Economic benefit and competitive advantage from commercial adoption of an innovative non-invasive delivery method for drugs and vaccines
Submitting Institution
University of StrathclydeUnit of Assessment
Allied Health Professions, Dentistry, Nursing and PharmacySummary Impact Type
TechnologicalResearch Subject Area(s)
Technology: Medical Biotechnology
Medical and Health Sciences: Pharmacology and Pharmaceutical Sciences
Summary of the impact
Research into non-ionic surfactant vesicles (NIV) led to the development
of an innovative platform
system for delivery of vaccines and drugs, either through oral
administration or inhalation. The
technology was licensed to a US company, VBI Vaccines in 2008 and led to
product development
in that company. The adoption of the technology supported the creation of
35 FTE jobs in
US/Canada and attracted 50% of the licensor company's Series A VC
investment (approximately
$18M). It was also adopted by Morvus Technology Ltd. (2010). The
University collaborated with
Biovaxpahrma Ltd to create a new biotechnology spin out Inhalosome-C,
which was awarded a
£196k TSB grant in December 2012. The technology is currently being used
in commercial R&D in
two further companies, Aptuit Ltd and Philips Respiratory Drug Delivery.
Underpinning research
Context
Non-ionic surfactant vesicles (NIV) have a synthetic bi-layer that mimics
naturally derived cell
membranes. These make them chemically stable in a biological environment,
with very low toxicity.
The Strathclyde research into NIV as a system for drug delivery led to a
non-invasive delivery,
directly to the site of therapeutic need. This method negates the need for
injections removes cold
chain storage and enables lower doses of drug to be used therapeutically,
increasing treatment
options and reducing manufacturing costs, all of which are desirable
attributes by both consumers
and the pharmaceutical industry. Delivery systems have been used to
improve drug treatment and
vaccination as they can target the incorporated therapeutic to the site of
action and protect it from
degradation. This ensures that sufficient quantities of the therapeutic
are present to kill the
pathogen (with respect to drug) or to elicit the appropriate immune
response (with respect to
vaccine). A successful delivery system must give high entrapment values
for the relevant
therapeutic, favourably modify its in vivo pharmacokinetics, allow
treatment by different routes of
administration, and have the potential to be adapted so that it can be
used with a range of
therapeutics. This is challenging as the delivery system must incorporate
therapeutics with different
physiochemical properties, be non-toxic, be stable on storage and have a
simple manufacture
method to make it economically viable as a product.
Key findings: The core technology, non-ionic surfactant vesicles,
has led to two parallel streams
of research for two administration routes (oral and inhalation) using two
therapeutic agents
(vaccines and drugs respectively). The purpose of the core technology was
to produce a delivery
system that not only resulted in improved therapeutic efficacy but allowed
treatment by a non-invasive
route and could be manufactured on a commercial scale. We originally
demonstrated that
NIV could be used to improve the delivery of a number of antileishmanial
drugs and identified the
optimal NIV formulation for the delivery of sodium stibogluconate (SSG) in
a World Health
Organisation funded project [References 1 and 3]. We demonstrated that
this formulation was
effective against Leishmania donovani, a major parasitic disease
that causes significant mortality in
endemic countries, could be manufactured using a method suitable for
large-scale production, and
pre-clinical toxicology studies in rats showed that it was safe. We also
demonstrated that the SSG-NIV
formulation was more effective in dogs than conventional treatment with
SSG solution, an
important finding as the dog can act as the reservoir host for Leishmania
and canine leishmaniasis
is a significant veterinary health problem. We then extended our studies
to demonstrate that NIV
could be used for the oral delivery of proteins for vaccination and that
vaccination using this
formulation was not only more effective that similar vaccination with
protein solution as it not only
induced higher antibody titres, it also induced a cell-mediated immune
responses. Inclusion of bile
salts into the formulation helped to protect the incorporated protein from
degradation in the gastro-intestinal
tract [References 2, 4 and 5]. We named this type of formulation
`Bilosome' to give it its
own identity and showed that lyophilisation of Bilosomes removed the
requirement for cold storage.
The high efficacy of Bilosomes was demonstrated in a ferret model (gold
standard for influenza)
where oral immunisation induced higher antibody responses and reduced the
time of infection
compared with a commercially available injectable vaccine. The Bilosome
technology was licensed
to Variation Biotechnologies Inc. and more recently we have identified a
new method of
manufacture that is more environmentally friendly and significantly
reduces the time of
manufacture (new patent filing). NIV can be used to deliver drugs by
inhalation, resulting lung
levels compared to administration by the intravenous route [Reference 6].
We have named this
type of formulation `Inhalosome' to give it its own identity and shown in
a murine model of lung
cancer that treatment with Inhalosome formulations of cisplatin or
gemcitabine is more effective
than similar treatment of drug solution by the pulmonary route. We have
also shown that an
amphotericin B Inhalosome formulation is more effective than amphotericin
B solution in a rodent
model of aspergillosis.
Key researchers and positions at University of Strathclyde:
Research was carried out
between 1995 and 2012 by academic staff in the School of Pharmacy and
Biomedical Sciences —
Dr K. C. Carter (Post-doctoral Research Fellow, Royal Society Research
Fellow, Lecturer, Senior
Lecturer); Dr V.A. Ferro (Post-doctoral Research Fellow, Senior Research
Fellow, Lecturer), Dr
A.B. Mullen (PhD student, Lecturer, Professor), Prof James Alexander
(Senior Lecturer, Reader,
Professor).
References to the research
1. Williams DM, Carter KC, Baillie AJ. Visceral leishmaniasis in the
BALB/c mouse: a
comparison of the in vivo activity of five non-ionic surfactant
vesicle preparations of sodium
stibogluconate. J Drug Target. 1995 3(1):1-7.
2. Conacher M, Alexander J, Brewer JM. Oral immunisation with peptide and
protein antigens
by formulation in lipid vesicles incorporating bile salts (bilosomes).
Vaccine. 2001 19(20-22):
2965-74.
3. Carter KC, Mullen AB, Sundar S, Kenney RT. Efficacies of vesicular and
free sodium
stibogluconate formulations against clinical isolates of Leishmania
donovani. Antimicrob.
Agents Chemother. 2001 45(12):3555-9.
4. Mann JF, Shakir E, Carter KC, Mullen AB, Alexander J, Ferro VA. Lipid
vesicle size of an
oral influenza vaccine delivery vehicle influences the Th1/Th2 bias in the
immune response
and protection against infection. 2009. Vaccine, 27(27):3643-9
5. Bennett E, Mullen AB, Ferro VA Translational modifications to improve
vaccine efficacy in
an oral influenza vaccine. 2009. Methods 49(4):322-7
6. Alsaadi M, Italia JL, Mullen AB, Ravi Kumar MN, Candlish AA, Williams
RA, Shaw CD, Al
Gawhari F, Coombs GH, Wiese M, Thomson AH, Puig-Sellart M, Wallace J,
Sharp A,
Wheeler L, Warn P, Carter KC. The efficacy of aerosol treatment with
non-ionic surfactant
vesicles containing amphotericin B in rodent models of leishmaniasis and
pulmonary
aspergillosis infection. J Control Release. 2012 160(3):685-91.
Other evidence for quality of research
All references have undergone rigorous peer-review process prior to
publication.
A portfolio of external funding from a variety of sources has supported
the research. This includes
total funding from the following:
World Health Organisation |
1993-1998 |
$177,556 |
Scottish Enterprise/Proof of Concept: |
2002-2010 |
£523, 523 |
NIH funding: |
2008-2013 |
$4,280,909, SIPBS allocation: £350,000 |
Commercial sources |
2007-2013 |
£137, 868 |
Examples of grant funding include
• Application of an oral delivery technology to the development of a
near-to-market influenza
vaccine, based on NISV technology, 2005-2006, Synergy Fund, (£150, 000),
VA Ferro, J
Alexander, KC Carter, AB Mullen
• Development of an oral vaccine, 2002-2004, Scottish Enterprise Proof of
Concept Fund Round
3, (£162, 000), WH Stimson, J Alexander, KC Carter, VA Ferro
• Demonstration of a platform enabling delivery system for non invasive
drug delivery to the
lungs, 2008-2009 Scottish Enterprise Proof of Concept (£100,500) Carter,
K.C., Ferro V. A.,
Mullen A B.,
Patents awarded or applied for:
• Vesicle Formulation. PCT/GB95/01859 Priority date 10/8/94 UK, Europe,
EP0774958; USA,
5,869,091; pending in Japan, JP10504034)
• Pulmonary drug delivery published by the USPTO on 31st December 2009
under publication
number US-2009-0324743-A1
• Patent Number US20110177163 Compositions and methods for treating
hepatitis A - 21st July
2011
• Patent Number US 20110097418 Compositions and methods for treating
influenza 28th April
2011
• Patent Number US-20120177683 Methods for preparing vesicles and
formulations produced
therefrom. 12th July 2012
• Patent Number US 20120156240 Methods for preparing vesicles and
formulations produced
therefrom 21st June 2012
Details of the impact
Process from Research to Impact
The underpinning research led to two non-invasive drug delivery methods
with commercial
potential. The development of an effective oral delivery system for
vaccines, Bilosomes, and the
development of an inhalation formulation technology for delivery of drug,
Inhalosomes. The
inhalosome technology initially encapsulated Cisplatin for the treatment
of non-small cell lung
cancer, but has potential for application to all lung cancers and other
respiratory diseases. Several
commercial collaborations then developed involving the Research and
Knowledge Exchange
Service at the University of Strathclyde, leading to the following types
of impact.
Commercial adoption of new technology: VBI Vaccines is a company
dedicated to the
innovative formulation, development and delivery of safe and effective
vaccines. Their approach to
vaccine development addresses significant market opportunities, and aims
to fulfil critical unmet
medical needs. Through a recent strategic acquisition, VBI has expanded
its pipeline of
thermostable vaccine programs and is also developing its own Lipid
Particle based vaccines
(Source A). VBI licensed the patented Bilosome technology from Strathclyde
University in July
2008, and benefitted from access to the Bilosome patent. Technology
transfer assistance from the
Strathclyde research team has allowed VBI to further develop the Bilosome
technology and they
have filed further patents in related areas between 2008 and 2013. The
Vice President Operations
of VBI has confirmed that "After acquiring the Bilosome technology from
the University of
Strathclyde in 2007 VBI has made great efforts in attempting to
formulate and manufacture various
antigens into effective vaccine candidates. Three of the key antigens
focused on within VBI's
bilosome projects were Hepatitis A, shigella and Influenza. The
experiments conducted between
2008 and 2012 helped to build a knowledge base on the technology's
advantages and
disadvantages as an effective drug delivery platform. The existing
bilosome technology was
effective in its ability to induce an immunogenic response with the
appropriate antigen however its
manufacturing method in Chloroform was viewed as not viable for
manufacturing at a commercial
scale. As a consequence and based on feedback from Strathclyde
scientists, VBI began evaluation
of alternate manufacturing processes." (Source B).
Following the signing of the licence agreement in 2008 VBI Vaccines
achieved a Series A funding
of $36M and accredit 50% of that to access to the NIV technology. This
funding allowed them to
employ between 35 and 40 skilled scientists in two locations in North
America, working on NIV
related activities (Source A).
Morvus Technology Limited is a pharmaceutical company specialising in the
discovery and
commercialisation of novel drugs for the oncology market (Source C). The
company has the
capability to generate revenue by out-licensing a number of early-stage
products whilst
simultaneously progressing selected candidates through clinical
development and into patient
trials. Morvus collaborated with the researchers at Strathclyde to
understand how NIV technology
could improve the solubility of certain small molecule compounds and
therefore make them viable
drug candidates. Success has meant that they are now looking to partner
and license their IP for
further development.
The Chief Executive Officer of Morvus has confirmed that "In 2010-2012
Morvus Technology Ltd
used the research findings of Dr K. C. Carter, Dr V. Ferro and Professor
A. Mullen to help develop
a formulation of their in-house drug for delivery using Inhalosomes as a
treatment for lung cancer.
This has involved knowledge transfer from the University to establish
processes and protocols. The
Strathclyde 'inhalosome' method offers significant advantages over other
available delivery
systems as it permits us to target (Cisplatin or drug) directly to the
lung — reducing the need for
intravenous delivery with associated disadvantages (discomfort to
patient/side effects). The
application of this technology is affecting our business plans as we
anticipate it will give us
competitive advantage over other pharmaceutical companies in this area."
(Source D)
Investment in research and development: The University of
Strathclyde has collaborated with
Biovaxpahrma Ltd to create a new biotechnology spin out Inhalosome-C,
which was awarded a
£196k TSB grant in December 2012 to develop the NIV/cisplatin combination
for inhalation delivery
in lung cancer. In collaboration with Respironics Respiratory Drug
Delivery Inc. a subsidiary of
Philips Healthcare, the researchers are also investigating how nebulisers
can be used to improve
pulmonary delivery. This project is in the early stages and the Business
Development Manager of
Philips Respironics Drug Delivery confirms that "Since this project
commenced in July 2013 there
has been a useful exchange of information. In particular, Philips
Respiratory Drug Delivery (RDD)
has used your research findings...to assess the Inhalosome technology in
drug delivery. This has
helped RDD develop processes and protocols for the in-vivo and in-vitro
delivery of the NIV
platform with our I-neb aerosol drug delivery device." (Source E)
Inhalosome technology has been the subject of a technology transfer
project with Aptuit Ltd, a
pharmaceutical services company that delivers early to mid-phase drug
development solutions.
This has enabled the technology to move to proof of manufacture through
the creation of suitable
processes and protocols related to the manufacture of Inhalosomes
encapsulating the
chemotherapy drug Cisplatin. They have a successful division working on
Inhaled Dosage form
and formulation (Source F) and this experience of working with the
University of Strathclyde
Inhalosome project fits well within their expertise and areas of
scientific interest. The Director of
Development at Aptuit confirms that "From February 2013 Aptuit has used
the research findings of
Dr K. C. Carter, Dr V .Ferro and Professor A. Mullen to successfully
establish a manufacturing
process for lnhalosomes as a step towards scale-up for commercial
production" (Source G).
Improved drug manufacture and delivery: The new inhalation
formulation technology
(inhalosomes) permits delivery of small molecule therapeutics, initially
encapsulating Cisplatin for
the treatment of non-small cell lung cancer, but with potential for other
therapeutics for lung
cancers and other respiratory diseases. The development of an oral vaccine
allows for absorption
of the pharmaceutically active ingredients into the blood stream from
contact with the mucous
membranes of the gastrointestinal tract, providing greater effectiveness
of the vaccine. A further
beneficial impact is the "green synthesis" of the vaccine removing the
need for the use of
chloroform in its preparation. The new manufacturing process with
inclusion of novel lipids has
been tested with Encap Drug Delivery Ltd, Livingstone and has reduced the
time of manufacture.
In addition both delivery systems allow the therapeutic to be given by a
non-invasive method,
reducing the need for trained staff (which is a requirement for
intravenous delivery). This will
reduce healthcare costs and increase patient compliance, particularly with
those who are reluctant
to take injectable medication.
Sources to corroborate the impact
A. http://www.vbivaccines.com/pdfs/VBI-Fact-Sheet.pdf
B. Statement via email from Vice President, Operations VBI Vaccines
C http://www.morvus.com/index.htm
— Morvus Techology Ltd website
D. Statement from Chief Executive Officer Morvus Technology Ltd
E. Statement from Business Development Manager, Respironics Respiratory
Drug Delivery, Philips
Healthcare
F Aptuit website http://www.aptuit.com/Services/Inhaled-Dosage-Form-Development-and-Manufacture.aspx
G. Statement from the Director of Development, Aptuit Ltd.