Madness and Modernity: Mental Illness, Psychiatry and the Visual Arts in Vienna 1900
Submitting Institution
Plymouth UniversityUnit of Assessment
Art and Design: History, Practice and TheorySummary Impact Type
SocietalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
From 2004 to the present, Gemma Blackshaw (Reader in Art History at
Plymouth, 2002-present)
has worked on the relationship between mental illness, psychiatry, and the
visual arts in Vienna
1900. Through exhibition, a non-specialist book, film, and associated
social media platforms, this
work has reached and responded to audiences outside academia, including
mental health
communities. It has generated new knowledge, interpretations and
approaches to the history and
study of mental illness. It has encouraged international public discourse
on how society used to
engage with the mentally ill, and how we continue to engage with this
community 100 years on.
Underpinning research
Blackshaw's work began with her role as co-investigator on an AHRC-funded
4-year major
research project 'Madness and Modernity: Art, Architecture and Mental
Illness in Vienna and the
Habsburg Empire, 1890-1914', working with Leslie Topp (Birkbeck) and
Sabine Wieber (now
University of Glasgow) as research associate. The project was rated A* by
the AHRC, the
anonymous expert reviewer remarking: `We have here an enterprise with the
potential for serving
as a model for future interdisciplinary research.' The project was funded
from 2004-08 and resulted
in outputs that stretch across the RAE and REF periods of assessment,
including multiple articles
in peer-reviewed journals (eg. Blackshaw, 2007), a conference funded by
the British Academy and
the Wellcome Trust (2007), a co-edited collections of essays (Blackshaw
and Wieber, 2012), and
two exhibitions (2009-10). Since the exhibitions, Blackshaw has worked
independently on issues
related specifically to the visual arts in Vienna.
The turn of the 19th into the 20th century was a
momentous time in the history of the city of Vienna,
seeing its rapid development into one of Europe's leading centres for
modernism. Political,
economic, and social change brought about unprecedented innovation in such
fields as psychiatry
and the visual arts. The project established the formative links that
existed between these two
`distinct' fields. Vienna was the home of Freud, who dominates our
understanding of modern
European culture. The project demonstrated that his contribution was in
fact one of many new
approaches to the mind and body, and associated ideas on sickness and
health. It re-positioned
Freud's work, re-mapped psychiatry in the `City of Dreams', and identified
new territories to
explore: namely, the important relationships that existed between artists,
psychiatrists and the
mentally ill. Blackshaw has considered the various ways and contexts in
which psychiatry, mental
illness, painting, writing and caricature interacted in Vienna in 1900.
With a focus on the `mad'
writer Peter Altenberg, she has reconsidered assumptions made about the
links between
madness, modernity, and the development of modernist portraiture and
literature in the city at this
time.
The earlier phase of the research led to an invitation to Blackshaw and
Topp from the Wellcome
Collection to present the results through a major international loan
exhibition `Madness and
Modernity: Mental Illness and the Visual Arts in Vienna 1900' in London in
2009. The aim of the
exhibition was 1) to explore through a range of different objects the
relationship between the
development of modern psychiatry and modernism in the arts in Vienna 1900,
and 2) to investigate
how this relationship has influenced our attitudes to the mentally ill.
The accompanying catalogue
presented the research for a non-specialist readership. Critical acclaim
for the exhibition led to a
commission to present it in an expanded form at the Wien Museum, Vienna in
2010. The catalogue
was translated into German but the first part of the English title -
`Madness and Modernity' - was
maintained at the request of the museum director, to signal to Austrian
audiences that this was a
new and controversial `outsider' perspective on Vienna 1900.
An image of Altenberg was chosen to advertise both exhibitions, and from
2011 to the present
Blackshaw has focused on this individual, reconstructing the history of
his mental illness and its
intersection with his image in painting and caricature. Despite his
celebrity status in Vienna around
1900, Altenberg is not a well-known figure outside Austria and few of his
works are available in
translation. Blackshaw engaged in extensive archival research to re-trace
his journey through
psychiatric hospitals in order to contextualise his identity as Vienna's
`mad' writer. In bringing
Altenberg to the attention of English-speaking audiences, and in
translating unpublished
correspondence between the writer, his family and friends, Blackshaw
generated further
knowledge on modernist circles and patient experience in Vienna circa
1900, proposing new
interpretations of artistic identity formation. She presented this
research at the College Art
Association's annual conference in Los Angeles (2009), and in her
co-edited collection of essays
Journeys into Madness (2012). The `Madness and Modernity'
exhibitions contained film
installations by the artist filmmaker David Bickerstaff. Blackshaw and
Bickerstaff went on to
collaborate on a feature-length documentary film devoted to Altenberg,
which premiered at the
Neue Galerie for Austrian and German Art, New York, and the Freud Museum,
London (2012).
Images of Altenberg will appear in Blackshaw's new, major exhibition Facing
the Modern: The
Portrait in Vienna 1900 at the National Gallery London (2013-14).
His work will also feature in
Blackshaw's forthcoming single-authored book Exhibiting Portraiture in
Vienna 1900, supported by
the Leverhulme Trust.
References to the research
(1) Blackshaw, single-authored essay on `Peter Altenberg: Authoring
Madness in Vienna circa
1900', and, with Wieber, `Introduction to Journeys into Madness'
in Blackshaw and Wieber (eds),
Journeys into Madness: Mapping Mental Illness in the Austro-Hungarian
Empire, New
York: Berghahn, 2012. This peer-reviewed book was the 14th
volume of Berghahn Book's
prestigious series devoted to Austrian and Habsburg Studies, sponsored by
the Centre for Austrian
Studies at the University of Minnesota.
(2) Blackshaw, `The Pathological Body: Modernist Strategising in the
Self-Portraits of Egon
Schiele', single-authored scholarly article, Oxford Art Journal,
vol. 30, no. 3, 2007, 377-401.
The peer-reviewed Oxford Art Journal has an international
reputation for publishing innovative
critical work in art history, and has played a major role in the recent
rethinking of the discipline.
Blackshaw's article has consistently remained in its Top 50 `most read'
articles, which is generated
on a monthly basis; in August 2013 it was listed at no. 24.
(3) Blackshaw and Topp, Madness and Modernity: Mental Illness and the
Visual Arts in Vienna
1900/ Madness and Modernity: Kunst und Wahn in Wien um 1900,
co-edited exhibition catalogue,
Surrey: Lund Humphries, 2009; Vienna: Brandstätter, 2010. Includes key
essays by Blackshaw on
`Gustav Jagerspacher: Portrait of Peter Altenberg' and `Mad Modernists:
Imaging Mental Illness in
Viennese Portraits'. Blackshaw and Topp cooperated on `Scrutinised Bodies
and Lunatic Utopias:
Mental Illness, Psychiatry and the Visual Arts in Vienna, 1898-1914'.
Since the 1980s, Lund
Humphries has pioneered museum co-publications; it joined the Ashgate
Publishing group in 1999,
a leading independent press dedicated to publishing the finest academic
research. Christian
Brandstätter publishes the major exhibition catalogues devoted to modern
Austrian and German
art from the continent.
(4) Blackshaw and Bickerstaff, Peter Altenberg: The Little Pocket
Mirror, documentary film
collaboration, 2012.
(5) Blackshaw, single authored essays `On Stage: The New Viennese' and
`Past Times and
Present Anxieties at the Galerie Miethke' and `The Appeal of the Artist:
Self Portraits by Klimt,
Schiele and Schönberg' in Blackshaw (ed), Facing the Modern: The
Portrait in Vienna 1900,
National Gallery Company in association with Yale University Press, 2013.
The manuscript was
peer-reviewed by the other authors, and by a further, independent expert
in the field: Professor
Clare Willsdon at the University of Glasgow.
(6) `The Mad Objects of Fin-de-Siècle Vienna: Journeys, Contexts and
Dislocations in the
Exhibition "Madness and Modernity"', single-authored essay by Topp
(Birkbeck university)
reflecting on the co-curated exhibition in in Blackshaw and Wieber (eds),
Journeys into
Madness, 2012.
Details of the impact
The research project was selected as the case study for the AHRC's
website to illustrate
excellence in the public engagement with the humanities (1). As Nobel
Prize winner Eric Kandel
acknowledged in his 2012 publication on Vienna 1900, The Age of
Insight, `Madness and
Modernity' re-wrote a significant period in modern European history (2).
Responses to the research
as presented through the exhibitions were captured primarily in reviews
(93 in the case of the
London exhibition, with a circulation of 55,975,642 people; 126 in the
case of the Vienna exhibition)
and visitor book comments. The feedback highlighted the project's
generation of new knowledge.
For example, in an article for The Lancet, Joanna Bourke declared
the London exhibition `a "must
see"... the exhibits have been carefully chosen, and many appear in the UK
for the first time' (3).
Both exhibitions provided visitors with the opportunity to engage with
work that was completely
new, enriching their lives. As one visitor commented: `This exhibition is
a knock out... The
discovery of Raedler and Frau St. is gold indeed. And so much Egon Schiele
too! I am gratified
beyond belief.' 40,320 people, including mental health service users and
professionals, visited the
London exhibition. As one doctor working in psychological medicine
remarked: `It's just so
wonderful. I have a real emotional high' (4). The Governor of The Retreat,
a centre for those with
mental health needs in York, was also struck, asking for copies of the
exhibition labels: `because of
parallels with late 18th-century developments in the treatment
of mental illness by Quakers' (4). The
London exhibition was paired with another devoted to a contemporary artist
who exhibited
drawings reflecting upon her experience as a NHS patient. The dialogue
between our look back at
how society used to engage with the mentally ill in `Madness and
Modernity', and how society
continues to engage with it 100 years on in `Bobby Baker's Diary Drawings:
Mental Illness and Me,
1997-2008', was very much a part of how the Wellcome presented the
research. This was
acknowledged in the public discourse. In Nature magazine, one
writer reflected: `Fears of living in a
modern city created anxieties that resonate today, raising questions about
our attitudes to mental
illness and its treatment.' (5) In preparing for the exhibition, Wellcome
staff had guidance on how to
treat people with mental health problems in anticipation of the number of
people with experiences
of mental health issues that would be attracted to the exhibition. The
staff used elements of `Open
to All', a training programme for gallery staff produced by the Department
of Health. But it was not
only the lives of exhibition staff and visitors that were enriched by the
project: radio and blog
coverage engaged audiences unable to visit London or Vienna. ABC Radio
Australia devoted a
programme on the exhibition for their series `All in the Mind', broadcast
on 25 July 2009 (6);
Blackshaw's interview was used to develop a blog for their listeners. The
Wellcome produced a
film on the making of the exhibition which was uploaded on to their site
and to You Tube: since
appearing in 2009 the film has had 2,745 hits (7).
In terms of the ongoing enrichment of cultural life, the statement issued
by the Wellcome on the
project highlighted `how it helped greatly to increase the breadth of
Wellcome Collection's
audience... cementing our reputation for mounting the kind of intelligent
and accessible
interdisciplinary exhibitions which have put us on the cultural map' (8).
The impact of the Wellcome
exhibition is also evident in collecting and display endeavours. For
example, the work of Raedler, a
schizophrenic, was shown to audiences in the UK for the first time in
`Madness and Modernity'; on
closing, every drawing by Raedler exhibited was purchased by James Brett
for his new public arts
space `The Museum of Everything' in London, devoted to self-taught artists
living `outside modern
society'. In a broader sense, the exhibition had a demonstrable impact on
cultural programming in
London, igniting an interest in modern Viennese culture, and Blackshaw's
ongoing research has
been very much a part of this. Since 2009, she has been working on two
exhibition projects: Facing
the Modern: The Portrait in Vienna 1900 for the National Gallery
(2013-14) and Egon Schiele: The
Radical Nude for the Courtauld (2014). Such projects have led to a
greater interest in the modern
period in Europe in UK film and broadcasting. Blackshaw was invited to
collaborate with David
Bickerstaff on the documentary film Peter Altenberg: The Little Pocket
Mirror, which was shown at
the Freud Museum London in 2012 and the Shakespeare & Company bookshop
in Vienna in 2013
(9). Following up on her co-edited book Journeys into Madness
(10), the BBC approached
Blackshaw to advise on a series presented by Michael Portillo on `Great
Continental Railway
Journeys' that engages with health tourism around 1900. The development of
such projects,
outside of the book and exhibition outputs that characterise the work of
art historians in
universities, shows the richness and relevance of the `Madness and
Modernity' research.
Sources to corroborate the impact
- For the AHRC's acknowledgement of the impact of the research project
see:
http://www.ahrc.ac.uk/News-and-Events/News/Pages/AHRC-funded-research-leads-to-acclaimed-
exhibition-at-the-Wellcome-Collection.aspx
- For an example of the impact of `Madness and Modernity' on
interpretations and approaches to
Vienna 1900 see Nobel Prize winner Eric Kandel's The Age of Insight:
The Quest to Understand
the Unconscious in Art, Mind, and Brain, from Vienna 1900 to the
Present, New York: Random
House, 2012.
- For a review of the exhibition by Joanna Bourke in The Lancet
see:
http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(09)60968-5/fulltext
- Visitor's book for `Madness and Modernity: Mental Illness and the
Visual Arts in Vienna 1900',
property of Wellcome Collection, London.
- For a review of the exhibition in Nature see Volume 458, No.
973 (23 April 2009).
- For the ABC radio programme devoted to the contemporary resonances of
the exhibition,
including an interview with Blackshaw see:
http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/allinthemind/madness-modernity-and-those-nervous-
times-vienna/3064276
- For the film devoted to the making of the exhibition see:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x4QVIpLaRS4
- Testimony from James Peto, Head of Exhibitions at Wellcome Collection,
London.
- For a review of Peter Altenberg: The Little Pocket Mirror see:
http://www.viennareview.net/on-
the-town/on-screen/the-man-who-lived-at-the-cafe-central
- For Blackshaw's interview with Berghahn Books on Peter Altenberg see:
http://berghahnbooks.com/blog/interview-with-the-editor-gemma-blackshaw-co-editor-of-journeys-
into-madness-mapping-mental-illness-in-the-austro-hungarian-empire