Parish Matters: The Local and the Making of History
Submitting Institution
University of WarwickUnit of Assessment
HistorySummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Language, Communication and Culture: Literary Studies
History and Archaeology: Historical Studies
Philosophy and Religious Studies: Religion and Religious Studies
Summary of the impact
The Warwick Network for Parish Research (WNPR) was established in 2003 to
facilitate public participation in the making of history, specifically the
production of new historical knowledge about parishes from the Middle Ages
to the present. Parishes were fundamental units of governance, worship,
and everyday life across Europe for over a thousand years, and the primary
resources for family and community historians are archived by their parish
of generation (in 2010/11 5% of the UK population visited a local record
office, 60% of whom were researching family history). WNPR has helped
formulate the place of locality in a globalising world and is a point of
connection between independent researchers, local history societies,
archivists and university-based scholars. It has supported non-academic
historians in exploring their communities past and present, built capacity
for independent research and writing, and encouraged local historians to
contextualise their findings through engagement with wider historical
debates. Impact has been achieved in three principal ways:
-
increasing public understanding of communities as brought
together by links that relate to their locality, heritage, culture and
historical experience;
-
enriching cultural life through the development of
community-based initiatives;
-
creating intellectual and methodological tools for scholarship
and research opportunities among non-academic historians.
Underpinning research
Warwick's Parish Network scholars have undertaken pioneering research
into the social and cultural history of parish communities in early modern
Europe. Exploring local identities, political agency, and the social
dynamics of parish life, they have shown how contemporaries negotiated the
dramatic religious and cultural changes of the `long' Reformation, which
have had repercussions to the present day. Their work is central to the
on-going scholarly re-assessment of `popular' religion, cultural conflict,
political life, social space, commemoration and memorialisation in
sixteenth- to eighteenth-century Europe.
Professor Bernard Capp (1968-present) is a leading scholar of the
cultural, social and religious history of early modern England, notably by
his research into local manifestations of Reformation change. He examined
the rich ecclesiastical court records of Sileby parish (Leicestershire)
from the 1630s to reconstruct the social dynamics of a small community and
the role of gossip in personal and village conflict. When Gossips Meet
(2003) demonstrated the multiple ways in which non-elite women negotiated
patriarchal norms and restrictions and exerted collective pressure on
parish officers through informal networks and gossip, playing a role that
was hitherto unrecognised in community public life. England's Culture
Wars (2012) evaluated the impact and mixed success of the Puritan
Reformation in a variety of local contexts during the Interregnum through
an examination of parish records, demonstrating the importance of local
differences and community structures in this process.
Professor Beat Kümin's (2001-present) research into German-speaking
Europe examined communal organisation, sociability and conviviality in the
early modern period. The Shaping of a Community (1996) emphasised
the growing power of parishes in shaping church practice in the late
medieval era and local impact on Reformation change. He has also explored
the secular dimensions of late medieval parish life, identifying the key
feature of `horizontal' social organisation, the relatively broad level of
political participation and the development of local government expertise
by `ordinary' parishioners. The Communal Age in Western Europe
(2013) offers a new interpretation of the significance of towns, villages
and parishes in the medieval and early modern period: a case-study of the
Swiss parish republic of Gersau shows that local communities empowered
common people with collective agency and a degree of local autonomy.
Republican representation was not an urban prerogative but also existed at
the level of the parish.
Professor Peter Marshall (1994-present) is one of the UK's leading
historians of the English Reformation and has published several seminal
works, with a particular focus on the social and political impacts of
religious change at a local level. Mother Leakey and the Bishop
(2007) employed a micro-history of a local Somerset ghost story to examine
change and continuity in elite and popular rituals, focussing on changing
perceptions of the afterlife, forms of commemoration, and the construction
of community memory. This complemented Beliefs and the Dead in
Reformation England (2002), which explored how the conflicting
messages of the Tudor Reformation changed understandings of identity and
community within a framework of remarkable continuities.
References to the research
Capp, B., `Life, Love and Litigation: Sileby in the 1630s', Past
& Present, 182:1 (2004), 55-83.
Capp, B., England's Culture Wars: Puritan Reformation and its Enemies
in the Interregnum, 1649-1660 (Oxford University Press, 2012).
[REF2]
Kümin, B., `The Secular Legacy of the Late Medieval English Parish', in
C. Burgess and E. Duffy (eds), The Parish in Later Medieval England,
Harlaxton Medieval Studies, XIV (Shaun Tyas, 2006), 95-111 and pl. 1-4.
Kümin, B., The Communal Age in Western Europe c.1100-1800:
Towns, Villages and Parishes in Pre-modern Society (Palgrave, 2013).
Marshall, P., Beliefs and the Dead in Reformation England (Oxford
University Press, 2002).
Marshall, P., Mother Leakey and the Bishop: A Ghost Story (Oxford
University Press, 2007; pbk. edn, 2008).
Evidence of quality:
All publications have been peer-reviewed and favourably reviewed in
academic and/or popular media. Beliefs and the Dead was described
as `one of the most powerful and persuasive accounts of the cultural
impact of the English Reformation yet written (Times Literary
Supplement, 21 May 2004) while Mother Leakey was judged `as
fine an example of microhistory as is likely to be written' (Craig Harline
in Church History and Religious Culture) and featured as a `Pick
of the Paperbacks' in the Sunday Times (19 October 2008). England's
Culture Wars was deemed `a highly significant work which greatly
aids our understanding of godly reformation ... a "must read" for all
scholars of the period' (Reviews in History, review no. 1346,
November 2012).
Research Awards:
Bernard Capp
British Academy Research Grant, `The War of Two Cultures: Godly
Reformation and its Enemies in England 1649-60', 2003-04, £3,614.
Beat Kümin
British Academy Research Grant, `"Above us only sky": The Swiss Parish
Republic of Gersau c.1500-1800', 2011-13, £7,284.
Alfried Krupp Wissenschaftskolleg (Greifswald/Germany) Senior Research
Fellowship, `Communal Culture, Communal Power: Parishes in the Holy Roman
Empire', 2012-13, €35,000.
Peter Marshall
Leverhulme Trust Research Fellowship, `Heretics and Believers: A New
History of the English Reformation', 2012-13, £28,146.
AHRB Research Leave, `The Return of Mother Leakey: Ghosts and Stories in
Early Modern Britain and Ireland', 2005-06, £10,510.
Details of the impact
WNPR has highlighted the significance of parish records and, by drawing
attention to new intellectual and methodological tools, has encouraged
local historians to uncover, interpret and communicate the heritage of
their local community or parish. It has prompted members of the general
public to connect with their past and to use local history as a means of
interrogating social and cultural issues which have relevance today.
Since 2003 the annual Warwick Symposium on Parish Research has provided a
forum for knowledge exchange between academics and independent
researchers. Supported by a University Impact Award in November 2011 and
held in collaboration with the British Association for Local History,
attendance figures have tripled in recent years, culminating in the 2012
weekend showcase event, which attracted over 120 delegates (representing
archivists, community groups, local history societies, conservation
bodies, church groups and academics). The Symposium gives non-academics an
opportunity to present their work to large audiences and to discuss local
history projects and new developments in parish research. The new
relationships forged through these events have facilitated the exchange of
knowledge and skills between `amateur' and `professional' historians. The
opportunity to interact with others engaged in parish research was
highlighted as particularly important by independent researchers: it
brought the benefits of `fresh approaches for my own work' and `much more
awareness of the broad range of parish research, useful contacts made or
renewed, and useful feedback on my talk'. In post-event feedback after the
Tenth Anniversary Symposium (25-27.05.12), 54% of non-academic respondents
stated that their study of the parish had been enhanced by dialogue with
fellow researchers. Responding to a request made in the concluding panel
discussion at the 2012 Symposium, the Network collaborated with two local
history societies to host the 2013 Parish Symposium in Berkswell,
Warwickshire (25.05.13). It attracted a capacity audience of 87
(predominantly non-academic) and further extended the WNPR's reach, with
69% of participants attending the Symposium for the first time.
My-Parish.org (launched November 2012) is a public and community resource
linking WNPR scholars with local historians, history societies and
community groups. It showcases research, forges collaborations, and
highlights the range of rich source materials available for parish and
community history, art, heritage and culture. Since its launch the website
has been visited by 3,928 users across the world, with the highest numbers
from the UK, US, Germany, and China. Total page views to July 31st are
14,444. Resources made available include an extensive bibliography of
printed primary and secondary works in several languages, research guides,
audio and visual materials and digitised archival sources. These provide
independent researchers with a broad range of new tools for conducting and
extending the scope of their work. In 1,907 views of the `Parish Research'
page (since November 2012) the most used sections were the bibliographies
and digital parish sources, sections which provide basic tools for new
researchers. Bibliographic tools have developed amateur historians'
background knowledge, access to information and understanding of local
histories. My-Parish users praised the `excellent bibliography' as `the
most useful part of the website'. The My-Parish forum has fostered closer
connections between individuals and groups engaged in research. Its users
acknowledge the benefits of communication and increased awareness of
others' research: `It is useful to know what is going on elsewhere ... As
someone living in Warwickshire but on the edge of Leicestershire I do feel
that local history can get compartmentalised into counties and so I miss
interesting links and connections.'
Through our research into parish life, we have stimulated wider public
interest in the heritage of local communities and increased public
knowledge of local history. Capps' Past & Present article
(2004) prompted the Sileby Local History Group to pursue its own local
research into ecclesiastical court records. The Chair of the group
commented that the article formed `the backbone of research for early
seventeenth-century Sileby'. Via public talks the researchers have engaged
diverse audiences, including local history societies, community groups and
schools throughout the UK and Europe, particularly in Northamptonshire,
Warwickshire and Worcestershire. In September 2008, Marshall addressed
National Trust volunteers and the general public at Coughton Court on the
Throckmorton family's influence on the local Reformation. Kümin delivered
a talk in October 2010 to the Kineton Local History Group on its parish
history, described by the audience as `accessible' and `extremely
interesting', leaving them `hungry for more'. Network members have also
worked actively with local history groups to produce genuinely
collaborative works of public history: Kümin was invited to direct the
steering committee for a history of the Parish of St Mary Immaculate
(Warwick). Published in 2009, the book Catholic Warwick was
launched with a public panel debate involving Kümin and Marshall, and
attended by 50 parishioners. Available in local bookstores and the parish
church, several hundred copies have gone in to circulation. Kümin's
research on communal self-reflection in Gersau, Switzerland, prompted
district authorities to approve his proposal for bicentenary events
celebrating the restoration of a parish republic in 1814 and to invite him
onto the planning committee. As historical consultant, he helped design
events that will give local residents the opportunity to commemorate their
unique past and to reflect on its relevance for contemporary issues, such
as centralisation and globalisation.
The WNPR's research has reached large audiences through broadcast and
print media. Capp acted as a specialist expert for the popular BBC 1
series Who Do You Think You Are, appearing in episode 5, series 6
(02.03.09; audience 6 million), and also contributed to BBC 4's Roundhead
or Cavalier (15.05.12). Marshall appeared in two episodes of
Channels 4's Gods and Monsters, attracting a viewing audience of
880,000 (03.12.11). The significance of Marshall's research is evidenced
by invited contributions to BBC Radio 3 programmes: `The Enduring Appeal
of Angels', Nightwaves (18.03.10) and `William Byrd and
Catholicism', Twenty Minutes (05.12.12). Marshall presented an
edition of the BBC Radio 4 series The Essay, which examined Henry
VIII's relationship with God (06.04.10). Marshall wrote articles for the
popular magazines History Today (readership c. 50,000): `Sex,
Scandal and the Supernatural' (vol. 52, issue 2, 2007) and BBC History
Magazine (readership c. 70,000) `The Ghost that Convicted the
Bishop' (vol. 8, issue 2, 2007).
Through connecting independent researchers and local history societies
with academic scholarship, the WNPR has stimulated the use of new
archival, bibliographical and research materials, has broadened knowledge
of methodological approaches and historical perspectives to local history,
and suggested new visions of a community past.
Sources to corroborate the impact
My-Parish online community and resources:
http://my-parish.org Google Analytics
Report
Warwick Symposium for Parish Research 2012, post-symposium participant
feedback.
Local media coverage of the launch of Catholic Warwick: `Warwick
Catholic History Investigated', Leamington Spa Courier, 16.11.09.
Email correspondence between Sileby Local History Society and Bernard
Capp.
Swiss media coverage of Kümin's role in Gersau's bicentenary
celebrations; `Ich bezeichne Gersau als Extremfall', Bote der
Urschweiz, 30.08.12.
Gersau District Council Minutes, June 2012, recording bicentenary
approval and funding.
Public Talks:
Beat Kümin, `Development of a Parish': a public talk to Kineton and
District Local History Group,
October 2010 (http://www.kinetonhistory.co.uk/?s=beat+kumin).
Peter Marshall, `The Catholic Gentry in English Society': public talk at
Throckmorton Literary
Festival, September 2008
http://www.spaghettigazetti.com/2008/08/throckmorton-literary-festival-at.html
Media:
Marshall, BBC Radio 3 Twenty Minutes: a discussant on `William
Byrd and Catholicism', 05.03.10
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01cvp35
Bernard Capp, BBC 1 Who Do You Think You Are, 02.03.09
http://www.bbc.co.uk/whodoyouthinkyouare/how-we-did-it/kevin-whately/how-we-did-it-4.shtml
(BARB audience figure, 6 million)