Enhancing Public Understanding of Dickens and 19th Century London
Submitting Institution
University of OxfordUnit of Assessment
English Language and LiteratureSummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Cultural Studies, Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Robert Douglas-Fairhurst has been credited with enabling a `reinvention'
of biography. His studies of Charles Dickens and 19th century London have
been communicated to a diverse audience in the UK and worldwide through
his work as a biographer and an advisor on highly regarded TV adaptations
of classic novels. His contributions to events marking the bicentenary of
Dickens's birth include advising on BBC1's 3-part adaptation of Great
Expectations (2011), assisting with sound historical and creative
interpretation to support the film's educational, cultural and market
value. Wider public understanding of the life and motivations of Dickens
was achieved through various means including television and radio
appearances, newspaper articles, blogs, podcasts, and public speaking
engagements.
Underpinning research
The main strand of Douglas-Fairhurst's research during this assessment
period concerns Dickens and his context. The most significant output is Becoming
Dickens: The Invention of a Novelist (2011), a critical biography
offering a fresh investigation into the personal and cultural factors that
led to an unknown legal clerk becoming the most famous novelist in the
world. The originality of this book lies in its revelation of how often
Dickens's career turned on an unpredictable mixture of choice and chance,
and how haunted his fiction remained by the ghostly alternative selves
that circumstances did not allow to flourish: (positively) the actor,
stage-manager, clerk, journalist, he might have been; (negatively) the man
who might never have made it out of a life of menial or relatively menial
labour. The biography is an important contribution to an emerging trend,
among life-writers, towards engaging imaginatively with plausible
`counterfactuals'—the lives that might have been lived, which run in
parallel with and have a bearing (emotional, ethical, or critical) on the
subject's and his or her contemporaries' understanding of the meaning and
value of the life observably lived. It also reinforces a move away from
`full' lives towards biographical slices or snapshots in time. As one
reviewer put it: `Becoming Dickens never takes Dickens for granted,
but helps us to be surprised—shocked even—that he existed, worked and
wrote in the way that he did. This counterfactual emphasis gives the book
breathing space and a sense of play that is too often missing from more
orthodoxly organized biographies.' (John Bowen, University of York,
prepublication review at
http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674050037&content=reviews)
Central to the research was the establishment of a fresh perspective on
Dickens's cultural context as a London writer of the 1830s. The biography
includes extensive original investigation into the worlds of politics and
journalism that launched Dickens's career, and explains in detail how
these experiences informed his literary style. This work built on research
Douglas-Fairhurst had previously undertaken for a new critical edition of
Henry Mayhew's London Labour and the London Poor (2010) with a
long critical introduction and detailed explanatory notes.
Becoming Dickens was the culmination of a four-year period of
research during which Douglas- Fairhurst produced several related
publications, all disseminated to a broad non-academic readership. They
include an essay on Dickens published in The Cambridge Companion to
English Novelists, ed. Adrian Poole (2009); a new edition of
Dickens's Great Expectations (2008) in which Douglas-Fairhurst
discussed popular adaptations of the novel and reprinted (for the first
time) part of a rare theatrical version either written by Dickens or done
with his blessing; and a detailed critical essay on Dickens's style.
References to the research
ii) Charles Dickens, Great Expectations, with an introduction and
notes by Robert Douglas-Fairhurst (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008).
Available on ProQuest ebrary
iii) Henry Mayhew, London Labour and the London Poor, ed. Robert
Douglas-Fairhurst (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010). Available on
request.
Chosen as a Book of the Year in the Evening Standard (`a superb
new edition' — Ian Thomson). Sales of over 9000 copies to date, and net
revenue of £46,600.
2. Articles
i) `Dickens', in The Cambridge Companion to English Novelists,
ed. Adrian Poole (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009). DOI:
10.1017/CCOL9780521871198.009
`[E]xceptional ... The discoveries of Douglas-Fairhurst's close reading
yield a new way of thinking about this familiar writer' (Leo Robson, New
Statesman).
ii) `Dickens's Rhythms', in Dickens and Style, ed. Daniel Tyler
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013). Available on request.
Details of the impact
Douglas-Fairhurst's research has enhanced understanding of Dickens
for a wide variety of audiences, refreshing and challenging conventional
readings of the writer's life: numerous reviewers have observed the
striking revisionism of the biography (Ref. i). Becoming Dickens
sold 11,000 copies in all formats (slightly over 9,000 in hardcover), and
is described by his editor at Harvard UP as `financially successful'
(profits not disclosed) (Ref. 1). A measure of its reach is
international media coverage: the book was reviewed over 100 times by
newspapers in countries including the UK, USA, Australia, India, Croatia,
and the UAE. It was featured on an edition of the BBC2 Review Show
entitled `Charles Dickens in Biography' (average viewing figures c.
450,000), and was the focus of a special edition of the Australian radio
programme `Lingua Franca' (ABC Radio National Australia: average listening
figures c. 45,000 in 5 cities, with additional listeners nationwide and
worldwide via the internet). The biography has been studied by numerous
book groups, including the Sewanee Book Club (Tennessee), the American
Association of University Women Book Groups (Pennyslvania Branch and
Schenectady NY Branch), and the Friends of the Palo Alto Library Book
Discussion Group (California). An indicative comment comes from Indian
novelist and blogger Chandrahas Choudhury, who argues that Becoming
Dickens shows that `If the reason we are attracted to biography is
the allure of the drama of human self-fashioning seen from the inside,
then these rewards can just as well be gleaned by the choice of a suite of
years, and not the whole life. ... The excitement of this method — that of
the partial, but pointed, biography — is that it is defamiliarising,
hovering not above its subject but beside it' (Ref. ii). The international
impact of the biography is further evidenced by its translation into
Chinese.
Douglas-Fairhurst enriched debate about Dickens's cultural
significance in the bicentenary year (2011-12) through numerous
interactions with media and the public. He participated in an hour long
discussion of Dickens's life and legacy with a panel including Simon
Callow and Salman Rushdie on PBS's Charlie Rose Show (average
viewing figures c. 300,000), first broadcast in February 2012 and repeated
on Christmas day 2012 (Ref. iii). He authored articles in several national
UK newspapers with a wide circulation, including (as part of the Guardian's
build-up to the bicentenary of the birth of Charles Dickens) `My Favourite
Dickens: Great Expectations' (Guardian, 23 September 2011)
and `Dickens on Screen: The Highs and Lows' (Guardian, 23 December
2011); also `The Sparkler of Albion: The Many Faces of Charles Dickens' (Daily
Telegraph, 26 September 2011); and `The Roads Not Taken' (New
Statesman, 10 October 2011). Douglas-Fairhurst wrote blog entries
for two popular American websites run by the Campaign for the American
Reader: `The Page 99 Test' (Ref. iv) and `My Book, The Movie' (Ref. v),
and contributed an analysis of the best Dickens novels and criticism to
the Smithsonian Magazine (Ref. vi). He also filmed a podcast for
the Podularity website (Ref. vii). He was featured on the cover of the
magazine Oxford Today (to which he contributed an article on
parallels between Dickens's world and our own), and recorded a free access
introduction to Dickens for Oxford University's `Great Writers' project
(1786 hits by the end of the audited period).
Face to face engagement with the general public includes the event `Why
Dickens?', co-hosted by Douglas-Fairhurst with Prof John Carey at the
British Academy, which attracted a capacity audience of 230 and prompted
vigorous discussion about the development of Dickens's career and his
contemporary relevance. Douglas-Fairhurst spoke on numerous occasions
about Dickens to audiences of between 20 and 200 people in a variety of
settings (including schools, churches, literary societies, libraries, and
literary festivals) across the UK. He gave invited lectures to general
audiences (students and members of the public as well as academics) in
London, Durham, York, Leicester, Bologna, Hong Kong, New Orleans,
Virginia, and Indiana (total audience attendance c. 2000). A
representative response comes from an attendee of the Aye Write!
literary festival, Glasgow: `"Why Dickens?" This seemingly straightforward
question was the premise of the excellent talk given by Robert
Douglas-Fairhurst ... [which] proved him an inimitable Dickens scholar ...
[H]is knowledge and insight into Dickens the man made for a entertaining
and informative evening' (Ref. viii). Several of these engagements drew on
Douglas-Fairhurst's specialist knowledge of Dickens's London: for example,
his contribution to the series of `Talks on the Thames' hosted by Somerset
House (Ref. ix).
Douglas-Fairhurst has made significant contributions to film and
other creative industries, using his expertise on Dickens and
Dickensian London to assist sound new interpretations. In 2010 he
was appointed historical advisor on a major 3-part adaptation of Great
Expectations, co-produced by the BBC with PBS Masterpiece. It was
viewed by millions across the UK when it aired over Christmas 2011 as the
flagship programme in the BBC's Dickens season, the three episodes
garnering audiences of 7.57m, 7.19m, and 6.97m (ranking 11, 12 and 13 in
BBC1's popularity ratings for the week ending 1 January) (Ref. x).
Douglas-Fairhurst read successive drafts of the scripts, commented on
their historical accuracy, suggested revisions to the dialogue, discussed
the novel's historical context and major themes with the director (Brian
Kirk), answered queries from the design team, and was available during
filming to advise actors. Much of this knowledge was acquired while
researching the edition of Great Expectations (the edition has
sold over 60,000 copies to date, to the value of £125,900 for OUP), but
the research for Becoming Dickens also had a significant impact on
the visual style of the film. According to producer George Ormond, `Robert
was invaluable in helping us realise Great Expectations. He fed in
research as we developed the script, advising on everything from what kind
of drinks Mrs Joe might serve at Christmas to Pumblechook, to Dickens'
obsession with dirt, to what a London street might feel like. Brian Kirk
... and I spent time with Robert discussing details of the production like
how best to realise Dickensian London, and what the world of the marshes
might feel like. Robert's advice and research was made available to and
used by every department, from costume, to design, to hair and makeup'
(Ref. 2). The effectiveness of the contribution to high quality
broadcasting is evidenced by the many awards it garnered, including
3 Baftas, 4 Emmys, and 2 Royal Television Society Awards.
Douglas-Fairhurst assisted the BBC's promotional activities by publishing
two articles in the Guardian (see 3.2 above), contributing to a
feature on fashion inspired by Miss Havisham (`It Girl', Interview
Magazine, August 2011), and participating in a Dickens Day at
Foyles, where he discussed (to an audience of c. 100) the problems of
adapting classic novels for the screen with screenwriter Sarah Phelps
(Ref. xi).
Douglas-Fairhurst was subsequently (December 2011) an informal advisor
and on-screen contributor to BBC2's `Mrs Dickens's Family Christmas',
exploring Dickens's early life and the factors that led to the failure of
his marriage. This programme (viewing figures 1.5 million) used Becoming
Dickens as one of its principal research resources, influencing both
the script and the visual style (the claim is corroborated by the
programme's executive producer, Basil Comely (Ref. 3)).
Further advisory work for creative content producers includes the
provision of an original framework for the project `Our Mutual Friends'
undertaken by film production company Film and Video Umbrella (a
commissioning agency and client organisation of Arts Council England) to
accompany a series of specially commissioned artworks connecting Dickens's
legacy with modern social media (see http://www.fvu.co.uk/projects/group-details/our-mutual-friends/).
Steven Boden, director, reports that `Robert was a great supporter and
advisor on the concept': `Our Mutual Friends was a new initiative for us,
and, arguably, one of the first projects of its type to try and integrate
and mobilise social media creatively, rather than just promotionally,
within a conceptual/curatorial framework'; Robert enabled us `to compare
the "dustheaps" of Victorian London that feature in the Dickens novel with
all the digital detritus we accumulate today, and the salon-society social
whirl that embellishes and punctuates the book with the flurry of social
media activity as characterised by the contemporary phenomena of Twitter,
Facebook etc.' (Ref. 4).
Sources to corroborate the impact
Testimony
(1). Email from editor at Harvard UP.
(2). Corroborating email from Producer of Great Expectations,
BBC, 22.3.13.
(3). Email from Executive Producer of Mrs Dickens's Family Christmas,
BBC, 25.3.13.
(4). Email from Director, Film and Video Umbrella, 27.3.13.
Other evidence sources
(i). `Reinvention of biography' quotation: Frances Wilson, Times
Literary Supplement 2 December 2011. http://www.the-tls.co.uk/tls/reviews/other_categories/article833726.ece
(ii). Chandrahas blog: http://middlestage.blogspot.co.uk/2012/02/on-robert-douglas-fairhursts-becoming.html
(iii). `Charles Dickens at 200', Charlie Rose Show, 17 February and
repeated 25 December 2012, with Simon Callow, Salman Rushdie et al., PBS
broadcasting, USA:
http://www.charlierose.com/view/interview/1216
(iv). American reader blogspots: http://page99test.blogspot.co.uk/2011/10/robert-douglas-fairhursts-becoming.html
(v). http://mybookthemovie.blogspot.co.uk/2011/10/robert-douglas-fairhursts-becoming.html
(vi). Smithsonian Magazine: http://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/The-Essentials-Charles-Dickens.html
(vii). http://podularity.com/2011/09/10/robert-douglas-fairhurst-on-becoming-dickens/
(viii). Review of `Why Dickens?' at the Aye Write! literary festival
(Glasgow):
http://glasgowbookgroups.wordpress.com/2012/03/12/becoming-dickens-reviewed-by-lauren
(ix). http://www.somersethouse.org.uk/literature/tales-of-the-thames-a-day-downriver-at-somerset-house
(x). Viewing figures from BARB: http://www.barb.co.uk/viewing/weekly-top-30
for BBC1 week Dec26 — Jan01 2012.
(xi). http://www.foyles.co.uk/Dickens-Day