Technological solutions to facilitate independence in the community for people with long term conditions affecting their mobility
Submitting Institution
Keele UniversityUnit of Assessment
General EngineeringSummary Impact Type
HealthResearch Subject Area(s)
Medical and Health Sciences: Clinical Sciences, Human Movement and Sports Science, Neurosciences
Summary of the impact
The Orthotic Research & Locomotor Assessment Unit (ORLAU)
(http://www.rjah.nhs.uk/ORLAU)
has run multidisciplinary services to improve the function and lifestyle
of severely disabled patients since 1975. New specialist clinical services
have been established, based on research and development activity. The
effectiveness of these services has been the subject of further
investigations. Work has focused on the development of novel technology
(in gait analysis and orthotics) and increasing understanding of human
movement. Conditions treated include cerebral palsy, spinal cord injury,
neuromuscular disorders, arthritis and stroke. Technological developments
have led to licencing within the commercial sector. ORLAU has also
contributed to the development of national and international clinical
education and guidelines.
Underpinning research
ORLAU is based at The Robert Jones & Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic Hospital
NHS Foundation Trust in Oswestry, a specialist tertiary hospital providing
a comprehensive range of musculoskeletal (bone, joint and tissue)
surgical, medical and rehabilitation services; locally, regionally and
nationally. ORLAU's specialist staff, facilities and clinical services
mean that it is very well placed to deliver translational research.
Research and development projects have focused on improving the function
and welfare of patients. Research has covered 4 key areas, as listed
below.
• Development of movement analysis technology
The analysis of movement, particularly gait, was fundamental to ORLAU's
original vision. In 1975 commercial movement analysis systems were not
available, so ORLAU engineers developed ways of presenting forces and
muscle activities in combination with sequential video images. The Video
Vector technology, available to ORLAU in the 1970s, has only been
commercially available in the last ten years. The system continues to be
used for new research projects1.
• Human gait assessment
ORLAU has continued to be an internationally recognised centre of
excellence in gait-related research and has extended the portfolio of
research to include the use of computer modelling techniques. These
techniques have been used to inform surgical decision making in cerebral
palsy2. The role of muscles during gait has been further
elucidated using the novel approach of random electrical stimulus
application to a muscle during walking3. In recent years a new
programme of research has looked at gait patterns before and after total
knee replacement. The novelty of this work is in its focus on the loading
on both hip and knee joints in single joint disease. The risk to the other
joints of continued muscular co-contraction and overloading has been
highlighted.
• Novel clinical services
ORLAU/RJAH hospital was the first organisation in the UK to offer
Selective Dorsal Rhizotomy (SDR), a surgical procedure for children with
cerebral palsy. Research from ORLAU has impacted significantly to the
development of selection criteria, using gait analysis to select suitable
patients for SDR procedures. The focus on rigorous selection criteria in
patients has resulted in significant improvements in spasticity reduction4.
• New orthotic devices
ORLAU researchers have also developed novel orthotic devices for the
management of contractures5, standing frames to support the
training of motor control (supporting the research of the Movement Centre)
and a unique range of walking devices, such as the ORLAU Parawalker and
Swivel walker6. ORLAU's rehabilitation engineering team have
secured funding from a number of NHS/NIHR/EU/NIH funding streams.
ORLAU's expertise in orthotic design and manufacture enabled the
development of a device for measuring muscle strength, which was
subsequently used for research in an acute stroke unit, following funding
from Action Medical Research (AP1131). Two postgraduate projects followed
on from this work, extending ORLAU's interests into the prevention and
reversal of muscle atrophy.
• Grant Funding includes:
Title |
Funder |
Award |
Technical support to produce a performance specification for lower
limb orthotic devices |
EU Craft |
£74,200 |
A comparative study of the effectiveness of treatment of
contractures with mechanically applied stretch and heat |
Action Medical Research |
£82,870 |
Feasibility study for a free knee reciprocal walking orthosis |
Dept of Health HTD |
£70,218 |
Prosthesis control by forward dynamic simulation of the intact
biomedical system (with University of Chicago and US National
Institute of Biomedical Imaging & Bioengineering) |
National Institutes of Health (USA) |
$13,860 |
Development of an integrated service model incorporating
innovative technology for the rehabilitation of the upper limb
following stroke. |
NIHR |
£137,849 |
Strength training with electrical stimulation-Is this is a
viable method of facilitating independence and improving muscle
function following a severe stroke? |
Action Medical Research |
£78,002 |
Can sNMES of the wrist and hand, in conjunction with routine
therapy, facilitate recovery of arm function in people with poor
prognostic indicators of functional recovery? |
Action Medical Research & UHNS R&D |
£124,300 |
References to the research
(three key quality references are highlighted: 3, 4 & 6)
1. Butler PB et al. The effect of fixed ankle foot orthoses in children
with cerebral palsy. Disabil Rehab Assist Technol. 2007 2(1):51-8
2. Stewart C et al. Estimation of hamstring length at initial contact
based on kinematic gait data. Gait Posture. 2004 20(1):61-6.
3. Stewart C et al. An exploration of the function of the triceps surae
during normal gait using functional electrical stimulation. Gait
Posture. 2007 26(4):482-8.
4. Cole GF et al. Selective dorsal rhizotomy for children with cerebral
palsy: The Oswestry experience. Arch Dis Child. 2007 92(2):781-5.
5. Farmer SE et al. Dynamic Orthoses in the Management of Joint
Contracture. J Bone and Joint Surg Br. 2005 87(3) 291-5.
6. Stallard J. Walking for the Severely Disabled: Research and
Development, Experience and Clinical Outcomes. J Bone Joint Surg Br.
2005: 87(5):604-607.
Details of the impact
• Development of movement analysis technology
The availability of video vector technology enabled ORLAU to be a pioneer
in the field. This resulted in the establishment of the first
comprehensive gait analysis service in the UK. The technology allowed
existing interventions, such as plastic Ankle Foot Orthoses (AFOs) to be
biomechanically aligned, or `tuned'. Video vector technology has
only been introduced to the market in the last decade or so (e.g. Templo
system, Contemplas (www.contemplas.com/motion_analysis_templo.aspx)).
A major pressure to develop these technologies has come from an
understanding of the need to tune AFOs, an insight, whilst not originating
in ORLAU, was significantly developed by ORLAU clinical teams1 (source
a).
ORLAU has been a leading contributor to the development of both national
and international practice and education in movement analysis. ORLAU
hosted the first meeting of the ESMAC Society (European Society of
Movement Analysis for Adults and Children) (source b) and was a
founder member of CMAS (Clinical Movement Analysis Society, UK) (source c)
and will host its 13th (2014) Annual Scientific
Meeting. ORLAU has continued to significantly contribute to the movement
analysis community with ORLAU staff chairing both the committee and the
standards groups of CMAS. ORLAU staff played a significant role in the
development of standards with Dr Caroline Stewart overseeing the
introduction of the UK's first accreditation programme for gait
laboratories (source c).
• Human gait analysis
Movement analysis research has had an impact on both clinical services
and the establishment of significant international collaborations2,3.
One key area has been the construction of computer models of the human
musculoskeletal system. These models are used at every clinical review of
patients going through the ORLAU gait laboratory in order to understand
the length of their hamstring muscles and consequent need for surgery. The
research has led to an overall reduction in the need for certain muscle
lengthening procedures in children with cerebral palsy (source d).
• New Novel clinical services
The development of a specialist movement analysis service has allowed
ORLAU to be innovative in the introduction of new clinical procedures, in
particular the orthopaedic management of children with cerebral palsy (source
e) and other severely disabled neurological patients (source f).
ORLAU/RJAH was responsible for the introduction of Selective Dorsal
Rhizotomy (SDR) to the UK. The selection criteria for SDR developed by
Cole et al 20074 has since been embedded in service provision
within ORLAU and been presented internationally. In recognition of the
work carried out by ORLAU the Director has been invited as an External
Adviser to the NICE Clinical Guideline 145 (source g). ORLAU staff
have also provided input to the development of NICE guidance
(Interventional Procedures 195 (2006) and 373 (2010), source h)
and are currently participating in the planning of national commissioning
planning for SDR services.
• New orthotic devices
ORLAU continues to deliver clinical services supplying novel devices
developed by the rehabilitation engineering team. Commercialisation has
occurred through licensing to Otto Bock (source i). The Swivel
Walker and the Parawalker allow patients with little or no active lower
limb muscle power to mobilise in a normal upright posture. The Standing
Frame also allows patients to be supported in weight bearing. ORLAU
records show around 90 standing frames are being produced for patients
every year. An upright posture has many functional, social and
physiological benefits. The Swivel walker won a Design Council Award in
1981. The only commercially available swivel walkers are based on the
designs originating from the original research from ORLAU. Joint
deformities (contractures) are common secondary complications in patients
with severe levels of disability. Research has demonstrated that the
treatment has the ability to give significant clinical benefit and this is
reflected in the number of devices sold (1760).
• General impacts of the work described
ORLAU's specialist work has led to a number of requests to run training
courses. Over the years courses have been run in specialist orthotic
devices and in gait analysis. ORLAU staff support the training of
specialist registrar training in orthopaedics and participating in FRCS
preparation courses. Caroline Stewart, Neil Postans and Andrew Roberts
have all been involved in teaching on ESMAC's European Gait Analysis
course (source j), an annual event associated with the European
conference.
Sources to corroborate the impact
a) Morris C et al. Orthotic management of cerebral palsy: recommendations
from a consensus conference. NeuroRehabilitation. 2011 28(1):37-46
b) ESMAC: http://www.esmac.org/index.php/about-esmac
c) CMAS: http://www.cmasuki.org
d) Laracca et al. The effects of surgical lengthening of dynamically long
hamstring muscles in children with cerebral palsy. Gait Posture
2009 30(S2):s75-s76
e) Patrick JH. Techniques of psoas tenotomy and rectus femoris transfer:
"new" operations for cerebral palsy diplegia — a description. J
Pediatr Orthop B. 1996 5(4):242-6
f) Patrick JH, Keenan MA. Gait Analysis to Assist Walking After Stroke.
Lancet 2007 369(9558):256-7
g) NICE Clinical Guidelines, No 145 "Spasticity in Children and Young
People with Non-Progressive Brain Disorders" July 2012. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK116587/
h) NICE Interventional Procedure No 373 "Selective dorsal rhizotomy for
spasticity in cerebral palsy", December 2010. http://www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/11220/52083/52083.pdf
i) Managing Director, Otto Bock Healthcare Plc, 32 Parsonage Road,
Englefield Green, Egham, Surrey, TW20 0LD
j) European Gait Analysis course: http://www.ior.it/en/didattica-e-formazione/esmac-gait-analysis-course