Promoting the popular understanding of the importance of the Grand Tour and its role in advocating civil society since the Renaissance.
Submitting Institution
Southampton Solent UniversityUnit of Assessment
Art and Design: History, Practice and TheorySummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Philosophy and Religious Studies: History and Philosophy of Specific Fields
Summary of the impact
Professor Chaney's research has had a major impact on the awareness of
the Grand Tour as one of the most significant cultural phenomena since the
Renaissance, today's cultural tourism being its most obvious legacy. This
has been achieved by international publications, the organization of
conferences, exhibitions, numerous well attended public lectures
throughout Britain, continental Europe, Egypt, America and Australia, and
contributions to television and radio programmes, including BBC 4 and
Radio 4. His promotion of Italian culture has been recognized by the
Italian government with the title of Commendatore. His research continues
to reach global audiences through Adam Matthew Digital's publication on The
Grand Tour, 2009.
Underpinning research
After graduating with a first in art history, Prof Chaney chose the
Warburg in preference to the Courtauld Institute in order to broaden his
cultural range and be taught by Ernst Gombrich. Having produced a
mid-17th-century travelogue for his MPhil dissertation, he concluded that
while the 18th-century Grand Tour was relatively well-covered, the origins
of (and deeper justifications for) this extraordinary cultural phenomenon
were insufficiently studied. After the Reformation those in newly
Protestant countries who had once gone on pilgrimages to Rome were obliged
to evolve new, non-Catholic justifications to travel abroad, among which
secularized criteria, art, antiquity and architecture eventually
predominated leading directly to today's tourism. En route to this
becoming the case, the acquisition of languages, good manners, diplomatic
skills, `riding the great horse', the study of fortifications, hospitals
and the like predominated. Chaney documented the continuing and crucial
role of British Catholics and, during and after the Civil War, of Royalist
exiles, via a large quantity of published and unpublished travel accounts
and diaries as well as portraits, passports, and government
correspondence.
After completing his PhD in Italy and teaching at Pisa University, Chaney
returned to Britain as Shuffrey Research Fellow in Architectural History
at Lincoln College, Oxford. His research meanwhile underpinned the more
popular Traveller's Companion to Florence (2nd revised ed. 2002).
He then worked as an Historian for the London Region of English Heritage
(on listed buildings and promoting Blue Plaques) and taught art history at
Oxford Brookes University (where he played a major role in their very
successful RAE submission). In 1997 he came to the then Southampton
Institute to developed a new unit on the Fine Arts Valuation degree
entitled `Travel, Taste and Collecting' and launch the History of
Collecting Research Centre. Chaney's Yale U.P. book on The Evolution
of English Collecting was based on lectures given on this course and
the international conference he organized through this centre. His
124-page introduction was written with this and related courses in mind. A
set book in Southampton and elsewhere this has emerged as one of the most
popular in the Mellon series of Studies in British Art. Chaney's selection
of younger scholars for conference and book proved beneficial both to the
subject and their careers throughout Britain and beyond. His Stuart
Portraits catalogue has also proved influential. Meanwhile, Prof
Chaney became increasingly interested in receptions of ancient Egypt, the
visual legacy of which European travellers first encountered in Rome
before crossing the Mediterranean to Egypt itself. Having published two
major articles on this subject (as well as more accessible versions in the
London Magazine, in 2010) he was awarded a Leverhulme Major Research
Fellowship to work on this subject. Whilst working predominantly on the
Idea of ancient Egypt in Early Modern Britain (through the Grand Tour),
Chaney also followed the effect of this phenomenon through to more recent
times as evidenced in artists such R.B. Kitaj. He researched the role of
Warburgian ideas and the conscious and unconscious legacy of ancient Egypt
behind Kitaj's injunction to `invent a Jewish style, like the Egyptian
figure style' in his contribution to Obsessions: R.B. Kitaj 1932-2007
(Berlin, 2012), pp. 97-103.
References to the research
Professor Chaney research output over the period 1January 1993 to 31
December 2013 comprises some 65 published outputs including books, book
chapters, journal articles, catalogue essays, and reviews, the majority of
which focus upon the impact of antiquity, via the Renaissance, on British
culture. From the longer list the following six items have been selected:
• The Evolution of the Grand Tour: Anglo-Italian Cultural Relations
since the Renaissance, Frank Cass & Co (London and Portland,
Oregon 1998), 416 pp and 60 illustrations. Revised and expanded paperback
edition with additional critical bibliography, Cass and Co., November,
2000. Now in print with Routledge. Set book for art history degrees at
Cambridge and elsewhere. (http://www.amazon.com/Evolution-Grand-Tour-Anglo-Italian-Renaissance/dp/0714644749).
Supplemented
by A Traveller's Companion to Florence and the 4th
edition of John Hale's England and the Italian Renaissance (both
popular paperbacks, Constable Robinson and Blackwells, ed. E. Chaney).
• The Stuart Portrait: Status and Legacy (with Godfrey Worsdale),
Southampton City Art Gallery and Paul Holberton Publishing, 2001. Loans
from Tate, NPG, Ferens (Hull), Ashmolean Museum, Oxford; National Gallery,
London; National Maritime Museum, London; Gainsborough's House, Sudbury,
and the Royal Academy, London. (http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Stuart-Portrait-Status-
Legacy/dp/B001OQZF4K)
• The Evolution of English Collecting: Receptions of Italian Art in
the Tudor and Stuart Periods (Mellon Studies in British Art: Yale
University Press, 2003). (Sole editor and author of 125 page
introduction). Based on international conference on collecting at History
of Collecting Centre, Southampton Institute. (http://yalepress.yale.edu/book.asp?isbn=9780300102246)
• `Ein echter Warburgianer: Kitaj, Edgar Wind, Ernst Gombrich und das
Warburg Institute,' essay in the catalogue of the Kitaj retrospective at
the Jewish Museum, Berlin (September 2012-January 2013); then at Pallant
House, Chichester, the Jewish Museum in London and the Hamburg
Kunsthalle). English edition of the catalogue published simulataneously as
Obsessions: R.B. Kitaj (1932-2007): my essay: `Warburgian Artist:
Kitaj, Edgar Wind, Ernst Gombrich and the Warburg Institute' (Berlin,
2012), pp. 97-103. Digital version with e-maj (the Melbourne Art
Journal).
• The Jacobean Grand Tour: Early Stuart Travellers in Europe
(I.B. Tauris: London, 2013). The product of long-term scholarly
collaboration by Profs Chaney and Professor Wilks. 300 pages; 112 black
and white illustrations and 12 in colour.
Grant information: Leverhulme Trust Funded Major Research
Fellowship (c.£90,000). 2010-12. Polytheism and its Discontents.
Details of the impact
In 1998 Chaney published The Evolution of the Grand Tour to great
acclaim; see selection of reviews on the back of the revised, paperback
edition. It was chosen as `Book of the Year' by Jan Morris in the
Independent and was the lead feature by John Mortimer in the Sunday
Times. Melvyn Bragg asked Chaney to talk about the book on Start
the Week (Radio 4). After the publication of the revised and
enlarged paperback edition of this book by Frank Cass in 2000 (now in
print with Routledge) Bragg asked Chaney back to discuss it on In Our
Time in a special programme devoted to the Grand Tour (2002)
(audience figures in both cases in the millions:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00548fs). As well as articles in Apollo,
the Burlington and London Magazines, he contributed entries
in the Dictionary of Art and the Oxford Dictionary of National
Biography (which he reviewed in the British Art Journal) and
to exhibition catalogues such as the Tate's Grand Tour. This book
and his popular anthology on Florence underpinned the annual
student trips to Florence. In 2006 Chaney was awarded a visiting
scholarship at the British School at Rome by the Mellon Centre for Studies
in British Art. In all such venues he was able to promote his subject via
seminars, lectures and liaising with colleagues, students and members of
the public.
Meanwhile he co-curated and edited the catalogue for The Stuart
Portrait: Status and Legacy, a major loan exhibition at the
Southampton City Art Gallery in 2001. Since then he has co-curated and
co-written Richard Eurich: 1903-1992: Visionary Artist (an
exhibition which travelled to Southampton, Bournemouth and London in 2003)
and contributed to Obsessions: R.B. Kitaj 1932-2007 (2012) His
Kitaj essay has been singled out for praise. He gave a related paper at
the Wyndham Lewis conference hosted by the University of London School of
Advanced Studies on Lewis and Kitaj in December 2012. His catalogue essay
on Kitaj as Warburgian artist is being in revised and in more substantial
form in both English and French and has appeared in the E version of Melbourne
Art Journal (emaj); http://emajartjournal.com/2013/11/30/edward-chaney-r-b-kitaj-1932-2007-warburgian-artist/
Via the Grand Tour literature of visitors to Rome Chaney gradually became
more interested in what was said about ancient Egyptian artefacts and
early-modern speculation about Egyptian history and religion. He gave a
paper on the reception of ancient 'Egypt in England and America' in Naples
in 2004 which was published in Sites of Exchange: European Crossroads
and Faultlines (Amsterdam and New York, 2006), after which he
published a more accessible, popular version in The London Magazine.
He also gave a paper on the Collector Earl of Arundel and the Obelisk of
Domitian which was eventually published in Roma Britannica in
2011. On the basis of this research he applied to the Leverhulme Trust for
a Major Research Fellowship, awarded in 2010. He gave a paper on
`Shakespeare and Egypt' to a large number of Egyptian students and members
of the public at the Alexandrian Library, Egypt, in early 2011 (just as
the `Arab Spring' was getting underway), and related papers in Oxford,
Cambridge, Chichester, London, Florence and Rome, where he gave the
opening, plenary lecture on `Torino Britannica and the Cultural Memory of
Egypt' at the Mellon-sponsored Torino Britannica conference held at the
British School and the Veneria Reale, Turin (20 June 2013) the proceedings
of which are to be published by Cambridge University Press. Meanwhile, the
Kitaj exhibition opened at the Jewish Museum Berlin in July 2012 and has
since, thanks to his entrepreneurship, re-located to Pallant House,
Chichester, and the Jewish Museum London, whence it travelled in July 2013
to Hamburg's Kunsthalle. This has been widely reviewed, discussed
on Radio 4 and the catalogue has appeared in German and English. Chaney's
catalogue essay was singled out for praise by Tim Hyman in his Burlington
Magazine review. In connection with this Chaney gave a paper on
Lewis and Kitaj in London in December 2012. His expertise in the history
of collecting and interest in the welfare of the Southampton City Art
Gallery and its collections, enabled him to lead a successful campaign
against the proposed sale of works of art to fund the Titanic museum. This
involved him appearing on BBC TV South and in radio debates with the
leader of the council, he further supported the campaign objectives by
publishing articles in local and national newspapers in the summer of
2009. Where the history of collecting is concerned he advised on James
Stourton and Charles Sebag Montefiore's The British as Art Collectors
(Scala, 2012) as a result of which he was asked to act as consultant to
BBC 4's 2013 Great British Art Collectors , narrated by Lady Helen
Rosslyn.
Impact of `Roma Britannica and the Cultural Memory of Egypt: Lord Arundel
and the Obelisk of Domitian' (published by the British School at Rome in
their conference proceedings: Roma Britannica (2011). Prof
Chaney's article on the Collector Earl of Arundel's attempt to acquire the
Obelisk of Domitian was initially given as a lecture at the British
School's `Roma Britannica' conference, and subsequently Southampton,
Arundel Castle (under the auspices of the Mellon Centre for Studies in
British Art), the British Institute in Florence and at the University of
Cambridge. The idea was first mooted in Chaney, The Evolution of
English Collecting (New Haven and London, 2003), p. 105. Material
from it was included in `A Grand Tour and its Cultural Memorials', The
Grand Tour, Gayle Chong Kwan, eds. Alexandra Boyd and Peter Bonnell
(Artsway, Sway, 2009), pp. 1-3; book review of Obelisk: A History,
Brian Curran, Anthony Grafton, Pamela O. Long and Benjamin Weiss (MIT
Press, Cambridge, Mass., 2009), in the popular History Today
magazine (January, 2010), pp. 56-57; the entry on `The Grand Tour', Encyclopedia
of Consumer Culture, ed. Dale Southerton, 3 vols, Sage Publications,
2011, pp. 688-92; postscript to David Carrigan's illustrated poem: Panormus
(Palermo, 2012); conference paper: `Inigo Jones and Egypt', given at
conference on `Inigo Jones, the Queen's House and languages of Stuart
culture', 15-16 February 2012 The Queen's House, Greenwich, London. Also
for lecture: `The Evolution of the Grand Tour and the Discovery of Art,'
at the University of Oxford's Department for Continuing Education (Rewley
House) day school (audience 127) on The European Grand Tour, 2-3
March 2013, Torino Britannica conference and the Annual Conference of the
Sussex Archaeological Society, Lewes, 2 November 2013 (audience 210).
Global impact has resulted from two major essays and co-editorship of
Adam Matthew Digital (a Sage Company) The Grand Tour (based on
research carried out over a thirty year period). http://www.amdigital.co.uk/m-collections/collection/the-grand-tour/detailed-information/
This major digital resource includes searchable scans of hundreds of books
and manuscripts selected from the Chaney library, currently housed in two
locations in Southampton Solent University and available to research
students and for undergraduate dissertations, and my research in the form
of two substantial essays, `A Bibliographical Survey of the Literature of
the Grand Tour since 1900' and `Travel as Education and the Origins of the
Grand Tour' (subsequently uploaded); Adam Matthew Digital. 2009-2013.
Available since 2009 but recently enhanced as a digitized data-base of
primary and secondary sources on the cultural history of the European
Grand Tour to include diaries and journals, account books, published
guidebooks and travelogues of the period, paintings and sketches,
architectural drawings and maps, selected by the editors Jeremy Black,
Edward Chaney and Rosemary Sweet.
Sources to corroborate the impact
During the relevant period Prof Chaney has been awarded the title of Commendatore
by the Italian Republic for services to Anglo-Italian relations. He has
been selected for inclusion in Who's Who, been made an honorary
member of the Society of Fine Art Auctioneers, received a scholarship from
the Mellon Centre for Studies in British Art, been elected a Fellow of the
Royal Society of Arts, Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries, Fellow of the
Royal Historical Society, made an Honorary Life Member the British
Institute in Florence and the Guernsey Society.
Sources corroborating the specific impact of outputs mentioned in section
4 above include, for Roma Britannica: The Court Historian
(2012) in which Dr Clare Hornsby, author of Digging and Dealing,
referenced `Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, whose deep love of the ancient
world extended beyond Rome to Egypt, as examined by Edward Chaney in his
brilliant essay on Lord Arundel and the Obelisk of Domitian. A valid point
is made that there was a link between classical antiquity and the
not-so-distant English Catholic past; the "sense of loss, of mourning";
that is part of the motivation of Arundel in his fervent collecting and
the pursuit of the antique as part of our shared "cultural memory".' Dr
John Bold singled it out for praise in Times Higher Education.
The exhibition Obsessions: R.B. Kitaj, 1932-2007, which has only
been shown in Britain thanks to Prof Chaney's promotion of it when he
discovered that the Tel Aviv slot had fallen through, has been widely
reviewed and praised (after Chichester and London it moves to Hamburg's
Kunsthalle). His catalogue essay has been singled out for praise in
lectures (eg Warburg Institute `Picture Act' conference, 25 January) and
Tim Hyman wrote an enthusiastic review in the Burlington Magazine in May
2013. Revised and enlarged edition widely circulated in E version of Melbourne
Art Journal (emaj); see http://emajartjournal.com/2013/11/30/edward-
chaney-r-b-kitaj-1932-2007-warburgian-artist/
Adam Matthew Digital Grand Tour: Library subscriptions throughout
the world Reviews in History , December 2009, Library Journal,
June 2009 and Choice November 2009. Related lectures: 26 November
2009 at `Art and Travel' conference at the Mellon Centre for Studies in
British Art, organized by National Maritime Museum. `The Evolution of the
Grand Tour and the Discovery of Art,' forthcoming at the University of
Oxford conference on The European Grand Tour, 2-3 March 2013 and the
Annual Conference of the Sussex Archaeological Society, Lewes, 2 November
2013. Adam Matthew Digital may be contacted re number of sales
The Jacobean Grand Tour: Early Stuart Travellers in Europe
(I.B. Tauris: London, 2014). Although Tauris wanted this dated 2014 they
have confirmed it was in the public domain in 2013. Reviews are
anticipated in Times Higher Education, Country Life, Apollo,
Spectator, BBC History Magazine and IHR Reviews in History.