Log in
The University of Oxford's International Subarachnoid Aneurysm Trial (ISAT) changed clinical practice worldwide by showing that endovascular coiling is a more effective and safer treatment than neurosurgery following subarachnoid haemorrhage, with fewer complications and improved quality of life. Subarachnoid haemorrhages account for 1 in 14 strokes and are caused by bleeding in and around the brain; approximately 85% occur when cerebral aneurysms rupture. ISAT was the first trial to compare neurosurgery, or neuroradiological endovascular coiling in patients with ruptured cerebral aneurysms causing acute subarachnoid haemorrhage.
Impact: Health and welfare; a UK clinical trial of uterine artery embolisation (UAE), with five-year follow-up, defined the risk- and cost-benefit of UAE versus surgery.
Significance: The trial informed guidelines/recommendations internationally and changed clinical practice. Women worldwide can now make an informed choice about their treatment; economic factors have been quantitated.
Beneficiaries: Uterine fibroid patients, the NHS, healthcare providers.
Attribution: G. Murray, UoE, developed and delivered innovative trial methodology; clinical aspects led by University of Glasgow.
Reach: UK guidelines; worldwide (Australia, USA, Europe) effect on clinical practice that will impact up to 25% of women.
The MRC Conventional versus Laparoscopic-Assisted Surgery In Colorectal Cancer trial (CLASICC) is the largest and most successful UK trial of a technology applied to general surgery. It addressed an area of huge clinical uncertainty, providing a rigorous evaluation of a new technology and enabling its safe and widespread implementation. The impact of CLASICC has been global, confirming the advantages for patients (quicker recovery) and healthcare providers (cost-effectiveness) and so influencing national and international policy in favour of the laparoscopic technique. It informed NICE guidance and led to a major DH initiative that has seen the UK become one of the largest providers in the world of laparoscopic colorectal cancer surgery. CLASICC is regarded as a benchmark surgical trial, combining high quality trial design with rigorous quality assurance, which has informed the design of many subsequent colorectal cancer studies.
Three national, multicentre randomised controlled trials and associated studies during a 20-year research programme on abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) led by Imperial College researchers have altered international practice. The United Kingdom Small Aneurysm Trial (UKSAT) set the threshold for intervention at 5.5cm to repair AAAs. Population screening programmes and guidelines in Europe (UK, Sweden and Europe as a whole), Australia and the United States are based on these data. The results from EndoVascular abdominal Aortic Repair (EVAR) trials have informed international audits, guidelines (including NICE) and task forces in the same countries.
Research at UCL firmly established tacrolimus as the optimal calcineurin inhibitor to use in immunosuppressive regimens following liver transplantation. Compared to ciclosporin its use improved graft survival by 6% and patient survival by 7%. Assuming 550 liver transplants per year in the UK since 2008, we can estimate that, with 90% of patients treated with tacrolimus and 10% ciclosporin, tacrolimus-based immunosuppression has resulted in 165 grafts and 192 lives being saved during the period 2008-13.
Neonatal extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) is a complex procedure of life support used in severe but potentially reversible respiratory failure in newborn infants. In 1993 researchers in Leicester carried out the first and, to date, only large-scale randomised trial comparing the value of ECMO with other means of life support. The trial, with follow-up research at 4 and 7-year intervals, has shown ECMO to be a life-saving and cost-effective treatment, and has led to the establishment of a centrally funded neonatal programme that is estimated to have saved around 340 lives in the UK alone. In 2013 the University remains internationally renowned in the field of ECMO research, and since 2009 Glenfield Hospital has been home to the world's largest ECMO centre for the treatment of newborns, older babies and adults. The trial is still held up by advocates of fair clinical trials as an example of how evidence should translate into practice and policy.
University of Bristol researchers at the Bristol Heart Institute (BHI) have pioneered the development and clinical take-up of the novel technique of off-pump coronary artery bypass (OPCAB) surgery. Over ten clinical trials and several large cohort analyses have assessed the impact of this technique on elective and high-risk patients. The results have shown that it is as safe as the conventional coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) technique that uses a cardiopulmonary bypass pump and cardioplegic arrest. Most importantly, however, OPCAB significantly reduces the risk of post-operative complications, and reduces morbidity and mortality. It also uses less hospital resources, reducing time in intensive care and length of hospital stay. In 2011 (the last year for which data are available), 20% of CABG operations in the UK were carried out with the OPCAB technique and it has had significant take-up overseas (for example, 18% of CABG operations in the US and 21% in the EU in 2010). NICE has recommended the safety and efficacy of OPCAB surgery.
Trauma is a rapidly increasing global healthcare problem which is predicted by the World Health Organisation (WHO) to overtake infectious disease globally by 2020. The discovery of the acute coagulopathy of trauma (uncontrolled bleeding) and the subsequent establishment of the clot stabiliser tranexamic acid (TXA) as a treatment for this condition has led to a change in national and international trauma management protocols. British armed forces and the US military implemented the use of the drug soon after the results were published. Every injured British or American soldier now receives this treatment. The use of TXA has been included in national and international guidance for trauma care.
A decade of research at the University of Southampton has given thousands of people around the world suffering from dizziness and balance disorders access to a self-management resource that can alleviate their symptoms. Professor Lucy Yardley has pioneered the use of a Balance Retraining (BR) booklet to transform the means of delivering cost-effective, life-changing treatment previously offered to less than one in ten UK patients. The booklet, translated into several languages, has been distributed to patients and practitioners as far afield as China and Japan. Yardley's findings have contributed the bulk of good quality evidence to the Cochrane Review on vestibular rehabilitation.
Impact: Health and wellbeing; translation of a clear evidence base for reducing red blood cell use in intensive care and surgery into guidelines and changed clinical practice.
Significance: A 20% reduction in overall UK red blood cell usage between 2002-2012, saving the NHS approximately £100M annually; 7000 fewer patients are exposed to red cell transfusion annually, saving 500 lives.
Beneficiaries: Patients in intensive care units; the NHS and healthcare delivery agencies.
Attribution: Studies were led by Walsh at UoE with NHS and Canadian collaborators.
Reach: 7000 patients per year, UK-wide; incorporation into international guidelines.