Open Educational Resources (OERs) in English: Enriching the School Curriculum and Supporting Transition from School to University
Submitting Institution
University of OxfordUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
SocietalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
Summary of the impact
Great Writers Inspire (www.writersinspire.org)
is a JISC funded project designed by Smith, Williams and Beasley in
collaboration with IT services to expand the Oxford English Faculty's open
educational resources on the web. Prompted by the success of Smith's
Approaching Shakespeare podcast lectures (2010), GWI represents a
systematic approach to creating, gathering and curating online research
content targeted directly at students and teachers in secondary schools,
further education, lifelong learning, and universities. Combining
tailor-made podcasts, curated eBooks, audio talks, video files, and
scholarly essays, GWI and AS have brought the Faculty's research to a
global audience of over 740,000.
Underpinning research
Great Writers Inspire (GWI) draws on the research expertise of 37 Faculty
members, as well as a number of post-graduate researchers based within the
Faculty who have acted as Student Ambassadors, making their own
contributions and supporting project activities. The underpinning research
is highly various, but the contributors have in common a concern to
mediate current ideas and questions galvanising university-level research
for students at an earlier stage in their literature and language
education. Horobin, for example, draws upon his publications in the field
of historical sociolinguistics and analysis of processes of linguistic
standardisation, for an accessible critical appraisal of historical and
modern attitudes to linguistic variation and normativity. His early period
expertise is complemented by Wakelin's (2011-) work on textuality and
editorial issues in late medieval literature. Stern (2008-) specializes in
Renaissance Theatre, Smith (1999-) in Shakespeare's Contemporary
Dramatists; both have a strong focus on performance. 18C literature is
studied by Ballaster (1994-), who has a long-standing interest in oriental
fictions, Williams (2001-), who has produced a critical edition of
Jonathan Swift's Journal to Stella and completed a major digital
project on poetic miscellanies, and Sutherland (1996-) who evaluates
manuscript sources of 18th and early 19th century fiction, with special
attention to Austen. The Victorian period is an area of interest for
Douglas-Fairhurst (2002-), working on Tennyson and Dickens, and Brown
(2007- 2013), focusing on George Eliot. Two contributing scholars are
experts in modernism: Beasley (2009-) studies Ezra Pound, with a focus on
the visual arts; Binckes (2002-2013) examines the writing of Katherine
Mansfield and modernist magazines. Boehmer (2007-), Peter D. McDonald
(1995-), and Mukherjee (2003-) work on postcolonial, anticolonial and
transnational writers and themes from 1870 to the present, including Olive
Schreiner and J.M. Coetzee.
The initial development of GWI rested especially on Smith's research into
Shakespeare. Her `Approaching Shakespeare' podcasts draw together a range
of methodologies to focus on specific plays and the questions they
generate. Asking why Hamlet is called Hamlet, for instance, enables her to
develop the history of character and psychological criticism;
investigating where the political sympathies of Richard II might lie draws
on new bibliographical work and on the history of performance; working
with the unnecessary character of Antonio in Twelfth Night is a
way to engage in a nexus of queer criticism, historicism, and theatre.
Throughout the lecture series she builds on the interdisciplinary
approaches of her published research.
References to the research
(selected examples, with evidence of quality)
Simon Horobin, Studying the History of Early English. Palgrave
Macmillan, 2010; Chaucer's Language. Palgrave Macmillan, 2006. Available
on request.
Peter McDonald, The Literature Police: Apartheid Censorship and its
Cultural Consequences, O.U.P, 2009, pbk and etext 2010; REF2:
McDonald - N01; website
www.theliteraturepolice.com.
TLS book of the year, Guardian Christmas book, 2009;
shortlisted for the Warwick Prize for Writing, 2011.
Robert Douglas-Fairhurst, Becoming Dickens (Harvard UP, 2011),
REF2: Douglas-Fairhurst - N01; 2011 Duff Cooper Prize
Tiffany Stern: Documents of Performance in Early Modern England
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009), REF2: Stern - N01; TLS book
of the year, 2010; Winner of The David Bevington Award for Best New Book
in Early Drama Studies, 2010; George Freedley Award Finalist, 2010.
Emma Smith, Five History Plays (Continuum, 2000). Available on
request; edited, with Garrett Sullivan, The Cambridge Companion to
English Renaissance Tragedy (CUP 2010). DOI:
10.1017/CCOL9780521519373; The Cambridge Shakespeare Guide (CUP,
2012). Available on request; Macbeth: Language and Writing
(Bloomsbury, 2013). Available on request.
Ros Ballaster, Fabulous Orients: Fictions of the East in England
1662-1785 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005).
DOI:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199234295.001.0001. Winner of the Rose Mary
Crawshay Prize 2006.
Ankhi Mukherjee, "What is a Classic?": International Literary
Criticism and the Classic Question', PMLA 125 (2010). REF2:
Mukherjee - N01
Rebecca Beasley, Ezra Pound and the Visual Culture of Modernism
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007). Available on request.
Supporting grants: Funding from JISC for 12 months £127,108,
October 2011-October 2012.
Details of the impact
`Approaching Shakespeare' and `Great Writers Inspire' have had
significant impact on a range of beneficiaries outside Higher Education,
including school students and their teachers and life- long learners.
AS was and is the most successful of the Faculty's early experiments with
the podcast lecture format. Downloaded 407,319 times by the end of
the audit period, it is a recommended resource in schools across the UK.
The series was trialled by Smith in October 2010 with technical assistance
from IT Services, and quickly taken up by the school and university
sectors, becoming a staple resource for teaching and learning about
Shakespeare. Email feedback includes: `I came across [AS] last year on
iTunes when writing on Othello, and found your lecture a fantastic help...
as an introduction to ways of thinking about the play, and to how I might
try to put together an argument about it' (Ref. 1) from a 6th form
student; and `As head of More Able and Talented at a large state school, I
am constantly looking for resources to improve our teaching and your
podcasts are giving us just that opportunity. Members of the English
department are now using Wittgenstein's Dabbit illustration in the way you
did and finding it to be a very effective approach and our more able
students are being encouraged to listen to the podcasts both to improve
their understanding of the plays and to encourage them to believe that
Oxford ... operates at A-level they will find accessible' (Ref. 2) from a
teacher.
Experiencing this success, and recognising a need for further resources
to bridge the divide between the research university and other learning
environments, Smith worked with Beasley and Williams on a JISC grant
proposal for funding to support more ambitious efforts at making Faculty
research freely available on-line. Launched 18 April 2012, www.writersinspire.org
now makes 3,598 open resource content items available to the
public. All are licensed for educational reuse worldwide, the majority
labelled with a Creative Commons licence. The figure includes 3,021
eBooks (the majority, c. 3,000, from the Oxford Text Archive of
scholarly texts deposited with IT services in pre-1990s electronic
versions), 195 audio talks, including 119 video files, 89
short scholarly contextual essays written by academic researchers or
graduate students, plus 96 images. 37 academics from the
UOA have contributed content in the form of lectures and/or scholarly
essays. Curated by subject specialists from within the Faculty, steered
and evaluated by the demands of the subject community with the help of
school partners, GWI was designed to combat the data deluge facing
potential users of online digital materials related to English literature.
eBooks and videos are framed and introduced with essays and contextual
material. A number of resources have been adapted for presentation on
portable devices such as tablets and smartphones. Collecting existing
materials together and enriching them with new resources has gained an
audience for materials unlikely otherwise to attract notice at secondary
school level. This process has taken place in part through a WordPress
blog (http://writersinspire.wordpress.com/),
launched
June 2009, which captures new resources and academics' scholarly posts.
Paid graduate student ambassadors contributed content, including blog
entries and short essays (e.g. explanatory context for items in the Oxford
Text Archive). All material goes into Apple's global publishing platform
Apple iTunes U, and (in parallel) into the main university media website www.podcast.ox.ac.uk to enable
more direct retrieval through Google. IT-Support have worked closely with
Google, who already ranked the University of Oxford highly, using titles,
keywords, and sheer volume of content to maximize GWI's ranking in their
search engine. Type the word `lectures' and the name of a major British
author or text into Google (e.g. `Shakespeare', `Dickens', `Beowulf'), and
Oxford English Faculty material will generally be the first search
finding. (Ref. i).
The popularity of GWI encouraged the Faculty to invest further resources
of time and money in the project. GWI was given a design update in summer
2013, with the aid of £5000 of Faculty funding. Two interns worked under
the direction of IT to redesign the site and engage in promotional social
networking. New content was added, in particular a new series entitled
`Challenging the Canon', launched 25 July. As described on the site (http://podcasts.ox.ac.uk/series/challenging-canon),
`This unique mini-series aims to challenge the literary canon by posing
the thorny question "why should we study...?" to experts at the University
of Oxford. Beginning with the overarching question "why should we study
the humanities?" and moving on to illuminating discussions about key
writers... these podcasts will introduce you to new perspectives ... A
perfect study companion for prospective undergraduates, lifelong learners
and literary enthusiasts.' The redesign was recommended to Apple by Peter
Robinson (IT Services), on the basis that the series `would suit a broad
audience ... would have a lot of varied expert content on `The Canon' and
would be worth promoting IMHO.' Apple responded enthusiastically,
promoting the series prominently with the advertising hook `Challenging
the Canon' (Ref. ii). Activity on Twitter and Facebook led popular blogger
Oliver Tearle to volunteer a wordpress guest blog, boosting the site's
following (Ref. iii). At the close of the audited period GWI had attracted
292,110 video downloads and 42,252 audio downloads. `Challenging
the Canon' has already reached 31,000+ views, 6000+ downloads and is
averaging 1177 downloads weekly (168 daily). The recent presence of
GWI and CC on Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/greatwritersinspire)
and Twitter has to date produced 267 likes and over 400 followers. The
global relevance and usefulness of the project and its constituent
materials are indicated by the range of countries in which the project
blog has been accessed, including the USA, India, Canada, Japan, as well
as the UK.
GWI's impact in schools has been enhanced by active engagement of
the researchers with teachers through conference participation. Smith was
invited (in 2012 and 13) to address the eMagazine 6th Form Conference, the
London Association for Teachers of English, and a number of schools
including Queen's Park Community College and Harris Academy Dulwich. She
used the occasions to introduce teachers and students to the resources.
School English teachers have also benefited from workshops organised by
members of the Faculty with GWI, such as the `Engage' workshop (April
2012), and the `Teaching with Shakespeare's First Folio' workshop (June
2013). These events (total attendance 52) offered participants
opportunities to engage in resource creation and distribution,
demonstrating a real exchange of ideas and expertise with scholars working
on specific literary themes and topics. All those who completed feedback
forms thought the workshop `extremely useful'; all but one were planning
to use the First Folio resource in their teaching — e.g. by adopting the
workshop `focus on language change and aspects of graphology' and `using
it for Language Change as part of the English Language A-level'. Many secondary
school teachers have testified to how GWI is enriching their
teaching materials. `Some of the students have definitely got into
considering writers that they wouldn't have considered before. For example
two girls were interested in Aphra Behn and they'd never heard of her
before ... [T]he website prompts that sort of thing; students can
investigate aspects of literature that they wouldn't have thought of
before' (A-level teacher, Oxford, July 2012); `from my point of view as a
Head of English it's already fantastically useful. It contains very
accessible, critical material, contextual material, background material'
(A-level teacher, Derbyshire, June 2012). `Some students feel that they do
not belong in this literary world - they ask how does this fit in with all
this literature? Access to [GWI] helps us address this question' (A-level
teacher, Somerset, June 2012). School students too have benefited
from GWI's encouragement of a wide range of learning styles. The resources
include items complementary to GCSE and A-level syllabi, as well as
undergraduate level materials suitable for students who can handle more
challenging texts and ideas. 6th form student feedback on a workshop
undertaken by members of Faculty with a local school in June 2012
includes: `It was great learning about Aphra Behn - we'd never heard of
her before and she's really interesting' (Ref. iv). GWI also offers life-long
learners with an interest in classic texts a wealth of material. In
particular the categorisation of resources into themed collections such as
`Feminist Readings of Literature' and `Questioning Genre' has allowed
self- educators to develop their understanding of familiar literary works,
and engage with previously unknown ones. A beneficiary responds: `For
retired people like me podcasts of lectures (recorded raw, not dressed up
as some have them, complete with distracting background music) are a boon.
Lifelong learning! Saves us from having to watch "countdown"' (Ref. v).
Within the HEI, GWI has greatly assisted institutional policy and
practice with regard to creative commons licenses. The designers and
curators of the project have worked closely with other institutions
possessing experience in provision of free online resources (notably
Adelaide University, which has long been providing free literary etexts
under CC licence; links to many of their texts are provided in supporting
reading lists to GWI material). The project has raised academic awareness
about open access to research, and encouraged proactive engagement with
the political and legal debates (Ref. vi).
Sources to corroborate the impact
Testimony
(1). Email from 6th form student, Birmingham, 16.10.11.
(2). Email from teacher, London 4.11.10.
Other evidence sources
(i). The Great Writers OER Project Evaluation Report
(independently commissioned).
(ii). Screen shot of Apple promotion of `Challenging the Canon', 13
September 2013
(iii). Oliver Tearle's blog entry: http://writersinspire.wordpress.com
(iv). GWI Schools Engagement:
http://writersinspire.wordpress.com/2012/07/17/schools-engagement-at-cheney-oxford/
http://writersinspire.wordpress.com/2012/07/17/schools-engagement-at-cheney-teachers-comments/
(v). Anonymous respondent. Collated www.wordpress.com
feedback.
(vi). OpenSpires discussion of Open Data and Policies on OA: http://blogs.it.ox.ac.uk/openspires/
All download figures courtesy of IT-Support, University of Oxford.