PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT AND POLICY FORMATION RELATED TO CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION BY INDIVIDUALS
Submitting Institution
University of EdinburghUnit of Assessment
Earth Systems and Environmental SciencesSummary Impact Type
SocietalResearch Subject Area(s)
Built Environment and Design: Other Built Environment and Design
Economics: Applied Economics
Summary of the impact
Impacts: I) Enhanced public engagement with, and understanding of,
climate mitigation by
individuals, delivered through two successful popular science publications
and sustained bodies of
media and outreach work. II) Public policy formation related to climate
change mitigation.
Significance and reach: Impacts of the popular science books
include >5,500 sales of a children's
book (2009 - 2011) and documented household-level behaviour changes in
energy usage. The
European Commission issued new directives on energy saving appliances in
December 2008.
Underpinned by: Research into the role of individuals in climate
change mitigation, undertaken at
the University of Edinburgh (2001 onwards).
Underpinning research
Numbered references refer to research outputs in Section 3.
Key researchers
The start and end dates of continuous employment in the School of
GeoSciences, University of
Edinburgh, are shown along with the most recent / current position of each
researcher.
Reay, Reader in Carbon Management (2001 onwards)
Grace, Professor (1970 - 2010; 2013 onwards)
Research overview and context
Research led by Reay at the University of Edinburgh (2001 onwards) has
investigated the climate
change mitigation potentials of individuals, both as a function of
differing lifestyles and within
specific sectors. This work builds upon pre-2001 research by Reay that
documented the potential
for greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reductions at the household level
equivalent to that aimed at
by all Annex 1 nations within the UNFCCC's Kyoto Protocol (5% by 2008-2012
on a 1990
baseline). This foundational work demonstrated that such a reduction was
relatively straightforward
for the average developed-world household, with emissions reductions in
the energy use and
transport sectors being especially significant and attractive.
Key research findings that underpin the subsequent impact
An influential study by Reay, published in 2002, assessed the climate
change mitigation potential
and financial costs/benefits of `climate aware' and `climate ignorant'
lifestyles [1]. The study has
also gone on to be reproduced in book chapter form in a Royal Society
volume [2]. This work
established that emission cuts of >80% for the domestic sector were
possible via behavioural
changes and increased energy efficiency, providing a developed world cut
in total emissions from
all sectors of approximately 30%. The household-level emission cuts
detailed in the research could
also be achieved at negative net cost to the individual, with a `climate
aware' lifestyle accruing
savings of approximately £80k (net present value) over the course of a
lifetime [1,2,3].
Reay has also investigated climate change mitigation by individuals in
specific sectors, including
transport, technology, agriculture and waste. Work co-authored by Reay and
Grace in 2006
focussed on the transport sector and the relationship of emissions with
household income [4],
identifying a strong correlation between income and transport emissions.
Co-authored work by
Reay has also examined the role of technology in mitigating emissions
from the transport sector,
identifying the potential of virtual meetings to significantly reduce
business travel emissions [2]. In
the agriculture sector, Reay was a lead author for the European Nitrogen
Assessment (2008-2011),
investigating the potential for, and barriers to, reductions in nitrogen
wastage and nitrous
oxide emissions through behavioural change [5]. This research
identified the need for more
stakeholder-specific policy and public communication in order to engender
behavioural change.
Associated work by Reay has addressed climate change mitigation through
dietary choice and
reduced food wastage and led to a landmark assessment, published in Nature
Climate Change in
2011, revealing that reductions in meat consumption and in food wastage by
consumers can
provide substantial emissions savings both within the UK and globally [6].
References to the research
Comments in bold on individual outputs give information on the quality of
the underpinning
research and may include the number of citations (Scopus, up to September
2013) and/or the 2012
Thomson Reuters Journal Impact Factor (JIF). The starred outputs best
indicate this quality.
[1]* Peer-reviewed journal article, JIF: 2.9
Reay, D.S. (2002) `Costing climate change', Philosophical Transactions
of the Royal Society
Series A 360 (1801), 2947-2962, DOI: 10.1098/rsta.2002.1063
[2] Peer-reviewed book chapter based on output [1]
Reay, D.S. (2007) `The Price of Climate Change', chapter in P. R. Sammonds
and J. M. T.
Thompson (eds.), Royal Society Series on Advances in Earth Science.
From Earthquakes to
Global Warming. London: Imperial College Press, ISBN:
978-1860947629, available upon request.
[3] Peer-reviewed journal article (Houston was an MSc student at
Edinburgh, 2008 - 2009)
Houston, K., and Reay, D.S. (2011) `The impact of ICT on greenhouse gas
emissions: how green
are virtual worlds?', Carbon Management 2(6), 629-643, DOI:
10.4155/cmt.11.62
[4] Peer-reviewed journal article (Korbetis was an MRes student at
Edinburgh, 2005 - 2006)
Korbetis, M., Reay, D.S., and Grace, J. (2006) `New directions: rich in
CO2', Atmospheric
Environment 40 (17), 3219-3220, DOI: 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2006.01.032
[5]* Peer-reviewed chapter in the European Nitrogen Assessment with
Reay as lead author
Reay, D.S., Clare Howard, Albert Bleeker, Pete Higgins, Keith Smith, Henk
Westhoek, Trudy
Rood, Mark Theobald, Alberto Sanz Cobeña, Bob Rees, Dominic Moran, Stefan
Reis (2011)
Societal choice and communicating the European nitrogen challenge.
In: European Nitrogen
Assessment, Cambridge University Press. 26, 586- 601, http://www.clrtap-tfrn.org/webfm_send/334.
[6]* Peer-reviewed journal article, >10 citations in one year, JIF:
14.5
Reay, D. S., Davidson, E.A., Smith, K., Smith, P., Melillo, J.M.,
Dentener, F., and Crutzen, P.J.
2012) `Global agriculture and nitrous oxide emissions', Nature Climate
Change 2, 410-416, DOI:
10.1038/nclimate1458
A further metric of research quality is given by the peer-reviewed
knowledge transfer grant that
contributed to the preceding outputs: ClimateWatchers (Interactive
exhibit on individual action on
climate change) (2005), sponsor: National Science Week Award,
Research Councils UK, value:
£2k, awarded to Reay.
Details of the impact
Lettered references relate to corroboration sources in Section 5.
Enhanced public engagement with, and understanding of, climate
mitigation by individuals
Pathway: One pathway arises through the continuing popularity and
influence of the Climate
Change Begins at Home book [A], much of the content of which
is underpinned by the work
encapsulated in research output [1], Section 3. First published in 2005,
the impacts of the book
over the period January 2008 — July 2013 include continuing sales and the
commissioning of Reay
by Macmillan to write a popular book for children on climate change
mitigation by individuals,
entitled Your Planet Needs You!, which was published in 2009
jointly by the Science Museum [B].
Over the same period Reay has also delivered a wide range of public
lectures and media pieces.
Significance and reach:
- Although the majority of the >7,500 to-date sales of Climate
Change Begins at Home
occurred 2005 - 2007, it has continued to sell >250 copies over the
period January 2008 — June
2010 [A]. That Climate Change Begins at Home has
translated directly into
household-level changes in behaviour is exemplified in the 2011 case
study of the Cayley
Family, as presented on the 10:10 Global website. They say: `We're
tackling this as a
family, and we're always searching for new ways to cut carbon
together. We aren't
extremists by any account, but I really do believe that individuals
can make an impact by
making simple changes day by day. We've been using Dave Reay's
'Climate Change
Begins at Home', a really entertaining read, to see what we can do.'
[C].
-
Your Planet Needs You! sold over 5,000 copies in its first year
(2009) and continued to sell
over 600 copies in 2010 [B]. The book has been widely praised in
the print and broadcast
media, for example on The Hour (STV, June 2009) [D].
- Between January 2008 and July 2013, Reay gave 35 public lectures,
school and science
festival talks (including three British Council events), reaching the
UK, Mexico and the
Philippines.
- Several of the research outputs cited in Section 3 have also gained
considerable media
attention. For example, the work published in 2011 on dietary choice and
food wastage ([6],
Section 3) has received widespread popular media coverage (including
ITV.com,
Independent, Metro and International Business Times, combined
circulation 18million) [E].
The study was described by the UK Government's Chief Scientist as `a
really intriguing
study and very important' [F].
Public policy formation related to climate change mitigation
Pathway: Reay's research into the role of individuals in climate
change mitigation has led to his
establishment as an expert advisor to government on these issues. For
example, research-led
evidence given by Reay was cited six times in the UK Government's House of
Commons
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Select Committee on `Climate
Change: the citizens' agenda'
(2006 - 2007) [G] and the resultant recommendations for reducing
emissions from lighting and
stand-by power were adopted in December 2008 European Commission
directives [H]. Reay's
work on climate change communication and mitigation has also been
recognised directly by
several MPs and MSPs over the period 2008 — July 2013.
Significance and reach:
- The UK Government response to Climate Change: the citizens' agenda
confirmed that
proposals would be developed and supported under the Eco-Design of
Energy-Using
Products (EuP) framework directive to restrict standby power usage for
most appliances to
2 watts within one year, and 1 watt within three years, such that the
impact extends into the
period 2008 - 2010 [G]. The European Commission regulations
based on these proposals
came into force across the EU in 2009 [H].
- The influence within UK and Scottish Government of Reay's research is
illustrated by the
following statements (both made in 2011). The MP for Edinburgh North and
Leith, Member
of Environmental Audit Committee and Prime Minister's Special
Representative on Global
Carbon Trading (2008 - 2010) said: `Dave Reay's work on climate
change communication
and individual action has made a substantive impact over several
years. His advice on
climate change to MPs such as myself has helped to inform policy
recommendations and to
enhance understanding of climate change by the public and politicians
alike.' [I]. The MSP
for Glasgow and Co-Convener of the Scottish Green Party said: `As
Scotland's Climate
Change Act worked its way through Parliament [ed: this occurred in
2009], it was vital to
raise the awareness of climate science and its implications among
MSPs. It was only with a
good degree of cross party involvement and continual pressure from
outside of politics, that
we ended up with a strong Act and world-leading CO2
targets. Dave Reay's work on climate
change communication and individual action has made a substantive
impact during that
period and since.' [J].
Sources to corroborate the impact
Where two web-links are given, the first is the primary source and the
second an archived version.
[A] Climate Change Begins at Home
Reay, D.S. (2005) Climate Change Begins at Home, Macmillan, 203pp,
ISBN: 978-1403945785.
The quoted primary sales figures are from Macmillan Publishers Ltd,
Houndmills, Basingstoke,
Hampshire, RG21 6XS.
[B] Your Planet Needs You!
Reay, D.S. (June 2009), Your Planet Needs You!, Macmillan
Children's Books, 176pp,
ISBN: 978-0330450959. The quoted primary sales figures (January 2009 —
December 2010, with
total sales over that time of 5,674) are from Palgrave Macmillan Ltd,
address as for [A].
[C] "Shrinking A Family Footprint", a 10:10 report (June 2011)
http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-XC
or http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-C
Evidences household-level behaviour change resulting from `Climate Change
Begins at Home'.
[D] The Hour TV programme on `Your Planet Needs You!' (STV, June 2009
and on-line)
http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-XD
Evidence of mainstream media coverage for `Your Planet Needs
You!'. STV has an audience of >4M TV viewers per month and 3.2M
digital viewers.
[E] Selected May 2012 media coverage on food wastage research
Wasted Milk causes carbon footprint equivalent to `thousands of cars'
(ITV.com)
http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-XE1
or http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-E1
Drink your milk: waste is equal to gas emissions from 20,000 cars (Independent)
http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-XE2
or http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-E2
Waste milk creates excess CO2, says research (International Business
Times)
http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-XE3
or http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-E3
Drinking your milk instead of pouring it down the sink can save the planet
(Metro)
http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-XE4
or http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-E4
Provides evidence of the widespread reach of the coverage of Reay's work,
in this example
research output [6], Section 3. The quoted on-line circulation figures are
from a Meltwater News
search, results of which are available upon request.
[F] Factual statement from the UK government Chief Scientist
Provides corroboration of the quote in Section 4 and distribution within
Government of the work.
[G] House of Commons Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee.
Climate Change:
the "citizen's agenda". Eighth Report of Session 2006 -
07, Volume 1 (July 2007)
http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-XG
or http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-G
Evidences I) Reay's advisory role to the
government on issues regarding the role of individuals in climate change
mitigation (Pages 8, 11,
12, 21, 29, 30, 41, 42, 64 and 66) and II) proposals to be developed and
supported under the Eco-Design
of Energy-Using Products (EuP) framework directive (Page 31).
[H] European Commission Regulation Document No 1275/2008 (December
2008)
http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-XH
or http://tinyurl.com/B7-2-S5-H
Evidences the adoption of proposals to restrict standby power usage for
most appliances by the
European Commission (Regulation No. 1275/2008) following the citizen's
agenda report [G] and
the Eco-Design of Energy-Using Products framework directive.
[I] Factual Statement from the MP for Edinburgh North and Leith
(September 2011)
Provides corroboration of the quote given in Section 4. The MP is also a
member of the
Environmental Audit Committee; Prime Minister's Special Representative on
Global Carbon
Trading (2008 - 2010) and Chair of the Edinburgh Community Energy
Cooperative.
[J] Factual Statement from the MSP for Glasgow / Co-Convener of the
Scottish Green Party
(June 2011) Provides corroboration of the quote given in Section 4.