Case 4 - Influencing international climate mitigation strategies by understanding the role of tropical forests
Submitting InstitutionUniversity of Leeds
Unit of AssessmentGeography, Environmental Studies and Archaeology
Summary Impact TypeEnvironmental
Research Subject Area(s)
Environmental Sciences: Environmental Science and Management
Biological Sciences: Ecology, Other Biological Sciences
Summary of the impact
Research led by the School of Geography at the University of Leeds has
enabled, for the first time, the use of on-the-ground observations to
evaluate directly the role of tropical forests in the global carbon cycle
and to assess their sensitivity to change. Findings from the research have
had a significant impact on international debates on the future trajectory
of climate change and appropriate policy responses, and are influencing
national-scale efforts across the tropics to manage forests in the face of
climate change and to reduce carbon emissions resulting from deforestation
[D, E, G, H, J]. The success of this Leeds-led initiative has been
achieved through the extensive network of scientists involved in this
global forest observatory: more than 250 scientists from over 50
institutions across more than 30 countries are now involved.
Tropical forests store 300 billion tonnes of carbon, annually process 30
billion tonnes and occupy an area of more than 10 million km2.
Small differences in the carbon balance of the forests can therefore have
big impacts on the global carbon cycle and climate. Before 1998 it was
generally accepted that undisturbed forests were static stores of carbon:
that the rate of decay was equivalent to the rate of growth. Since 1998,
Oliver Phillips, Professor in the School of Geography, has led an
international team to make on-the-ground observations and measurements
(e.g. tree size, diversity) of permanent forest plots and showed for the
first time that undisturbed forests in Amazonia were continuing to take
in, or sequester, carbon . A key part of the work was to
develop, for the first time, a standardised package of techniques
(biomass, production, biodiversity, soil, biogeochemistry, and a database
server to the world's foresters: www.forestplots.net), and to train an
extensive network of scientists in many countries to use these techniques,
thereby establishing a unique, robust and scientifically credible global
observatory of permanent plots of intact tropical forests.
The network established for Amazonia, the Amazon Forest Inventory Network
(RAINFOR), allowed Phillips and collaborators to make the first
field-based estimate of the tropical carbon sink [4, 5] and the
first demonstration of increasing growth in tropical forests likely to be
caused by an increase in atmospheric CO2 . In
Africa, an equivalent organisation (AfriTRON) led by Lewis that
unites European and African scientists similarly demonstrated the
existence of a significant carbon sink in intact African tropical forests
. The research networks (RAINFOR, AfriTRON, AMAZONICA)
coordinated by Leeds School of Geography now involve over 50 institutions,
and more than 300 participants from more than 30 nations. The combined,
multi-continental monitoring led by Leeds shows that tropical forests
remove 4.8 billion tonnes of CO2 emissions from the atmosphere
The 2005 Amazon drought allowed the Leeds-led team to measure the first
on-the-ground determination of drought sensitivity of forests and trees in
Amazonia  and showed that the drought increased CO2 emissions
by 5 billion tonnes from tree mortality. These results have allowed the
first estimation of the risk that climate change poses for projects that
aim to receive payments for conserving the carbon stocks of these
Oliver Phillips (NERC Research Fellow 1996-9; Lecturer 1999-2003;
Reader 2003-6; Professor since 2006); Simon Lewis (Royal Society
Research Fellow since 2000); Tim Baker (NERC Research Fellow, RCUK
Research Fellow, 2005-2010, Lecturer 2010-12, Associate Professor 2013-);
Gabriela Lopez-Gonzalez (Database Analyst since 2005); Emanuel Gloor
(Leeds since 2007; Professor since 2008); Roel Brienen (RAINFOR
Research Fellow 2008-11, NERC Fellow 2011-Present); Ted Feldpausch
(Research fellow, left Leeds in 2013 for Exeter); Nikos Fyllas
(Marie Curie Intra-European Fellow 2009-11, left Leeds in 2012 for
University of Athens).
References to the research
The research — supported by major grant funding — has produced a range of
outputs in leading, rigorously peer reviewed international journals.
Outputs 1, 3 and 5 are included in REF2.
The work by Phillips and colleagues has attracted major grants
(>£7M), including invited grant awards by charitable foundations, such
as the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation, "RAINFOR: a proposal to
understand the carbon balance of Amazon forests", PI Phillips
($4.4M to Leeds, 2008-12).
NERC funding includes Integrated Carbon Analysis of Amazonia , AMAZONICA
, PI Gloor (£1,268,880, 2008-2014); NE/I028122/1, co-PI Baker
(£258,552, 2012-2015) ; NE/D000300/1, PI Lewis (£51,754,
2005-2009); NE/G00840X/1, PI Baker (£70,557, 2009).
EU: ERC Advanced Grant to Phillips (T-FORCES, €1,824,905, 2012 -
2017), AMAZALERT, PIs Baker/Gloor (FP7, €227,999, 2011-2014)
GEOCARBON projects (FP7, €565,244, 2011-2014). Royal Society Fellowships,
Lewis (£250,830, 2004-2009 and £280,863, 2009-2013).
Selected key publications from this research include the following:
1. Baker TR and 7 others (2010). How can ecologists help realise
the potential of payments for carbon in tropical forest countries? Journal
of Applied Ecology 47: 1159-1165. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-
2. Lewis SL, Phillips OL, Baker TR, and 14 others
(2004). Concerted changes in tropical forest structure and dynamics:
evidence from 50 South American long-term plots. Philosophical
Transactions of the Royal Society, Series B 359: 421-436.
3. Lewis SL with Phillips OL, Gloor, E, Baker, TR,
Lopez-Gonzalez, G and 27 others (2009) Increasing carbon storage in intact
African tropical forests, Nature 457: 1003-1006. doi:
4. Phillips OL and 10 others (1998). Changes in the carbon
balance of tropical forest: evidence from long-term plots. Science
282: 439-442. doi: 10.1126/science.282.5388.439
5. Phillips OL with Lewis SL, Baker TR, Gloor E, Lopez-Gonzalez G
and 60 others (2009). Drought sensitivity of the Amazon rainforest. Science
323: 1344-1347. doi: 10.1126/science.1164033
Details of the impact
Impacts on international climate change policy
The Leeds-led research has played a significant role in shaping key
contributions of the global scientific community that inform and impact
international climate change policy. Our research was cited in the
`Copenhagen Diagnosis' climate science report that synthesised the most
policy-relevant science prior to the United Nations Framework Convention
on Climate Change (UNFCCC) in 2009 [A], and embedded in the
InterAcademies Panel statement on tropical forests and climate change that
was given to all delegates at UNFCCC in 2009 [B].
Impacts on mapping carbon stocks and forest science in tropical
In Gabon, Peru, and Colombia, training provided by projects led by Leeds
has allowed in-country organisations to participate in mapping tropical
forest carbon stocks [C, D, E]. For example, the
World Wildlife Fund (WWF) Peru attests: `Collaboration with the School of
Geography, University of Leeds has been fundamental for completing the
forest biomass analysis of Madre de Dios and San Martin. The high quality
of the science and methods, and the extensive experience in tropical
forest ecology provided by Leeds staff has significantly contributed to
building local support for developing regional maps of forest carbon
stocks' [D]. In all three countries, our teams have ground-truthed
carbon stock maps based on remote sensing.
NASA has used the Leeds-developed standardised carbon stock data to
produce the first consistent, baseline carbon map of the world's tropical
Following Leeds-led research analysing forest inventory data from the
region of Madre de Dios in southern Peru funded by WWF-Peru, the Madre de
Dios regional government awarded a contract to WWF-Peru to produce a map
of the carbon stocks of the region to support the development of REDD+
(see below for an explanation of the REDD scheme) in the region [D].
The sophisticated data management utility developed by RAINFOR (www.forestplots.net)
allows analysis of forest dynamics worldwide, and is in demand as the tool
of choice for NGOs and forest managers (439 registered users, 7717 unique
visitors; up to October 2013).
Impacts on research, training and policy strategies of non-HE
organisations and agencies
Training courses run by Leeds during research projects have been repeated
at universities in Peru and Colombia and have been used to design a
vocational diploma programme by WWF-Peru to train forest managers [D,
In Colombia, the Botanic Garden in Medellin has used Leeds training
materials to develop a REDD+ project, in collaboration with government
organisations and NGOs [E].
In Peru, IIAP (Institute for Peruvian Amazon Research) is using the
carbon assessment approach that Leeds has developed across the Loreto
region in the northern Peruvian Amazon [G], and SERNANP (National
Service for Protected Areas) is adopting RAINFOR monitoring strategies in
protected areas in Amazonia [H].
In Brazil, NGOs have used criteria and indicators for evaluating the
environmental and social benefits of REDD projects that were developed as
part of Leeds-led research in the Peruvian Amazon, to develop principles
for implementing these types of project in Brazil [I].
In Gabon, ANPN (Gabon's National Park Service) and the US Forest Service
organised a workshop and group to make recommendations to plan Gabon's
national carbon monitoring programme. Our carbon assessment approach was
selected to be used, including training Gabon's national carbon inventory
field teams, overseen by Lewis [C]. Research by Lewis and
colleagues has been a direct input into the National Climate Plan of Gabon
Impacts on governmental strategies for obtaining REDD+ financing
The UN REDD programme, and REDD+ in developing countries, will provide a
mechanism to support activities that maximise the carbon storage of
forests and minimise deforestation and forest degradation through the
provision of finance to pay countries the opportunity costs associated
with not deforesting; alternatively, these can be seen as payments for the
carbon storage service that these ecosystems provide. Following
publication of Lewis et al. (2009), the Gabon Government won a
$500K grant from the Moore and Packard foundations to map carbon across
the Congo Basin. This resulted in a grant to Leeds School of Geography
from the government of Gabon (US$73,342) [C] to work with NASA to
produce the first wall-to-wall carbon map of an African country in time
for the UN climate change summit in Copenhagen in December 2009. The
project enabled the Gabon Government and the Central African negotiating
block in the UN to demonstrate that they had the technical capability to
monitor the carbon in their forests, removing a key obstacle in the UN
Lewis presented at Copenhagen, on behalf of the government of
Gabon, the wall-to-wall carbon map of the country [C]. As part of
this scientific case Lewis attended the Copenhagen talks as an
advisory member of the Gabon Government delegation. Lewis also
played a similar role as part of the Gabonese delegation at the UN Climate
Summits in Cancun, Mexico in December 2010, in Durban in November 2011,
and represented Gabon at the UNESCO summit in Paris in September 2011.
Similarly, in February 2010, Lewis acted as a technical advisor to
the Gabon Government at the Central African Forest Commission (COMIFAC) to
discuss how carbon storage and carbon fluxes in the Congo Basin should be
Sources to corroborate the impact
A. The Copenhagen Diagnosis cites reference  above on p.19.
[Available on request].
B. The InterAcademies Report, paragraph 2 - based on reference  above
and written by Lewis.
[Available on request].
C. Grant Award Letter Agreement for the University of Leeds from Gabon
Government for US$73,342, awarded to S.L. Lewis; dated 23 June 2009.
[Available on request].
D. Letter from Conservation Director of WWF-Peru letter to corroborate
research methods impact on a Peruvian non-governmental organization; dated
2 July 2013. [Available on request]
E. Letter from the director of the Medellin Botanical Garden (Colombia),
dated 25 June 2013 [Available on request]
F. Letter from a senior researcher at NASA to corroborate research
methods impact on national and pan-tropical carbon mapping; dated 13
August 2013. [Available on request].
G. Letter from Head of Forest Management and Environmental Services
Payment Programme at IIAP, The Institute for Research into the Peruvian
Amazon; dated 5 July 2013. [Available on request].
H. Letter from head of SERNANP, the state body responsible for protected
areas in Peru; dated 5 March 2013. [Available on request]
I. Leeds-led research is cited in a document produced by a consortium of
NGOs in Brazil to establish carbon-conservation guidelines: http://www.imaflora.org/downloads/biblioteca/PC_redd_imaflora_julho2010.pdf.
Document in Portuguese. Leeds is referenced on page 4. [Available on
J. Le Plan Climate National [The National Climate Plan] of Gabon cites
Leeds-led research on pp. 39, 40, 42. Document in French. [Available on