Changing Understanding of British Land Art
Submitting Institution
University of NottinghamUnit of Assessment
Art and Design: History, Practice and TheorySummary Impact Type
CulturalResearch Subject Area(s)
Studies In Creative Arts and Writing: Visual Arts and Crafts
History and Archaeology: Curatorial and Related Studies, Historical Studies
Summary of the impact
Nicholas Alfrey's work has led to a reassessment of modern British art of
the 1960s and 1970s
concerned with landscape and the environment. This has been achieved
through his curatorship of
exhibitions at the Djanogly Art Gallery, Nottingham (2009) and at
Southampton Art Gallery, the
latter under the aegis of Arts Council England (2013), and their
subsequent press reception. Alfrey
has selected work for these exhibitions by leading British artists never
before displayed and he has
therefore increased the visibility of this material. Through his
activities, the dominance of American
Land Art has been questioned. In a related strand of activity, Alfrey's
Land Art Network, funded by
the AHRC, has initiated a dialogue between different generations of
contemporary artists and
created new networks and interaction between art historians, museum and
gallery curators, artists
and writers. The careers of individual artists, notably Katie Paterson,
have been transformed by
their participation in the Network. The institutions concerned have
thereby invested and promoted
Land Art as part of their exhibition strategy, which has been linked to
Arts Council England's
historic promotion of British Land Art and the more recent revival of
Southampton Art Gallery.
Underpinning research
The underpinning research for Alfrey's work on landscape and geography
concerns the use of
cartography by land artists, and it addresses the relationship between
Land Art, the British
landscape tradition and the cultures of geographical locations such as
Exmoor and Dartmoor.
Alfrey joined the University of Nottingham in 1977, where he is currently
Associate Professor, and
this phase of his research began in the early 1990s. He laid its
foundations in two exhibitions that
he curated or co-curated, Mapping the Landscape at the Djanogly
Art Gallery, Nottingham (1993),
and Art of the Garden (Alfrey with Stephen Daniels and Martin
Postle) at Tate Britain (2004) (3.1).
More recently, his research has been delivered through the meetings and
events held by the
Land Art Network that he set up in 2006 with AHRC funding, working in
collaboration with Dr Joy
Sleeman (Slade School of Fine Art). The Network set out to explore how and
why landscape
became the focus of innovatory practice in the 1960s and it has aimed to
stimulate the renewal of
interest in it amongst contemporary artists. Alfrey brought the longer,
historical perspective to the
research, situating Land Art in relation to the romantic tradition.
Sleeman's contribution was more
exclusively focused on contemporary practice.
This has led to two exhibitions, the first being Earth-Moon-Earth
at the Djanogly Art Gallery,
Nottingham (June-August 2009) which drew on the idea that the moon was a
context in which
Land art might be understood (3.2). This was a stepping-stone to a more
ambitious proposal,
Uncommon Ground. Land Art in Britain 1966-1979 which was accepted
for funding by Arts Council
England and opened at Southampton Art Gallery (May-August 2013). Beyond
the current REF
period it will travel to the National Museum of Wales, Cardiff; the Mead
Art Gallery, University of
Warwick; and the Longside Gallery at Yorkshire Sculpture Park (2013-14).
It is the first
comprehensive historical exhibition of British Land Art (3.3).
A key publication has been written in collaboration between Alfrey and
Sleeman (3.4), and they
are joint curators (with Tufnall) of the Arts Council exhibition (3.3).
Other strands of their research
have helped document Land Art through a series of interviews with key
artists. One with David
Lamelas and Katie Paterson formed the basis of the Earth-Moon-Earth
catalogue (3.2). This
material was further developed when Alfrey and other members of the
Network made a significant
contribution to the Landscape and Environment conference at Tate in June
2010 (3.5). The
proceedings were published online in Tate Papers (3.6) an issue
co-edited by Alfrey with Professor
Stephen Daniels (Director of the AHRC Landscape and Environment Programme,
the larger
context for the Network).
Subsequently, Alfrey was invited to contribute to the exhibition Verstand
und Gefül. Landschaft
und die zeitgenössische Romantik (Springhornhof, Neuenkirchen,
2013), indicating the
international reach of this research project.
References to the research
A. Curating. Exhibitions in national institutions with international
reputations, with
accompanying catalogues
(1). Art of the Garden, curated by Nicholas Alfrey, Stephen
Daniels and Martin Postle, Tate Britain,
London (3 June-30 August, 2004). Reviewed in the Observer (6 June
2004); Daily Telegraph (9
June 2004); London Review of Books (8 July 2004). The catalogue is
available on request. For
the exhibition see http://www.tate.org.uk/whats-on/tate-britain/exhibition/art-garden.
(2). Earth-Moon-Earth, curated by Nicholas Alfrey and Joy
Sleeman, Djanogly Art Gallery,
Nottingham (20 June-9 August, 2009). An exhibition portfolio which
contains the exhibition
catalogue is included in REF2.
(3). Uncommon Ground. Land Art in Britain 1966-1979, Arts Council
Touring Exhibition curated by
Nicholas Alfrey, Ben Tufnell, and Joy Sleeman, Southampton Art Gallery (10
May 3 August
2013). It will later be shown outside the current REF period at National
Museum of Wales,
Cardiff (28 September 2013-5 January 2014); Mead Art Gallery, University
of Warwick (18
January-6 March 2014); Longside Gallery, Yorkshire Sculpture Park (5
April-15 June 2014).
Reviewed in The Independent, 11 May 2013; Daily Telegraph,
20 May 2013; Art Monthly; June
2013), Financial Times (11 June 2013), see 5.1. The catalogue is
included in REF2. For the
exhibition as an event see http://www.artscouncilcollection.org.uk/showExhibition.do?id=274.
B. Peer-reviewed essays
(4). (with Joy Sleeman), 'Framing the outdoors: landscape and Land Art in
Britain, 1973-77' essay
in Studies in the History of Gardens and Designed Landscapes, 29,
Nos 1-2, 2009, pp. 83-94.
DOI: 10.1080/14601170701807054. Included in REF2.
C. Funding
(7). Grant title: Land Art and the Culture of Landscape, 1967-1977.
Principal investigator: Nicholas
Alfrey. Sponsor: AHRC. PI report graded 'outstanding' (ref. NWLE/ PID
Number: 8012/ AID
Number. 120840). Period of the grant: 01/10/2006 to 31/10/2008. Value:
£27,760. Document
available on request (5.1).
Details of the impact
The activity described here builds on Alfrey's career-long interaction
with British artists and
photographers, the British landscape tradition, and national galleries and
museums. The AHRC
network that he founded and in which he was Principal Investigator (5.1),
as described above,
allowed him to develop these links into a sustained collaboration between
participants in the
Network (Sleeman, Tufnell., Lamelas, Paterson, etc.) This generated a
critical reconsideration
of the production, display and reception of Land Art in Britain. The
network also created an
opportunity for contemporary engagement with the same material,
stimulating new artistic practice
and the re-staging of seminal work by David Lamelas from the late 1960s
(5.2).
Exhibitions curated by Alfrey at Djanogly Gallery, Nottingham (1993,
2009), Tate Britain (with
Daniels and Martin Postle, 2004) and Arts Council England (with Sleeman
and Tufnell, 2013)
increased the visibility of modern British art concerned with landscape
and the
environment. This visibility can be measured most recently through
the press reception for
Uncommon Ground (5.3). Richard Cork, writing in the Financial
Times (11 June 2013), said that
the exhibition 'proves that Land art can be made in an inexhaustible
variety of settings. The sense
of freedom is exhilarating at every turn' (5.3). This press attention
reflects a demonstrable
breakthrough for an area of art practice that has previously not always
been easily accessible to
many viewers, and forms part of a wider critical assessment of Land Art in
which Alfrey's work has
played a pivotal role.
This critical reassessment can be demonstrated by widespread engagement
from the press (both
broadsheet and art historical), focussing on the new and comprehensive
definition of Land Art
that has been brought to public attention: Charles Darwent, in a
review of Uncommon Ground
(Independent, 11 May 2013), admitted to having dismissed British
Land Art as long ago as 2003
but added that that the exhibition showed that he was wrong to have done
so (5.3). The most
nuanced discussion of the issues involved was made by Andrew Wilson in The
Burlington
Magazine (August, 2013) who wrote that the exhibition raises 'the
problem of defining what Land
Art might mean in British art of the 1960s and 1970s' (5.3). Mark Hudson
in the Daily Telegraph
(20 May 2013) found that 'The message of this survey of British land art —
the most comprehensive
to date — is that the British variant...was not only more domestically
scaled, but a lot quirkier than
its American counterpart' (5.3).
Alfrey's national profile and Network was a catalyst for the display or
re-staging of rarely or never
seen art from the 1960s. In the case of some established artists,
his research has led a critical
reassessment of their contribution in the 1960s. Impromptu exhibitions
were arranged by the
Network and in them the artists themselves led the discussion, among them
was John Hilliard who
presented his little-known landscape work of the 1960s (5.1). This led to
its display for the first time
in Alfrey's exhibition Uncommon Ground (3.3). Paul Carey-Kent
wrote in Art Monthly (June 2013)
that 'What struck me most...was the amount of relatively unfamiliar work
[in the exhibition]' (5.3).
Another key event was the 're-performance' of a seminal film made in 1969
by David Lamelas (one
of the pioneering figures in conceptual art) at the Camden Arts Centre and
at the National Film
Theatre in 2009 (5.2).
Alfrey's research and related exhibitions and network activities have
been instrumental in
inspiring and supporting new artistic practice. This was stimulated
by the bringing together of
artists originally associated with Land Art with those working with
aspects of its legacy. Emerging
artists who participated in the Land Art Network were thereby brought into
direct contact with
established practitioners. These can be defined in three groups. The first
contained key figures
from among the original protagonists, in particular John Hilliard, Bruce
McLean, and David
Lamelas. The second included Garry Fabian Miler (b. 1957) and other
artists who emerged at the
end of the 1970s who showed their work in relation to that of the first
generation of Land artists in
Uncommon Ground (2013). The third was represented by a much younger
artist, Katie Paterson
(b. 1981) who shared the Earth-Moon-Earth exhibition in Nottingham
(2009) with Lamelas (b.
1946) (3.2, 5.4). Paterson participated in a discussion session at the
Slade which led to her
collaboration with Alfrey on the exhibition Earth-Moon-Earth, and,
in turn, to her re-creation of an
installation for it (3.2). Her work was subsequently represented by the
Haunch of Venison Gallery,
whose former curator (Tufnell) has been a key figure in the Network (5.1):
'meeting Ben
Tufnell...led on to me being represented by Haunch of Venison the best
gallery that I have ever
worked with' (5.5). Her current visibility can be measured in a piece by
Brian Dillon in The
Guardian (6 April 2012) which discusses Earth-Moon-Earth as
a key early work (5.6).This activity
would not have happened without the fertile environment created through
Alfrey's long association
with British landscape art, its practitioners and gallerists, and the AHRC
Network. The ensuing
dialogue cut across assumptions about historical and contemporary
practice. It also created space
for a new dialogue and sharing of knowledge between generations.
The network also led to ideas being shared across different
professional boundaries through
interaction between these artists, art historians, museum and gallery
curators, publishers and
writers. These came from a range of organizations including universities,
museums, commercial
galleries and small presses (5.1, 5.7). Amongst them were participants
from Tate Britain (Andrew
Wilson); the Henry Moore Institute and the Yorkshire Sculpture Park (Jon
Wood); galleries in the
private sector, notably the Haunch of Venison (Ben Tufnell) as well as
independent critics and
writers such as Patrick Eyres (Managing Editor and publisher, New Arcadian
Press). Many of these
meetings involved presentations by participants or invited keynote
speakers (5.1, 5.7). Crucially,
installations of work by new and emerging artists such as Susan Collins,
Simon Faithfull and
Rebecca Birch, who were not themselves part of the Network, were
arranged and discussed
through its activities (5.1).
Alfrey has made British Land Art accessible to a range of audiences
beyond a specialist art
historical community through public programme activity:
- Amongst the activities generated by Earth-Moon-Earth in 2009
(attendance of 3,000) was a
'Space Week' involving local primary and secondary schools as well as
staff from the science
departments at the university of Nottingham (5.8). The total number of
school children
attending was 288 with 35 adults (5.8). The activities were seen as
crucial in the way the
university connects to the regional community.
- The 're-performance' by the Network of a seminal film made in 1969 by
David Lamelas at the
Camden Arts Centre (not ticketed) and at the National Film Theatre
(ticketed), made this
material accessible to core members of these institutions' audiences
(5.2).
- Feedback from the Re-visiting Land Art Symposium held at the
University of Southampton (11
May 2013), described how many participants had been stimulated to find
out more about Land
Art, and to think about issues to do with the environment (5.9).
- After seeing the exhibition, feedback from an Adult Study Day at Uncommon
Ground on 20
July 2013 changed the way some participants thought about Land Art, and
helped them
recognise an identifiable British Land Art (5.9). One respondent
wrote that the experience had
"provoked participation among participants. It has also made me start
thinking about the use of
imagination in the changes to landscape and urban settings" (5.9).
Arts Council investment in Uncommon Ground, and its decision to
let the exhibition be staged first
in Southampton, is evidence that Alfrey has contributed to the decision by
a major national
institution to promote Land Art as part of its exhibition strategy
(5.10) Furthermore, the
exhibition is part of a revival of Southampton Art Gallery and recognition
of its outstanding
collection of Land Art. The Education Pack created by the Arts Council for
the exhibition (5.11)
shows its commitment to the value of this material for a wide audience. In
addition, the exhibition
complements the Arts Council's historic promotion of Land Art in its own
collection, as described in
the catalogue (3.3, pp. 108-109). The decision of the John Hansard Gallery
at the University of
Southampton to present the exhibition Robert Smithson and Nancy Holt:
England and Wales 1969
(10 May-17 August 2013) alongside the exhibition at the City Art Gallery,
suggests the ripple effect
of Alfrey's and Sleeman's work (5.9).
Sources to corroborate the impact
- AHRC, Networks and Workshops, Final FEC Report: Land Art and the
Culture of Landscape,
1967-1977, 29 September 2009, ref. NWLE/ PID Number: 8012/ AID Number.
120840
(available on file).
-
Environments Reversal Revisited: A project to revisit the 1969
Camden exhibition with David
Lamelas and Ivor Abrahams in collaboration with Jayne Wilton dedicated
to the
groundbreaking work of Peter Carey. Curated by Joy Sleeman and
Nicholas Alfrey, Camden
Arts Centre, 2009 (22 page booklet documenting the event, available on
file)
- Press reception of Uncommon Ground. Land Art in Britain 1966-1979
(dossier available on file)
- Interview with David Lamelas by Fay Nicolson, Nottingham Visual Arts,
8 July 2009. URL:,
http://www.nottinghamvisualarts.net/articles/200907/outside-frame-interview-david-lamelas
(pdf
available on file)
- Statement by Katie Paterson, 26 September 2013 (available on file)
- Brian Dillon, 'Katie Paterson, the cosmicomical artist', The
Guardian (6 April 2012). URL
http://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2012/apr/06/katie-paterson-cosmicomical-artist
(pdf
available on file)
- Landscape and Environment website. URL:
(http://www.landscape.ac.uk/landscape/research/networksworkshops/landartandthecultureoflandscape%2c1967-77.aspx) (pdf available on file)
- Documentation for 'Space Week' at Lakeside Arts Centre, 2009 (dossier
on file)
- Public engagement events connected to Uncommon Ground at
Southampton Art Gallery,
including gallery questionnaires, an adult workshop (20 July 2013), and
the Re-visiting Land Art
symposium, University of Southampton (11 May 2013). Spreadsheet of
material and attached
files gathered by Helen Wainwright (dossier available on file)
- Statement by Senior Curator, Arts Council England, 14 October 2013
(available on file)
- Education pack for Uncommon Ground created by Arts Council
England (dossier available).