality international
peer reviewed journals since the formation of the Spectrum Centre at
Lancaster University in 2008. The work is led by Steve Jones (Professor of
Clinical Psychology from Feb 2008), and Fiona Lobban (Senior Lecturer in
Clinical Psychology from Feb 2008), with contributions from all the
Spectrum team which includes people with lived experience of bipolar
disorder.
This research includes the development and evaluation of a range of
psychological interventions for people with bipolar experiences. This has
required the creation of new measures of underlying psychological
processes and relevant outcomes, including a measure of awareness of Early
Warning Signs of depression and mania, which can be used to improve
relapse prevention (3.1), and a questionnaire to assess personal
experiences of recovery, which service users have identified as a highly
valued outcome from clinical care (3.2). Our work on psychological
interventions includes the development and evaluation of:
1. Individual and family interventions — We have developed and
evaluated various interventions combining psychoeducation and cognitive
behavioural therapy (CBT) that have been trialled in real world NHS
settings to ensure ecological validity. Interventions have been
specifically designed to reduce risk of relapse with trained front line
Care Coordinators (3.3), to improve personal recovery outcomes with
specialist psychologist therapists (3.4, 3.7), and to reduce relatives'
distress by deploying supported self-management toolkits (3.5, 3.8). In
recognition of the continuing problems of access to face to face therapy,
we have also developed online packages to offer these approaches more
widely (3.9, 3.10). Outcome data, which already indicates significant
improvements in a range of outcome measures when compared to current
treatment, has been provided to NICE to inform the revision of the NICE
Guidelines for Bipolar Disorder (3.3, 3.4, 3.12) and Psychosis (3.5, 3.8).
2. Group interventions — we have demonstrated the feasibility and
effective implementation of adapted psychoeducation and peer support group
interventions for UK NHS service users and are currently collecting
follow-up outcome data over 2 years on the largest international trial of
face to face psychological interventions for people with BD (3.6). In
advance of follow-up data Nottingham and Leicester NHS Trusts have already
announced plans to adopt the group psychoeducation approach in response to
service user demand. This trial is part of the PARADES programme which is
the first NIHR programme grant dedicated to psychological understanding of
bipolar disorder (3.11). Both interventions are 21 weekly sessions of
groups co-facilitated by health professionals and service users.
Psychoeducation follows a structured manual and aims to provide
participants with comprehensive information about Bipolar Disorder and an
in depth understanding of how this relates to their individual
experiences. Peer support is unstructured and allows the participants to
determine the agenda and focus of the group, highlighting value of shared
experience.
References to the research
The highly rigorous, original and significant nature of our applied
clinical research is reflected in our success in obtaining large-scale
competitive grants totalling over £4.8 million since 2008, including
programme funding from the National Institute for Health Research. All
references are published in high quality international peer reviewed
journals and significantly contribute to the research basis for
psychological models and treatments of Bipolar Disorder.
References:
3.1 Lobban, F., Solis-Trapala, I., Symes, W., Morriss, R & ERP Group
(2011). Early Warning Signs Checklists for Bipolar Depression and Mania:
utility, reliability and validity. Journal of Affective Disorders 133,
413-422. (DOI:10.1016/j.jad.2011.04.026 submitted in REF2)
3.2 Jones, S., Mulligan, L., Higginson S., Dunn, G. & Morrison, A. P
(2012). The Bipolar Recovery Questionnaire: Psychometric Properties of a
Quantitative Measure of Recovery Experiences in Bipolar Disorder. Journal
of Affective Disorders 147, 34-43. (DOI: 10.1016/j.jad.2012.10.003
submitted in REF2)
3.3 Lobban, F., Taylor, L., Chandler, C., Tyler, E., Kinderman, P.,
Kolamunnage-Dona, R., Gamble, C., & Pontin, E., Peters, S., &
Sellwood, W., Morriss, R.M (2010). Enhanced relapse prevention for bipolar
disorder by community mental health teams: cluster feasibility randomized
trial. British Journal of Psychiatry, 196, 59-63. (DOI: 10.1192/bjp.bp.109
submitted in REF2)
3.4 Jones, S., Mulligan, L., Law, H., Dunn, G., Welford, M., Smith, G.
& Morrison, A. (2012). A randomised controlled trial of recovery
focussed CBT for individuals with early bipolar disorder. BMC Psychiatry
12, 204. (DOI: 10.1186/1471-244X-12-204)
3.5 Lobban, F., Glentworth, D., Chapman, L., Wainwright, L.,
Postlethwaite, A., Dunn, G., Pinfold, V., Larkin, W., Haddock, G., (2013).
Feasibility of a supported self-management intervention for relatives of
people with recent onset psychosis: REACT study. British Journal of
Psychiatry , 203, 366-372. (DOI: 10.1192/bjp.bp.112.113613 submitted in
REF2)
3.6 Morriss, R.K., Lobban, F., Jones, S., Riste, L., Peters, S., Roberts,
C., Davies, L., Mayes, D. (2011) Pragmatic randomised controlled trial of
group psychoeducation versus group support in the maintenance of bipolar
disorder. BMC Psychiatry 11, 114. (DOI: 10.1186/1471-244X-11-114)
Major grants supporting the research:
3.7 Morrison, A, Jones, S. et al. (2007-2013). Psychological approaches
to understanding and promoting recovery from psychosis (RECOVERY).
(Bipolar stream 2008-2013). National Institute for Health Research
Programme Grant. (£1,950 000). (RP-PG-0606-1086).
3.8 Lobban, F., Glentworth, D., Pinfold, V., Minns, V., Dunn, G., Larkin,
W., Haddock, G. (2009- 2012). An evaluation of the feasibility and
effectiveness of a supported self management package for relatives of
people with recent onset psychosis. NIHR research for patient benefit.
(£249,696) (PB-PG-0807-14075).
3.9 Jones, S., Lobban, F., Mayes, D., Calam, R, Parker, R & Sanders,
M. (2012-2014) Web-based Integrated Bipolar Parenting Intervention for
Bipolar Parents of Young Children Medical Research Council (£380,000)
(MR/J011886/1).
3.10 Lobban, F., Jones, S., Dodd, A., Diggle, P., Morriss, R., Mallinson,
S., Stevenson-Turner, K., (2012 -2015). Pilot Study to Assess the
Feasibility of a Web-based Intervention for Prevention of Relapse in
Bipolar Disorder NIHR Research for Patient Benefit (£250, 000)
(PB-PG-0211-10001)
3.11 Jones, S (CI), Morriss, R., Lobban, F., et al. (2008-2013) Reducing
relapse and suicide in bipolar disorder: Practical clinical approaches to
identifying risk, reducing harm and engaging service users in planning and
delivery of care (PARADES). National Institute for Health Research
Programme Grant. (£1,997,000) (RP-PG-0407-10389).
3.12 Lobban, F. & Jones, S. (2009- 2012). Web-based self-management
intervention for people with bipolar spectrum disorders. (£60,000) Mersey
Care NHS Trust R&D)
Details of the impact
We provide evidence that the research as cited in s2 and s3 has delivered
3 major impacts. It has: fundamentally changed understanding of Bipolar
Disorder in professional and lay audiences; changed treatment in terms of
policy and practice, including NICE clinical guidelines; and changed
professional training delivered both nationally and internationally.
Impact 1 — Changing Understanding
Our research-based model of a psychological approach to bipolar disorder
is summarised in a key document commissioned by the British Psychological
Society called "Understanding Bipolar Disorder: Why some people experience
extreme mood states and what can help" (5.1). This document was written
for a general audience, has been widely accessed (downloaded 4793 times;
as of 30/7/2013), has been very positively reviewed by the national
service user Bipolar organisation (5.2), and been celebrity endorsed
(described on twitter as "fascinating" by Stephen Fry 06/09/2011).
We have further influenced the psychological understanding of Bipolar
Disorder in the general public in the following ways:
i. Maintaining a confidential database of people with bipolar experiences
interested in our research (Spectrum Connect, 516 members) with regular
research updates, and including a full day conference for Spectrum Connect
members (50 participants 19/09/2012).
ii. A series of debate-changing media events which have reached large
audiences, including Radio 4, the Guardian and Radio Lancashire (5.3).
iii. Disseminating our clinical research findings through our website www.spectrumcentre.org (28,506
page views in 12 months to 31/07/13) social media including twitter
(@SpectrumCentre — 835 followers), and Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/thespectrumcentre - 211 members).
Impact 2 — Changing Treatment (policy and practice)
We have developed and evaluated a range of psychological interventions,
aiming to ensure people have choice depending on needs and preferences. We
have conducted 6 trials of psychological therapies for people with BD
since 2008, including individual face to face treatment, online self-management
packages, and group therapy programmes. Some 700 people have
been recruited, of whom over 500 have received a psychological treatment
as a direct result of the trials (as of 25/07/2013) via the Recovery
Programme and PARADES Programme (3.3-3.6, 5.4, 5.5). The popularity of the
group psychoeducation approach (3.6) in our PARADES programme among
service users and clinicians has led to Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS
Trust including this in their plan for mainstream clinical care (5.6). All
our work is carried out with extensive user involvement to ensure it is
acceptable, user friendly and targets their valued outcomes. Our PARADES
programme was shortlisted for (and came second) in the MHRN national
service user involvement awards (2010) and both our PARADES
psychoeducation trials and our Recovery trial are referred to by MHRN as
good practice case studies (2011; 5.7).
Jones currently sits on the expert panel writing the revised NICE
guideline (5.8; publication due 2014) and Lobban represents the British
Association of Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy (BABCP) providing
expert input to the NICE guideline process (5.9). Research we have
completed at Spectrum, specifically around relapse prevention (3.3),
recovery focused CBT (3.4) and web-based support (3.12) is being reviewed
and will determine clinical recommendations. Our work in reducing carer's
distress has been included in the recent draft NICE Guideline for
Psychosis (http://bit.ly/1gtOjLG).
Impact 3 — Changing Professional Training
Even when treatments are recommended by NICE, there is a national problem
of access. People with mental health problems on average wait up to 2
years for talking therapies. The IAPT programme aims to improve access and
now includes bipolar disorder in recognition of the even greater delay for
this population. As a direct result of our research, individual CBT (3.4),
relapse prevention (3.3) and group psychoeducation (3.6), are now all
recommended for people with Bipolar Disorder and are part of core
competencies for NHS staff delivering psychological therapies to those
with bipolar disorder (5.10, 5.11). Spectrum was selected by the IAPT
programme to work in collaboration with Birmingham and Solihull Trust as
the only UK demonstration site for development of IAPT services for
Bipolar Disorder (Nov 2012 - Nov 2014). This good practice demonstration
site specifically cites the research of our team (5.12).
Based on our research (3.3-3.6) and in addition to the IAPT programme we
have been invited to give a series of national and international training
events training approximately 1040 clinicians across 16 clinical workshops
in the US, Norway and UK to deliver psychological interventions (5.13).
Directly within the research trials we have trained 87 clinical staff in
the delivery of individual face to face therapies. The PARADES Group trial
has trained 10 health professional group facilitators and 9 service user
facilitators for Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust. Thus we have
impacted on the clinical practice of a significant number of
practitioners.
Sources to corroborate the impact
5.1 (www.bps.org.uk/news/download-free-report-bipolar-disorder).
Download figures available from BPS shop (www.bpsshop.org.uk)
5.2 Pendulum. Bipolar UK publication. Winter 2010 pg 4. Copy available
from www.lancaster.ac.uk/fhm/research/spectrum/resources
5.3 Media events all available from www.lancaster.ac.uk/fhm/research/spectrum/resources:
i) Podcast of Radio 4 Woman's Hour debate about psychology of parenting
issues in Bipolar Disorder (Jones and Long 28/01/2013)
(> 2.5 million listeners http://www.rajar.co.uk/listening/quarterly_listening.php)
ii) The Guardian newspaper (education section) "Double sided perspective:
users of mental health services are increasingly being recruited as
academic researchers" (Mayes 26.08.2009) (> 1 million readers; http://www.mediauk.com/newspapers/13698/the-guardian/readership-figures)
iii) Podcast of BBC Radio Lancashire (drive time programme hosted by
Graham Liver) Early interventions for Bipolar Disorder (Jones 18/12/2012)
(193,000 listeners http://www.rajar.co.uk/listening/quarterly_listening.php)
5.4 PARADES Bipolar Research Programme Manager, Manchester Mental Health
and Social Care Trust
5.5 Research Co-ordinator, Greater Manchester West Mental Health NHS
Foundation Trust
5.6 Consultant, Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust
5.7 http://www.mhrn.info/pages/involving-service-users-in-mhrn-supported-research-case-studies-.html
5.8 http://guidance.nice.org.uk/cg/waveR/114
lists Jones as member Guideline Committee group
5.9 Former President of BABCP
5.10 www.ucl.ac.uk/clinical-
psychology//CORE/competence_mentalillness_psychosisandbipolar.html.
5.11 Delivery & Finance Lead, National IAPT Operations, Department of
Health
5.12 IAPT SMI project and Demonstration Site (http://www.iapt.nhs.uk/smi-/)
5.13 website www.spectrumcentre.org